Most Undeserving Oscar Winners


The Contenders: Page 2

21 Charlton Heston - Ben-Hur Charlton Heston - Ben-Hur

Charlton Heston was good at who he actually plays: himself! - Dancedom

22 Frances Mcdormand - Fargo

Emily Watson was better in Breaking the Waves - Irina2932

It was a cartoon cariacature of transparently disingenuous face pulling. It was entertaining and in the spirit of the film but is that really good acting?

Watson and Brenda Blethyn should have tied that year.

23 Marlee Matlin - Children of a Lesser God

She was OK but Sigourney Weaver (Aliens), Jane Fonda (The Morning After) and Kathleen Turner (Peggy Sue Got Married) were much more impressive! - Irina2932

24 Natalie Portman – Black Swan Natalie Portman – Black Swan Natalie Portman is an actress, film producer and film director with dual American and Israeli citizenship.

Really? Natalie Portman is so amazing in this film. One of the most deserved of the last years.

I think she deserved. Her performance in Black Swan was incredible.

She's an ok actress ( nothing special ). An oscar-worthy actress? Certainly not. She's too overrated.

25 Alan Arkin - Little Miss Sunshine

I agree with Irini. Djimon Hounsou's acting touched me so much! So passionate! Surely a man who's love for his missing son moved all movie goers. Djimon deserved to win the Oscar. What a great acting performance that should have been rewarded! - curlyqgirly

Djimon Hounsou was better in Blood Diamond - Irina2932

26 Colin Firth - The King's Speech
27 Jessica Lange - Blue Sky

Winona Ryder (Little Women), Susan Sarandon (The Client) and Jodie Foster (Nell) were much better. - Irina2932

I was never impressed by this actress acting skills. This is an actress who should never win or be nominated! She's a too bad actress for that ( whatever movie she's playing ).

28 Alicia Vikander - The Danish Girl

Alicia should have won for Ex Machina instead.

So very overrated. She is just bland.

Really underved! This actress has proved nothing yet to be concidered as a top actress ( she made only a few films that can be count on one hand ) and she gets away with an oscar for best supporting actress.
Rachel McAdams who was also nominated as best supporting actress should have win ( she's an actress who is so underrated but at least she has proved after so many films that she's very talented ). I'm so dissapointed. Rachel McAdams earned her first deserved nomination and she lost against an actress that will be forgotten in a few years.

29 Tom Hanks - Forrest Gump

If there's one actor / actress who should have won an oscar for this " overrated " movie, it should have been Sally Field. The best acting performance in this movie came from her.

Who put him on this list. Forrest Gump is the 2nd best movie of all time after the Departed and Tom Hanks is brilliant in the role.

Hell no.. It's the best movie and Tom Hanks work in this movie was great.. No way he should be in this list

I think Tom was great, but Travolta was really outstanding.

V 2 Comments
30 Philip Seymour Hoffman - Capote
31 Meryl Streep - The Iron lady Meryl Streep - The Iron lady Mary Louise "Meryl" Streep is an American actress. Cited in the media as the "best actress of her generation", Streep is particularly known for her versatility in her roles, transformation into the characters she plays, and her accent adaptation.

A crap movie about the much hated M. Thatcher. That movie is almost praising her and is not realistic for that matter. So my question is how could they give an oscar to Meryl Streep if she's not playing the real Thatcher? This movie was losing money, so they give it an oscar to this overrated actress in the hope to win their money back. I remember when Thatcher died people were dancing in the Streets and postcards were print that were saying " Ding Dong The witch is dead ". Honestly I hope they will print the same postcards when Meryl Streep dies, because it's a real shame when actresses plays crappy scripts and get away with an oscar for that.

I agree that this is a crap movie! Rooney Mara in " Girl with dragon tattoo ", Michelle Williams in " My week with Marilyn " and Viola Davis in " The help " ( too bad sissy spacek wasn't nominated for that movie ) deserved a Thousand times more to win than Meryl Streep. Living proof that she is overrated!

What kind of idiots thinks that she deserved an oscar for such a stupid movie. This movie didn't deserve to be nominated at the first place and certainly didn't deserve to get a winning oscar. This is an overrated actress who gets away with too many undeserved nominations ( thank god she didn't win an oscar for her nomination for " Julie and Julia " because that would have been a really undeserved oscar. Amy Adams was so much better in that movie and was not even nominated ). Just like in " Julie and Julia ", she did get the praise for her accent in the movie " The Iron lady " but being good in accents doesn't make her a top actress to deserve Oscars when a movie is bad or when another actress plays more convincing than her ( Amy Adams in " Julie and Julia " and " Doubt " ).
Belongs without a doubt on this list for her undeserved oscar in this movie!

Nobody is comparing her to Thatcher. But Meryl Streep is known to be a " perfectionist " ( I prefer to call her as " obsessive maniacal " ) and I'm sure she spend long days watching footages of Thather to get " into the skin " of Thatcher. And guess what, she didn't portray her very well! Second, the movie IS almost praising Thatcher and therefor not very realistic. Is all that oscar-worthy? And third, I understand better than you what movies are or what they means.

V 3 Comments
32 Art Carney - Harry and Tonto

This has to be in the top 10 undeserved ones.Jack Nicholson in Chinatown and Al Pacino in Godfather part 2 gave so much better performances

V 1 Comment
33 Hilary Swank - Million Dollar Baby

Hilary was great, but Kate Winslet was awesome in "Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind", and you know it.

She was good but Catalina Sandino Moreno in "Maria Full of Grace" was just phenomenal.

What a joke? All the four nominees were better than her that year.Her first Oscar is well deserved though.

Imelda Staunton should have won this year

34 Matthew McConaughey - Dallas Buyers Club

Losing 40 pounds may bring you an award... But not the respect from the audiences.

That guy sucks as an actor. Whoever gave him that Oscar should have his ass kicked. - MissionImpossible

Matt was really good, but Leo DiCaprio was better.

35 Sean Penn - Milk

It was a very great performance, but Mickey Rourke was heartbreaking in "The Wrestler".

He wouldn't be in the business if it weren't for his family. - MissionImpossible

One of the nost overrated actors ever. He is not as good as critics want us to think.

36 Julia Roberts - Erin Brockovich

She was OK, but Ellen Burstyn gave the best performance of the last decade. It was a shame!

For once I have to admid that her oscar for that movie was deserved. She's not one of my favorite actresses but she was really good in this film.

V 2 Comments
37 Judi Dench - Shakespeare in Love

She's only in the film for like 5 minutes, and she lacked character development and depth.

38 Whoopi Goldberg - Ghost Whoopi Goldberg - Ghost Caryn Elaine Johnson, known professionally by her stage name Whoopi Goldberg, is an American actress, comedian, and television host.

I love her in this film. Her role allowed to prove her ability to shine in a comedic role after her turn in a dramatic film.

V 2 Comments
39 Mira Sorvino - Mighty Aphrodite Mira Sorvino - Mighty Aphrodite Mira Katherine Sorvino is an American actress. She came to prominence after winning the Academy Award and Golden Globe for Best Supporting Actress for her performance as a hooker with a heart of gold in Woody Allen's Mighty Aphrodite.
40 Elizabeth Taylor - Butterfield 8 Elizabeth Taylor - Butterfield 8 Dame Elizabeth Rosemond Taylor, DBE (February 27, 1932 – March 23, 2011) was a British-American actress, businesswoman, and humanitarian. more.

Elizabeth Taylor herself didn't like the movie

PSearch List

Recommended Lists

Related Lists

Most Undeserving Best Picture Oscar Winners Top Ten Best Picture Oscar Winners Best Picture Oscar Winners That Didn't Deserve It Top 10 Best Picture Oscar Winners of the 2000s Most Overrated Best Picture Oscar Winners

List StatsUpdated 23 Aug 2017

700 votes
59 listings
8 years, 9 days old

Top Remixes

1. Roberto Benigni - Life Is Beautiful
2. Tommy Lee Jones - The Fugitive
3. Denzel Washington - Training Day
1. Gwyneth Paltrow - Shakespeare In Love
2. Denzel Washington - Training Day
3. Jennifer Lawrence - Silver Linings Playbook
1. Gwyneth Paltrow - Shakespeare In Love
2. Reese Witherspoon - Walk the Line
3. Anne Hathaway - Les Miserables



Add Post

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.