Top Ten Worst Big Brother Players

The Top Ten

1 Lawon Exum - 10th place - Big Brother 13

Asking to go on the block? Asking to be evicted? Thinking he would have some kind of "special power" and get back in the house? I don't even know where to begin. He never played the game

As described below, Kaysar is a completely overrated player both strategically and competitively, but Lawon made a mistake that no other contestant ever would or could make. Not only did he ask to be evicted due to delusions of a 'special power', but he consequently allowed Rachel, the eventual winner, to stay in the game. If he hadn't made that huge error, he himself wouldn't have won, but a fellow newbie may well have!

Kaysar is overrated, but Lawon's easily the worst player ever. Not only did he want to be evicted because he thought he would come back with a "special power"- when he got his chance to return, he lost the competition that would send him back into the House by a huge margin.

It is a shame that I will never get handsomified ever again

V 21 Comments
2 Kaysar Ridha- 10th place- Big Brother 6 and 7 Kaysar Ridha- 10th place- Big Brother 6 and 7

I agree, he is so overrated. CBS made him appear to be an amazing player, due to his "mysterious" nature. This was just because he was a by nature quite person, and they made him look as though he was an amazing person who conquered Eric in season 6... In season 7 against Will the doctor, they showed just how poorly he played the game, particularly by not going after the Doctor and Mike Boogie. Both seasons he was too trustworthy, which lost him the game very quickly in both.

He made way too many strategic moves that hurt him. He was voted out fourth by making stupid moves, voted back in by America, then made another stupid deal, and was voted right back out next. In All-Stars, he made some more stupid moves, and went home fifth. He entered the house three times, and never even made it to the jury once.

Yeah... He had a huge target from Week 1 of S6, and it only grew and grew, leading to him being evicted the week after his HOH reign ended. He returned a week later, and he was not after blood from being evicted and coming back... He should have realized that being a returned would make him an easy target, which is exactly what happened.

In All Stars, did he seriously think that ridding Nakomis was going to help him? She was at the bottom of the totem pole in the house. Like Nakomis herself said, he was so wishy washy and made a huge mistake. His alliance thought ridding of Season 5 was going to get them to the end, and they thought that they would win all of the HOHs.

Him not playing in the Veto caused him his game in this season, since he did not want to put his ass out there for Janelle and James (he said this when his partner Michael was on the block in S6), completely not thinking about it one of them came off, Danielle would put his ass up, so someone from their ...more

I mean he's a great player and yes I too admit he's overrated even though he's 1 of my favorites but he is NOT a bad player. in my opinion he's the greatest player to never make jury

V 7 Comments
3 Kathy Hillis- 8th place- Big Brother 12

Absolutely one of the worst players. She couldn't win a competition to save her life. I still laugh when I see clips of her falling off of the hot dog in the first competition and her being kicked in the head by Brit while she was stuck in the molasses.

She was so dumb it was no wonder this texan was not the first to go I was in shock when she lasted until 8th place.

She's been a police officer for 20 years and she is probably the most weakest houseguest she failed at ever challenge my cat could do better than her told britney she was the weakest player ever and she made it that obvious she was the saboteour idiot

She could not when a thing! But as a 40 year old woman she deserved better treatment by everyone

V 12 Comments
4 Devin Shepherd - Season 16 Devin Shepherd - Season 16

This guy is a combo version of Amanda and Jeremy from BB15 aka bully. All he talks about is being loyal, having integrity, and doing this game for his daughter. And plays the gentle giant role when he clearly isn't. Created an all-everyone alliance with half the house and thinks he's running the ship.

What an idiot! He created an alliance on day 1, which would only work if you knew and trusted them, and then revealed the alliance just TWO WEEKS LATER! He tried to be "honest" and tried to have "integrity" but started to lie and scam everyone the minute he finished his awful speech. Finally, he tried to bring another member in the alliance when he should've known that zach had the votes to stay! WHAT AN IDIOT!

Not only was he the most annoying and frustrating player, but he also exhibited abusive tendencies to the women in the house. Not letting them speak, making them feel like they had to be wary of him. Just in general, even if he was "playing the game" I could never see myself seeing him and not wanting to punch him in the face.

This guy is the rude and never deserved to play.

V 28 Comments
5 Willie Hantz - 10th place - Big Brother 14

He was the H.O.H. in week one, and got himself evicted week 2. He didn't make any solid deals in his time as HOH. And instead of being allies with the best player in the game (frank) he puts him on the block without having the votes. He freaked out at frank before the eviction ceremony which basicaly turned the house against him. And he evicted himself before the point of view which he would have a pretty solid chance of winning... Just an allaround bad player

He had the temper of his nephew and he had the game of his brother russel learned from his first 2 seasons but Willie didn't get the memo of how to win big brother/survivor

He was actually 14th place; not 10th place. Anyways, he as this season's example of "Guy playing too hard, too fast", as right as his HOH ended, it was clear that his ass was leaving in Week 2, but because he was a punk and did not want to leave with class, he got himself expelled. Ugh.

King Frank ended his ass C:

V 13 Comments
6 Victoria Rafaeli - Big Brother 16 Victoria Rafaeli - Big Brother 16

In my opinion, Victoria played a flawless game... for a floater/pawn. Victoria was a pawn nominee when Donny, Nicole, etc. were all evicted. Her only role was comic relief for the audience, with her "I'm gonna win the point of view! ", and then proceeding to fail miserably in the challenge. She didn't have any strategy, and her only "alliances" were friendships with outsiders wo had a foot out the door already thanks to Derrick and the rest of the Detonators (except Christine). If she wrote a book, it would be called "How To Be A Floater And Get $50,000 For It", which would be ironic because Cody (AKA Derrick's puppet) made the imbecile move to evict her over his master. The book would also be like, 5 pages long because she's an idiot. Well done, Victoria, I bet your family's proud... - Turkeyasylum

I agree with the fact that she had no strategy nod went into all competitions saying "I'm gonna fight for this as hard as I can, and I WILL dominate! An then she loses by a huge margin. I bet everybody else on the jury was thinking "How was I evicted before Victoria? " And maybe Cody should be on this list for NOT taking her to the final 2. Victoria: a floater and possibly the biggest pawn EVER in the history of BB with to strategic, competitive or social skills. She was only kept in because Derrick was smart and knew she wasn't a threat.

What's a criteria to finding out if a big brother player is good or not, Manipulative skills, Social skills, Likability/Personality, Comp skills, Self awareness skills. Game Tactics. No social skills, not likable, no comp skills, no strategy and no self awareness. I would say at least some people on the list above her as it stands had at least comp skills. This is why she should be first on this list, she is the epitome of floater and got there just by being so bad. She was never in control of her fate and tried to win the comps didn't deliberately throw them.

She got 3rd...

V 29 Comments
7 James Huling - Big Brother 17 James Huling - Big Brother 17

The dumbest player of Season 17 and I'm furious he won the money from America's Favorite Player because he SUCKED. He made one terrible move after another, it was painful to watch how dumb he and Meg were in this game. I don't get why he is popular. Because he put up Shelli and Clay? Wow, what an achievement. He didn't even get the person he wanted out.

And then he flips on Becky and keeps Vanessa, the biggest threat and manipulator in the house?! Then he sends Becky home?! WHAT?! He and Meg practically gave the money to the other side of the house. With Becky in the game and Vanessa out, one of them might have actually won.

If he follows through with his plan to evict Shelli instead of Vanessa, he will be by FAR the dumbest player of this season.

James is doing great in bb18, staying below the radar. Everyone trusts him and no one has thrown out his name at all. Granted, everyone in BB18 are emotional and VERY DUMB.


8 Jase Wirey - 10th place - Big Brother 5, 12th place - Big Brother 7

Tried to win everything at the very start of Big Brother 5, which puts a huge target on your back. Acted cocky and annoying when he was in power, and had a creepy power bro-mance with Scott, making him an even bigger target. Loved his face when he realized Nakomis was getting rid of him. Somehow he was voted back into the All-Star house, and again won the first co-HoH. Jumped from side to side, and when Kaysar told his S6 was putting him up, he freaked out instead of trying to get votes to stay. - koenbertens

He's just one of those born competitors that are only good competitively and very bad strategist and are OK socialists and are gone early

I never understood why he got a second chance to play

Why can't we have a good player represent the US for BB Canada. Aries keeps calling Jase iconic but he never really was iconic.

V 4 Comments
9 Adam Poch - 3rd place - Big Brother 13 Adam Poch - 3rd place - Big Brother 13

If there was a book titled "How to win 500 thousand dollars on Big Brother" I'd expect the author to be Dan from BB10 or Will Kirby. If there was a book titled "How to win 25 thousand dollars on Big Brother" I'd expect the author to be Jeff from BB11. If there was a book titled "How to win 50 thousand dollars on Big Brother" I'd expect the author to be Adam Poch. He was the ultimate floater and butt-kisser. He seemed so sure he'd be asked back for all-stars on finale I felt embarrassed for the guy. I'm sure America can't wait to watch him float and butt-kiss and try to collect his 50k this time.

! This guy was really annoying and on finale night he tells everyone that the reason why he isn't in the final 2 is because he would have beaten everyone. Yeah right! Plus he said that he would be coming back for all-stars 2 and win it. He is the biggest floater and butt kisser in the history of Big Brother.

Adam was always afraid to make a big move and didn't want to make enemies with America's golden couple Jeff and Jordan. It's no wonder he finished 3rd because he was carried most of the game by Jeff and Jordan. Least Shelly got it that if you want to win big brother cutting off certain relationships will get you the money. - BlackDiamonds

If he saved kalia then he could've had a chance b/c he would have been in more safety cause he could've been in the final 2

V 8 Comments
10 Aaryn Gries - Big Brother 15 Aaryn Gries - Big Brother 15

People are just saying this because she was racist. She played a very strong game, being nominated a lot in the early part, then letting people control her nominations. Very smart game played.

Her biggest mistakes in this game was opening her mouth and letting the absolutely most evil person to ever play the game (Amanda) to control her nominations.

I agree, she was a heck of a competitor, but socially was one of the worst on her season on because of her comments, racist or homophobic comments can drive people away from you, she was lucky enough to last until final 8 because their were bigger targets than her and her competition prowess

Her name should be put on the Death Note.

V 19 Comments

The Contenders

11 Mike Dutz- 11th place- Big Brother 8

He was told if he tried to make Dick, the current HOH lose the veto challenge, he'd be on the block, but he did it anyway, and he was put on the block, and sent home.

I just can't understand the thought process that made him think distracting dick was a good game move

He blew his game for Kail by annoying Evel Dick in the Veto challenge


V 5 Comments
12 Justin Sebik - Big Brother 2

Psychopath! This guy is a total psychopath. How in the hell is he not on here yet? He was really creepy the entire time he was on the show. He constantly threatened houseguests with violence and held a knife up to Krista's throat.

He's crazy. He got himself kicked out of the house! If he played with the rules he would have done way better even though he's still creepy. Instead he wanted to threaten his way to the top, how is he not ranked the top most horrible player?

He said that if you thought that holding a knife to someones throat while making out with him was threatening then you're an idiot

Why is he not in the Top 10? Didn't he try to murder someone?

V 3 Comments
13 Frankie Grande - Season 16 Frankie Grande - Season 16 Frank James Michael Grande Marchione (born January 24, 1983), usually credited as Frankie Grande or Frankie J. Grande, is an American dancer, musical theatre actor and singer, producer, TV host and YouTube personality. He is the older half-brother of singer and actress Ariana Grande.

Plays the exact same game as ANDY therefore I hope someone in that house gets him outta there I hate this guy - htoutlaws2012

Okay Frankie haters, you are only ranking him this high because of his personality. Despite that, he was the only person in that house playing to win the game, was aware of what went on, and actually took control of the game (other than Derrick, obviously). He was strong physically, mentally, and socially. Sure, he might be nasty and vile, but being nice and friendly rarely is not the point of Big Brother (at least not in the North American version).

You can see his true colors as the season goes on. Anything he does that is nice is to cover up what a terrible person he really is. He thinks he's better than everybody because of who his Step-sister is

One word, lots of syllables... narcissist.

V 22 Comments
14 Chima Simone - 8th Place - Big Brother 11 Chima Simone - 8th Place - Big Brother 11 Chima Simone is a TV personality and freelance journalist, best known as a former contestant on Big Brother 11. She is also notable for surviving an attack by the Bathtub Killer, Dale Devon Scheanette.

Chima should be high in this list because she was dumb enough to disobey the Big Brother rules and not wear her microphone. She had been throughout the game disobeying rules like not going to the diary room when asked and not wearing her microphone. The night before the veto comp, Big Brother set out a mini golf game to practice for the upcoming veto comp. Chima had put a big enough target on her back that at that point she was pretty much feeling defeated, so she took her microphone and tossed it in the pool. When they asked her to get a new mic and wear it, she refused and got herself expelled from the game.

I don't understand why did their alliance think they were the good and genuine side of the house. They were grateful for nobody but themselves, and they had the evildoers Natalie, Ronnie, Lydia, Jessie and mostly herself.

She should be #1 in my book. She "gave up" playing the game, which is a slap in the face to all fans who applied to be on the show.

Did chima have drugs in her bag

V 7 Comments
15 Jessie Godderz - 10th place - Big Brother 10, 9th place - Big Brother 11 Jessie Godderz - 10th place - Big Brother 10, 9th place - Big Brother 11 Jessie Godderz also known as Mr. Pec-Tacular is an American professional wrestler signed with Total Nonstop Action Wrestling where he is a former two-time TNA World Tag Team Champion with Robbie E as The BroMans.

It was America's fault jesse went out twice, though I do agree that he played badly season 10. He was running the house until CBS handed jeff a coup de ta which is the only reason he was sent to JURY.

Of course I would vote for jessie because he is hot.

Very lackluster gameplay. Slept for 70% of his time in the house.

I can't stand this guy. Why do they keep bringing him back?

V 4 Comments
16 Elissa Slater - 6th place - Big Brother 15 Elissa Slater - 6th place - Big Brother 15

Only survived first 3 evictions because of the horrible mvp twist, cries about it when the mvp is in America's hands, then floats and rides Helen's coattails till helen was evicted, then wins hoh and doesn't nominate the power couple together, then decides she wants to keep the most hated person in bb history thus making herself equally hated, the getting the boot right after

Would've been booted pre-jury if not for the MVP twist. Speaking of which, I wonder what would've happened if she actually was booted pre-jury...

She was popular because of her sister, but her gameplay and social skills were horrible.

Actually elissa is a cute duckling and shut up haters

V 4 Comments
17 GinaMarie Zimmerman - Big Brother 15 GinaMarie Zimmerman - Big Brother 15

Her comments to Candice before her eviction are awful

She is so crazy over Nick, who was evicted weeks ago, and has a shrine devoted to him. She is also very poor when it comes to strategy, just following Aaryn's commands.

Happy she didn't win bb 15, she was a horrible racist person. No one should ever say those things to someone who was adopted.

NOTICE ME SENPAI! Yea, that's ginamarie. Racist. Crazy. Stupid. Didn't deserve to be in the final 2 AT ALL! Thank god she lost.

V 7 Comments
18 Joey Van Pelt - Season 16

How is she ahead of Paola? Sure, she was the first to be evicted and was bad at the game, but she at least TRIED to make moves and play the game. Whereas Paola did absolutely nothing in the house and got evicted the week after Joey. Heck, if Joey was bad at the game, then half the cast of BB16 deserves to be ahead of her on the list because they were essentially on vacation in the house and did little to nothing in terms of gameplay. Joey at least tried to do something.

Telling the Bomb Squad that you have an all girl alliance. Now your on the block!

She was a recruit who didn't know how to play the game. She was also Team America and that failed quickly.

She was definitely likable, but definitely one of the worst players in history. She didn't even know anything about the show

V 10 Comments
19 Amanda Zuckerman - 7th Place - Big Brother 15 Amanda Zuckerman - 7th Place - Big Brother 15

Are people only ranking her this high because of her behavior? All questionable comments aside, she was one of the few people that season actually playing the game. She basically ran the house for half of it. How exactly is she a bad player from a game standpoint?

Because too many people can't or don't know hoe to distinguish between personality and gameplay. - theOpinionatedOne

She went more than half of the game having never won a competition and still manipulating everyone in the house. She used her loud mouth and ability to get in people's heads as strategy. Sometimes she took it a step too far, but ultimately she played a strong strategic game and they all feared her. I loved her, and if she made it to the final two she would've won hands down.

The Nastiest Bitch to ever be on a reality show

She had no idea that Andy was playing her. That is why she is not a great player.

V 13 Comments
20 Lydia Tavera - 7th place - Big Brother 11

, when Jessie was evicted from the game she acted like Jessie was hit by a double decker bus, struck by lightning and eaten by an elephant all at the same time HE WAS ALIVE WHEN HE LEFT AND PROBABLY HAPPY HE MADE IT A WEEK FURTHER THAN LAST TIME. She was in Jessie's trans all along and just lost her mind when he left

She was obsessed with Jessie since Week 1, if it was different and she didn't go off the block week one chima would've most likely go home and she'd have Kevin, Jeff, Jordan, Michele, Braden, Laura, Casey, and maybe Ronnie as allies. But no she fell under control of Jessie and dragged Kevin with her. Ugh

She didn't have much game; she was blinded by Jessie the whole time and asked people to vote her out just to be with Jessie.

Was there for Jessie. - Tito1711

V 2 Comments
PSearch List

Recommended Lists

Related Lists

Best Big Brother US Players Top Ten Best Big Brother Canada Players Top 10 Best Big Brother 14 (US) Players Most Underrated Big Brother U.S. Players Big Brother USA Players as of Dan's Funeral

List Stats

2,000 votes
120 listings
9 years, 36 days old

Top Remixes (15)

1. Victoria Rafaeli - Big Brother 16
2. Lawon Exum - 10th place - Big Brother 13
3. Jase Wirey - 10th place - Big Brother 5, 12th place - Big Brother 7
1. Devin Shepherd - Season 16
2. Willie Hantz - 10th place - Big Brother 14
3. Lawon Exum - 10th place - Big Brother 13
1. Devin Shepherd - Season 16
2. Justin Sebik - Big Brother 2
3. Aaryn Gries - Big Brother 15

View All 15


Add Post

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.