Top Ten Warrior Cats Who Shouldn't Have DiedWolftail
The Top Ten
I was so sad that Honeyfern died! She is a much better mate to Berrynose than Poppyfrost. I feel bad for Poppyfrost because Berrynose only seems to love her because he loved Honeyfern and the sisters are alike. I wish she never died!
If Honeyfern didn't die, Berrynose would have a higher reputation and would probably be a nicer cat, Poppyfrost would get a better mate, Jayfeather wouldn't have gone to the Moonpool and be attacked by Breezepelt, and Hollyleaf wouldn't have been able to threaten Leafpool with the deathberries. - Wolftail
She should not have died! She saved briarkits life but briarkit/paw/light was going to get paralyzed anyway so it seemed like a waste:'(!
What with the deathberrys - kittymittens2014
Silverstream SHOULD NOT HAVE EVER EVER DIED! She would have made a FANTASTIC mom for Feathertail and Stormfur, and even loved Graystripe enough that she was trying to get to ThunderClan to join it right as she began her kitting (where she also died, so sad)! Silverstream was so wonderful and sweet, I wish that she had made it to ThunderClan. That way she and Graystripe could have spent their entire lives together as they should have. I think that Millie is an AWESOME and brave character, and I'm for her and Graystripe as best friends, I just wish they weren't a couple.
She died kitting! She would have been a wonderful mother and mate, and I guess every reader of Warriors wanted to see her have a longer appearance in the books. - Wolftail
She is much better than Millie
I'm glad she kitted :3 otherwise feathertail and stormfur would never had been born and the cats may never had moved to the lake
I wish he did not die, we will remember you shrew paw
He was only trying to feed his clan! - Wolftail
Personally, that death was unecessary. Sorry.
Shrewpaw was a noble cat. I f I were leader, I'd have named him Shrewtail.
Snowfur should've realized her Thistleclaw mistake at least before she died... - SeeU
For this I blame Bluestar. If she got Snowfur to take a walk with her the day before or after Snowfur's death, Snowfur would have probably had a longer life. - Wolftail
Snowfur shouldn't have died... she lived such a short life!
Bluestar chouldent tell the fuser - kittymittens2014
Tigerstar's sisters. If they hadn't have died, Tigerstar would probably have been a better cat. - Wolftail
Ha she shouldn't have died! Look Firestar is waay down there because he died a death that had to happen! - Catsarah123V 2 Comments
She shouldn't have died, either time
Her death... So sad. - Badgerflame
Stupid Clawface! But Fire x Spotted would have caused a lot of problems... And it would have distracted Firepaw/heart/star from the prophecy. - Wolftail
I agree-she shoudn't have died, but when she took her own starclan life for Firestar, now that is a truw symbol of love.
I wonder if starclan cats go somewhere else when they die, or just not exist... - SeeU
I agree. If she had lived, well, first hadn't been dumped, she wouldn't die, she would be happier, and the following wouldn't have died: Spottedleaf (second time, I cried) I forget the name of everyone in Crookedstars famile other than Silverstream - AnonymousChick
If Appledusk hadn't of complimented the kits none of it would have happened.
Shellheart, and Minnowkit
It was willowbreez, willowkit, oakheart, rainflower, the dad (don't rember his name) other kit, and hailstar. Any body named willow is dead and cursed.V 1 Comment
Fell off a cliff during the journey to the lake. - Wolftail
We don't know if he died though. I even read a fanfic about his life afterward - ruJILLousV 2 Comments
Hit by a falling tree. - Wolftail
She's loyal and has proven herself. She should be #1
Hollyleaf was redeemed and then hung up to dry a second time. It's honestly a little ridiculous.
She shouldn't of died... ;(
People hate her because she killed Ashfur. UM ASHFUR TRIED TO KILL HER AND HER FAMILY! Yet, people love him. He also tried to kill her grandfather, not that she knew though.
She killed Ashfur to save her family, and she only told the secret because she couldn't hide it any longer.
She came back from the tunnels and taught the clans tunnel fighting moves, therefore saving them from Windclan. Then, she helped the clan fight Dark Forest and saved Ivypool.
Then she forgave Leafpool. HOW INNOCENT CAN YOU BE?!?
Darkstripe might have died and he and his sis with their apprentices would escape un harmed - AnonymousChick
Stonefur is just innocent. He have done nothing wrong! He was the best. - Tigertail
Really? Number 10? He died because he didn't want to fight Graystripes kits, even though it meant dying himself. How noble. - Minecraftcrazy530
Stonefur was amazing! We hardly knew him at all, yet he is really loved all because he was willing to be killed for two apprentices! He was so noble and should've lived longer :(
Me kill cold weather that kill kitten.
Mosskit had it all to make a great Warrior.Do Erin Hunter really had to kill her? She was too young to die also it's kinda unfair that more than 1000 kits dies on the series.
I like CRIED! He was just a kit...;(;(;(;(;(
Why did FireStar have to die? Cause the reader sort of gets feelings for FireStar (not that way ) which makes It when he dies usually the reader would just cry a little like I did
He dident need to die but I know why he died he was in too many books when I ack erin hunter - kittymittens2014
He died when he just became deputy. He was a great warrior, he did not deserve to die.
Yes she was a good cat - kittymittens2014
YELLOWFANG WAS AWESOME she totally didn't deserve to die ( to be honest I like her better than Cinderpelt)
She was a great cat I know she had her times but she saved lots of cats - kittymittens2014
No why did all my favourites DIE!
I HATE clear sky with a passion he's Stupid!V 3 Comments
What the dark forest is that
Who even IS Unicornheart?
Who is this cat? - Walla
Great StarClan, who is this? - IcetailofWishClanV 2 Comments
Dark tabby she-cat, killed by a bear while trying to save her son Forestkit.
Forestkit? No offense Gary Stu name. Otherwise she seems good.
nice - kittymittens2014
Related ListsWarrior Cats that Died in Horrible Ways Top Ten Things That Shouldn't Have Happened In Warrior Cats Top Ten Warrior Cats that Should Have Died Top 10 Kits and Apprentices in Warrior Cats Who Died Warrior Cats Who Died the Most Wistful Ways
List StatsUpdated 16 Oct 2017
3 years, 34 days old