Top Ten Worst Hell's Kitchen Contestants That Got a Black Jacket

The Contenders: Page 2

21 Joy - Season 12

She had such a great chance to win. Then she decides to throw it all away over a few mistakes in one service. Such a shame.

A bully with kashias fat ass as musle, as soon as she went their little let's stick together plan burned so she ran off in tears - BogsDollocks

I'll give her credit, she can cook. Too bad her attitude sucks along with her confidence level. She may have been taking out on the rest of the team, especially individuals (I.E. Jessica, Scott), but never Keshia. If people don't see that then what kind of a smart person would eliminate themselves knowingly?

She was great. Too bad she quit. I wonder why she didn't return on the last episode to help the finalists.

22 Susan - Season 11

Susan have an issues with cooking lamb, should be here - Orbitovsky

Shouldn't be on here

What a moron you can't cook lamb over and over again should been eliminated a lot earlier

What are you nardia in narnia? Susan should have been in final - BogsDollocks

V 1 Comment
23 Jared - Season 15

He was just so annoying. He didn't take responsibility for his own mistakes and blamed in others causing their eliminations. His attitude was bad and just not deserving of a black jacket.

If you think that he shouldn't be on here, then rewatch episodes 2 and 3. Never take jabs at a relatively strong team member.

V 1 Comment
24 Tommy - Season 9

He is a good cook. He should not be on here

Shouldn't be on here

Maybe he's not a good communicator, but he's a good cook

Should be number 1

25 Julia - Season 3

Purposely sabotaged Bonnie during the finale, what a sore loser.

She doesn't deserve to be in n the list. For someone with no culinary education, she did great. Even if she did what she did to Bonnie, all the other so called "great chefs" would use her as an scapegoat. I don't blame her for what she did. If anything, she's the only contestant that would learn the quickest.

Julia was one of the best contestants EVER!

26 Clemenza - Season 10

Clemenza is a good chef. He didn't deserve to be nominated 6 times.

Why is Clemenza here?

Terrible personality.. Screwed Justin in the finale...

It was 7 times actually.

V 1 Comment
27 Ed - Season 7

Shouldn't be on here

28 Andrea - Season 5

What this girl was doing in final three or even in Black is beyond me... Her saving crace was that Coleen and Lacey were on her team without them she would have been out long before black... Ben, Robert (without health problems) or Giovanni were thousand times better than Andrea could have hoped to be. and most of the blue team...

V 1 Comment
29 Ashley - Season 15
30 Benjamin - Season 7

I can't believe he said rice is POOR food! Everyone eats it.

His ego got in the way.

31 Garrett - Season 2

Garrett shouldn't be on here.

32 Barbie - Season 10

Shouldn't be on here

Barbie didn't deserve a black jacket or a season 17 all star spot she deserves a spot in a psych ward where crazy can be kept safe.

BArbie didn't deserve to get a black jacket

Why not? Despite having to put up with Tiffany, she was a pretty good chef overall and definitely one of the better contestants of season 10. - HanSolo69

Barbie didn't deserve a black jacket

33 Autumn - Season 7

Shouldn't be here - Orbitovsky

34 Bonnie - Season 3

Oh hell no! Bonnie was one of the best contestants of her season! If there's any contestant that should have been eliminated instead of Brad, it was Josh.

It was not that she was a bad person but I think Brad should of gotten the black jacket that she got>

35 Scott - Season 12

What is he doing on this list?

I love Scott... what the hell?

Scott made a biggest comeback

Joy should have won...

V 3 Comments
36 Sara - Season 2

Look, I don't care if she was able to cook. The fact that she actively tried to sabotage her team throughout the season is enough to land her a spot on this list.

Not all the chefs eliminated were worse than her, Rachel was a little better

Who else should have been worthy of a black jacket instead of Sara. Granted her attitude stink, but everybody eliminated before the black jackets were very terrible except maybe Maribel. Aside from Heather and Keith and in the latter part Virginia, it wasn't the best year at HK.

37 Giovanni - Season 5

Seems that the last episode, his attitude turned for the worst, first by been disrespectful to Paula, than to Chef Ramsey himself (and been confrontational as well) and than caused a major burn to Robert's hand because he left a sizzling plate in the freezer.

He made the biggest mistake ever talking back to Chef Ramsay.

Shouldn't be on here

He said, "I'm not d***f ace." WHILE HE WAS WEARING A BLACKJACKET.

38 Ben - Season 5

Ben is a good cook and I don't understand why he is up here

Shouldn't be on here

Ben is clumsy, he should be on here. Though he's far superior to Josh, Matt, Jimmy and Virginia

39 Jessica - Season 1

Cry Baby...

40 Keith - Season 2

He should have gotten into the final over Virginia.

Shouldn't be on here.

He should. Instead of rudely accusing Ramsay of favoritism, he should have kept his mouth shut and accepted his defeat.

Should have been in the final 2

PSearch List

Recommended Lists

Related Lists

Top 10 Hell's Kitchen Contestants That Did Not Get a Black Jacket Top Ten Hell's Kitchen Chefs With Black Jackets That Did Not Make It to the Finale Top Ten Hell's Kitchen Chefs Without Black Jackets that Did Not Make It to the Finale Best Hell's Kitchen Contestants Top 10 Hell's Kitchen Season 16 Contestants

List Stats

300 votes
43 listings
3 years, 271 days old

Top Remixes

1. Matt - Season 4
2. Josh - Season 14
3. Sabrina - Season 8
1. Elise - Season 9
2. Robyn - Season 10
3. Kashia - Season 12
1. Elise - Season 9
2. Kashia - Season 12
3. Matt - Season 4



Add Post

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.