Top Ten Worst Lord of the Rings Characters

CaptainComedy17
Vote for your least favorite Lord of the Rings character.

The Top Ten

1 Denethor

I hate him for being so cruel with Faramir, who is one of the greatest guys in the whole book/movie. And he didn't accept the return of the real king, and almost gave away Gondor to Sauron...

IDIOT #1 he tried to set himself on fire with his son all he ended up was drinking oil and setting himself on fire then as he was burning he threw himself off the citidel of gondor which is the highest building ever it literally is the tip of the city and this was all during the biggest war in the whole series! His army was versing 4 different nations while he committed suicide because his oldest son boromir died and his younger son survived. He didn't even care about the war! What an idiot

Dude he is a total freak and cannot accept his younger son and throws himself off a cliff! FAIL.

How is Frodo higher than this guy? Denethor was THE WORST. I would actually rather hang out with Saruman, Sauron or a whole city full of Orcs than with this guy.

V 36 Comments
2 Frodo Frodo Frodo Baggins is a fictional character and is the main protagonist of J. R. R. Tolkien's novel The Lord of the Rings. He was a Hobbit of the Shire during the Third Age. He was also a Ring-bearer, a best friend to Samwise Gamgee, and one of the three Hobbits who sailed from Middle-earth to the Uttermost ...read more.

FIRST OFF I WOULD JUST LIKE EVERYONE TO KNOW THAT I WASTED A VOTE ON FRODO SO I COULD TELL ALL OF YOU WHO VOTED FOR HIM THAT YOU WERE IN EVERY WAY COMPLETELY 100% WRONG. First of all, frodo had the hardest, most challenging and life threatening mission off all of them, and he was carrying the RING so I think he has an excuse for being a little crazy! Without frodo sauron would have easily had the ring and taken control of all middle earth! Frodo was also the only character to not be drawn to the rings power at first notice of it. If you recall, one of the first things he does with the ring is TRY TO GIVE IT BACK TO GANDALF. Everyone else, including SAM was drawn immediately to the rings power. Also he didn't know who to trust with sam and gollum! The ring was messing up with his thoughts, it wasn't his fault you would have probably done the same thing! Oh wait, no you wouldn't have because you would NEVER have made it that far in the first place! K rant over bye

Agreed. People just use these lists to put good characters on here as a joke or because they are just stupid. It's like when you look on a list of the worst and Someone always has to put the best - Dodgers27

YES! Isn't it brilliant. Frodo complaining all through the trilogy, blaming Sam for things that he hadn't actually had done, misunderstood the obvious, and, in sheer stupidity, holding the one ring clearly in line of sight towards the villains that want to take it from him. I mean seriously, instead of just running away out of sight and keeping the ring hidden underneath his close, he stands in one spot, takes the ring out from either underneath his shirt or his pocket, and uselessly shows it to the person or creature who is after it. What an IDIOT. I'm surprised that Sam went through the whole journey without saying "you know what?, you're an idiot, I'm leaving

Sam didn't say that because Sam is a nice person who will always be loyal to Frodo. - PeeledBanana

People are incredibly unfair to Frodo. He was wearing the ring the whole journey. He wasn't himself! Of course he was unpleasant at times. The ring was playing with his mind. I mean Boromir didn't even wear it, and was in contact much less longer, yet got manipulated to the point he tries stealing it. The fact the Frodo managed to resist as long as he did is very impressive. I'd like to see anyone else do the same! - Debbie9

Frodo is the most revolting, pathetic, boring and uninspiring little turd I've ever seen in the entire trilogy! I mean seriously all he does is nag, then drops dead, then gets up without a scratch, nags, drops dead again and the story continues... has the habit of taunting all the enemies by showing them the ring and then standing in the exact spot motionless for them to take it(it got me to the point of thinking that he's actually on their side! )... trusts deformed freaks over his best friend and kinsman... and at the very end in some moronic and awkward way he decides to keep the ring...
Now contrary to Frodo's incompetence and aggravating character, The character of Sam was the true hero as he did almost all the work, even carrying Frodo while he nagged about the ring being such a tremendous burden(sigh). Sam will always be my most favorite character in LOTRs. - NightRay

V 49 Comments
3 Arwen

Can she ever speak without changing her volume? Seriously, every time she speaks it like (LOUD then soft LOUDER soft LOUD) And she keeps speaking then whispering. JUST EITHER SPEAK, OR WHISPER! Don't DO BOTH! Its difficult to describe in words about how she speaks but hopefully you understand what I mean

I really did not like her. Probably because she was only ever MENTIONED twice in the WHOLE series in the books, AND replaced my favorite character (Glorfindel) just so the movies could be "non-sexist". Such a pile of crap. I don't want so watch a girl cry every time she shouldn't be on screen instead of watching an ancient Elvish Lord rip orcs to shreds.

In the book, her strength was spiritual and emotional. We have this idea that to be a good female character, she has to be an action girl. - FrozenHatingPokefan

A Mary sue, boring, trophy wife, and shoehorned through few phrases in the books and unconvincing mentions in letter. Worst character indeed.

Boring and useless eowyn deserves Aragorn

V 6 Comments
4 Grima Wormtongue

I don't think you understand. Grima was once a man of Rohan, tainted by Saruman's foul magic. In the end, Grima betrayed Saruman before he was shot himself.

What could he have gained out of screwing around with Rohans leader. If gandolf did not save that king guy than everything would of been bad...

Ew get away you ugly maniac! Your crazy and stupid!

This little buttwipe tainted a KING! He deserves to die a very painful death. Grima Wormtongue is the worst LOTR character there is.

V 4 Comments
5 Gollum Gollum Gollum is a fictional character from J. R. R. Tolkien's legendarium. He was introduced in the 1937 children's fantasy novel The Hobbit, and became an important supporting character in its sequel, The Lord of the Rings.

He's creepy. In general all the lotr characters are good. Plus everyone should stop hating on Frodo because his job was very hard.

Everyone stop hating poor Frodo! He had to carry the Ring as a huge burden in all the movies! It's not his fault he was making poor choices! It was the Rings! Sure he was stupid at times, but the Ring did most!

Why does everyone hate fro do

I must say, Gollum is really an amazing complicated character. But, to tell the truth, all his moments are so boring, like.. when you watch the movie again, you're obviously gonna skip through his scenes

V 13 Comments
6 Galadriel Galadriel

She's really bossy and gives everyone presents.

She's just a bit pointless really and very presumptuous

Everyone makes such a big deal about this chick who does nothing and couldn't be less helpful. She just stands there with that stupid, smug grin being useless

Don't mess with Galadriel, she banished Sauron and the nine to middle with only Earendils light.

V 4 Comments
7 Elrond

People say they hate him because of the arwen situation, but actually, he was pretty cool about it, if a normal dad found out his daughter was gonna die over someone, well he would hack him apart witha, a machete

I wish Elrond was my dad!

Elrond is not that bad. Imagine being immortal and coming to terms with having your daughter die and living without her,forever. You would not be too keen on having that happen. But in the end, he made the greatest sacrifice and let her stay, despite how much it hurt him because he knew the most important thing was his daughters happiness, more important than his own.

ELROND SHOULD NOT BE ON HERE. - dragonfly99

8 Boromir

One Shall Not Simply vote for this one

One shall not put Boromir on this list. I don't know why Boromir is on this list. He went down like a boss. He also was the only person to die. That proves he fought his hardest and fought till the very end. We can all be proud of Boromir in our hearts. Should have used his shield though.

He was not a bad character, but he had absolutely nothing to set him apart from a normal soldier besides that he was strong, and was kinda royalty. Not bad, just really bland. I was so happy that he died instead of an important character.

Boromir is bad I just want to annoy the people claiming he is not

V 7 Comments
9 Gimli

Gimli is cool, tough, and rocks

I dislike any person who voted on him. Gimli is an intelligent kind dwarf who wants to help out

Gimli is awesome and hilarious.

How come everyone who voted on this is saying good things about him? This is for the WORST character in LOTR. (Also I like Gimli, I just voted so I could ask)

V 1 Comment
10 Eowyn

Guys, Eowyn was brave. She fell in love and that was sad. She just tried to be in love which I admire. She also is a fighter of the women and this makes me so happy. She is handy with a sword and is very brave and fearless. She slayed a fell beast and killed the witch king! She is awesome and I waisted a vote to tell you how epic she is and how crazy you guys are for putting her on here!

Eowyn was pretty much useless- just flicking her hair around through out the films and lusting so obviously after Aragorn. It's pathetic. Also she is so attention seeking- just constantly wanting to go to battle when really she should've been listening to the King!

Eowyn is one of the best characters! You peeps are crazy!

Cringy character

V 10 Comments

The Contenders

11 Bilbo

Agree about Legolas go Legolas! He is the best movie character of all time

V 2 Comments
12 Pippin

I actually really like his character. Yes, he caused a lot of trouble, but eventually he had a much more important role and was pretty interesting and likeable.

I didn't want to vote on Pippin, but I had to tell you guys that you're all wrong. Yes, in the first two films he was there for mostly comic relief, but during the Return of the King he was the main vantage point for Minas Tirith. His character evolves from care-free and funny to burdened and wise. His charge with the rest at the Battle of the Black Gate was heroic. He's a great, likeable character and no one should hate him.

What? Noo.. He is the cutest

Pippin is amazingly annoyin thoughout the story. Why they kept him on the team is a mystery to me. He caused Frodo to be attacked by the Nazgul at weathertop, Gandalf to die, he's just a burden.

V 5 Comments
13 Sauron Sauron

I don't really hate any character so I'm voting for Sauron because he's evil. Hehe. - BKAllmighty

Sauron wasn't even a character in the trilogy. He was just a long range outdoor surveillance camera. He did nothing else than sometimes giving Frodo some LSD to keep him permanently high.

Sauron wasn't even a real character. You get a little background on him, and then he just ends up being this ever-present entity that doesn't actually do anything. He just somehow sends armies in the hope that he will get the ring and destroy the world, but the rest of the time he is completely useless. Just an eye looking for it's ring of power. The ring had more character than Sauron ever did.

Well, he is the Devil's right hand.

V 3 Comments
14 Legolas Legolas Legolas is a character in J. R. R. Tolkien's legendarium. He is a Sindarin Elf of the Woodland Realm and one of nine members of the Fellowship of the Ring.

He doesn't just shoot arrows. Id say he is a better swordsman than the rest as well. Plus he is the most agile and can accomplish physical feats none of the others can

I don't dislike Legolas, but I am really annoyed at the people who treat him like the best character ever. He can shoot arrows. I can't really list many other character traits.

Legolas has a certain feeling that makes him funny, but adorable at the same time. He does have traits, but a person like you can't recognize them. - LegoGeek21

I'm not kidding when I say that I want legolas out of the movies. He doesn't change the story in any way, he's just useless. Not obeying fysics while fighting does not make a good character. Unlike good character's should legolas doesn't change, accomplish or learn anything in the entire trilogy.

Seriously, no member of the fellowship belongs here! As for Legolas, I think people are just jealous at the amount of attention he received, especially from fangirls. But the fellowship wouldn't have been the same without him or Gimli, or Frodo. - Debbie9

V 10 Comments
15 Merry

May I please make something very clear? SAM is #4 ranked on best LotR characters. SAM is also a girl name. MERRY is a boy and a girl name, just like SAM. I'm sorry, but the fact that Merry is in top ten WORST LotR characters because of his Name blew my mind. He's my second favorite character after Pippin. PIPPIN is also a boy AND girl name, thank you!

I wasted s vote on this to share some information. Merry's full name is Meriadoc Brandybuck, Merry is a nicname. Pipin's is the same way, his is Peregrin Took - Hannah_Hannah

He would have been the best character in the book if it weren't for the fact that because of his name I didn't know he was male until chapter four! MERRY IS A GIRL NAME, ACTUALLY SO IS PIPPIN! If Tolkien wanted to give them those names he should have made them girls

16 Sam

Sam is awesome, I mean when he carried Frodo up the mountain, you can't beat that

What's Wrong With Sam?

This guy was so in love with frodo it made the whole movie so cringy my god I swore I fast forward the scenes with him and frodo its just not good at all I think its just the actor

His fault why gollum overtook smeagol!

V 4 Comments
17 Eomer

He isn't ugly, I only hate him for when he said he would cut of Gimli's head. That is really mean

V 4 Comments
18 Mrs. Sackville-Baggins
19 Tom Bombadil

He is one of the kindest characters in the book series. He doesn't do a lot in the books, but that isn't the reason to hate him.

Honestly, he was kind of pointless in the books and I almost stopped reading it because of him.

There's a reason he wasn't in the movies lol

Gay.

V 3 Comments
20 Otho Sackville-Baggins
21 Saruman Saruman Saruman the White is a fictional character and a major antagonist in J. R. R. Tolkien's fantasy novel The Lord of the Rings.

Ok why does everyone hate Sam!? Forget about far! Frodo wouldn't of gone ANYWHERE without Sam!

The White Wizard. The Elder and wise Istari. The First badass Bad guy. Puppet of Sauron, still, a Good character.

It's Christopher Lee! How can you hate Christopher Lee? He is Willy Wonka's father and a Sith Lord...

He died singing trololololololo

22 Hama

Why do you guys hate him? What did he ever do to become on this list?

What did he ever do to get on this list?!

23 Braga

He isn't even in the lord of the rings! He is in the Hobbit, not the LOTR series because he died already by getting crushed by a greedy dragon

24 Fatty Bolger

He's fat and he fights like my grandmas gramdmas great grandma

25 Deagol

The only thing he does is to die!

26 Gothmog

He was awesome directing the siege of Gondor. So what if he's deformed? They're probably scars from previous battles! - IronSabbathPriest

Whoa.. the arrogant and ugly (even amid the orcs community) bastard. Not the worst character but definitely the most annoying one.

V 1 Comment
27 Mr. Sackville-Baggins
28 Tauriel

Was not in the books and was just used to make teenage girls squeal over the romance

What did she ever do?!

Extremely pointless.

The character was pointless and the actress was a bitch.

V 4 Comments
29 Thranduil

I hate him for capturing the dwarves, if Gandalf was with the dwarves at that time, then they wouldn't be captured. Thranduil should get his head cut off by Gandalf, he deserves it, really.

He is racist towards Dwarves. I mean he doesn't even want to reconcile he just goes straight to being grumpy and war hungry the moment the Dwarves ask him for his Jewels or whatever

Thranduil is the biggest jerk and I hate him.

30 Master of Laketown

He is ugly and fat and greedy. Why the heck didn't bard chop of his head when he still could!
Jobs, shelter and food are no laughing matter! I hope Smaug personally murders him in the next hobbit movie

Why are Thranduil, Frodo, Galadriel and Pippin on this list? Clearly Frodo was the main reason this whole trilogy even happened.

V 1 Comment
31 Gandalf Gandalf Gandalf the Grey, later known as Gandalf the White, is a fictional character and one of the protagonists in J. R. R. Tolkien's novels The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings. He was an Istar, sent by the West in the Third Age to combat the threat of Sauron, as well as leader of the Fellowship of the Ring ...read more.

He lit a light

The GRAND Wizard who did not cast a single spell in the whole movie, I mean offensive spells. Is it not what a wizard does? Casting spells? Destructive or protective? He was using his staff as a melee weapon, nothing else. Ok I admit he did some Jedi trick on the possessed king but I wasn't satisfied by one trick. Show us some meteor shower or at least some fireballs. Lvl1 magician spell in every gameXD.

32 Alfrid

I'm pretty sure he was only put in the Hobbit movies just for everybody to hate.

V 1 Comment
33 Orcs

They tortured Gallup. 'enough said. Moria Orcs are a different story though.

V 1 Comment
34 Lurtz
35 Isildur

He could have thrown the ring in the Fire then nothing would have happened

36 Aragorn Aragorn Aragorn II, the son of Arathorn II and Gilraen, is a fictional character from J. R. R. Tolkien's legendarium and is one of the main protagonists of The Lord of the Rings. He was a great ranger and warrior, and as Isildur's heir he bore the shards of Narsil, reforged and renamed Andúril, in the War ...read more.

I love Aragorn! I mean he would do anything for Those little hobbits and he protects everyone and is very wise (maybe not as much as Gandalf) ❤

Just shoved into the spotlight too often. I believe he was overdone...

Creepy as hell. I try to understand why this guy annoys me so much. That line in the film: "The age of Men is over. The time of the Orc has come. " Yeah, like Sauron thought the Orcs as more than just servants and soldiers

37 Théoden

I cannot believe no one mentioned anything about Théoden, the king of Rohan. He was totally helpless and yet showed so much attitude to Gandalf and Aragorn.

V 1 Comment
38 Gamling

What's wrong with him?!

39 Bain

He's from The Hobbit not L.O.T.R.

Who the heck is Bain?

40 Kili the Dwarf

Annoying. Acts like a typical immature American teenager or college boy. And worst of all, he stole spotlight from Fili, who was much cooler.

Yeah, I think Kili is slightly overrated, but he is still cool. Fili is better looking in my opinion and he is a better fighter.

41 Oin the Dwarf

If you dislike him for being a fool to try to reclaim Moria, then it's fine with me

42 Tilda
43 Sigrid
44 Madril

Why did they add him in the movies? He's just a minor captain of the ithilien Rangers who gets impaled by an ugly Orc.

45 Glorfindel
46 Gil-Galad
47 Elros
48 Shelob

She's an evil fat ugly spider. Of course everyone hates her.

49 Rosie

What a stupid name!

50 Percy
PSearch List

Recommended Lists

P