Most Underrated Metallica Songs


The Contenders: Page 4

61 The House Jack Built

Dark, and unlike anything else Metallica has ever done.

This is fantastic, until Hetfield butchers it around 4:17

The whole song is great! Love it and it is underrated!

62 All Nightmare Long

This song is quite famous but doesn't get the credit it deserves. by far the best chorus Metallica have made.
St. anger is also underrated. but the most underrated song I feel is Judas Kiss. It's a brilliant song and its actually a Metallica great.

This must be one of Metallica's best ever. Don't get why it gets so little attention.

I agree famous but gets no credit!

63 Some Kind of Monster

Beginning of song justifies my vote

This is overrated! It's annoying!

64 Fade to Black

Great song and so fun to play on the guitar!

Simple, Great! Not a masterpiece... Pretty epic though.

65 Through the Never

Many of the songs above are not underrated at all but this is definitely very underrated - LMARINE

This song is great. Way underrated!

V 1 Comment
66 Breadfan

I know... I know... Covers aren't usually my favorites either... but this's an and justice for all era release that retained a master of puppets feel, sound and composition... And it's a straight up ass kicker that offers a kind of unique lyrical style for Hetfield... And, because it was released as a B side to eye of the beholder (I think it was), almost nobody's familiar.

67 Purify

So underrated!

Best Metallica song of the 2000s.. peroid!

68 The Unnamed Feeling
69 The Struggle Within

I find it underrated! It's a great song that doesn't get any credit

70 Holier Than Thou

This is the second best song on the black album (behind sad but true) and although the black album is overrated this is the only thrash song on it. I love the intro, the guitar and bass riffs, James also has some great vocals and lyrics and the drums were also great, I don't see why everyone thinks Lars is such a bad drummer he's actually pretty good

A great song. Totally underrated! But it's not the second best song on the album!

V 1 Comment
71 Prince Charming
72 Attitude

Great song but underrated. I like this song, but no one that I know has ever even heard this song before. And this song has never been played live at all. Should be higher than 38!

73 Whiskey In the Jar

Actually I think dyers eve and whiskey in the jar are the two most underrated metallica songs! Though whiskey in the jar is one of very few I like off of garage inc.

74 Enter Sandman

Not underrated by any means! Jeez! Do these people know what underrated means?

What? This is by far their most popular. It is not at ALL underrated.

Nobody's ever heard this one before. Shame.

V 1 Comment
75 Invisible Kid

This is from St. anger album I think its an awesome song, but no one seems to like this album.

76 Where the Wild Things Are

Overrated I hate this song with a passion! My 2nd least favorite song Metallica ever made!

This list sucks. A lot of these songs are well known.

77 Cure
78 Bad Seed
79 Better Than You
80 Carpe Diem Baby

So emotional and so good. The main riff is brilliant. One of the best songs by Metallica in my opinion

GROSSLY underrated! This should be number one. One of the best songs ever!

PSearch List

Recommended Lists

Related Lists

Top Ten Most Underrated Metallica Songs After ... and Justice for All Metallica Songs with the Most Underrated Riffs Best Metallica Songs Most Underrated Rock Songs Best Songs On Metallica's Black Album

List StatsUpdated 26 Sep 2017

1,000 votes
97 listings
8 years, 97 days old

Top Remixes (17)

1. Whiplash
2. The God that Failed
3. Jump in the Fire
1. Disposable Heroes
2. Jump in the Fire
3. Dyers Eve
1. Jump in the Fire
2. Trapped Under Ice
3. Disposable Heroes

View All 17


Add Post

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.