Most Underrated Total Drama Characters


The Top Ten

1 Geoff

I like Geoff a lot though. But I hate his couple with Bridgette even though I like her too.

They screwed him after season 1

I really like Geoff in Tdi

Here it's very embarrassing what they did to this character before the Ridonculous race. After a great season in tdi making him 6th, they made crueler than ever before until the Ridonculous race

V 2 Comments
2 Max

One overrated contestant aka my despise for total drama. I hope he dies! Or gets eliminated first. The writers favor him in season five point five

This guy is just a joke and a huge shame to evil. - BlueDiamondFromNowhere

The writers, his fan base and hate base overrates him so much

Max needs way more credit than he gets!

V 2 Comments
3 Amy

She's the worst character, and her fans totally overrate her. - Turkeyasylum

Overrated by the writers! Overrated! She doesn't deserve credit, she sucks!

4 Trent

He was good until TDA, where the writers derailed him. - Turkeyasylum

5 Justin

Justin wasn't my favorite in the beginning, but in Action, I started warming up to the guy! Sure, he's always super conscious about his looks, but tell me you didn't laugh at him at least once or twice! The guy is pure comedy gold with his "NOT THE FACE! " comments. Most fans only hate Justin because he brags about himself, but at least he isn't completely irritating like Lightning. Courtney brags about herself more than any character, yet she's WORSHIPPED by the fans! Needless to say, Justin is pretty underrated

He's so full of himself and is very annoying. I don't see why he is so high - BlueDiamondFromNowhere

I never found him too big of a character. I'm indifferent towards him.

V 1 Comment
6 Sam

He is a cool and nice man, even if I don't think he deserves to be on All Stars. - BlueDiamondFromNowhere

I hope he can win a season soon, he deserves better

One thing very bad Sam/Harold's voice actor split from frsh so no more Sam or Harold 😭

7 Eva

Another underrated character. She's in a tie for #1 with Ezekiel and staci. If she comes back on. She should hit he finals, I like ever

I feel bad for ever, I feel like she needs a boyfriend. That would take some of her anger away.

Finally! A supremely underrated character makes it on here! - Turkeyasylum

V 1 Comment
8 B

B is probably the most underrated character in the show. Is it because he doesn't talk or something? I've always loved B because he's smart, friendly, and just a cool guy. I also hate how people constantly ship Dawn with Scott because she complimented him once and they look "cute". I've always liked B x Dawn because at least they're friends. Come on, guys! B needs more love!

B is an amazing character with a lot of potential, he just gets overlooked too much

If B actually starts talking I think he will not B so underrated

True underrated. I love Beverly a lot

V 2 Comments
9 Zoey

Gosh, she can be annoying and boring. She is just bland and she's dependent on Mike. I don't understand why someone can call her "underrated". - BlueDiamondFromNowhere

Woah wait this is a list for underrated characters she is one of the most overrated characters in the series

Um.. I like Zoey and all, but she's pretty overrated..

Bland overrated Mary Sue

V 1 Comment
10 Tyler

Tyler deserves way more screen time and attention than he is given. He really is an awesome character, I love jocks!

Tyler deserves to win, he's such a fun character.

Tyler is so underrated in my opinion. He's one of my favourite chracters. Even though I ddon't think that there is going to be an TD season, if there will I hope he'll be back and hopefully win.

The Contenders

11 Beardo

He seemed really interesting to me, too bad he had no character at all.. I really hope we'll get to know him better in a new season - Alivi

He's the funniest contestant ever but I don't know if he'll come back maybe in some total drama no stars - simpsondude

I love beardo. He's extremely underrated and is really cool. He deserves to make it far in a season. (Pac man reference when eliminated)


V 3 Comments
12 Beth

Let's see... Put up with Heather? Check. Put up with Courtney at her absolute worst? Check. Get herself cursed? Check. Miss out on competing in World Tour? Double check. Do Samey's type of storyline before and better? Check, and yes, I did just say that. Get arrested through no fault of her own? Check. Work hard throughout an entire season and still lose to an elimination houdini? Big check. Be the only previous finalist to not be present for "The Final Wreck-ening"?...That might be a blessing in disguise, but still a check nonetheless. Be genuinely nice to Chris of all people? I couldn't make a bigger check if I tried.

Was originally gonna choose Geoff, but honestly, Beth gets so much hate when she was actually a much better finalist than Duncan. Not a good finalist, mind you, (LINDSAY SHOULD HAVE WON) but at least she played a clean game and made me laugh. Duncan was a cheater and a bully all season long.

Beth deserves way more recognition than she receives. She hasn't won Total Drama yet,( only in alternate ending) so she needs to stay in the game til she actually wins.

She is the most underrated contestant ever. She's got a stupid hate base, she didn't win TDA in north america(a reason Duncan sucks), and blainley ruined her shot of being in all stars and making it to the finals instead of bland 1 and 2(Mike and Zoey).

V 5 Comments
13 Ezekiel

Possibly the most underrated contestant ever. My favorite is mistreated left and right. The writers like to bully him. I hope he turns back to normal and kills Chris and wins a season. He doesn't deserve mistreatment writers

Instead of giving him more attention, they turned him into a zombie. That sucks. I feel bad for him.

14 Mike

Mike receives way too much hate for no reason, but I would like to see Mike develop his own personality now that he's himself.

Extremely overrated

15 Lindsay

She is mistreated by writers a lot

16 Sadie

She is overrated then katie but she is steal pretty underrated

17 Brick

He's really cool and nice, and I think he deserves more attention - BlueDiamondFromNowhere

Brick is a sweetheart, he needs more attention then he gets. He deserves it.

18 Harold

Most underrated and overhated. He should have won TDA, but stupid fat face Owen had to ruin his all star chances

19 Carrie
20 Tammy
BAdd New Item

Recommended Lists