Top Ten Worst Big Brother Players

The Contenders: Page 4

61 Natalie Cunial - 5th Place - Big Brother 9
62 Andy Herren - Big Brother 15 Andy Herren - Big Brother 15

To many fans, unlikable = bad game-player, but you don't usually win by being a good person (except for Jordan for some reason). Also, he may not have been a Dr. Will, a Dan, or even a Derrick, but I can appreciate the progression of his game-play, from being so subtle at the beginning by gaining everyone's trust as to put him below the radar to becoming more aggressive by breaking that trust and winning comps. He practically pulled the strings behind the scenes, practically the opposite of Derrick. In sum, he might not have played how the fans would've liked him to, but his game-play wasn't bad, just different.

Just an all around nasty person. His constant spewing of hatred is almost unbearable...must have extremely low self esteem along with a total lack of self awareness as most things he says about others are qualities he possesses. Gross, nasty "human"...using that word loosely. He will look back at the season and cringe at himself...I can hardly watch him without being embarrassed for him. Nice job, DONKEY!

I think Andy is honestly right under the level of where Dan and Will are. He is on the same level of Derrick because with both of them, when they were in the house they weren't even an option to vote out despite running the house

Hate him. he has the ugliest camletoe

V 6 Comments
63 Jeremy McGuire - 14th Place - Big Brother 15 Jeremy McGuire - 14th Place - Big Brother 15

No concept of the game. Was a male "mean girl" who started fights just for fun

Needs to shut his mouth about being Cherokee. How does that affect your game in any way? If Big Brother was a game that was focused on getting everyone to hate you for being an insensitive, immature, jerk, then hand this boy his 500k.

This season seemed to be a season where the casting directors just bet each other to see who could cast the most heinous people. Whoever got Jeremy won 3rd place.

64 Zach Swerdzewski - 3rd Place - Big Brother 8

Oh my gosh, this dude was a total moron. In final 5 he won the veto and saved jameka or eric and vote out danielle when dick was the hoh and powerless in the voting, but no he decides to go after them the next week when he's hoh and it totally backfired in his face. I really could not stand watching this idiot play.

V 1 Comment
65 Candice Stewart - 11th Place - Big Brother 15

Just like the'Vonne in that she's perceptive of what's going on but can't put her findings into action.

66 Clay Honeycutt - Big Brother 17

He sacrificed himself for a girl he has been with for almost two months. Now this is a big difference to when Rupert Boneham put his game on the line for his wife Laura, because Rupert has gotten many chances to play and his wife never did so I can understand that. But this is nothing like that Clay purposely gave up half a million dollars for love.

Got evicted for a woman he knew for almost 2 months. She got sent out right after him anyway, so it wasn't even like she had a good chance of winning the game. The two dated for 2 weeks and then broke up after the show.

Who gives up there game for a lady they had only known for less than 2 months. The funny thing is that she was sent packing right after him.

He sacrificed his game for Shelli and Shelli was evicted over a shirt.

V 4 Comments
67 Shelli Poole - 11th Place - Big Brother 17

Shelli evicted her allies just for her man. She made an idiotic move not throwing Vanessa under the bus when James won HOH. And when Becky nominated her next to Vanessa she made an idiotic move by making James feel uncomfortable by stealing a shirt. Very overrated as a player.

She won to many HOH's and her and her crappy alliance ran the house from weeks 2-5 and just set herself up. Then she trusts the other side of the house to keep her and never secures herself staying against Vanessa? She was completely arrogant and kind of brought her alliance members down with her. She made too much deals and was all over the place. She played Way to hard to fast. You want proof... 11th Place.

68 Dick Donato - Winner - Big Brother 8 Dick Donato - Winner - Big Brother 8 Richard Louis Donato, known as "Evel Dick" Donato, a bar manager from Los Angeles, California, is the winner of the reality game show Big Brother 8. He and his daughter, Daniele Donato, are the only family member pair to win the American Big Brother program's top two prizes in the same competition.

He only won because of America's Player. He would have been evicted if Eric was able to play his own game.

Meanest, nastiest person ever!

If he were female, he'd be in the Top 25 like Amanda and Chelsia.

Come on people... He played a good game in BB8 which made him win. Yeah he is mean and creul but He did what he had to win. In BB13 he had to walk so what?

69 Ian Terry - Winner - Big Brother 14

Ian is still a solid Big Brother player but Dan should've won again

Dan basically carried Ian to the end and won only because of a bitter jury. If not for the Coaches Twist that allowed Boogie to grant him immunity the first week, he would've left pre-jury. BB17 Steve played a better game than him.

70 Julia Nolan - 6th place - Big Brother 17

Made no moves throughout the game. She just rode her sister's coattails. She had the opportunity to turn on Vanessa's power by working with James, Meg, Jackie, Becky, and Johnny Mac, but she just did nothing. Her bio said she would win independent from Liz but she basically just quit when both of them were put on the block next to each other.

71 Tonya Paoni - 11th Place - Big Brother 3

A weak character among an otherwise strong cast, and one of the few players in the history of the show to get arrested post-show.

72 Frank Eudy - 7th Place - Big Brother 14 Frank Eudy - 7th Place - Big Brother 14

To think he'd be better in BB18. Nope! He got booted pre-jury and sexually harassed many girls in the house.

Only made it to 7th place and Won America's Favorite Player by the help of Grodner.

73 Victor Arroyo - Big Brother 18 Victor Arroyo - Big Brother 18

Very Ditzy. I can't BELIVE he got a third chance in the house. Glad that he evicted Paulie though.

He's so annoying. Like shut up about your weight! Sad that he got a chance to return.

Team up with Jozea lmfao!

I like him but he's a horrible gameplayer and the fact is he got 3 chances on BB18 and still couldn't make it to the end

V 2 Comments
74 Neil Garcia - 15th Place - Big Brother 9

He was literally in the house for only seven days. Even though he had to leave for personal reasons, you came to play a game you should have tried to stay longer. When the show was broadcasted he had only one diary room session so he was a pointless player.


75 Enzo Palumbo - 3rd Place - Season 12 Enzo Palumbo - 3rd Place - Season 12

Enzo was really, really, annoying! I was just praying he would be evicted, but no! The "Meow Meow" HAD to slide/float!

V 2 Comments
76 Caleb Reynolds - Big Brother 16 Caleb Reynolds - Big Brother 16 Caleb Matthew Reynolds is a hunting guide from Hopkinsville, Kentucky. He is best known for his appearance on the sixteenth season of the reality series Big Brother, where he placed fourth,.

The first half of the season Beast Mode is just a creepy stalker... But he became such a cute ninja after Amber's eviction. Dumbest player ever, yet really adorable.

He actually did decent once Amber was evicted, and he got rid of that flamingo hair diva, so we can't complain too much.

Quite possibly the dumbest player ever to play the game. Everybody in the house manipulates him, yet he thinks he's running te house. He can win comps but how did he make it this far in life?

Probably in my top 20 dumbest players list to of ever play this game

V 3 Comments
77 Nick Uhas - 15th Place - Big Brother 15

The only thing I remember about him was that he was a total tool.

MVP twist was the only reason he left.

Way to confident in his alliance

V 1 Comment
78 Eric Littmann - 12th Place - Big Brother 6 Eric Littmann - 12th Place - Big Brother 6

A pathetic bald little ass who needs to get his teeth knocked down his throat. I wish Michael would've hit him.

79 Adam Jasinski - Winner - Big Brother 9 Adam Jasinski - Winner - Big Brother 9 Adam Jasinski is the winner of the U.S. series Big Brother 9. Jasinski is a public relations manager from Cherry Hill, New Jersey.

Awful winner to a bad season of Big Brother. The minute he won he took his earnings to invest in the drug trade.

By far the worst winner in BB History. He only won out of sheer luck.

80 John McGuire - Big Brother 17

I like John but he was a pawn too much.

Not to be confused with Jeremy from BB15. Anyway, volunteering to be a pawn more than once? Throwing the Battle of the Block? If he keeps this up, he's gonna be out of the house sooner or later because, as Steve said, pawns go home!

WHY IS JOHNNY HERE? Broke a record for most veto holds or being on the block so many weeks in a row. I can't quite remember. definitely should come back for All-Stars in s21

V 4 Comments
PSearch List

Recommended Lists

Related Lists

Best Big Brother US Players Top Ten Best Big Brother Canada Players Top 10 Best Big Brother 14 (US) Players Most Underrated Big Brother U.S. Players Big Brother USA Players as of Dan's Funeral

List Stats

2,000 votes
120 listings
8 years, 335 days old

Top Remixes (15)

1. Devin Shepherd - Season 16
2. Willie Hantz - 10th place - Big Brother 14
3. Lawon Exum - 10th place - Big Brother 13
1. Devin Shepherd - Season 16
2. Justin Sebik - Big Brother 2
3. Aaryn Gries - Big Brother 15
1. Frankie Grande - Season 16
2. Lawon Exum - 10th place - Big Brother 13
3. Jozea Flores - Big Brother 18

View All 15


Add Post

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.