Top 10 Worst Creepypastas

These short horror stories are TERRIBLE in my opinion.

The Top Ten

1 Jeff the Killer Jeff the Killer Jeff the killer is a creepypasta usually accompanied by a picture of a white face looking in to the camera smiling in an unsettling manner . The creepypasta is also usually accompanied by the term "Go to sleep" .

The fact that so many people are calling this "well-written" is honestly insulting to legitimate writers. The plot is incredibly contrived and unrealistic, every character is flat with no personality (especially Jeff, who flips from perfectly normal with occasional "strange feelings" to a homicidal sociopath in a second), and 99% of Jeff's injuries are ridiculous (after being lit on fire, his skin turned white, lips red, and hair black? How scientific! Not to mention how Jeff hasn't gone blind from dust and bacteria after burning his eyelids off, and how his cliche knife-carved "smile" hasn't gotten infected without medical treatment). The scariest thing about this story is its picture, which, after a couple years, has become very dated and obviously photoshopped (also, isn't Jeff supposed to be in, like, high school? The picture is clearly a grown man).

The popularity of garbage stories like this makes it impossible to have any faith in humanity. It's physically painful to see people praising such a poorly written, nonsensical piece of trash when there are so many other good stories/authors out there that get little to no attention at all. Cattle mentality at its finest.

This kid has no excuse for his attitude, his strength, or his amount if FANGIRLS. FANGIRLS need to get their heads outta his ass and actually act like a normal creepy pasta fan and not go goo goo for any creepy pasta with a homicidal guy. My favorite creepy pasta is The Stairs. (Read it so you can actually get a decent taste of what a good story is.) One second is a normal emo teen that has too much of a drama issue. The next, he's a serial killer? What, just because of some bleach. BLEACH. And might I add that in this story, he's 13? he's 13 AND CAN DODGE ALL THE POLICE'S BULLETS, KILL HIS ENTIRE FAMILY, AND BE A "Badass"?!?! NO! The writer did change this later on but the story was still a pathetic waste of time. To recap;

1. FANGIRLS need to read some good creepy pasta like an actual fan would and not write fan fics of Jeff, or any creepypasta. Respect the website. You are supposed to get scared, not have a orgasm.

2. The story is poorly written and very ...more - Peculiar


V 55 Comments
2 Sonic.exe

"The animal was bleeding... WITH HYPER REALISTIC BLOOD" actual line in the story, not kidding, read it

I hyper realistically saw the hyper realistic story, with my hyper realistic eyes. - SirSkeletorThe3rd

You all should see what the creator said after this story was removed!

This is so silly and not scary, creepy pasta she about sonic are just horrible and silly. - Cobbleborg

Now first things first, I liked this creepypasta when I watched PewDiePie's gameplay of Sonic.EXE. But mostly Markiplier's gameplay. Thus makes me a big fan of this creepypasta.

V 29 Comments
3 Clockwork: Your Time is Up

This story is stupidity incarnate. At first I couldn't stop laughing. Then I found the original on Wattpad. It make me sick to my stomach. It made me so mad that I looked up the author of said story. When I wrote then, they told me that all of what happened to Natalie, happened to them. Now, don't get me wrong. It's very possible that something like this Could happen. But then they went on to say that they wanted to educate people of the problem... Then I got upset. You don't educate people of Serious issues, through a Creepypasta story. A story primarily made for popularity.

The plot twist was horrible in my opinion. Removing your own eye, which she probably didn't have any problems sight wise, and replacing it with a clock? This seems more like torture porn than anything else.

The grammar was so horrible that I could not stand it. Natalie is a ridiculous Jeff The Killer ripoff, and the whole story just sucks. It's filled with pointless gore and has no real plot- the entire point of it is to serve as a fangirl fantasy of what it would be like to be Jeff. Now I'm just wondering why I even bothered to read it.

If you like cringing then this is the story for you.

V 28 Comments
4 Tails Doll

This creepypasta is horrible. Its badly written, and just not scary at all. the concept is really bad too. I have no idea why this one is so popular.

Would be scary if they didn't just pick a random character and turn them evil.

This Creepypasta is the product of poor writing, and pure stupidity - AlienKing

You've gotta have something wrong with you if you're scared of a fox plushie.. Ridiculous! - RaccoonCartoon

V 13 Comments
5 Nina the Killer

This story is just awful plain and simple. For a troll pasta it would be AMAZING, but its that key word 'creepy' that ruins it. Before I read it I knew it was going to be terrible, but it was even worse than I thought. It is a rip off of Jeff the killer which isn't even a good story to begin with, she is too sexualized, the most cliche character ever, and to top it off: she is a jeff FAN GIRL. -_- I don't even like Jeff but this is really stupid.

How the hell is this not first? Jeff's story is overrated, but at least it was unique and well written. This story is clearly a huge ripoff of Jeff the killer. Even her catchphrase is Go To Sleep, ending with My Prince. Weren't creepy pastas meant to be scary? This is a ripoff, and her design makes her a Mary Sue. I mean, how does her hair suddenly get a purple streak in it? And why is her skirt so short? I hate this story.

This one really disappointed me. It sounds like a cheap remake of Jeff the Killer, only with a female character. The whole story sounds so similar to Jeff the Killer and she even has the same catch phrase as Jeff, only it ends with "my prince." So far, this is the only one I've heard that I don't care for.

Jane the killer is kind of alright like jeff, but somehow they made this worse

V 10 Comments
6 Slenderman Slenderman The Slender Man is a fictional supernatural character that originated as an Internet meme created by Something Awful forums user Eric Knudsen

Slenderman actually is a Creepypasta, and personally I like him. He's mysterious and supernatural, which is half the reason he's so interesting. Plus, anyone who sees him comes up missing without a trace and are never seen or heard from again, which is probably the scariest part. I love Slenderman!

The Creepypasta makes him much more powerful, and makes him unbelievable. Teleportation? Really? When he was stalking children, or depicted as the operator in Marble Hornets, he was much better. It's sad to see such a great concept be ruined. - GREATEST

This is in fact one of the better creepypastas, and an original story that makes you scared to go near any forest or woods in general. Personally, I think is a very good story in general.

Slenderman is actually not bad. The fangirls are cringy, and the game aged badly, but it was well made. The only bad thing is how the cringy fans think he's real, and make fanart of him as a girl with blood all over. - RaccoonCartoon

V 21 Comments
7 Sally.exe

This is just a pathetic version of Sonic. Exe - HELLADERE120

The moral of the story is to get your candy ass out of here.

Never read it, but I can tell by the title that it's garbage.

Who made this list? WHO MADE THIS LIST?



[We are having some technical difficulties. Please wait.]

V 9 Comments
8 Luna Platformer

Is this like Luna Game? If so, jump scares and that's it.

You play the game. You see a jump scare. THE END!

Not really that scary

What? This creepypasta is just weird though. How can I get scared by that Pink Annoying Horse staring at me in the screen? It's also creepy to smile. Not creepy to get scared but I'm literally freaked out and cringed. If she screamed one more time, I'm gonna [bleep for haters].

V 4 Comments
9 Squidward's Suicide

Like the Abandoned Disney Theme Park piece, this starts out beautifully, very suspenseful and atmospheric. Then it remembers "oh yeah, I'm a horror story," and the shock effects start piling up until everything that was good about it disappears.

This story is a swirling storm of angry flaming cliches, and it includes gore and dead children only for shock factor. They are not a major part of the story, however they are the main attraction. Because pointless violence totally makes everything scary, right guys? - GREATEST

I'll agree with these statements because it was not all that scary and the accompanying videos are not at scary

The actual SpongeBob show itself is scarier than this, haha. - RaccoonCartoon

V 12 Comments
10 Eyeless Jack Eyeless Jack

Let's check out the flaws of this story, shall we?

-The main character, Mitch, is not only blander than sandpaper and not interesting or likable in the slightest, but also somehow manages to function and walk perfectly WITHOUT A KIDNEY. Heck, he barely even notices it until the doctor tells him about it!

-When spotting Jack on the second night, Mitch takes a photo of him, instead of, I don't know, hitting him with something heavy, fighting back, calling the cops. And hell, why did he sleep at his brother's house the SECOND time around AFTER he had something REMOVE HIS KIDNEY at night? How about staying in the hospital? Or getting some police escort?

-Jack isn't scary. He really isn't. His appearance isn't particularly unsettling, his Modus Operandi is ludicrous and unrealistic, and we are just not given enough to actually become afraid of this character!

In conclusion, the ridiculous amount of cliches, hilariously dumb character decisions, and the plain ...more

Warning: this story includes a Mary-sue. Mitch, is so stupid! First of all, how does he not realize there's a cut on his face? Second of all, how do not wake up while someone is taking your kidney out? Third, why did Mitch think the most logical thing to do was take a picture of the thing instead of maybe, I don't know, screaming? And lastly, how come the guys body was still there even though the police knew about his death? Honestly, the worst story I've ever read.

Eh, one of the few Creepypastas that are actually scary. Not the scariest, but better than many Creepypastas - XxDarkStorm_PhoenixMothxX

Why did he take a PHOTO?!

V 3 Comments

The Contenders

11 666

Never heard of it but it sounds like it sucks.

Yes it's a YouTube CreepyPasta that sucks

Is this even a story?

Is this about Username 666? but that's not even a creepypasta! it's just an edited video, and I don't think it was even intended to be a scary story or an urban legend.

V 4 Comments
12 Laughing Jack

The sins of this one include:

-It's laughably (no pun intended) overrated.

-Instead of showing us some actual chemistry between James and Jack, maybe letting the mother see them interact more, we are introduced to, wait for it, GORE! Because that's what makes a good story. Gore. Unnecessary, overly detailed gore and torture, ESPECIALLY relating to a dog and a FIVE YEAR-OLD.

-When finally meeting Jack face-to-face, the mother suddenly turns into a damn ninja.

-Yet another 'AND DEN I DYED/WANT INSANE' ending. That, and the painful overabundance of unneeded cliches such as creepy children, a nightmare sequence that has no purpose but to showcase some more gore, and the dog in the story has no purpose but to get killed. NONE.

-People actually defend this one like their only child. Really? Fangirls are that stupid?

No character development to the Jack himself or even his victims, poor writing, a lot of cliche's, unnecessary over detailed gore and tortures and why he had bunch of fangirls? He is just a clown from the box!

I would say something but the other comment is pretty much spot-on

Like him as a character/ his design, not his story.

V 1 Comment
13 Jane The Killer: The Real Story

I love Jane, but the story could've been written better. At least her appearance was closer to realistic than Jeff's after a fire. People think her skin is white and her hair black, but that's the mask and wig. She is really bald. At least, in the version I heard.

I LOVE Jane but this story is mostly about Jeff and this story is way to short - spodermanfan1000

About as true as harry potter note: that's fake

Crappy Jeff ripoff, all you need to know - TwilightKitsune

V 2 Comments
14 Voicebox

I'm not kidding, this is probably the worst Creepypasta (or fanfiction in general) I have ever had the displeasure of reading. It is cliché beyond belief, doesn't make any sense, almost every character is either to corny to comprehend or is just 1 dimensional. The plot is the typical cliché romance drama, only its trying to add as much blood, raping, and killing as possible. Did I even mention its about a emo character meeting Creepypasta characters and befriending them, and marrying the Creepypasta character Ticci Toby? - AlienKing

15 Come Play With ME (Sally)

Her creator ruined her

Horribly handled rape.

16 Cupcakes

This was just a gore fest and nothing but a gore fest. I could barely get through a quarter of it, because all the gore in it just got really boring and some of it unintentionally funny. Also it was painfully slow, Pinkie doesn't even have a reason to kill Rainbow Dash or any other ponies for that matter. And I don't even like MLP but this story was still awful.

Absolutely no point. It's a torture porn and nothing else. It has nothing to do with the show and the writer should be ashamed of this because this is an absolute terrible concept.

The only reason I sort of like this pasta is it introduced me to Muffins and Pinkamena Diane Pie.

Worst out of the "shok ending" and "OBSESSIVE VIOLENCE" category on Trollpasta - AgentofAnarchy

V 7 Comments
17 Homicidal Liu

I like him, but maybe something could change, but I don't know what.

Most cliche Creepypasta I have EVER read. - AlienKing

He is cool but is very cliche

I can't stand this creepypasta. Like, really, Jeff the Killer was already a horrible story, but this contradicts every small thing of that Creepypasta. Next to that there is Pedophila in it, and it is so cliche. They want us to care about their relathionship, but they spend extremly little time on it, causing it to be boring AND creepy. That being said, it is better than most (if not all) of the " --- the killer " creepypastas, since at least the author tries to make it diffrente, and it doesn't have that silly second name thing.

V 3 Comments
18 Lavender Town Syndrome

Just not scary. How am I supposed to be scared of a SONG! Ben drowned wasn't really scary, but at least it was entertaining to read ( and watch. ) Lavender town has a creepy song, but writing a full creepy pasta on a SONG? Just doesn't cut it for me.

How do you get a song that kills people on a gameboy cart you can't even fit graphics more advanced than blobs of pixels on those

It's so boring I mean my cousin who is 4 wasn't even scared

Pokemon creepypastas are always bad. - RaccoonCartoon

V 5 Comments
19 Blood Whistle

This story is the product of stupidity, hyper realism, and poor writing. They include a topic that most likely wouldn't happen to a person. The main character does the most stupid, thing you could possibly do kill yourself over a video game. Put it down and move on with your life! Seriously!

Oh noo, there's blood so it's obviously scary! Seriously, this story is terrible. Too many cliches, bad story, and the character seriously kills himself over a ROM hack... No, I'm 100% serious there.

This deserves to be a lot higher. The main character is just so STUPID!

It's so bad its good, the pinacle of stupidity and genius

V 10 Comments
20 South Park: The REAL Pilot

If you watch South Park and you read Creepypasta, then you should know that it is IMPOSSIBLE to make a Creepypasta on South Park. Especially if it's a lost episode Creepypasta! Go read Suicidemouse.avi guys, because this is just terrible!

... I uhmmm.. well, it kind of looks like something that could happen in the actual cartoon, I mean, cartman killing all south park, it actually can be an eric's fantasy jajajajaaj... this ones crappy.

¡¡¡¡HAHAAHAHAAHAHA! oh... it's so cute to see how they are trying to make the most satiricly funny show on comedy central an actual creepypasta.

PSearch List

Recommended Lists

Related Lists

Best CreepyPastas Ever Top 10 Scariest Creepypastas Top 10 Gaming Creepypastas Top 10 Creepypastas That Should Be Made Into Movies Top Ten Pokemon Creepypastas

List Stats

700 votes
92 listings
3 years, 294 days old

Top Remixes (7)

1. Jeff the Killer
2. Clockwork: Your Time is Up
3. Tails Doll
1. Slenderman
2. Luna Platformer
3. Sonic.exe
1. Clockwork: Your Time is Up
2. Sonic.exe
3. Jeff the Killer

View All 7


Add Post

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.