Top Ten Worst Big Brother Players

The Contenders: Page 5

81 John McGuire - Big Brother 17

I like John but he was a pawn too much.

Not to be confused with Jeremy from BB15. Anyway, volunteering to be a pawn more than once? Throwing the Battle of the Block? If he keeps this up, he's gonna be out of the house sooner or later because, as Steve said, pawns go home!

WHY IS JOHNNY HERE? Broke a record for most veto holds or being on the block so many weeks in a row. I can't quite remember. definitely should come back for All-Stars in s21

V 4 Comments
82 Jackie Ibarra - 10th Place - Big Brother 17

Miscommunication on her end led to her own eviction by Steve's hand instead of Austin or Becky.

V 1 Comment
83 Paola Aviles - 14th Place - Big Brother 12

Unless I'm mistaken, she is the only person to quit while in sequester before the show began, which is basically a slap in the face to Big Brother fans everywhere who applied to be on the show but didn't get on. She gave up like Chima did in Big Brother 11. Anyway, this explains why there were 13 official houseguests during Big Brother 12 instead of 14 like there initially was supposed to be.

84 Shane Meaney - 4th Place - Big Brother 14 Shane Meaney - 4th Place - Big Brother 14 V 1 Comment
85 Ragan Fox - 5th Place - Big Brother 12

Say what you want about Frankie and Andy. At least they actually played the game in spite of their personalities (Frankie being worse). Ragan was just whiny.

86 Kara Monaco - 15th Place - Big Brother 14
87 Brittany Martinez - Big Brother 16

Nope sorry Brittany was a GOOD player. She was willing to make big moves and that scared the male houseguests so Cody and Derrick basically turned on her and evicted her when they realized they couldn't manipulate her

Her biggest mistake was trusting Cody and Derrick much too soon in the game. Once she got herself removed from the block in Week 3 on Devin's HOH, I figured she might have potential to at least get to jury. That's until she opened her mouth and couldn't see a shift power if it smacked her upside the head. Plus she was a recruit that apparently never watched a single episode of Big Brother. A part of me wished she wasn't blindsided but another side of me was if your that oblivious you should be voted out.

I liked Brittany... She fought hard to stay in the house. I think if she had stayed longer she would've made season 16 a little more interesting.

V 3 Comments
88 April Lewis - 4th Place - BB6

This was a woman who tried to hide how evil she really is, but didn't always do a good job.

V 2 Comments
89 Hayden Voss - Big Brother 16

Another moron from BB16. If you get evicted by a bunch of idiots, what does that make you? I don't think he understood that BB is a game that you try to win. He thought he got selected to hang out and party with strangers. He was a complete waste of space. He should not be allowed to procreate with Nicole... That kid would not stand a chance in life.

All he care about was his showmance and he didn't even realize what was going on until he was blindsided.

Hayden is actually really good he was just too lax

V 1 Comment
90 Kaitlin Barnaby - 13th Place - Big Brother 15

Her downfall was being one of Aaryn's cohorts and not trying to separate herself from the Mean Girls in time. She might've made it to the jury phase, otherwise. Decent competitor on her own, but bad at picking allies.

91 Jeff Weldon - 14th Place - Big Brother 17

His intro in the beginning of the show is horrendous...

In week 3, he thought James was still HOH (who was HOH in week 1). He was the epitome of a floater, maybe close to as much as Victoria. - Turkeyasylum

Failed at the floater strategy. Even told other hgs who he wanted evicted prejury which got around to other hgs that made him a target. Plus his douchebag attitude didn't help him neither.

V 2 Comments
92 Lane Elenbug - 2nd Place - Big Brother 12

Arguably a bigger floater than Enzo, and was the least strategic member of the Brigade.

Easily the dumbest Brigade member.

He followed Hayden's lead and otherwise didn't do much gaming on his own.

93 Howard Overby - 12th Place - Big Brother 15

He lied about the Moving Company and put a huge target on his back as a result.

94 Spencer Clawson - 3rd Place - Big Brother 15 Spencer Clawson - 3rd Place - Big Brother 15

Unlike most fans, I would actually like him to return and actually have a chance to play. For most of the game, he couldn't do much because he had next to no leverage, and he made himself clear that he would do more of he could. After the BB15 finale, I grew something of a retroactive appreciation towards him.

95 Judd Daugherty - 5th Place - Big Brother 15 Judd Daugherty - 5th Place - Big Brother 15

As far as the game was concerned, he was basically useless.

I do not fault Judd for not using the F6 veto. I do fault him for returning to the house after his eviction. He should never have returned, considering he only got more paranoid and anxious than ever before.

Probably made one of the dumbest moves of any double eviction was not use the point of view on Elissa. Had he and Mccrae been smart to keep her til F3 or F4 they both been final 2 and Judd would had won the season. Idiot.

V 1 Comment
96 Ronnie Talbott - 10th Place - Big Brother 11 Ronnie Talbott - 10th Place - Big Brother 11

Played an inferior version of Andy's game. Yes, Ronnie was the original "rat" but Andy was the one who perfected it and made it a viable winning strategy.

97 Steven Daigle - 12th place - Big Brother 10

He put too much trust into Brian and it got him evicted a week later

V 3 Comments
98 McCrae Olson - 4th Place - Big Brother 15 McCrae Olson - 4th Place - Big Brother 15

Unlike most fans, I do not fault him for putting up Elissa. Unless he had psychic powers; how was he supposed to know that Andy evicted Amanda and not Elissa? It was a private deal between the two girls. It just highlights the big issue that what fans consider a big move is the move that fans want players to make, not the moves that most benefit the players.

The first week of the season, when McCrae won both HOH and point of view, you could tell he was passionate about the game. Once he latched himself to Amanda, all of that passion was gone. It re-emerged after Amanda got evicted, but the damage was done and his game was ruined beyond repair. If not for Amanda, he probably would've won.

If there is one thing McCrae should be faulted for, it's throwing away his game for Amanda by the end of week 2.

V 2 Comments
99 Beau Beasley - 6th Place - Big Brother 6

Other than winning one competition, he was only there for the numbers advantage in favor of the Friendship.

100 Dana Varela - 9th place - Big Brother 4

Dana knew the mistake ruined her game when she was a candidate for all stars she admitted that flipping on the elite 8 for no reason cost her the game

The one thing that pisses me off more than anything is when someone makes a godawful game move, and never accepts that it was bad. Dana's HoH nominations were so painfully stupid, turning the entire house (aka the entire jury), completely against her, destroying her odds of winning, but she has the gall to claim she "just made the move no one had the balls to". Got evicted a week later. Well deserved

PSearch List

Recommended Lists

Related Lists

Best Big Brother US Players Top Ten Best Big Brother Canada Players Top 10 Best Big Brother 14 (US) Players Most Underrated Big Brother U.S. Players Big Brother USA Players as of Dan's Funeral

List StatsUpdated 20 Aug 2017

2,000 votes
121 listings
8 years, 219 days old

Top Remixes (15)

1. Devin Shepherd - Season 16
2. Willie Hantz - 10th place - Big Brother 14
3. Lawon Exum - 10th place - Big Brother 13
1. Devin Shepherd - Season 16
2. Justin Sebik - Big Brother 2
3. Aaryn Gries - Big Brother 15
1. Frankie Grande - Season 16
2. Lawon Exum - 10th place - Big Brother 13
3. Jozea Flores - Big Brother 18

View All 15


Add Post

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.