Top Ten Ways Why Sally Acorn Is Better Than Amy Rose

TwilightKitsune

The Top Ten

1 She doesn't scream

Who cares. Rouge The bat screams and everyone loves her! - AngelOfTheSkyStarsMoon

"Sigh" This list is really dumb. These are all silly reasons. I like both girls. I would say the same thing if this list was called (reasons why amy rose is better then sally acorn.) This list is kinda fan bratty and Amy isn't a "useless character" Amy has her own team called team rose. Its honestly sad that people like this still exist today. Why can't people just respect people who like Amy. And why can't people who like Sally be respected. I've been bashed for liking Amy a few times. And this list disgust me. Plus what does "humping sonics leg" even mean? If you really hate Amy, then stick with SatAM and archie so you don't have to see Amy.If you hate Sally, Then just stick with the games. Since these characters are "SOOO BAD! D:" I just want peace in the fanbase. People like this makes me wanna leave the fanbase. Is it so hard to respect others opinions? Once again I like Amy and Sally so I'm not taking sides here.

And she stands up to bad guys like Eggman!

I hate both characters.

4 Comments
2 She doesn't hump Sonic's leg

Neither does Blaze The Cat. ❤ - AngelOfTheSkyStarsMoon

3 Sally is a princess

A princess? I never heard of her being a princess. :/ - Videogamesgal

So is Cream. Her mother Vanilla is a Queen. ❤ - AngelOfTheSkyStarsMoon

Christ, it's "Dora Is a Girl" all over again!

4 She doesn't claim Sonic as hers

Neither does Tikal. - AngelOfTheSkyStarsMoon

exactly

You know who else would do the same thing? Serena from Pokémon in the anime! And Chris Thorndyke! And Kootie Pie Koopa!

5 Amy Rose is a useless character

Amy is not useless and neither is Sally. They are both awesome and this list is dumb. - AngelOfTheSkyStarsMoon

Sally only appeared like once. Amy can fight and be swag unlike Sally.

Amy is a girly and annoying addition to Sonic CD. Dude, Sally was Sonic's girlfriend before but why Amy?

Amy Rules! Sally Acorn Drools! because Amy Is Better Than Sally And Sally Is really Bad And A Useless Dumb CHARACTER!

6 She's not spoiled

Neither is Maria. - AngelOfTheSkyStarsMoon

7 Nobody loves Amy in Sonic

I like Amy! I like her much more than Sally! - Videogamesgal

I hate her! - SuperBreakSonic

Tails loves Amy and has a thing for her. They eventually get married ❤ - AngelOfTheSkyStarsMoon

Also, Wave has a thing for Amy as well. ❤ - AngelOfTheSkyStarsMoon

4 Comments
8 She leads Freedom Fighters

Not anymore. Julie-Su leads them now. - AngelOfTheSkyStarsMoon

9 Amy Rose deserves to die

No she doesn't. And Neither does Princess Elise. - AngelOfTheSkyStarsMoon

You can't kill people over the internet, Psycho (Took me several attempts to say Psycho correctly). Just because she has an obsession doesn't mean you should go THAT Far, like seriously she is twelve years old and might be in a phase. You can't kill her for that, nor in general for that matter. - Qryzx

Well, I think Sally Acorn is the most forgotten Sonic Characters now. And... Ok... Back in Sonic Generations, how did she not appear in this game if this is bringing back the old levels game. She would of appeared as her 3D self and not fan made. Ok... Back in topic, in the future. What if Sally Acorn Replaced Amy and like she wears a blue princess dress (not Rosalina's dress) and not make it girlier and a nicer voice act by not dropping her voice down. And she has more skills than Amy. That's my idea for sega

Amy does not I hate you Sally deserves to die not Amy

3 Comments
10 Sally saves people

So does Lara-su. - AngelOfTheSkyStarsMoon

Amy doesn't?

The Contenders

11 Sally is more sexy

Mina Mongoose is sexy ❤ - AngelOfTheSkyStarsMoon

Not that I have anything against Amy, but there's no denying that Sally is definitely more sexy. Out of the two, Sally is presented as more mature and compassionate, not to mention shapely in all the right ways. Add to that the fact that she rocked the classic "bottomless" look like no other female Sonic character ever has, which not only helped draw more attention to her lean physique than anything else and perfectly sum up her "no nonsense" personality, but also showed that the people at DiC were willing to push the envelope with Sonic SatAM (until the IDW comics did her character a major disservice, that is), and it's no wonder why she's garnered such a dedicated fan following.

LOL, um, no.

Sally Acorn is just wearing a tiny vest she probably wore for 5 years. - Qryzx

This is the wierdest part of the lists - Carsrule300

1 Comment
12 Amy Rose is the most overrated Sega character

So is Cosmo. - AngelOfTheSkyStarsMoon

Modern Sally Acorn is a close second and not the best female Sonic character. Blaze the Cat is.

No she is underrated Sally sucks Amy is the best

The only reason sally loves sonic is because of his super speed powers,sally is nothing but a flirter who wishes to have for herself cause his a popular hero and I hate her for that is reason 1.
reason 2 she wanted a relationship with him so others will think of her in an incredible way as in being oh am sonic's gril so no one touches me, some thing like as also an additional fake title.
reason 3 is that she is such a show off.
If you don't about what I say of sally then,i give an assignment to watch the film "SONIC THE HEDGHOG" and observ her grilly cooing whenever sonic saves from robotnik or when sonic or some one in the freedom fighter does some thing brave,she rewards them with her flirt kisses on the cheek.😠👎
i prefer amy rose although she can be stuburn atimes but due to my observation she is may be naive and anoying but she show pasion,love and caring for sonic and smid to love him with nor with out his powers but trys to confess to sonic although he run away ...more

13 Amy is a stalker and a rapist

Well. Sonia stalked her for a while too. - AngelOfTheSkyStarsMoon

How loud is Amy Rose's voice anyways.

I mean, stalker makes sense, but RAPIST?
How? - Qryzx

Um...this sounds racist

14 Sally actually kissed Sonic

Okay? And Amy kissed Knuckles. So ha! - AngelOfTheSkyStarsMoon

15 Sally is prettier

Rouge is pretty. - AngelOfTheSkyStarsMoon

16 Sally Acorn was Sonic's girlfriend

Okay? And Amy was Sonic's girlfriend as well. And guess what? She also dated Shadow and Cream. So yeah. She gets more love interests than Sally because more people like her. - AngelOfTheSkyStarsMoon

Unlike Amy Sonic was legitimately happy to be with Sally, now Amy, every time he sees her he looks like he wants to kill himself. on top of that Sally and Sonic have kissed and showed they loved each other on multiple occasions. when has Sonic and Amy ever done that that isn't a fan fiction?

Right and then they made amy a chearcter in the show and now she replaced sally acorn because everyone thinks sonic is with amy just because he saved her in sonic boom. it shows no proof! sonic is 15, amy is 12, amy is too young for sonic

17 Sally isn't a fangirl

Sally is a Silver fangirl actually. And also Maria. - AngelOfTheSkyStarsMoon

Amy "loves" Sonic to the point of being a stupid yandere while Sonic and Sally are honestly true love.

Which causes Amy Rose to be unfairly overrated. >:(

18 Amy is stupid

She's not stupid. Charmy and Cosmo worship her! - AngelOfTheSkyStarsMoon

19 Classic Sally Acorn is extremely skillful and does not rely on anyone to rescue her

Neither does Breezie. - AngelOfTheSkyStarsMoon

20 Sally is more mature

Tikal is mature. - AngelOfTheSkyStarsMoon

I agree, Amy is very immature, whiny, spoiled, and emotional. Sally is more focused on the job, takes care of her kingdom, and isn’t so clingy

21 Sally can defend herself without having an emotional breakdown

So can Amy! - AngelOfTheSkyStarsMoon

In sonic x amy kills the robot because it crushed her stupid bracelet hallelujah she killed it. But sally on the other hand fights metal sonic for her life. Not for a bracelet made out of sea shells 😒

I agree! Amy only fights for real when she's out of it. Sally can fight shes so amazing I love Sally. Have you seen amy in sonic CD? Crying and whining like a baby oh sonic I love you and in the comics WA I WANNA BE A FREEDOM FIGHTER

And Sally doesn't stalk sonic. SEGA put Sally in more games! Put her in the movie! I feel like everyone hates Sally but me! 😡

I ask my friends who their favorite
sonic girl is and their like amyyy

I say ok nice I like Sally acorn and they look at me like I'm from planet stupid and their like who? I'm like Sally is so underrated! I wish people esp. SEGA respected her😭

22 Sally is chill.

I like this! Very true.

So is Barby Koala. - AngelOfTheSkyStarsMoon

The reason why I say that is cause she is brave and caring cause she doesn't let people turn her down to dust. Also, I think she is caring because she cares about other people if they are nice to her back. She is a great character! 😀

23 Sally acorn is not a coward.

Neither is Conquering Storm. - AngelOfTheSkyStarsMoon

Neither is Bernadette. - AngelOfTheSkyStarsMoon

Amy is kinda a coward. If she gets sonic mad, she freaks out. She apologizes and agrees with sonic, whether or not she wants to...

But Sally is not afraid to state her opinion or be fiesty! When Sonic was being a jerk, Sally slapped him. For a good reason. She is NOT a mean character. She is just brave.

But Amy would never do that. She usually is scared to disagree with sonic. She chased him with her hammer in sonic x, but wasent gunna actually hit him. Amy kinda lets sonic walk all over her, without a thought about herself...

24 Sally Acorn didn't furiously accuse anyone for doing what she forced him/her to do

Neither did Cosmo. - AngelOfTheSkyStarsMoon

25 Sally doesn't get treated like a damsel in distress

Neither does Cream. - AngelOfTheSkyStarsMoon

Sally is the best - Carsrule300

26 Sally Acorn could kill Amy Rose

Honey The Cat could kill Sally. She actually tried to by the way because Sally was getting on her nerves. - AngelOfTheSkyStarsMoon

27 Sally is a pretty name

Twilight kitsune I feel so sorry that people hater you a lot, I will stick up for you, your rainbow dash hate lists may drive others anger but I agree I hate rainbow dash but I know that rainbow dash haters may be mean but I am not harsh or any thing about rainbow dash plus I am not into girl shows that much! But I love this list Sally is my all time fave classic female she may be mean in the comics but I love classic Sally and new Sally. Plus I’m a tomboy same as Sally! Amy is just a rip-off Amy rose should sit and see teen titans go but I also think she cries a lot like tabby form pleasant goat and big big wolf ( cartoon in China) but I understand why Amy rose is a fat brat she is also so UGH she was cute as a classic Amy but the modern one was so bratty like rainbow dash you rock keep this list up your lists are not Crap😇. Also I think. Amy looks like a little girl with furry like style than a hedgehog with a dress. Yes Sally may be a furry these days but the fans think she is ...more

28 Sally is Older

Julie-Su is older than Sally. - AngelOfTheSkyStarsMoon

29 Amy stole Sonic from Sally

Sally stole Lara-Le from Amy. - AngelOfTheSkyStarsMoon

Sally and sonic were the first couple but then, the little pink fangirl came in and basically kicked sally out of the way so she can be with sonic, who doesn't like her that way! amy rose should have died in the shark tank in sonic x! 😒😠😡

30 Sally is a leader

In sonic exe, Sally, Amy, and Cream are all trying to survive, but sally is more of the leader than either of them. She can fight, she is confident, she is bad@$$ and she's brave. Amy is there. Cream at least tries to save her poor mother! And, she refuses Merely's protection and risks her life to find her mom and her friends. But still, Sally is a fighter. Amy is rather useless in this game...

So is Lara-Su. - AngelOfTheSkyStarsMoon

31 Sally respects Sonic's wishes

If sonic wants to be left alone, sally respects his wishes and leaves. Amy doesn't. Amy will either act like he said nothing or take it personally, thinking he's mad at her (he very well could be considering how ANNOYING amy is), but she just doesn't give him any space! I would NEVER date someone like that if you paid me!

Lumina Flowlight and Big The Cat respects Amy's wishes. - AngelOfTheSkyStarsMoon

32 Amy Uses the Ring of Acorns to Wish Herself as a Teen

Based off of the Archie Comics, Amy begs Sally to go on a mission with the freedom fighters then she grumpily trudges and ran into where the ring of acorns was stored. Then she wishes then a blinding light flashes then Amy is now a teenager. In Issue 142, she became an official freedom fighter. - SuperBreakSonic

Sally only did that to Amy because Maria did it to Sally first. - AngelOfTheSkyStarsMoon

33 Sally is a realist

Sally takes things seriously. Amy is a goofball. Sally is also more daring. She stood up and fought for her kingdom. In sonic forces amy just stood there, waiting to die from the sun. I like Amy, but she isn't really much of a realist.

So is Marine The Raccoon. - AngelOfTheSkyStarsMoon

BAdd New Item

Related Lists

Why Princess Peach is Way Better Than Amy Rose Top 10 Reasons Why Amy Rose Is Cuter Than Yoshi Top Ten Reasons Why Amy Rose Sucks Top 10 Best Mario Characters to Rival Amy Rose Top 10 Best Future Designs for Amy Rose the Hedgehog

List Stats

33 listings
4 years, 109 days old

Top Remixes

1. Sally is a princess
2. She's not spoiled
3. She doesn't scream
TwilightKitsune
1. She doesn't hump Sonic's leg
2. She doesn't scream
3. Amy Rose is a useless character
cosmo

WRemix

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.