Worst Fairy Tail Characters

Even though Fairy Tail is somewhat good, some characters are really bad.

The Top Ten

1 Lucy Heartfilia

She cries in every arc. She is weaker than dirt. It looks like she picks her outfits from the kids section. She is a horrible main character. She has no purpose in the series other than to be there for fanservice. She has no goals or motives that set her apart from others. Her personality is annoying and she's just annoying in general. She doesn't fight well at all. She relies on others every single time that she's in a fight. She is so mentally and emotionally unstable. She gets in the way of everyone. She gets dumber and more useless as the series goes on. What's there not to hate about Lucy? Honestly if you think that she is a quality character then you have your standards set really low. I don't like her at all, point blank period. I always used to wonder why everyone hated her while I was watching the anime. After I watched the anime (still watching it now because A-1 is doing a fantastic job of animating Fairy Tail so far! ) and caught up to the manga, I completely understand ...more

100 thumbs up for this. I absolutely hate this prostitute crybaby scumbag known as Lucy Heartfilia. - SelfDestruct

I HATE LUCY! She always complains about her guild when she has no right to. She acts all "kind and nice" just so she can wriggle her uselessly weak butt into Fairy Tail strongest team She is so seductive that is is disgusting. Even if you look her up it says she uses her sex appeal regularly for fighting and lowering prices (She said it too). WHAT THE FUDGE that won't help you in life! LUCY YOU HAVE KNOW RIGHT TO TALK ABOUT GRAY.

Lucy is so weak that everyone else has to save her. You guys can argue and say, Oh but she summons her spirits that takes lots of magic so she is not weak. But if you really think about it they can clearly come out on their own (which makes me think they don't like and pretend to when summon). OH and the Star Dress power is stupid and she never deserved it. And have any of you guys realized she never trained at all and that all her magic was bought and given to her: like star dress. She is a disgrace to all the Fairy Tail characters since all ...more

I don't hate her because of the way she dresses, people can wear whatever they want! Doesn't matter, what I DO hate her for is using her LOOKS to attract other male characters, and "weaken" them, I also don't like how she is just used as fan service, this is just the typical damsel in distress that the hero is supposed to save, in fact, when they told me Lucy was the main character I was like "what I thought it was Natsu" YEAH! The character that steals the spotlight here is Natsu, HE is the real protagonist. Anyway back to the topic. I also hate her because they seem to try so hard to make her seem like she is "Developing" when in reality she isn't we get all of this things about her getting more keys, and all the inspirational speeches about "trying your hardest" but she is a REAL HYPOCRITE! People say she is weak, and she in fact isn't! She is just a lazy who doesn't want to use her magic, think about it, in every fight we see, Lucy is always ...more

Just plain annoying

V 280 Comments
2 Carla

Has vision of guild member crying or dying... "Carla, what's wrong? " "Oh nothing...". It's ridiculous. Then while vision actually happens "I HAD A VISION ABOUT THIS! "... No point in knowing the future if you're just gonna keep it to yourself. -_-

She's so mean. Always trying to tell Wendy what to do. Bad attitude. I don't like her at all. I don't know why Happy likes her. -_- Happy deserves better.

But when Happy almost died trying to rescue the town for Jackals explosion you could see that Carla legitimately cared about Happy. - RockT123

CARLA JUST GETS ON MY NERVES. How Wendy loves this spoiled, sassy brat? I don't know why Happy likes her. She's is super stupid, and yes, ugly, never saw a moment while she smiles.

Maybe even worse than Maurice or Caramel, but okay, last chance to you, spoiled Carla.

Everything why I watch fairy tail she is just not. I wish there was a method to just skip her sentences because whenever she talks I blank out anyway. - oidawtf

V 20 Comments
3 Natsu Dragneel Natsu Dragneel Natsu Dragneel is a Mage of the Fairy Tail Guild.Natsu is carefree and reckless in nature, and, despite his consistent brawls with the other members of Fairy Tail, he is a fiercely loyal and protective friend. He is willing to go down fighting for his friends, regardless of how futile it might seem. ...read more.

I hate Natsu. He takes up way too much of the spotlight and his whole hotheaded persona is cliched and annoying, just like his constant nakama speeches that go nowhere and are forced down our throats because apparently Mashima thinks the audience is too stupid to get the weak theme of this bull show. I mean, Friendship is Magic is more subtle than this! And him constantly starring in the show happens so often that it literally prevents character development for other characters. And don't even get me started on his contrived fights. He constantly loses throughout the battle and than suddenly, he says something about friendship and wins in one punch. Sound familiar? Cause that's how every fight goes.

The power levels are way inconsistent. First Erza's supposed to be stronger than him, but she could lose a fight to an enemy and have Natsu beat them in the end. Then when he tries to fight her again SHE'S STILL STRONGER! How does that work? Also the whole stupid character thing is ...more

Relax he is one of the main character. What bothers me is that Lucy, Happy, and Natsu have too much screen time but I'm not going to hate them. I'm just worried that Erza and Gray will never be shown again. I love the two as much as those three. I'll really cry if they let go of Erza. - ErzaScarlet

Natsu has to be one of the most broken characters in anime. After all these years fairy tail has been released he has had no development. And his power levels are just so inconsistent. The fact that he has no character development is really sad. Also, his attitude is very cliche and, in some ways, cringe worthy to watch. Also most of his "impressive moments" don't come off as impressive, but they really come off in a way that makes him unlikable. It bothers me that no one decides to change him up a bit because he is the main male character of the show. He, along with lucy are the foundation of this whole show, and they are the two characters that are rusting the most, while the other characters have to age like fine wine to add more diversity to the show. He's become a big anchor of the show and it's not good when the anchor is the main character in the show. I've tried to give him a chance but it always goes back to the same "Natsu routine." Now if this show was a ...more

I cannot stand Natsu... literally I makes me sick. everything is the same from him... HEY fight me, lets see whos more powerful! *gets ass beat* HEY I said I'm gonna fight him no fair! HEY I don't feel good motion sick. HEY I'm fired up... gets ass beat. but then out of nowhere he manages to win after he spews some pointless crap about how my friends are all I need or those are your comrades how can you be mean to them... its just terrible. I have been totally annoyed by him every single time I hear his voice... lets also talk about how he has to scream everything... also, he seems to be extremely stupid or he doesn't process things that happen around him... he can be fighting someone and use some magic but it has no effect... the enemy says "hey, that wont work" but in Natsu's tiny mind that means do it over and over again. its always the same garbage. I honestly have to say Natsu ruins the anime for me... I like most of the characters in fact BUT Natsu always bums me out with his ...more

I LOVE NATSU whats wrong with him carla is stupid sassy crappy poo natsu is cool funny and awesome

V 92 Comments
4 Juvia

You know I hate when people say that Juvia fans are idiots and not sensible and other really stupid things because we really aren't and if you dorks haven't noticed It's A SHOW GET OVER IT so what if Juvia ends up with Gray to be honest I rather Juvia end up with Lyon cause he's less of a jerk. But it's what ever to me either way. In the same way Juvia isn't a useless stupid character. And she is very strong although her obsessions over Gray is annoying at times I'm a fan of her and I find it funny and both annoying and if you losers who don't like her haven't noticed she hasn't obsessed over Gray in a while. And when she does it's just for kicks. And her situation is way different from Naruto and sakura (plus I love Naruto and Hinata together more) I mean she's not a sakura in NO way is she useless, stupid and ugly! At times Juvia may seem stupid but once again every character is different and Juvia might just need some more character development but at least she's not crying all the ...more

I cannot understand how people like this sorry excuse for a character. Juvia is nothing more than an overly obsessed stalker who is hell bent on getting Gray all to herself despite the fact he doesn't like her like that (He isn't a tsundere you can even tell by how he acts around her most of the time.), She has only had enough development for sensible people to see that she is just a slightly prettier version of Ginny weasly from Harry Potter and her little habits include washing herself with Towels and soap bars with Grays face on them which is just plain creepy and disturbing. Every major fight she has is based around Gray and her 'love' for him. She doesn't add anything to the story, if anything she takes away from it just by being there in the first place. To those Juvia fanboys and fangirls I ask you to point out one good trait that only she has and no one else has, or at least she does better than anyone else because I have done etensive research into her character and I have ...more

I have watched the anime and read the manga over and over again and I have tried my hardest to see what people like about Juvia, but there is nothing redeemable about her. Her character is bland, dull and annoying. Her obsession with Gray is unhealthy and really detrimental to his relationship with other girls (and some boys). And whilst her magic is decent at best, she doesn't even have the brain capacity to use it to it's full potential.

Juvia fans always defend her by saying the same things over and over again. They always say that she is strong, cute, funny and sweet. Well, I am sorry to break you're hearts but she is none of those things. Nothing about her character stands out, Natsu is more determined than her, Erza is stronger than her, Lucy is smarter than her and Mirajane is more good looking than her.

Not once has she added anything to the story and many times over has she actually taken away from the story just for her existing. Her fight scenes are ...more

I hate Juvia...
I don't say, that Juvia is weak, but her character is sometimes really annoying...
I hate her Gray-sama, Gray-sama, Gray-sama, Gray-sama... But Gray is fine and cool :D
I really don't ship Gruvia -_-
I like Lucy more then Juvia.

V 64 Comments
5 Jiggle Jugs

I cringe every time they make an appearance

Just don't even ask why they are in the anime - NerdyPweeps

Seriously...I don't even know why they are in the anime

Ugh. These made Key of the Starry Sky unbearable.

V 24 Comments
6 Ivan Dreyar Ivan Dreyar

After excommunication from Fairy Tail, he created Raven Tail to destroy Fairy Tail, thinking he could achieve it! What a bastard! Get him higher! - SelfDestruct

I believe he should be Number 1 on this list. I mean, he is just pure evil.

Everybody hates him.

He is a terrible father and son to laxus and makarov

V 6 Comments
7 Daphne

My first thought when I saw her: Who is this crazy chick? Second thought: GET YOUR HANDS OFF GRAY! Third: Who does she think she is, using NATSU to power a FAKE DRAGON to destroy FAIRY TAIL? And she actually thought she could pull it of? Definitely one of my least favorite.

Daphne is just a useless character from a useless filler arc. Oh how much I seriously wish Juvia was there to slap her stupid face when she touched her Gray-sama. I would've done so

Should totally be Number 1 on the List. She was annoying and so damn useless. Really really sorry excuse for a character

Me: Yes yes YES! Shut the heck up.

To be honest, I feel bad for her. About the nobody believe her thing. But she's annoying.

V 12 Comments
8 Hades

He has the best name so shut up!

He tried to kill Fairy tail. - ErzaScarlet

Is a real greek god - FrankP


V 5 Comments
9 Erza Scarlet Erza Scarlet Erza Scarlet is an S-Class Mage from the infamous magic guild Fairy Tail . Erza starts off as a lone wolf and stays loyal to following the rules. As the story develops Erza changes into loving mage strong and independent. As her terrible past haunts her she ignores her friends' calls that they want ...read more.

How is Erza not on the top 10? She's easily the worst character in the entire show. For one thing, she's overpowered. She can easily take out her enemies just by swapping out her armor, and we have no idea how she gets it. Does she buy it at a shop? Does she seduce old perverts with her massive melons? We have no idea, the manga is over 400 chapters and we still haven't any idea. Getting back to the armor thing, its always some deus ex machina garbage. She always just so happens to have the right armor, which is not only bull, but also boring to the audience. It never really challenges her to make due with limited options, but rather gives her a billion ways to accomplish a single solution. We never see her get these armor sets either. She just always has the right one at the right time. Especially that overpowered armor that lets her DISPEL ANY MAGIC AND GIVES HER A SWORD THAT CAN EVEN CUT THROUGH SPACE!

Secondly, she, like many of the other characters on this show, tends to ...more - MadameSeagull

Erza Scarlet is one of my favorite character! She seems to be overpowered but she isn't always. Natsu may be even stronger than Erza because Natsu has defeated many opponents Erza couldn't and I'm not saying she weak! Erza can admit defeat like every humans do everyday. But she doesn't! She fights for her friends even if it kills her! The one thing I dislike is that she uses her looks to attract men and pretends she's not trying to! People complain about Lucy doing that when Erza does it worst! Though it's just her flaw. Erza is a great character even though she's not my favorite.

To be honest, Erza is an perfect example of an overpowered Mary Sue. She has no personality and always gets so much credit. And what makes her a Mary Sue is that she is overpowered and has a deeply tragic past, and we're supposed to like Erza for the "why she is"...? I don't think so

She WAS a pretty good character, but now she's way too overrated

V 73 Comments
10 Minerva Orlando

I used to hate minerva so much, until I read the manga and (spoiler) she got a lot nicer and she became a good guy. She even apologized to lucy for hurting her at the grand magic games and I don't hate her anymore now.

I hated Minerva at first, especially when she hurt Lucy, Erza and Kagura Until I read the manga. She apologized for everything she did and explained why she did this. But I do think they forgave her to fast.

She was never punished for her actions and never relay repented for them. We are supposed to feel sorry for her just because her father treated her badly. She is a sadistic thug who became a good guy out of the blue

Why isn't her dad higher then her?

V 7 Comments

The Contenders

11 Lisanna Strauss Lisanna Strauss

I swear, it's like people are desperate to find any stupid reason to hate on Lisanna. Yes, she's under-developed, barely has screen time, and her magic makes her look weak. But saying that she's out to get Natsu, or trying to copy Lucy is a bunch of crap. Lisanna is her own person, and she has not done anything wrong. She's kind, and extremely close with her siblings. She treats everyone in the guild (including Lucy) as a friend. Again, she is just an incomplete character who doesn't deserve all of this hate.

It's the annoying NaLu fan base that hates her lol. I don't have a problem with Lissana, she's nice. I like how all these comments about Lisanna all involve Lucy haha, it's so pathetic to hate a character for shipping reasons.

Lisanna is kinder than Lucy and not to mention, she's way prettier. Her talking about marrying Natsu kinda scares me, but overall she's pretty normal and really nice and never treated anyone meanly.

Lisanna has always been an extremely pointless character- except when she was dead. When we thought she was dead, she was incredibly powerful as a plot device and was a powerful motivation for the others. She was GOOD that way, because she was a loving sister and a tragic lost friend to Natsu.

And then she was suddenly back and all consequences erased. Her character wasn't funny, wasn't even as kind as they tried to portrayed, and her relationship with Natsu was just annoying. She was brought back only to be shoved to the background was a complete waste.

V 61 Comments
12 ichiya ichiya

Just seeing this makes me wanna barf and suicide at the same time. - Fandom_Lover

His face grosses me out enough that I couldn't eat. - waterlover

His not strong. I hate his face too


V 30 Comments
13 Zeref Zeref Zeref Dragneel is a character from the anime/manga series, Fairy Tail, created by Hiro Mashima. He debuted in chapter 200 of the manga, and episode 96 in the anime. In Fairy Tail, Zeref is considered to be the strongest, most evil Mage of all time, who possesses extremely dangerous, and powerful Magic. ...read more.

I don't know what you people are talking about like Zeref is so sweet even as a created of black magic he wants the world to be right even if that means that he has to die in the end it would all be for the sake of the new generation. He literally said that he has see many generation and seen them die. He cried people what bad guy would do that he asked Natsu to kill him and told them that they should not come near him. He understands he is a bad guy but he is trying to change. Don't even say he is a bad guy that's a bad excuse so don't even say that. Bad characters can be sick to so just shut up cause you don't know a damn thing.

Zeref is very misunderstood and he had good intentions but went about them the wrong way so people bashed and judged him for it. All he wanted was to resurrect his brother, Natsu. I deeply respect that. - RockT123

Zeref's my favorite Fairy Tail character! He's actually a good guy, with good purpose but is misunderstood. His curse kill every lives he values, so considering the fact that he was said to have killed many people, it means he values a lot of lives. He even isolated himself so as not to kill anymore lives. He loves his brother deeply, and sacrificed his whole life for the sake of his brother. His life is so tragic, 'because everyone always reject and hate him for what he has done, though he didn't mean it and can't control it. If I had a curse the same as Zeref's for 400 years like that, I think I would've gone mad a long time ago, so respect and sympathize him people. - Goku02

ARE YOU KIDDING ME!? HE IS THE CREATOR OF ALL DEMONS, HE'S KNOWN FOR HIS MEGA AWESOME POWER!, AND HE'S JUST so CUTE...and for those who haven't noticed he felt sorry for all the bad things that happened in the world, THE MAN CRIED FOR GOD'S SAKE! Honestly those who hate him just stop. You people can't just hate someone without giving them a chance especially if that person is as badass as Zeref.


V 24 Comments
14 Levy

She's smart, she has a good dynamic with Gajeel, I honestly don't see anything wrong with her

She's so weak and never even tries to get stronger, just keeps using her dumb scribbling nonsense. I was amazed when she got picked for S class seeing as she's so incredibly weak. She constantly just leads those two guys on seems to enjoy it, and adds nothing rather than being a helpless female who's smart on occasion

Why does she try to fight knowing she can't? Still, smartness makes her forgivable. - SelfDestruct


V 7 Comments
15 Evergreen

She's okay, but it kinda annoys me that she tries to take Erza's title as "Queen of the Fairies".

Too vain. WAY too vain. But she's cool.

Whaaa? I always thought she was pretty cool

ugh. - ayumi-oki

V 1 Comment
16 Lamy

Lamy should be the most hated character! Her laugh, her attitude JUST EVERYTHING IS HORRIBLE ABOUT HER (She's the character that created the demons) Thumbs up Jackal when you blew her away.

Anyone has a channel and knows Red Vs Blue? Edited the song "Let me blow you, away" by Donut

She is just stupid

B-but shes so cute and innocent... - ayumi-oki

V 3 Comments
17 Kinana

What has Kinana done that's deserve to be hated to be honest? - Goku02

Just no... Why is Kinana here?

Umm no. Shes okay in my book.

18 Erigor
19 Plue

What's so bad about Plue? I think he's adorable.

I love plue so much he is so adorable

I feel like if you stabbed plue he would just gush out dough.


V 4 Comments
20 Aquarius

Why would Aquarius even be here? I know she's mean. But deep down she's kind and she always cared for lucy. I really love her. Sacrificing her future moments with lucy to save lucy's friends/comrades (when she told lucy to break her key) it's the most heartbreaking episode

I love Aquarius lol she roasts so hard on lucy when I can't... makes me so happy

I love Aquarius. She is one of my favorite characters and is SUPER funny when she yells at Lucy. I love it when she's summoned and I don't understand why she's on this list. She's awesome

Bro. she is actually a really nice person...if you saw lucy's backstory with her you would see how. - ayumi-oki

V 8 Comments
PSearch List

Recommended Lists