Top Ten Warrior Cat Characters that Should Never Have Been Born
I had to use up my final vote... Look, nobody hate me here but I actually like Tigerstar. I don't love him, I don't hate him, I just like him. He's actually one of the only villains in the series that I like. I mean, take a walk in his paws! You wake up one day and your father decides he wants nothing to do with you, then your sister's die, and then your mom dies! So your dad left you, your sisters are dead, and your mom is dead, how would you react? You'd probably be angry too! I don't agree with all the things he's done, like killing Brindleface and crippling Brightheart, but I think his story is sad and I can relate to him in multiple ways. Tigerstar doesn't deserve all the hate he gets, he's actually an interesting cat! There's better cats in Warriors, like Briarlight and Jayfeather, but there's also worse, like Darktail and Skystar. -FeirceheartOfThunderClan
If Tigerstar was taught differently, he would've been a different cat. Why so much hate? I love him!
There's a prophecy about it in Bluestar's Super Edition. Goosefeather says he "should have never survived."
He literally was never meant to be born.
I remember when Yellowfang said he wished she was Firestar's / Fireheart/ Firepaws mother or something like that! Eve his own mother wishes he was not born
Poor Yellowfang,
Her birth broke the warrior code, and she killed Ashfur in fear of him revealing the truth over her family. She lived in the tunnels for a while, before rejoining ThunderClan. Hollyleaf was slain by Hawkfrost and spent her last moments with her mother Leafpool saying her last words ”I couldn’t bear to… to leave without knowing my mother.” ...read more.
Okay people! Try comparing Stonefur and Hollyleaf! Stonefur died protecting Feathertail and Stormfur while Hollyleaf left Lionblaze and Jayfeather to fend for themselves! I hate HOLLYLEAF!
What?! Hollyleaf is awesome, people! If there was someone who shouldn't have been born out of the tree, than it's the Mary Sue and brat, dovewing!
Look, I LOVE Hollyleaf, but I had to vote for someone and this one is legit. Her birth was litteraly an accident, it was against the code, and she should never have been born. I'm glad she was because she's AMAZING, but I can't say she should've been born because then I would be lying, her birth was an accident, so she litteraly never should've been born. Like, legit. -FeirceheartOfThunderClan
What is wrong with you?!
He has has a broken life.
Nah, tigerstar was gonna be evil anyway. It was a prophecy in Pinestars book.
If it weren't for him, Tigerstar wouldn't be evil.
Hawkfrost is now my mate he is the best
"he was okay in starlight...now I hate him
Ugh... Give him a break. 1. He used to be a really fierce warrior. 2. Who would let another cat destroy their herbs when leaf-bare is coming?! Obviously WindClan would be angry that Pinestar was leading an attack when they didn't do anything to provoke ThunderClan! If you want to blame someone, blame Goosefeather!
Hawkheart used to be a warrior before he chose the life of a medicine cat! It says so in one of the books. Also, his medicine supplies were under attack. That medicine could have helped in the future. Of course he had to attack Moonflower. Sure her death was sad, but would we have cared if the character was a side character? Hawkheart wasn’t bad, now stop saying he was bad because of a single cat’s death.
Oh my god if you say that "he wasn't bad" I will go like crazy each time I see your name. medicine cats don't KILL they cure..
He killed Bluestar's mother.
I want to know more about Breezepelt. Deep down he is a good cat. - sunheart360
I hate breezepelt
If it weren't for her, Scourge would not have been the way he is.
Dovewing should die people I hope that in the next battle of warrior cats she will die or someone would shove deathberries up her throat
I like her, but I don't think she should be leader/deputy/warrior.I think it would be better if she was kit/queen/elder/apprentice forever
Dovewing is a literal Mary Sue, she whines and complains while her sister is flipping spying and infiltrating cat hell and getting almost killed, like, bruh,
I MEAN REALLY WHY BRUH, YOU GET STARRY EYED FOR SOME TIGER LOOKINg TOM AND YOU BE LIKE: IMA GO LIVE WITH THEM NOW BUH BYE bruh. Bruh.
I hate her! She needs to go die a horrible death!
SPOILERS FOR A VISION OF SADOWS ARC(I think the reason he's not too far up is because A Vision of Shadows is a new book series, sort of)
He destroyed Shadowclan for a few books and also made Mistystar decide to close Riverclan's borders. He also made warriors in Shadowclan turn against Rowanclaw. He helped drown Needletail. He almost killed Violetshine. He drove out Riverclan for a moment.
How is he not further up?
Appledusk betrayed mapleshade
Look I know she did some pretty horrible things, but it was all Appledusk’s fault.
He was ruthless and bloodthirsty. He lived in the early days of the warrior clans. -sunheart360
Ivypoop needs to die a horrible death while Dovewing becomes Dovestar.
She is soo misunderstood.
The worst cat to ever live!
He wanted Dovewing to be hid mate even though she had no interest. In the Forgotten Warrior he sleeps in the apprentice den because there was a "leak" that only affected him. Weird.
I love Dovewing, everyone hates Dovewing because she was mean to Bumble. But Bumblestripe tried to force Dovewing into a relationship she didn’t want. Imagine if that was happening to you! You’d me mean too.
There are many Bluestar lovers who hate Bluestar haters so they are haters too and do not say that haters are stupid. But Bluestar lovers, you don't like brave Swiftpaw, poor Brightheart or cute Snowkit, YOU DON'T LIKE THEM?
There are many Bluestar lovers who wants DEATH of us (Bluestar haters) and they say that we hate Bluestar and love Scourge, Thistlclaw or Tigerstar, but that is not TRUE. I hate Bluestar but I don't like Brokenstar, Darkstripe and Tigerstar but I like Scourge because he killed Tigerstar. LOGIC.
Bluestar should never be born!
He made Tallstar hurt. He felt as though he really was a worm-cat