Why Princess Peach is Way Better Than Amy Rose

The Top Ten
1 Peach doesn’t beg for Mario to marry her unlike Amy

Before commenting, I just want to say that even though I think Peach gets way too much hate, I think Amy is still a much better character. Maybe this list will give some interesting arguments for thinking otherwise!...

I understand why you would say that Amy is worst than Peach because of that, but the thing is one of the reason why I love Amy is because seeing her trying to marry Sonic is so funny.

2 Peach has a heart element, good strength, and weapons. All Amy has is a hammer.

Well, you need good strenght to lift an hammer that big. Plus, besides an umbrella, I don't remember a lot of weapons that Peach had. But hey, I would maybe agree that Peach is stronger than Amy. Not that I love Amy for her strenght anyway.

Nope Amy have that and other stuff.

Very very true.

3 Amy Rose has too much pink

So does Peach. Plus, a color doesn't make a character bad.

I don't care about the colors both characters have.

4 Peach is sweet and cares for her friends. Amy is whiny, annoying, and cares too much about Sonic

What bothers me about this argument is not that it says Amy is annoying, even though I find her more funny than annoying. What bothers me is that the way the argument is structure says that Peach is sweet and cares of his friends, but not Amy. I'm sorry? What?! What about the time she took care of the little flicky in Adventure? What about the times she made both Gamma, and Shadow becoming good people? Or the time, she prevented Silver to kill Sonic? Amy do cares about her friends (not as much as Sonic, but that's kind of the joke), and she is a very sweet characters, and that's the main reason why she is a very good character.

5 Peach looks better than Amy

I disagree, but look is very subjective.

6 Amy’s voice is more irritating, especially in Sonic X

I thought Amy's voice was very good in Sonic X. It fits the character perfectly.

7 Amy can’t tell who Sonic is, always confusing him with Shadow and Silver. Peach can clearly see Mario from a distance

Well, the government thought Shadow was Sonic, so for her universe, Amy is not that dumb.

8 Peach is not competitive, Amy is

When was Amy competitive? And how being competitive is a bad thing?

9 When Peach gets mad, she does so in a calm way. Amy swings her hammer around and almost hurts people

Actually, when Peach gets mad she becomes so angry that she turns on fire (in super princess Peach). Plus, I would like to know in which game does Amy almost hurts people with her hammer, because I don't remember that moment.

10 Peach gives Mario a reward when he rescues her. Amy doesn’t do that with Sonic, just suffocates him with her hugs

Well, her hugs are more thoughtful, than Peach's kisses at least?...

The Contenders
11 Peach loves Toadette
12 Amy is annoying

Again, for me she is more funny than annoying.

13 Amy rose is stupid

You know what? Yes Amy isn't the smartest thing on earth. However, that what makes her charming.

BAdd New Item