Top 10 Most Unoriginal Sonic Games

CaptainMowzker
This list is somewhat inspired by darthvadern's "Most Unoriginal Mario Games" list. With that being said, let's get started and get this over with. I'll be excluding Sonic games like Sonic 06, and Sonic Forces for this list because they offer a different and cool story.

The Top Ten

1 Sonic Shuffle

SEGA tried to make a series that was more well selling than Mario Party. - iliekpiez

A bad Mario Party clone... that sucks at being fun or something even worth coming back to. - CaptainMowzker

Because the Dreamcast failed :( It was an ok system... and this is a horrible game. - LightningStrike

2 Sonic Dash

Subway Surfers - Not_A_Weeaboo

A mobile app game, that suffers from the same clichés you'd expect and offers nothing interesting at all. - CaptainMowzker

3 Sonic Jump

Almost as bad as Sonic Dash... and again not very interesting or original at all. - CaptainMowzker

4 Sonic R

A bland racing game that lacks originality. - CaptainMowzker

I watched Nathaniel Bandy play this backwards and it looked just plain horrrible - darthvadern

I don't think it's unoriginal(Sonic Drift is more unoriginal in my eyes), but it still sucked regardless. - Drawbox

5 Sonic Forces

You mean Sonic Forces Speed Battle. The scoring system is horrible though. - Drawbox

It's about as original as a average mobile game... AKA not original at all. - CaptainMowzker

Pretty boring honestly. - TheDarkOne_221b

6 Sonic's Schoolhouse

Welcome to sonic's schoolhouse in education and learning. That's me! - LightningStrike

Aka one of the original Baldi's Basics in Education and Learning, without the jump scares and fourth wall breaks. - IceFoxPlayz

7 Team Sonic Racing

Calling any racing sonic game a mario kart ripoff is like saying Call of Duty is a wolfenstein ripoff. - B1ueNew

It's literally a Mario Kart rip off... for Christ's sake. - CaptainMowzker

Not out yet. But I will say I'm not so interested as I was SART. - Drawbox

Hey look it’s another Mario Kart rip-off! - Randomator

8 Sonic Pinball Party

Who the hell thought that a Sonic pinball game was a good idea?! And it's not any different from your average pinball game... but honestly Peggle is way more worth your time than this trite garbage. - CaptainMowzker

9 Sonic Labyrinth

It's basically just another Sonic Pinball game with a different title... - CaptainMowzker

10 Sonic Pinball

Wait... there's a game gear version? Seriously? - LightningStrike

*Facepalms* JUST WHY? - CaptainMowzker

The Contenders

11 Shadow the Hedgehog

Other than being edgy, it doesn't really play that different a average Sonic game... also it's not really that original to be honest. - CaptainMowzker

More like shadOW THE hEDGEhog. - Drawbox

12 Sonic the Hedgehog (Gameboy Advance)
13 Sonic Sega All Stars Racing

For a Mario Kart ripoff its actually pretty good. - egnomac

Also a bad Mario Kart rip off... - CaptainMowzker

This game looks great! - B1ueNew

Actually, Mario kind of ripped of the whole "crossover" concept in MK8. This game is actually pretty good, even if it takes inspiration from Mario. - Drawbox

V 1 Comment
14 Dr. Robotnik's Mean Bean Machine

It feels a bit too similar to Dr. Mario for my liking... - CaptainMowzker

15 Sonic the Fighters Sonic the Fighters

A fighting game that lacks any originality at all... also who the hell is Bean? - CaptainMowzker

16 Sonic Drift 2
17 Sonic Drift

This is an ACTUAL Mario clone, not even SSASR was this unoriginal. - Drawbox

I tried to add that to the list but it wouldn't let me for some reason, when I was making the original draft. - CaptainMowzker

18 Sonic Lost World

One part Super Mario Galaxy, one part Sonic X-Treme, with world themes copied from the New Super Mario Bros games (at least games like Sonic 06 tried to have their own identity with the levels). - SuperSonic17

19 Sonic the Hedgehog 4: Episode II

If Episode 1 was okay, then this game is horrible. - Drawbox

20 Sonic Colors

What's unoriginal about it? - CaptainMowzker

This is a good game. - B1ueNew

21 Sonic the Hedgehog 4: Episode I

Copies gameplay from the first 2 games... and feels rather stale. - CaptainMowzker

BAdd New Item
P