Top 10 Worst Mario Games

The Contenders: Page 2

21 New Super Luigi U

Are you idiots done yapping about Peach? I'm sick of hearing you complaining about her. I hate her, but no need to complain about her 24/7. - TheYoshiOverlord

When I heard this was going to be an extra feature, I was thrilled. We all know the dread of deciding who has to be Mario. Everyone is tired of being Mario. Can we be Luigi or a Toad? Nintendo screwed up with a time limit for another character. Why don't we just have a character selection in the title screen? You could be anyone you wanted to, and not just Mario or Luigi. You would get to choose from the original 4, no matter how many players.

The time limit makes it so annoying. The levels may be shorter but it doesn't make that much of a difference.

I forgot about this game...
Worst Mario game ever. - DaisyandRosalina

V 9 Comments
22 Mario's Game Gallery

Princess Daisy & Pauline both were supposed to be in this overall great game, not Princess Peach (despite not being as bad in this game).

Don't you dare criticize this game. This game is a masterpiece!

You know, this is just Mario's (so called) FUNdamentals ALL OVER AGAIN!

It's only 5 games!

23 Mario's Fundamentals

Just 1 Year before the great Super Mario 64 was realased, Nintendo made a game for you to do whatever you want with the plumber... like play chess or go fish.
One intrusting note through this was the first time players heard the current voice of Mario.

Mario's Fundamentals is so underrated!

I'd give this game 13 stars out of 20.

The game seemed a bit interesting... But it's so underrated some how

Come here fishy fishy! CHII----- what is with the cut? - BlueSheepYT

V 4 Comments
24 Wrecking Crew

This game is great! It's better than Wreck it Ralph!

Also, Wrecking Crew is too underrated! This game is cool! Memorable graphics, great music, a purple Luigi, masculinity, the bonus, the level amount's proportion, & even this game isn't confusing! It also takes place at night! :D So this game could be low on this list.

Did nobody notice, that was Disney taking this game and was made like Wreck it Ralph the movie?

That game is not really that good, it is actually bad one.

Wrecking Crew isn't as bad as everyone says, it's actually quite enjoyable. - recaller

We all Know the Mario Bros's jobs are plumbers, but in this they done construction? An early game in the NES Library Wrecking Crew was about as boring as Luigi was purple.

I wouldn't really consider this a Mario game, more of a game with Mario plastered into it. - GengarGuy

V 13 Comments
25 Donkey Kong Country 2: Diddy's Kong Quest

I'd still play it.

Dixie Kong just ruined it!

Dixie Kong looks like a stupid version of Daisy Duck.

Diddy & Dixie are bitches. Despite Dixie Kong's severe courage, she sucks anyway, but won't be worse than Princess Peach. Also, Sonic the Hedgehog in person was actually supposed to be in this game, not just his shoes. The best part of the game is the King K. Rool levels whereas you get Diddy & Dixie actually encountering Link from Zelda.

26 Mario's Super Picross

Hitler's Super Picross sucks... (*Bweck*) - AldoFitrian

27 Mario and Luigi: Dream Team

This game is absolute trash it's passed with nothing but forced tutorials and when they don't don't show up the gameplay consists of long and tedious gimmicky battles. The characters are the same old boring cast and the new villain is missed potential because he is tossed aside.

Peach may have been kinda cold, but this game still had a ton of creative characters, creative worlds and humor! In my opinion this was the last good Mario RPG so far.

This game is so bad that it deserves to be top 1! And I can't believe people like Princess Peach in this game! She sucks & hates winning!

Terrible game I fell asleep, no action too many tutorials. I don't care for Luigi anymore he's no underdog he's just a more overrated mario now.

V 15 Comments
28 Super Mario Bros.: The Lost Levels

This is why they're called the lost levels when one of the earlier games were released, the Japanese people thought that some of the levels were too hard for Americans. For the English release, the hard levels were taken out. These levels are known as the lost levels. Later, they were released in America seperate from the actual games. You really can't complain; These levels were made to be impossible.

What?!? This game may be hard but keep pressing on! I've finished the game an it is awesome! - HeavyDonkeyKong

There could be a Super Mario Advance 7: The Lost Levels, please.

Stop complaining, it's just hard, OK? - BlueSheepYT

V 7 Comments
29 Mario & Luigi: Superstar Saga

Great game should be lower

If I see other people ay anything bad about the criminally underrated presentation of older RPGs than Mario & Luigi: Bowser's Inside Story (especially the ones released in the 2nd millennium's end) I will shoot myself.

I prefer Sonic and Tails: Superstar Saga.

1. sonic and tails super star saga sounds terrible reason have you played the sonic cronicals 2. I loved this game it had awesome music.

V 3 Comments
30 Mario vs Donkey Kong

Awesome, underrated game with unique puzzles and visuals, with exceptional gameplay. The only thing lacking here is the story, but it's not really important in a game like this. - Cobalt

What moron put this on here? - Devilking190

Why is this game here? I played it a couple of years ago on an emulator and it is amazing. It got clever puzzles the controls are actually fluid and the graphics are so colorful. The storyline is recycled thoug, no originality here. Saving Daisy from the mighty ape. It is like saving Peach(Toadstool) from the mighty King of the Koopas. But the gameplay is MIND BLOWING. Like literally. - OldSchoolGamer1983

31 New Super Mario Bros. Wii

Why is it on the list!?!? - terriblebeast13

Because of Princess Peach, the lack of Princess Daisy/Rosalina, the graphics, Princess Peach's voice, the story, Princess Peach's appearance & if awful at this game.

For the love of God, stop whining about how you have to rescue Peach! If you hate a Mario game for that, you hate almost all of them. - Garythesnail

Peach haters have the right to blame Nintendo. Nintendo originally planned Peach to be playable but they scrapped that because of how Peach's Dress to move.

Hey. Have you lost your mind? Do you hate this game? Do you think that this is he worst game ever? Is Mario a jerk? Are you stupid? If so...

V 31 Comments
32 Paper Mario Color Smash

It's basically Sticker Star 2. - noo7na7

It's Sticker Star 2 for the Wii U. (Need I say more? )

It's Not Even Out Yet!

The game is actually good, it actually has a plot, heartwarming seqences, and a better battle system, ok the battles are still based on sticker star, but you acctually get something. I say get it later.

V 4 Comments
33 Paper Mario: Color Splash

I think this game is underrated, and I will fight you on this opinion. - GengarGuy

Worse than hotel Mario? Nothing is worse than hotel Mario

Worse than hotel Mario? Man, people have weird opinions

Screw This Game

V 3 Comments
34 Mario Strikers Charged

Say what now?! This game is the best game

The Mario Strikers series could've taken place in British Columbia where Next Level Games actually is. & why was Super Mario Spikers discontinued?

This game is cool but could use improvements.

Are you guys high? This game is hella awesome - Hater

V 5 Comments
35 Paper Mario

You gotta be kidding me. How the heck is this game on this list? This game was the epitome of fun on the Nintendo 64 and virtual console.

I don't want to raise a finger of objection, but let's look at this game with a bit of critique. First of, the gameplay is always important. And given this was Mario's second coming into the RPG genre, the story needed to be kept simple for new gamers. Unfortunately, that does not excuse poor writing. And its boss fights aren't that creative either. Very minor nitpicks, but it's worth noticing.

Why the heck is this game on the list?!?! This game is amazing! Take this off! - Aaa2

What, this game rules! What's next, TTYD? - SonicFan4Life

V 9 Comments
36 Super Mario 3D Land

This disappoints at it's finest

What do the principles apply to? It's just another game in Mario history where Mario saves Peach and Daisy from Bowser. And now 3D? My sister died from a 3DS. The goomba is stupid too, no offensive to Goomba lovers.

Listen up, please. This is probably the only time I will ever agree with a Daisy fan(the rowdy ones.) Daisy should have been in this game. It's called Super Mario 3D Land. And there's a game called Super Mario Land and it was Daisy's first game. It would make sense to put Daisy as the damsel, but still, this game is great! - Drawbox

Come on... this is the 1st Hitler games released on 3DS... - AldoFitrian

V 18 Comments
37 New Super Mario Bros

How dare you put this on the list. It's one of the best games ever

At first glance, I thought this was a remake of the original games.

Do you also like SSMB due to Peach getting kidnapped & being in this game instead of Princess Daisy?! Because most of us don't.

Boring game. New Sonic The Hedgehog is better. - SonicFan4Life

V 10 Comments
38 Mario Kart 64

Yep, just another good Mario game that fits perfectly with all of the other great Mario games

Why hate on this game? Peach wasn't whiny in this game, so we should be grateful for that! Also, Daisy could've replaced Peach because Peach is too caught up on making appearances in gaming.

This game is great, but I'd only criticize Princess Daisy's hiatus causing Peach to appear in more games than any other gaming female in gaming history, which sucks.

Oh... Come on... this is just a good Hitler Kart games... - AldoFitrian

V 6 Comments
39 Mario's Early Years: Fun With Numbers
40 Mario's Early Years: Fun With Letters

The words are spread out, the voice is bad, and the gameplay is garbage

PSearch List

Recommended Lists

Related Lists

Top 10 Greatest Mario Games of All Time Best Mario Party Games Best Mario Kart Games Best Super Mario Wii Games Best Paper Mario Games

List Stats

1,000 votes
137 listings
6 years, 84 days old

Top Remixes (20)

1. Hotel Mario
2. Mario Party Advance
3. Mario's Time Machine
1. Hotel Mario
2. Mario's Time Machine
3. Mario Clash
1. Luigi's Mansion
2. Hotel Mario
3. Mario's Time Machine

View All 20


Add Post

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.