Top Ten Most Underrated Warrior CatsThis is a list of the most underrated warrior cats.
The Top Ten
Oh my god, poor Dovewing! She doesn't deserve all the hate she gets! She is not a mary sue: she's naive, stubborn, annoying at times, and others. She also saved her clan once or twice; half the ThunderClan cats would've died if she didn't alert the clan of the tree in Fading Echoes. My favorite.
Come on guys!? Dovewing is not a marry-sue! And you need to relate to "That's future me's problem," when you do homework! Oh and Bumblestripe is too clingy and annoying to relate to!
I guess we're making a list of the least underrated warrior cats then... - Murphypaw
I like Dovewing a lot. She was the reason why Ivypool(my 2nd favorite character from warriors) became the great badass she is!V 32 Comments
Yo I love heeerr, she's really unique and interesting character. It makes me happy she is now gaining more attention from the fandom. - subscribe2pewdiepie
I love Needletail so much, I love her rebellious and sarcastic/snarky nature, I love her relationship with Violetshine, and I love her relationship with Alderheart. I really hope when Alderheart dies and goes to StarClan he and Needletail become mates(If he weren't a medicine cat, I would totally ship him and Needletail).
Needle tail was a fun character Andrew I shipped her with alderheart
Honestly I liked her even before she redeemed herself because Needletail was different and refreshing and really, really FUN. - WarriorcatsfandomV 14 Comments
I don't see why people hate Millie. She's one of my favourite cats. Many people think she's a prat for showering so much attention on Briarlight, but I don't blame her. You people have no empathy, her daughter's SPINE was BROKEN. She has the right to snap at others. You think she's heartless because she's worried? Yeah, whatever. Another reason people dislike her is because her "undeveloped" relationship with Graystripe. 97% of the people who think Millie x Graystripe is the worst couple ever haven't even read Graystripe's manga series...Summary: The people who hate Millie haven't even looked into the exact reason as to why they hate her. They don't seem to be able to put themselves in someone else's paws.
Well, she did kinda replace Silverstream, but she did no harm besides that. And everybody hates her. And replacing sliver was really not as horrible. Graystripe still loves them both. She did pat much attention to briarlight. But what’s wrong with that!
I don't know, she's a great cat, rly
Everyone treats her so badly for what she is she isn't a fave cat but she is certainly better than Silverstream. People keep going on about her treating her kits like dirt but Blossomfall did need to grow up! As for Millie she was freaked out at how many times her kit had been put in danger and how she was paralysed for life! She got worried like any mother and reacted in a bit of a wrong way which is realistic I mean everyone makes mistakes! In real life a parent would care more for a injured child than a perfectly healthy one its natural! She saved Greystripe multiple times even when he treated her like dirt! She is also dictated about for keeping her kitty pet name but it IS NOT like living with a paw in each world she I saying she has no shame in her past! She left her life for Greystripe and their couple is far more developed than his with that brat Silverstream! We never have seen Greystripe with the kits anyway so WHY judge Millie and not him?! Anyway she cared for them all ...moreV 17 Comments
Ya like really there has to be a book explaining his life
We need a super edition on hawk heart or at least a novella, I want to know how he saw the world and viewed things; especially I want to know why starclan chose him.
Poor Hawkheart. Everyone hates him for killing Moonflower. Can you really blame him though? There's this warrior attacking the healing supply, what are you supposed to do? Beg with them? NO! You have to act quickly! At the time, herbs were very scarce so if Hawkheart didn't act, WindClan would have had a rough leaf bare. Don't give me that, "Oh! He didn't have to kill her! He was just being cruel on purpose." No, just no. Without the herbs, a lot of lives would have been lost without the herbs. Hawkheart did do the right thing. Plus, what was Goosefeather really thinking? I know he can see the future and stuff but I personally think he was a little too overconfident with this omen. Destroy the herbs supply of a clan? Goosefeather is a MEDICINE CAT! He should know better then to give this message to the clan.
You really can't blame him for killing Moonflower. I mean, come on!... Imagine if this ThunderClan cat was destroying the herbs. The herbs that save many lives. Of course you would act quickly, right? Right...? I hope you said yes because...V 12 Comments
Go briarlight but ya vote for her
She's great! I love her.
I am Briarlight's biggest fan. She's SOOO SWEET! She is so cute, and I love her so much! (SPOILER ALERT)I am so upset about her death! I nearly cried!
She's really nice, and she's definitely NOT a Mary-Sue. Mary-Sues are perfect. IS THERE ANYTHING PERFECT WITH A BROKEN SPINE?! NO! I only hate the Jayfeather x Briarlight ship, it's really a bad ship, I mean, Jayfeather witnessed her birth or something!V 7 Comments
WHAT?! Why is there an overrated cat here? - Pikafire
He can go die in the tunnels. - RoseWeasley
Nooo. The Bumblestripe love train needs to crash into a mountain and die. He was an absolute jerk; he was so pushy and apparently could not understand that not everyone you like has to like you back. - Warriorcatsfandom
What? So he's a jerk for loving Dovewing, being romantic, sweet, and caring. While Dovewing just played with him for awhile and dumped him. He deserves better. Way better. - WinddV 5 Comments
Its ironic. Hollyleaf strictly followed the warrior code, but then killed a cat.
She is SUPER loyal. She hid for a good reason. Why dose everyone hate her for hiding!?!?
SHE IS NOT UNDERRATED PEEPS
Hollyleaf is the BEST! I love Hollyleaf and she deserves more love!V 11 Comments
She's awesome! She deserves more!
She is the best cat, risked her life to save all four clans!
Huh. How interesting. Isn't it funny that I actually liked her before she ever gained so much popularity from the fandom? No but seriously, I wasn't expected her to get lots of love. Tons of people back in the day hated her, while I was literally one of those rare fans that liked her. Times change, I guess.
Alright, come on people, this is a list of characters underrated by the fandom, or else why would Dovewing be #1? Ivypool has many fans and is very popular with the fandom. Not saying that she shouldn't be (I love her as well) but she is NOT underrated. Even if it was cats who were underrated in the series, Ivypool is not on. She has a point of view! Everyone is putting cats on here like Thrushpelt and Brackenfur who get all the attention they need from the fandom. Save this list for REAL underrated characters, like Spottedleaf, Millie, Dovewing, Lionblaze, Bramblestar... The list goes on and on.
Person: She was annoying as an apprentice!
Me: umm... what does that have to do with this?
He was a great cat. He should've become leader instead of Rowanstar. - Stormyblaze
He was amazing. - Windd
Crow frost was a good cat! I think he had enough guts to say his clan was weak. I think of him, sacarficing him self for the remaining herbs
ShadowClan deputy as of Thunder and Shadow. He really deserves more attention. He was loyal, honest, brave, and true. Lemme just say one more thing: Dawnpelt did NOT deserve him.V 2 Comments
Aw, Pine, (not calling him Pinestar, not because he’s undeserving of it, but because I respect his choice of the path, and the name, of a non-Clan cat) you were too farsighted for the Clans. Far ahead of you, all you could see was endless war, while your cats were just preparing for the next battle. You were surrounded by fighters, trying to take back what was theirs and ensure their safety... but you saw that the only sure path to safety, was peace. You are too precious for them. If only you had been born in a time less divided...
Why hasn't anyone put rain whisker on here?
Hated for becoming a kittypet, and somewhat for becoming mates with Leopardfoot. Guys, bear in mind that cats with large age differences do become mates sometimes. Also, he still is worthy of StarClan, and didn't feel comfortable in ThunderClan. Don't automatically say he's a coward. Plus, if you've read thoroughly, you can see that he /regrets/ his choice.
Just because he knew clan life was not for him? He knew what he was giving up, and he knew what was meant for him. I kinda like him honestly. - Darktail_of_FireClan
Tigerheart did something many Warrior Cats wouldn't do across Clan borders. He followed his heart, which led him to Dovewing. Tiger x Dove is way better than Bumble x Dove. - Pikafire
He was so immature. I liked that about him. Not everyone can be perfect at 12 moons old. - RisingMoon
That derpy jerk - BlazeHeart
I hate him so badly. - RedTheGremlinV 1 Comment
Brackenfur is listed as an elder in Lost Stars, and a MAIN CHARACTER on the Warriors Wiki. - Pikafire
I've always felt bad for Brackenfur. He's an awesome warrior, loyal, wise, courageous, but when he was the obvious choice for deputy, Firestar had to break the warrior code for someone less qualified. But even through that, Brackenfur supported Brambleclaw, which reminds me of Whitestorm, a great warrior, also a bit underestimated. Then, Brackenfur lost his only son, his daughter from a snake, one of his daughters turned out to be a reincarnation of his sister, which gets weird, his mate dies, one of his kits dies. He goes through so much, and he's never rewarded for any of it.
I'd love him to become the next deputy after Squirrelflight retires/dies or Bramblestar dies.
I've always loved Brackenfur. He's always been a good-hearted cat in every series, and some books show more of his "kind side", like in Starlight, where he's really sweet and affectionate to Sorreltail (I know that they become mates in the future, and that's why he's kind to her, but you get the idea). Over all, Brackenfur is a kind cat who has gone through hard times and I think that he needs more recognition.V 6 Comments
She is really underrated.
Dawnpelt sacrificed herself for her kits while waiting for them to leave shadowclan during DarkTail’s reign. Dawnpelt may have threatened Jayfeather but that was because she was burdened by her brother’s death she felt like she HAD to blame someone. Aside from that Dawnpelt was an amazing mother/warrior and I enjoyed her last moments in AVOS. Too bad she died.
..;+;../ SPOILERS ..;+;../
I absolutely love Dawnpelt. During the DoTc arc she may have been a female dog but she only wanted to protect her brother’s legacy. She had the need to blame Jayfeather only because she was grief-stricken after Flametail’s death. She was also an exceptional mother but her children (Sleekwhisker, Strikestone, and Juniperclaw just took the wrong turn). Sleekwhisker was willingly abandoning Shadowclan while Strikestone and Juniperclaw stayed with their mother and Rowanstar loyally. At least she taught /them/ well. (Even though Juniperpaw -then- went willingly with Sleekpaw, in the end he ran away with Strikestone to Thunderclan). Unfortunately Dawnpelt did die in a very sad way. Presumed to have been drowned like how Needletail would have been if she were to be killed right there and then. She protected her kits and the cats she helped escape and was an amazing character. - Yarrow_Struck
Tigerstar is so OVERRATED - Pikafire
Hated and just dumped. Tigerstar may have started many issues of Thunderclan, but to be honest, aside from his story, he's a very unique villain. Unlike some others, Tigerstar developed to be evil, just as the prophecy said so. This was because of his past, probably receiving so much hatred and eventually, getting a mentor who decided to train him in the ways of the Dark Forest. This villain only came to be because he was determined to be the best he can, blinded by his mentor, became evil. Tigerstar is a villain well to work with, and took the story far as a powerful villain.
Actually, he is the second-most overrated villain just after Scourge (but I love Scourge) - RedTheGremlin
She is actually one of my favorite characters and I find her here finally.
I hate anybody who says sandstorm is overrated and that firestar x spottedleaf is a better ship. So firestar barely even new who spottedleaf is. It was a love at first sight thing and I think it is horrible. Spottedleaf was a grandma of some sort and firestar was like a kit still. It's just creepy. Meanwhile sandstorm is the same age as him. It's perfect for them. In the beginning she may have been a little mean to him... I know... but she was sort of with dustpaw(pelt) and they sort of were like, bfs or something. Until In fire and ice the worst book ever sandstorm is nicer to fire when he ask her about the patrol or something. Then if anyone even remembers sometimes dustpelt was mean to fire and sandstorm would step up and defend him. So I would def require sandstorm a little higher on the list. She is a good character! She should be higher than 16th place!
Sandstorm is simply the best.
She definitely deserves to be remembered more than just Firestar's mate and Squirrelflight's and Leafpool's mother. - Frecklewillow
She is the most annoying and overrated. Fireheart x Spotted is better.
They act like she doesn't really love Firestar, she just wants to make decisions for the clan, but she really does love him, and she is good for the clan too.V 8 Comments
Ok great. But why does everyone hate Daisy for being a kit machine, but everyone loves Ferncloud for being a kit machine?! - Puppytart
If you are Ferncloud's kit, then you are almost guaranteed to mate your cousin.
Kits, kits, and more kits - Pikafire
Something similar to Daisy, and the whole "kit machine" thing. Why are people mad at her for having /seven/ kits? Sorreltail had one less than she did. Also, bear in mind that some of these kits /died/. I can't believe you people for demanding Ferncloud should die. She /doesn't/ "do nothing in the nursery all day." Why are people so mad at her? If mad at her for being a kit machine, be mad at Sorreltail for having six kits, Robinwing for having 6+ kits (she has had other unnamed kits).V 1 Comment
Worst of the Three, boring, no personality, and EXTREMELY SLIGHTLY relatable - Pikafire
I don't dislike him because he's a gary-stu (which he isn't) I dislike him because he's boring, bland and has no discernible personality. Seriously. I dare you to, right now, give me a list of his character traits. - Warriorcatsfandom
Out of the three, Lionblaze is by far my favorite. Whoever calls him a so-called 'Gary Stu' does not know what the full definition is. A Gary Stu is someone who is entirely perfect and does no wrong. "But Lionblaze is perfect because he's invincible! " So what? Does that mean that Jayfeather is a Gary Stu because he can walk in other cat's dreams? Apparently not. Lionblaze, if I remember correct, made countless mistakes: He nearly began a half-clan relationship with Heatherpaw. He trained in the Dark Forest with Tigerstar for an amount of time. He even KILLED dang old Russetfur. I know first-hand that a Gary Stu would not begin a half-clan relationship; he would not train to do evil; heck, he'd never even THINK about killing anyone! It is not as if he WANTED the power to be invincible in battle. In fact, he downright DIDN'T. He himself said that he wanted to be normal, especially when Cinderheart rejected him because of his destiny. But honestly, aside from Berrynose, Lionblaze is ...more
Why is he underratedV 3 Comments
Love this girl, spends all her days taking care of kits and though she loves them it causes her so much pain, her time trying to decide if she was a clan cat or not was just heart breaking
I HATE DAISY!
This is what she did:
.Sat in the nursery begging for food
.Didn't even get her warrior name (SHE REFUSED TO! )
The good things she did:
Born kits stupid kits!
I HATE DAISY
I love Daisy. She’s not useless. She takes care of all the kits and if kits are given away who do you think takes care of them? - Puppytart
God she's so pure! I love her so much.V 3 Comments
To be honest I absolutely love Sol as a character. He is not underrated and not overrated. He had a lot to do with Blackfoot/star and Hollyleaf, Jayfeather, and Lionblaze
Umm... Hollymist? I think you are too angry for just one person that's being not so good. I don't think a one word comment is great, too, but don't be so angry about it! He/She would figure it out by herself/himself. You are not the leader of thetoptens website, right? Maybe I'm not supposed to be saying this either, but still. I hope you will read this comment. - Maplecloud
Thanks Maplecloud. Maybe I SHOULD have been more nicer! I would not do it again! - Hollymist
HateV 2 Comments
In case none of you read the title, this is a list for underrated characters. You know, like Dovewing and Millie and Daisy. Mapleshade is WAYYY overrated.
She should be way higher on this list her life is sooo sad. I love her.
She should be in StarClan
This list is for UNDERrated characters. Which means that Mapleshade, who is vastly OVERrated, should not be here. - WarriorcatsfandomV 10 Comments
Petal sacrificed herself for her kits to live, and yet I never see her on the best mother's in warrior cats lists
who is she
He is pretty underrated and gets a bit to much unwarranted hate. - oceanbreezetheawesomewarrior
Here's everything Goosefeather did wrong:
- Made Crookedstar break his jaw
- Caused Moonflower's death
- Basically isolated himself
- Made himself this "creepy medicine cat with a crazy brain"
- More if you can think of them
Everything Goosefeather did right:
- Let Spottedpaw and Bluefur know Thistleclaw's treachery - Pikafire
Yes Goosefeather is cool! - Warriorcatsfandom
Godfather is so fascinating, sympathetic and likeable.V 3 Comments
Starstarstar's death is so sad I also cried when grassgrass got killed by evilevil!
Even though it seems we know everything about Starsstarstar, the reveal his kits were with the medicine cat - Herbherb - was shocking! And Starstar, to this day, still doubts his father's choices. - Daroganheart
Starstarstar was the first cat to go to StarClan, joining when she was a kit. Everyone says she's a Mary Sue, but she has her flaws.
Starstarstar needs SO much more attention! She is the opposite of Mary-Sue, and her death is so sad! And after her death, her brother Kitkit became way more developed. But I’m still mad at her mother for ditching Clawclaw.V 3 Comments
Berrynose was absolutely adorable as a kit and apprentice. As a warrior he was pretty annoying. But in Bramblestar's Storm he matured a bit, and I actually came to like Berrynose! He is VERY underrated. I think people are looking back at his past, instead of forward at a new personality after the Great Battle.
Who killed Berrykit and made him this annoying furball?! Also, the fact that he is annoying to EVERY CAT (except for some reason Honeyfern and Poppyfrost) doesn't help his case!
I read Crowfeather's Trial, and Berrynose is this annoying character no cat likes. - Pikafire
At least he isn't a Gary Stu! - IcetailofWishClan
Everyone says he's too annoying. I agree with you, he's annoying. But he's really hated for it. I see him as some... comic relief. Plus, he isn't the worst.V 2 Comments
He was a GREAT character! First, he was a half clan kit who actually managed to make it to the rank of deputy in his clan before dying in an act of pure selfless heroism via saving Graystripe's (also half-clan born) kits. I believe he should be more loved for what he did.
People are so mad at him for having numerous kits with Ferncloud, bullying Firepaw (You know, they were /kids and teens/ back then), and even for choosing her as a mate when she's his niece. They are /fictional cats/ in a /fictional world/. Incest happens. And the Firepaw stuff, like I said in parentheses, they were KIDS/TEENS back then. Not adults.
After the first arc of the series everyone just assumes he so terrible but he isn't! - silverbird8228
He deserves so much. I love him. - Windd
HateV 1 Comment
Whitestorm needs more attention. He’s probably one of the best cats.
Why the hell isn't whitestorm on this list, most of the characters here are heavily overrated - thedragongirl77
This dude is my idol.
Whitestorm was always my favourite ♡
I agree. Brightsprit is important!
Agreed so much - Daroganheart
Brightspirit and her parents only show up once or twice, but they have an important message to bring when they do show up. The Erins created her to honor a girl who had passed away recently. I just think she should get more attention.
Although I do not remember reading about her, since I have not read the books in years, I feel like she is an amazing character, and girl.
It was so kind of the Erins to honour her and her parents' lives :D
But, personally, yeah, Brightspirit is so underrated!
explain - Pikafire
He should be 1
I love him a lot, squirrelflight just played with his head and feelings and that drived I'm insane so what did you think he'll do? After she made sure he fell in love with her, she dumped him and went for brambleclaw/star so of course he's gonna get mad and sad. Imagine if your crush did that and he or she did that. You would be sad and a little messed up. So I don't wanna hear it.
He’s not underrated he’s an overrated idiot - PuppytartV 3 Comments
Sorreltail- the ultimate bodyguard! Seriously, everyone on the underrated list is overrated.
Sorreltail for the win! - Warriorcatsfandom
Am I the only one that thought Sorreltail's picture on here looks like Sol? - YELLOWFANGLOVER
Okay... I like Sandgorse in StarClan and I of course see why people hate him alive. Tallpaw stuff, but haven't you heard what Sparrow, WindClan cats, and a dead Sandgorse have said?
She deserves more popularity. One of the best leaders!
Hated for things like being bossy and exiling Graystripe. Ahem, let me tell you something. She planned that attack on Sunningrocks to see if Graystripe's loyalty could be proved. When Graystripe, in battle against ThunderClan, turned on Leopardstar to help Fireheart she acted quickly and decisively. She banished him from the Clan without a second thought, which was the proper thing to do. There is no room for disloyal cats in a Clan, and the only things making Graystripe at all loyal to RiverClan was his kits and the memory of his mate. His disloyalty could have meant the difference between victory and failure for RiverClan, and ejecting him to make him rejoin ThunderClan was the best choice. Also, when she went crazy, please remember: Bluestar vs StarClan.
Poor Blossomfall. She isn't evil. Neglected by Millie, she felt the Dark Forest accepted her, and thought that she was being loyal to her Clan by learning better battle moves to defend them. - Nightstrike
Blame millie everyone - ZZZOLO
Its not her fault she was so neglected. She went to the Dark Forest because she was praised there. When in the book do you hear Greystripe talking to her or Millie not yelling at her. Its not her fault and I don't see how everyone hates her.
She is ANNOYING. She thinks she's the best and that everyone should pay attention to her. "Oh my sister is nearly dead? I don't care, PAY ATTENTION TO ME! "
She's just another Bella. - Stormyblaze
I now know why Rainflower is a decent character.
She wanted to encourage her kits to grow up as good warriors, like their father. After Stormkit broke his jaw, Rainflower refused to love him any more, because she thought we would die. After all, you can't experience grief if you don't love someone. She eventually realized her mistake, and Shellheart even told Crookedjaw that Rainflower found it hard to realize her mistakes.
Rainflower deserves to be higher. - Pikafire
I used to hate her, but then I learned that she was abused as a kit, I have a bit more sympathy for her, even if I don't like her that much. - RoseWeasley
I know that I am going to get a lot of hate for this, but let me explain:
She abandoned Crookedstar, yes, but Crookedstar abandoned Silverstream for a short while after Willowbreeze and his other kits, Willowkit and Minnowkit, died because he thought that she was going to die, too. So, technically, Rainflower abandoned Crookedstar because she thought that he was going to die. Plus, animals abandon their young when they think that they are going to die. - IcetailofWishClan
You guys do realize that Tall Shadow became Shadowstar, and Tallstar is the leader of WindClan... right?
She deserved better than Gray Wing! - ZZZOLO
Oh! We aren't talking about Tall Shadow, at least I think we're talking about former WindClan leader, also, Tall ShadowXGray Wing was never a thing - Swiftdawn
Tallstar deserved better than Gray Wing?
Acornfur or Acorn Fur? I'm confused... - Pikafire
No one talks about Foxleap. NO ONE. He is an amazing, funny character with a bright personality and deserves to have quite a few more lines!
He and Icecloud should be first. - RedTheGremlin
I personally love Turtle Tail, and I don't blame her for leaving. Gray Wing didn't see that she loved him and he left her for Storm. I would have done the same.
Yes! I love Rosepetal but I have never once heard anyone say anything about her. - RedTheGremlin
She's my favorite she-cat in ThunderClan! She has a good personality, and if she didn't exist many books afterward would be messed up. (( I'm talking about her death and the way she affected things ))
I loved Snowfur! She was a well written character with flaws and mistakes. She was a restless cat which I can relate to, she loved her kit and loved her sister. Sure, they had arguments, but all siblings do! -Snowfur2.0
He isn't a bad cat, just a abysmal leader. - RoseWeasley
Definitely. Rowanstar was a good leader at the beginning of his leadership, but as time went by, he lost more and more faith in himself and the clan. I cannot say I approve of his choices the last time he we saw him alive in Tigerheart's personal book, but I actually really liked him. (he is like, the only GOOD leader I like. Evil leaders are great in my opinion 👌👌)
Fernsong is the best dad!
Fernsong was such a nice guy ❤️
Mosspelt was not a really talked about character, in my opinion. She raised Greystripe's kits, Feathertail and Stormfur, and loved and cared for them as if they were her own and was a really great mother! She was one of the few kind to Greystripe in RiverClan and when he left promised to keep in touch about his kits. She also voted for Firestar to be temporary leader of the clans AND was a skilled warrior and mentor. She should have more recognition!
Please stop putting stupid names on this list. - RedTheGremlin
Clawclaw had a breif spotlight of evil deputy. But overall, he was a kind cat despite almost killing Kitkit and Evilkit, who later become Kitgiver and Evilclaw. - Daroganheart
YES SOMEONE WHI REMEMBERS HER
One of my favorite warrior cats! Great leader
I also like redscar
I thought he was awesome, and we feel really bad for him, but he was kinda a jerk in the last couple books. - ZZZOLO
I agree with ZZZOLO - Swiftdawn
Okay...this little cutie is totally a first favorite in DotC, just before Moon Shadow. He is so energetic and determined, and a fantastic hunter. Not only did he wander of by himself undaunted into the unknown, but he was so prideful casting the stone to leave.
Does he change and become sour? I don't know. Don't tell me, however, I've only just begun the Sun Trail.
Also, Jagged Peak is pretty much the best little brother ever, just throwing that thought out there. ~Rocky
Related ListsMost Underrated Warrior Cats Couples Most Evil Warrior Cats From the Forest Most Annoying Warrior Cats Most Misunderstood Warrior Cats Most Evil Warrior Cats
4 years, 60 days old
Top Remixes (5)
View All 5