Top 10 Ways Big Nate is Better Than Diary of a Wimpy Kid

I prefer reading Big Nate books rather than Wimpy Kid books for a few reasons.

The Top Ten

1 Better protagonist

Nate can be a jerk at times, but he cares about his friends. Greg just uses his friends.

Greg is condescending, uses people to get his way, and is pure arrogance at its finest. Nate, while kind of arrogant, is still respectful towards his friends and tries to be a good guy.

Nate can be a jerk sometimes but Greg is a pretty cool guy. But both of them are cool. - AlphaQ

2 Big Nate didn't lose its continuity

Big nate rules it's awsem.

Greg is supposed to be in high school (I'm not getting into why I think that, figure it out yourself), but he's still in middle school, and there's no plot point where he gets held back. Big Nate didn't have continuity to start with, so it couldn't lose any in the first place.

Fair point on continuity, it is true neither have continuity, but Wimpy Kid had some for a bit, then lost it at book 7.

3 Better recurring cast

It seems like there's a new cast every book in Wimpy Kid, which also goes under "loss of continuity." Plus, everyone is awful in their own ways, and not a single character seems to be decent at all. Big Nate has its likable characters, and very few characters to hate.

Francis and Teddy are much more likable than Rowley and Rodick. - AlphaQ

4 Better plots

Books 1-4 were pretty original with their ideas. The rest were pretty dull. - Not_A_Weeaboo

I've noticed in the newer Wimpy Kid books there seems to be a new story with every 10-20 pages. At least in Big Nate they can focus on just one main plot point each book.

5 Big Nate is realistic

If you read The Third Wheel, you'd probably agree. I read The Long Haul, it felt like reading the diary of a cartoon character rather than a realistic fiction book. And then there's Old School, arguably even less realistic. Big Nate actually feels like reading from the perspective of a 2000's preteen, and I felt like I could actually jump into that world.

6 Wimpy Kid books add random plot points not seen in previous books, Big Nate doesn't

That's amazing

There seems to be a bunch of random flashbacks to scenes Greg never mentioned in previous books. This would go under "better plots" but I decided to give this its own mention.

7 Nate is a better artist than Greg

I feel kinda stupid saying it, but hey, I should. Nate is much better at drawing than Greg. It seems like everyone in Greg's world got mutated into weird alien looking creatures. Everyone in Nate's world just looks almost the same on paper.

8 Big Nate is more grounded

I hate it

Big Nate's humor is a lot more of sarcasm and a lot less slapstick than Wimpy Kid, and Nate definitely isn't as stupid as Greg. Plus, Big Nate books normally only focus on a single story, while Wimpy Kid books are beginning to just have jumbled plot points that seem to be out of the blue.

9 Big Nate came first

The chapter books are trash, but the comic books have actual humor! - awesomedp900

The novels came later, but the original comic strips date back to the 90's. Goes to show sometimes you just can't run out of ideas.

10 Better characters

The Contenders

11 Big Nate has more likable characters
12 Big Nate is funnier

Wimpy Kid books are just not really funny, they seem to aim way too much at slapstick. Big Nate has its combination of slapstick and other types of comedy.

I love both series, but this list was awesome. Good job! - BlueTopazIceVanilla

13 Greg is a jerk


BAdd New Item