Top Ten Video Games Would You Rather Questions


The Top Ten

1 Would You Rather Play Superman 64 or E.T On the Atari 2600?

By far Superman 64, it sucks, but E.T. is one of the worst video games to ever be produced. - PackFan2005

E.T., Superman sucks 10x more than ET - Bboymakinwitthefrekfreak

I'd rather play superman 64.

Superman 64. Not because it’s good, but because I love seeing just how badly the game can be broken. - Zach808

V 3 Comments
2 Would You Rather Play First Person Shooter for 24 Hours or Play Role Playing Games for 24 Hours?

I would choose RPG - Martinglez

First person

RPG, many RPGs of today tend to have hours of content to keep me occupied. Most notably, Witcher 3 and Skyrim. - cjWriter1997

RPG - PackFan2005

V 2 Comments
3 Would You Rather Be the Hardcore Type or the Casual Fan?

If you wondering what I mean is someone who only knows the popular games, if you are Hardcore then your Hardcore and you've played a ton of games. - htoutlaws2012

I'm kind of already a more Hardcore type fan. - cjWriter1997

I would be hardcore - Martinglez

Casual, because I usually don’t want to be part of fans of certain things I like. - PackFan2005

V 2 Comments
4 Would You Rather Play Minecraft or Call of Duty?

Call of Duty, you at least have an objective where in Minecraft the goal is to build that's it. - htoutlaws2012

Minecraft, because more freedom of creativity I guess. - cjWriter1997

Call of Duty, Minecraft is for autistic 10 year olds - Bboymakinwitthefrekfreak

Well, both fanbases are bad, but if we’re basing it off of the game itself, I’m going Call of Duty. - PackFan2005

V 3 Comments
5 Would You Rather Watch a Good Cinematic Movie Game or a Bad One?

With a bad one, you can make fun of it throughout, so I go bad. - PackFan2005

Example: Wing Commander 3 is good, Night Trap is Bad. - htoutlaws2012

Bad one, just for the laughs - Bboymakinwitthefrekfreak

Good of coarse!

6 Would You Rather Play Online or Play by Yourself With No Internet?

I'm a single player guy, so definitely the latter - cjWriter1997

I tend to gravitate towards great single player experiences. Online communities are sometimes a bit... yeah. - Zach808

Now and days if you lived under a rock then the person like ''so what's new in gaming? '' - htoutlaws2012

I’m a solo person usually. - PackFan2005

7 Would You Rather Play the Mario Series or the Legend of Zelda Series?

Both are great Nintendo Franchises. If I had to pick between these two Icons I'd pick Mario and that would be very close. - htoutlaws2012

Depends on the game. They both have their classics and their uninspired rehashes. - Zach808

Pretty obvious choice for me, Zelda is one of my all-time favorite franchises. - cjWriter1997

Mario. - PackFan2005

V 4 Comments
8 Would You Rather Play the Newer Games or Older Classic Games?

I leaning more towards revisiting old classics then some of the newer hits. - htoutlaws2012

Older classic games.

I really love the PS2/Gamecube/Xbox era of games. Halo: Combat Evolved, Prince of Persia, Metroid Prime, Resident Evil 4 etc. - cjWriter1997

9 Would You Rather Play On a Sony Console or a Microsoft Console?

This is kinda hard depends on comparing systems you can go either way on this one. - htoutlaws2012

I own an Xbox 360 and a Windows PC but the latest Sony console I've played is a ps2 so Microsoft. - Skullkid755

Microsoft, but it’s close. - PackFan2005

PS2 or Xbox; PS2
PS3 or 360; Tough but probs PS3 because Infamous and Uncharted
PS4 or Xbox One; PS4 I guess although I mainly play PC now - cjWriter1997

10 Would You Rather Play the Underrated Games or Play the So Bad, But Good Games?

I would play the underrated ones - Martinglez

I played the underrated ones - TinyToonsGirl45

Easy underrated games - htoutlaws2012

Underrated. - PackFan2005

V 1 Comment

The Contenders

11 Would You Rather Play Street Fighter or Mortal Kombat?

Mortal Kombat, I mean yeah Street Fighter came first and all, but after maybe the third game I didn't care for them as hard as I did for Mortal Kombat. - htoutlaws2012

Mortal Kombat, but Tekken is more of my fighting game. - cjWriter1997

12 Would You Rather Watch the EA Conference from E3 or Watch the Ubisoft Conference from E3?

Ubisoft, last year there E3 conference was pretty decent - cjWriter1997


Oh god, anything but EA’s 2017 conference. That was BAD. - Zach808

After last year I will rather watch Ubisoft then EA ''SPORTS! SPORTS! SPORTS! '' - htoutlaws2012

13 Indie or AAA?

I've been playing way more indie games than I used to. AAA games have gotten pretty bad with all the repetitive cash cows and shady business practices. I've enjoyed games like Celeste and Cuphead better than the new Assassin's Creed which honestly got boring after the first few hours. - cjWriter1997

Depends on the game, and how much the publisher meddles with the game. This loot box craze needs to stop. - Zach808

14 Would You Rather Play Destiny 2 or Fortnite?

Both are nice but I'l go with Fortnite.-DarkBoi-X

15 Would You Rather Watch the Angry Video Game Nerd or TheAngryJoeShow?

AVGN is a distinctive selection, but I'd say him slightly although AngryJoe is no slouch either. - htoutlaws2012

AVGN easily. - Zach808

16 Would You Rather Have Sex With Samus Aran or Lara Croft?

Um...I'm a girl. So I'll choose Samus. - MeeMeeCandy777

I'll Take Samus anyday. - htoutlaws2012

Can I pick both? Lel - cjWriter1997

17 Would You Prefer Classic Sonic or Modern Sonic?

Classic hands down. Modern Sonic is just soulless and repetitive - cjWriter1997

Classic is far superior it ain't even funny allow me to give you an example.

STH 1, 2, 3, and even Adventure are all awesome games, and then take all the modern games like 06, Rise of Lyric, and all those others ones don't stack up well against those games. - htoutlaws2012

BAdd New Item

Related Lists

Top Ten Would You Rather Questions to Ask TopTenners Top 10 "Would You Rather" Questions to Ask People Top Ten Would You Rather Questions About Painful Risks to Ask TopTenners Top Ten Metallica "Would You Rather" Song Questions Top Ten Music Would You Rather Questions

List Stats

17 listings
2 years, 119 days old

Top Remixes

1. Would You Rather Play Superman 64 or E.T On the Atari 2600?
2. Would You Rather Play First Person Shooter for 24 Hours or Play Role Playing Games for 24 Hours?
3. Would You Rather Be the Hardcore Type or the Casual Fan?


Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.