Top Ten Worst Big Brother Players

The Contenders: Page 6

101 Steven Daigle - 12th place - Big Brother 10

He put too much trust into Brian and it got him evicted a week later

V 3 Comments
102 McCrae Olson - 4th Place - Big Brother 15 McCrae Olson - 4th Place - Big Brother 15

Unlike most fans, I do not fault him for putting up Elissa. Unless he had psychic powers; how was he supposed to know that Andy evicted Amanda and not Elissa? It was a private deal between the two girls. It just highlights the big issue that what fans consider a big move is the move that fans want players to make, not the moves that most benefit the players.

The first week of the season, when McCrae won both HOH and point of view, you could tell he was passionate about the game. Once he latched himself to Amanda, all of that passion was gone. It re-emerged after Amanda got evicted, but the damage was done and his game was ruined beyond repair. If not for Amanda, he probably would've won.

If there is one thing McCrae should be faulted for, it's throwing away his game for Amanda by the end of week 2.

V 2 Comments
103 Beau Beasley - 6th Place - Big Brother 6

Other than winning one competition, he was only there for the numbers advantage in favor of the Friendship.

104 Dana Varela - 9th place - Big Brother 4

Dana knew the mistake ruined her game when she was a candidate for all stars she admitted that flipping on the elite 8 for no reason cost her the game

The one thing that pisses me off more than anything is when someone makes a godawful game move, and never accepts that it was bad. Dana's HoH nominations were so painfully stupid, turning the entire house (aka the entire jury), completely against her, destroying her odds of winning, but she has the gall to claim she "just made the move no one had the balls to". Got evicted a week later. Well deserved

105 Braden Bacha - 13th place - Big Brother 11 Braden Bacha - 13th place - Big Brother 11

Made racist and sexist comments the first week, the only week that he was there.

V 1 Comment
106 Lisa Donahue - Winner - Big Brother 3

Lisa was not a BAD player, but she wasn't better than Danielle or Jason. Lisa made some good moves and I saw she learnt from her master (Danielle) how to play. But yes, Danielle or Jason deserved to win over Lisa, but Lisa deserves to win over anyone else in BB3.

107 Michael Donnellan - 13th Place - Season 6 Michael Donnellan - 13th Place - Season 6

Got into a showmance with 2 women on opposite sides of the house thn he sexually harassed the woman which made Jim a bigger target and personally attacked Eric Kayseri didn't want to play in the veto for him since ho dug his own grave

108 Porsche Briggs - 2nd Place - Big Brother 13

Did not deserve a final 2 spot she sucked strategy

109 Kalia Booker - 5th Place - Big Brother 13

She was very weird about everything and followed whoever was there to follow total dog

110 Parker Somerville - 14th Place - Big Brother 9
111 Andy Herren - Big Brother 15 Andy Herren - Big Brother 15

To many fans, unlikable = bad game-player, but you don't usually win by being a good person (except for Jordan for some reason). Also, he may not have been a Dr. Will, a Dan, or even a Derrick, but I can appreciate the progression of his game-play, from being so subtle at the beginning by gaining everyone's trust as to put him below the radar to becoming more aggressive by breaking that trust and winning comps. He practically pulled the strings behind the scenes, practically the opposite of Derrick. In sum, he might not have played how the fans would've liked him to, but his game-play wasn't bad, just different.

Just an all around nasty person. His constant spewing of hatred is almost unbearable...must have extremely low self esteem along with a total lack of self awareness as most things he says about others are qualities he possesses. Gross, nasty "human"...using that word loosely. He will look back at the season and cringe at himself...I can hardly watch him without being embarrassed for him. Nice job, DONKEY!

I think Andy is honestly right under the level of where Dan and Will are. He is on the same level of Derrick because with both of them, when they were in the house they weren't even an option to vote out despite running the house

Hate him. he has the ugliest camletoe

V 6 Comments
112 Janelle Pierzina- 3rd place- Big Brother 6 Janelle Pierzina- 3rd place- Big Brother 6 Janelle Marie Pierzina is an American reality show personality known for her appearances on the sixth, All-Star, and fourteenth seasons of the American version of the CBS reality show Big Brother.

Good competitor...terrible at strategy. Still don't understand how she was such a fan favorite in BB6. She was so annoying and displayed similar qualities of many other hated HGs in history. Season 7 and 14 she was much better and I was semi a fan of her's. But I disliked her in Season 6 and overall she is a very overrated player in history.

Janelle is so overrated! She often caused pointless drama and was much meaner and more spiteful than she had to be. As good as she was in competitions, she should have won both seasons, but she sucked as a social player and that's why she got 3rd place both times.

She won a lot of competitions but in season 7 Dr Will could make her do anything he wanted.

With how great Bye Bye Bitches was for T.V. that is a summary of Janelle's game 1 step forward 2 steps back. She wins a competition that was needed to win then gets overcelebratory and pisses off half the house

V 5 Comments
113 Keith Henderson - 13th place - Big Brother 13

His strategy was to basically copy the Brigade, and when that failed, he betrayed his partner Porsche, leading to his eviction Week 1. He also seemed to think calling out Kalia and Shelly was a good way to get their votes? Think again.

Yay I added this item laugh out loud Anyway, his strategy was to alienate his only allies

V 1 Comment
114 Joe Arvin - 6th Place - Big Brother 14

The worst player ever in the house all he did was sit and watch the drama. He would always float on Shane because the fact he couldn't do anything good in the house

Awful player lol

How is he not in Top 10? He never won HOH or even the Power Of Veto. He's pretty bad

Did absolutely nothing in the house. He makes Adam Poch look like Dr. Will.

V 1 Comment
115 Will Kirby - Winner - Big Brother 2, 4th place - All Stars Will Kirby - Winner - Big Brother 2, 4th place - All Stars

I Just voted for him because he's not even close to being the worst player ever.

He is the best player ever to play the game. When he was nominated he told the house guests that he hated everyone and no one voted against him

Dr Will is the bomb! Never had to win HOH or point of view manipulated everyone in the house except for boogie still one loves him! ;-)

V 1 Comment
116 Dan Gheesling - Runner Up - Big Brother 14 Dan Gheesling - Runner Up - Big Brother 14 Dan Gheesling is an American reality television personality who appeared on the Big Brother 10, which he won.

His jury management was awful. He is so overrated, yes his game was flashy. But losing in a 6-1 blowout with no one in the f4 he could beat in the end is not a god-tier game. Also he had three lifelines.

He is the second best player to play the game

Haha I just wanted to see his name his amazing


V 1 Comment
117 Derrick Levasseur - Big Brother 16 Derrick Levasseur - Big Brother 16

The only reason he made it so far is because a) he's a guy and all the guys target only girls, b) he is one of the only people who is not a retarded 20something year old that doesn't even have half a brain, and c) only half of this seasons cast even knew about big brother before they got put on the show. SOME OF THE PEOPLE AUDITIONED FOR OTHER SHOWS AND SOMEHOW GIT THROWN ON BIG BROTHER. He did not orchestrate anything that has happened. It is final 8 and he is still afraid to have power. He needs to go. ASAP

If he was on any other season he would've been caught, but these dumb house guests are oblivious. He is not a great player. He's just playing with clueless house guests who have no strategy.

Derrick played an amazing game. NEVER being nominated even though he wasn't near as strong as Frankie. He manipulated the whole house.

He's the puppets master he never should have been put on the list

V 4 Comments
118 Helen Kim - 9th Place - Big Brother 15

"It's too soon to get rid of Amanda."

After she was able to get rid of Jeremy in week 2, she was nothing more but a foolish player trapped in Andy's web. Annoying as hell!

119 Zach Rance - Big Brother 16 Zach Rance - Big Brother 16

Only house guest I can stand besides Donny. Very good entertainment.

The comedy relief of the season - htoutlaws2012

Came super close to going down as the worst BB in history. He wasn't on anybody's radar until he told Devin to put him on the block--he volunteered! What a moron. Then he rips off Dr. Will by telling the house he hates them all. Everybody said he was tough in comps but he barely won anything. He was The idiot among idiots. Fruitloopdingus was the only thing he brought to the table... But he probably ripped that off somebody as well.

Keep your mouth shut

V 2 Comments
120 Jameka Cameron - 4th Place - Big Brother 8

She gave up thousands of dollars, a trip to Barbados, and took MULTIPLE punishments all so that she could win veto to save house guests that weren't in her alliance. Why? Because it was "god's will"... Not to mention she was completely useless in the game.

I appreciate that she's focused on her religion but she let it get the best of her she saved people who weren't even aligned with her just idiotic

PSearch List

Recommended Lists

Related Lists

Best Big Brother US Players Top Ten Best Big Brother Canada Players Top 10 Best Big Brother 14 (US) Players Most Underrated Big Brother U.S. Players Big Brother USA Players as of Dan's Funeral

List StatsUpdated 21 Jul 2017

2,000 votes
121 listings
8 years, 189 days old

Top Remixes (15)

1. Victoria Rafaeli - Big Brother 16
2. Lawon Exum - 10th place - Big Brother 13
3. Jase Wirey - 10th place - Big Brother 5, 12th place - Big Brother 7
1. Devin Shepherd - Season 16
2. Willie Hantz - 10th place - Big Brother 14
3. Lawon Exum - 10th place - Big Brother 13
1. Devin Shepherd - Season 16
2. Justin Sebik - Big Brother 2
3. Aaryn Gries - Big Brother 15

View All 15


Add Post

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.