Top Ten Ways Anthrax is Better Than SlayerNightmareCinema I’m gonna get crucified for this list, but I don’t particularly care. I’m used to being crucified over criticizing Slayer in any way, shape, or form.
Well, once again, the title mostly explains. Don’t throw a hissy fit, this is just my opinion.
Anyway... I’ve actually wanted to make this list for a long time. Since my days as CostcoHotDogs, actually. But I never got around to it. But now that I’m less bad at making lists, I think I’ll take a crack at it.
Now, without further adieu, this is why I think Anthrax craps on Slayer, any day of the week.
The Top Ten
Anthrax had a rough time after Scott Ian kicked Joey Belladonna out of the band back in the 90’s, but they still churned out some great songs with John Bush on vocals, Black Lodge, Inside Out, and the list goes on. Slayer? I kinda like Undisputed Attitude... Diabolus In Musica and Divine Intervention are just bad. Their material in the 2000’s was just kinda eh...and Anthrax is better than ever now that Joey is back in the fold. Which is more than can be said for Slayer, cause I don’t think they’re getting Jeff Hanneman and Dave Lombardo back anytime soon for obvious reasons, especially considering the band is retiring after one final world tour. Anthrax, though, is still going strong to this very day. - NightmareCinema
Bringing up a single album that is considered bad is not good enough in terms of refuting the point that was made, which was that Anthrax have been more consistent overall. As it was said, Slayer have made some very poor albums as well, and their current material isn't up to the standard that it once was, while Anthrax have continued to be going strong today. By simply bringing up a single bad album from Anthrax, you are simply neglecting large aspects of the point made in an attempt to make your opinion seem like the only one that matters. - kempokid
Sure, Slayer tried nu metal with Diabolus In Musica and punk with Undisputed Attitude, but they kinda suck. Anthrax tried nu metal as well, but they’ve also tried groove metal, trad heavy metal, punk, and of course, pure thrash. Slayer has only really tried three genres: thrash metal, punk, and nu metal. Apart from that, Slayer rarely tries anything new and the rest of their discography all sounds exactly the same with slight variations. Which segues into the next thing... - NightmareCinema
Like mentioned above, Anthrax has done more genres than Slayer has, but that’s only part of what makes them more varied. They have more lyrical subject matters, more creative guitar work, and pretty much everything about Anthrax is less repetitive than Slayer. They’re almost impervious to variation. And don’t give me the “Hell Awaits is an accurate depiction of Hell, South Of Heaven is more atmospheric, and Reign In Blood is a brutal thrashfest, man! ” argument. Those are only slight variations, not enough to make Slayer a varied band in general. - NightmareCinema
Lyrically, the only subject matters Slayer really sings about are, you know, Satanic crap like in Hell Awaits, mutilations, the Holocaust, and just...uncreative crap that’s been done to death. I wouldn’t have such a problem with it if they actually DID something with it rather than just doing the same thing every other extreme metal band did. There’s exceptions, like there is with everything, but Slayer is mostly just bland. It gets old. Anthrax has sung about a ton of subject matters, ranging from Judge Dredd to Ronnie James Dio and Dimebag Darrell. I could give you a lot of other topics Anthrax has touched upon past those two examples, but then we’d be here all day. Onto the next entry. - NightmareCinema
Yeah, Anthrax almost created nu metal and rap metal (was this a good thing for the metal genre? No.), while Slayer almost created death metal. - Metal_Treasure
Dave Lombardo is nothing special as a drummer. He can play really fast and do double bass really fast and that’s about it. Not much else of note about him. But Charlie Benante? That guy is amazing. He can do double bass like no other (save for Mike Portnoy, of course), and he can generally destroy Lombardo any day.
As for guitar work...Kerry King is a wanker! He can’t write solos for crap. Jeff Hanneman could, Seasons In The Abyss for example, but he always seemed to take a backseat to Kerry King. Anthrax doesn’t have the strongest guitar solos, but their new lead guitarist, Jonathan Donais is really good at writing solos and they still have a lot of other strong solos without him. And as for the riffs, I’d say Anthrax has it in the bag for this one as well. There’s so many examples. Breathing Lightning has a better riff than Repentless, Caught In A Mosh has a better riff than Raining Blood, etc.
And when we get to bass...oh god. Anthrax wins this one easily. Tom ...more - NightmareCinema
Oh man, the riff to Raining Blood is the most copied metal riff of all time. It's because metal musicians think the riff to Caught In A Mosh is better, I guess. - Metal_Treasure
I know Anthrax can be a pretty damn funny band who don’t take themselves seriously all the time, but when they do, the listener can take them seriously as well. I can rarely ever listen to Slayer without at least chuckling at them. Because they’re just that ridiculous. Them taking themselves so seriously results in me not being able to take them seriously. Especially when Tom Araya does the Angel Of Death scream. That is just comedy gold, right there. - NightmareCinema
Nah, I'll tell ya what's comedy gold - a band from the Big 4 of Thrash (Anthrax), making the song Bring The Noise with Public Enemy. Now, that's what I call comedy gold, right there. - Metal_Treasure
Joey can sound genuinely aggressive without sounding laughable. Angel Of Death scream, or Caught In A Mosh?
(Before you say it, no, the Angel Of Death scream isn’t awesome. It’s hilarious.)
I could give you a laundry list of times Tom Araya tried to sound aggressive and failed miserably, Angel Of Death, Raining Blood, pretty much anything from the Reign In Blood album, and in Hell Awaits, the backing vocals and chanting are scarier than Tom Araya. I think I’ve said enough. - NightmareCinema
I know this doesn’t have anything to do with the music, but I really, REALLY want to take a shot at Slayer fanboys.
Oh my god...I have seen some BAD metal fanbases, but none like Slayer. Not even Megadeth fanboys are this bad, and that says a lot. They’re so obsessive and defensive of Slayer. If you say literally ANYTHING negative about Slayer, they get absurdly defensive over it, even if it’s just criticism. It’s rage inducing. Anthrax fans are the most civil of the Big 4’s fanbases. They may have somewhat violent live shows, but other than that, I haven’t seen anything about Anthrax fans and I haven’t had any bad encounters with their fans. I’ve had bad encounters with fans of all three others of the Big 4. - NightmareCinema
Not a valid reason. When people will start to separate the artist's work from the fanbase? - Metal_Treasure
This sorta ties in with the item about consistency, but I still think it’s a strong enough reason to get an entry of its own.
Lately, mostly in the 21st century, Slayer has just been...eh. Not good, not horrendous, but just...average to mediocre. Anthrax, on the other hand, has gotten better from their days with John Bush. They still had some good material there, but it was kind of a low point in their career. They’ve made Worship Music, which was an amazing album and For All Kings, which I believe is my favorite Anthrax album to date. That’s how much I love it. Slayer, though? Nah. They’ve only been producing the same record over and over again, just wish a slightly different style. - NightmareCinema
What I mean is, Anthrax is still the same thrash metal band they were back in the 80’s. They’re still producing kickass thrash record after kickass thrash record. Tying back into consistency yet again, Slayer isn’t really Slayer anymore. They’re just not the same band they used to be at all. And not in a good way.
I love Slayer’s old records, Seasons In The Abyss, Hell Awaits, South Of Heaven and the debut, but even those are kind of patchy, except for Seasons. There’s also the Haunting The Chapel EP. But they’re just not who they used to be at all, really...
Anyway, I guess that concludes this list. See you next time, I guess. - NightmareCinema
This item is ridiculous.
1) where did you find the information about the time these bands put into their music? Updated numbers as of 2018, please.
2) why do you think that playing faster and heavier doesn't need time (practice and rehearsals)? Actually it might need more time
3) "Anthrax puts time into their music". But Slayer write and play their music beyond time? - Metal_Treasure
This is true. Anthrax music is less heavy. Many of their songs aren't thrash metal. But accessibility isn't always a good thing in metal. Sometimes it means selling out. - Metal_Treasure
Mainly due to how Slayer is more explicit.
Related ListsBest Albums Between Slayer and Anthrax Best Songs Between Slayer and Anthrax Best Songs Between Slayer, Megadeth, and Anthrax Most Underrated Anthrax and Slayer Songs Top Ten Albums Between Metallica, Slayer, and Anthrax
168 days old
2. Anthrax is more experimental
3. Anthrax is more varied than Slayer