Top 10 Worst Creepypastas

These short horror stories are TERRIBLE in my opinion.

The Contenders: Page 2

21 Sweet Apple Massacre

NO. This story has clichés and over-used gore everywhere!

Oh Jesus. Why. Ugh. Ok, so the main plot line is torture, rape, eating puke and body parts, and...wait for it... GORE AND DEATH! so scary. Also why did the guy kill the three kids?

You see, we get tired of ponies brutally murdering other ponies, just for the sake of murdering ponies! I like to call these Creepypastas, "pony-pastas" because that's basically what they are. And this Creepypasta doesn't really help that title. It basically revolves around some sort of MLP character murdering little girls for no reason. The story just basically goes into detail on how he tortured and raped them to death. There is nothing scary about this what so ever, and stuff like "Cupcakes" and "Rainbow Factory" are no better. I hate MLP anyway so, I couldn't care less about ponies being murderd. - AlienKing

22 BEN Drowned

This story was actually decent. Which is a surprise since the "Gaming" and "Lost Episode" genera have had such a bad reputation. The writing in this one was AMAZING to the point were I felt like I was reading a Stephen King book rather than a Creepypasta. However, it doesn't do well when it comes to the scare factor. It pretty much does this pattern of stuff like "game glitches" and Ben Drowned communicating to Jusible through the game. Overall its entertaining, but not scary. - AlienKing

Unlike other stories on this list, this one is really well written, except if just isn't scary

I actually liked this one as a story.

Not a SCARY story, though.

Well, I have to admit that is one of the least videogames copypasta (Sorry, CREEPYpasta) that aren't so cliches whit the story-telling, and if I have to say something bad, maybe the videos are not so scary as you can imagine, but still being a good fake evidence for the story.

V 10 Comments
23 The Russian Sleep Experiment

This one is overrated. Dislike me all you want, dear hypocrites, but this one isn't very different from Jeff The Killer.

The writer was too lazy to even Google stuff. Yeah, people excuse it with "oh well he's not a professional what do you expect", I expect author treating his story seriously, because if he doesn't care, why should I? And he clearly doesn't care.

"The commanding officer, an ex-KGB" - KGB didn't even exist in the 40s, you dumbass.

"The abdominal organs below the ribcage of all four test subjects had been removed." - then how the heck their digesting tract was still working? That's not possible.

Not to mention that at one point author has the two remaining subjects, and then they suddenly turn into three (and that's not a part of the story, that's just his lack of attention to his own pasta).

The last quote is taken from Twilight Zone.

The ending is just stupid.

In my opinion, this is actually one of the best Creepypastas ever written. I love this story.

This is one of the greatest creepy pastas I ever read. Some people say it's real. They're are even pictures of it. Disturbing stuff right there - SirSkeletorThe3rd

Do you expect the readers to give a crap about when there were KGB’s? No, MOST of us don’t care. (Sorry if this comes off as mean, I’m just saying that most readers probably didn’t even care when there where KGB’s. Again, I apologize if I seem like a hypocrite.) Also, this is Much better then: Jeff the Killer, Eyeless Jack, Laughing Jack, Play With Me, Sonic.exe, Clockwork, and even Abandoned by Disney and Smile Dog.

V 11 Comments
24 Sonic.exe 2: Electric Boogaloo

What is it with people and writing Sonic.exe sequels? - AlienKing

25 Who Was Phone

This one is actually INTENDED to suck, but if it was serious is COULD be scary.

I once found a story about a guy who was trying to find something out, and when he did, I think he was in another world or something, but trying to tell who phone was

The writer needed to spend more time and do what most authors do... you know... ACTUALLY TRY.

But this is a troll pasta! it was intended to suck. Actually made me laugh, and despite is really too short, I think it mocks many creepys out there.

V 7 Comments
26 Smile Dog

I really like Smile Dog, but the story is poor unfortunately. Too bad.

V 2 Comments
27 Normal Porn For Normal People

Hey guys, I know I may be burning a golden calf here, but this story sucks. The premise is a cliche in and of itself to start. Also, nothing about it is even remotely scary. It's just disgusting. - GREATEST

Even if it is real its not scary at all unless you think amputees trying to break dance is

Actually, this one is rather unique and interesting. I enjoyed it a lot.

This is overrated, its not scary, and who the heck came up with the title? - AlienKing

V 1 Comment
28 Ticci Toby

Everyone keeps hating on Clockwork, but I this one (by the same author, I believe) is much worse. It's just so cliched, trite and stupid. The protagonist is your typical insane psycho cliche, father character is your typical abusive parent cliche, and mother isn't even enough of a character to talk about her. Also, unnecessary Slenderman appearance.

I like him, but even though is story is well written, it had almost every cliche I could think of for a Creepypasta. But what's worst is what he fangirls did to him. NOBODY would be that happy after that backstory. He shouldn't even trust others that well.

That plot twist though

A boy that can't feel pain gets really angry and kill his dad. He then burns himself and becomes a proxy, yay? That's pretty much the story in a nutshell, it is so shallow and cliché that the author could've taken out all the pointless details and it wouldn't be any different. - AlienKing

V 2 Comments
29 Aladdin is Dead

This story has no sense of direction.It reads like the author made it up while writing. The plot is nonsensical. Why did the protagonist want to exploit glitches in Alladin in the first place? How can a regular, non-supernatural copy of Alladin summon the devil as long as you activate a glitch?

Also, this line: "now I'm a ginger but without the red hair"

30 Candle Cove
31 Happy Appy

If you think Squidward's Suicide is horrible, take a look at this one. The beginning is not so bad, but the further the story goes, the more ridiculous and crappy it becomes. It's quite sad someone actually wasted so much of their time to write such garbage.

It was never an ACTUAL television show... The closest thing it ever got to being featured on television was a dumb YouTube series programmed by teens who read the creepypasta... The picture itself is enough for me to applaud it!

I heard about Happy Appy as a kids show and started laughing so hard when the popular results on Google were creepy pastas instead of the actual thing. - IAmNotARobot

Oh, I'm so scared because an apple murdered children. I can only eat Granny Smiths now. - AlienKing

V 5 Comments
32 The Death of Mac

I was sitting at my computer like, "what.." - Diistortions

"What the heck" was the first thing that came to my mind after reading this...

That should be a YouTube pooop no seriously it's that pathetic

V 2 Comments
33 Charlie the Killer

A horrible badly written self insert. It doesn't even feel like a creepypasta, it feels like a terrible romance!

Read this piece of crap for yourselves. - 1337MinerDude94

34 Bored
35 Rouge exe

Practically unreadable schlock.

I hope that whoever wrote this was drunk. Then they would have an excuse.

Proof that the whole "genre" can't be taken seriously anymore. Think about it, even if you think of a genuinely-liked story such as Funnymouth or Candle Cove, you have to remind yourself that it's in the same category of stories as this travesty. Seriously, trollpasta or not, this story killed Creepypasta for me.

37 Majour Complex Carnage Project (MCCP)

This... Is... So... Funny... And mainly stupid. Watch Michaelleori's read of it.

38 MaRio II
39 Pokemon.die
PSearch List

Recommended Lists

Related Lists

Best CreepyPastas Ever Top 10 Scariest Creepypasta Characters Top 10 Scariest Creepypastas Top 10 Gaming Creepypastas Top 10 Creepypastas That Should Be Made Into Movies

List Stats

700 votes
92 listings
3 years, 330 days old

Top Remixes (7)

1. Jeff the Killer
2. Clockwork: Your Time is Up
3. Tails Doll
1. Slenderman
2. Luna Platformer
3. Sonic.exe
1. Clockwork: Your Time is Up
2. Sonic.exe
3. Jeff the Killer

View All 7


Add Post

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.