Worst Mario and Sonic Characters

The Top Ten
1 Amy Rose (Sonic) Amy Rose is a fictional character in SEGA's Sonic the Hedgehog series. She is a pink anthropomorphic hedgehog with a cheerful, competitive personality, and is infatuated with the series' main character, Sonic. She serves as the first playable female character in the series.

Pointless: She has no reason to exist other than for Sonic to save her. Her using that giant hammer of hers is a rarity.
Awful person: She cares only about herself and Sonic, even threatening anyone that dares to be female and talk to him. Her new version isn't much better, where she is snobby, stereotypical and selfish.

In the comics she was a bit better, but only because the writer had a secret love-boner for Sonamy (Sonic and Amy as a couple) which is probably one of the most toxic relationships ever, with her constantly threatening and even hitting him, or forcing him to carry all of her shopping while she has a good time. She literally slows Sonic down.

In IDW she's weirdly out of character, but nobody seems to mind. She's suddenly very cunning and intelligent. Basically a Mary Sue, but it's okay because it's Amy and she can get away with anything because she looks cute.

2 Peach (Mario) Princess Peach is a major character in the Mario Bros. Franchise. She is the lead female of the The Mario franchise. She is usually the character who needs saved in most Mario Games, but also has appeared as a playable character in the Main-Series Mario Games, including Super Mario 3D World, Super Mario Bros. 2, Super Mario Run, and even starred in her own game, Super Princess Peach for the Nintendo DS. She has appeared in many spinoff series, too, including Mario and Sonic Olympic Games, the Mario Kart series, the Mario Party series, Mario Sports Games, the Super Smash Bros. Series, and many more.

Imagine if Princess Peach was in Sonic X & Archie Comics, & had her Piko-Piko Hammer & had the same temperamental, bossy, annoying & stubborn personality as Amy Rose did. Imagine if she were a temperamental, bossy, annoying, bone-breaking, fussy, stubborn & prissy (even Wikipedia said Peach's nature is girlish) Sonic X character. I hope she's underrated, because Wikipedia said that she received generally positive reviews, & Nintendo Wiki, on the other hand, said that Princess Peach has received praise & criticism. Princess Daisy got mixed reviews, like King Simba & Princess Ariel! Speaking of receiving, Bart Baker got a lot of hate comments, despite every video of his getting more likes than dislikes. Senior Citizen Love & Only Boy (in the World) are the top 2 worst Bart Baker videos ever! Senior Citizen love should be very underrated, being top 2 on (if they had one) a Top 10 Reasons to Hate Bart Baker's Channel List.

People need to stop hating Peach. She has done nothing wrong, and her purpose is to be the damsel in distress. Don't the haters of Peach realize that they're destroying half of Mario's games? If Peach could save herself, what would be the point? She has her own game, she tried to escape Count Bleck's castle, and has defended herself in lots of games. She's defensive and feisty as Paper Peach and is a hero in the following games: Super Mario 3D World, Super Princess Peach, Super Smash Bros, Super Paper Mario, etc. If you hate Peach because you think she does nothing, read this and think again please. Here's a piece of advice: Think before you post this reason.

Peach is an oddball. Sometimes, she can be a terrible damsel in distress who exists for nothing but trophy-fodder for the heroes to save. However in the games where Nintendo at least bothers to write her well (Super Paper Mario for example) she actually stands her ground and despite her dainty appearance, she can defend herself well and turns out to be surprisingly cunning. She fluctiates much, but she has some truly strong moments that make her not deserve the second-worst place on this list.

I knew she would be back to top 2! She gets very pissed when people tell her to fight back. She is 256% abusive! She always accuses Mario or anyone else for dying. I think when she arrived at the Vancouver International Airport (to people who can understand she did) she wore her hair loose & had a fit, fell to her knees & cried. She was pissed. She had to save Mario thrice herself & preferred to have an argumentative nature! She is bloody infantile! & mentally retarded!

3 Princess Elise III (Sonic) Princess Elise the Third (ソレアナ公女エリス3世, Soreana Kōjo Erisu 3-sei, literally "Soleanna Princess Elise the Third") is one of the main characters in Sonic the Hedgehog (2006).

Elise isn't really a great character, but she's far from the worst. Her writing was weak, but in concept she's interesting enough. She's been forced to learn to conceal her emotions and thus she has nobody to connect to until Sonic shows up. Their relationship is weird and she should've been made an anthropomorphic animal to counter this, but she's more interesting than some other characters.

OH MY GODS! Don't even get me started on that hündin. She has no life, is ugly, and worst of all, she kissed Sonic. she could've just died and everything would be good in the world. No Solaris, no Sonic dying and no Elise kissing Sonic! I'm surprised that Amy didn't wack her on the head with her hammer! I'm glad that she'll never remember Sonic and she needs to die NOW! Who wants to help ne with that?

This right here shows how peach is underrated. Elise III is a useless broad who got captured 6 times in ONE game and has less personality than a rock. She's gross and into beastality and is stupid as she'd kill the world so she won't forget sonic. Elise the 3rd gets my vote for worst female in gaming!

Scratchpad could've used on "Mario/Sonic Scratchpad", "Mario/Sonic X Scratchpad", "Mario/Sonic (Archie) Scratchpad & etc...

Princess Peach as Amy Rose? Not that much after Princess Elise showed up.

Princess Peach as Princess Sally Acorn? Kind of.

Princess Peach as Chris Thorndyke? To some people, yes.

Princess Peach as Princess Elise the Third? Yes, the most.

4 Rosalina (Mario) Rosalina, known as Rosetta in Japan, is a major character in the Mario Franchise created by Nintendo. She first appeared in the 2007 Mario Game, Super Mario Galaxy for the Nintendo Wii and later returned for the game's sequel in 2010. Since then, she has been featured in many main-series Mario Games and many spinoffs. She has appeared as a playable character in Super Mario 3D World for the Nintendo Wii U in 2013 and is a playable character in the Mario Kart series and Mario Party series. She also has come into Super Smash Bros. for Wii U/3DS as a part of the large character roster.

I agree. She could've replaced Princess Peach in Mario & Sonic at the Olympic Games series, Mario Party 9 & 10, Fortune Street, all other installments where Princess Peach (who is very similar to Minnie Mouse in personality) took Rosalina's spot. Why is Rosalina such a minor gaming character? She should appear in more games than any other female gaming character in gaming history, not Peach. Rosalina is much kinder & less grudge-holding compared to Princess Peach & Donald Duck.

Rosalina has personally never interested me much, although I feel that she's not deserving of such a high position (4th in time in this comment). There is definitely worse.

Rosalina isn't replacing anyone, she's not weak, she's not anything. How many Daisy fans are here to put Rosalina over her?

Please guys understand, she's not replacing anything and only her fangirls are annoying not the character.

5 Chris Thorndyke (Sonic) Chris Thorndyke is a fictional character and the main human protagonist of the Anime series based on the Sonic the Hedgehog series created by Sega, Sonic X.

He's a DRAG. His personality is so boring! He hardly does anything- apart from being a friend which, in fact, Sonic has enough friends already that are better than Chris.
…Also he's kinda clingy.

I agree. Chris is just so stupid and annoying. Does anyone aactually like the stupid git?

Chris thorndyke sounds like a typo more like Chris thorndick.

I can't take him any longer!
Get out of my life.

6 Sticks The Badger (Sonic Boom)

Is it just me or is Sticks a bit offensive? She is described to be mentally ill during her introduction trailer, although they play her schizophrenia for laughs with the overdone "I'm so crazy I will say a random thing! Evil banana! Ahhh! " shtick. I might just be sensitive, but it really leaves a bad taste in my mouth.

7 Blooper (Mario) Bloopers (Often Referred To Bloobers Until Paper Mario, Though Blooper was in use beforehand) are Squid-Like creatures that are found in the ocean. They made their first appearance in Super Mario Bros., and various kinds of them have appeared in the Mario games since, normally as enemies. Mario Party 8 was the first game to feature blooper as a playable character. Bloopers come in different sizes and colors, though the original variety shown in super Mario Bros is white.

Blooper isn't really a character and more of a type of enemy. You can't really apply a personality to it unless thinking about a specific one. Why is Blooper available to vote for?

8 Pink Gold Peach (Mario) Pink Gold Peach is a character who debuts in Mario Kart 8, where she appears as an unlockable playable character.

Lily Allen would be a great voice for Sally Acorn, especially if she sang the Lily Allen lyrics of "Five O' Clock feat T-Pain & Wiz Khalifa).

T-Pain would be a great voice for Blinky the red ghost.

Gex would be a great voice for Wiz Khalifa.

Sally Acorn's new height: 6'6" (2 meters).

Sally Acorn's new width: 3'3" (1000 millimeters).

Sally Acorn's new weight: Secret.

Blinky the red ghost of the Ghost Gang's new height: 5'6" (1675 millimeters).

Blinky the red ghost of the Ghost Gang's new width: 3'8" (1122 millimeters) meaning he will take steroids.

Blinky of the Ghost Gang's new weight: 99 pounds.

Gex's new height: 6'0" (182 centimeters).

Gex's new weight: 128 pounds (58 kilograms).

Gex's new width: 1'3" (405 millimeters).

You know what's ironic? Haters attacking Daisy/Rosalina for being 'Peach clones' when the REAL Peach clone is right here. Daisy and Rosalina are both characters that are different to Peach. Pink Gold Peach, however, is nothing more than a metal form of Peach. Did I mention she has absolutely no personality AT ALL? To sum it all up: Pink Gold Peach is a power-up that has been made a playable clone character with no personality or importance. So is Metal Mario. They are both boring, dull and completely pointless. This goes for those damn AWFUL baby versions, too. When will Nintendo stop with the clones?!

Sigh... Here we go with the clone characters. What I mean is, like Baby Daisy and Baby Rosalina, Pink Gold Peach has only been in spin-off games and never served an actually purpose in the main series. Those clone characters should knock Amy Rose and Princess Peach off their top spots on this list, because they're obviously downright pointless and excessive characters that should have been replaced by Dixie Kong, Bowser Jr., and Nabbit in Mario Kart 8.

Why is there Peach clones instead of Daisy clones?! Why Pink Gold Peach but no Orange Gold Daisy?! Why is Peach getting the better out of Daisy & Rosalina?! Peach deserves all criticism & bare praise.

Also, Princess Daisy of Sarasa Land (Peach's not-so-good friend), Miles "Tails" Prower (who is abused by his own best friend Sonic the Hedgehog), Pac-Man & Pluto the Pup would make a great Western Canadian quartet!

9 Birdo (Mario) Birdo is a dinosaur that is well known for her (or his) confused Gender. It was originally stated that Birdo was a male who believed he was a female, but this was changed in later games. Birdo is commonly referred to as a girl, however, they are in a relationship with Yoshi. Birdo first appeared in ...read more.

Birdo is great, most especially because she has feminine legs (which she/he cannot stop having herself) & is with two genders at the same time. Also, she's a little bit better than Yoshi & can rival Jet the Hawk for sure. But I may hate her a little, but Peach should be top 1 over Amy Rose & both are worse than Chris Thorndyke.

What the hell? Is she bad or good? Is she boy or girl? Is she cute and feminine or hideous and spoiled?

Sometimes Birdo gets on my nerve. I even like Toadette better and everyone hates Toadette!

Birdo is an underrated hermaphrodite.

10 Baby Rosalina (Mario) Baby Rosalina is an infant version of the major character from the Mario Bros . Franchise, Rosalina . She first appeared in Mario Kart 8 as a playable character and is now one of 5 baby characters in the roster, alongside infant versions of Mario, Luigi, Princess Peach, and Princess Daisy .
The Contenders
11 Goomba (Mario) Goombas, known in Japan as Kuribo, are a species of sentient mushrooms from Nintendo's Mario franchise.

Amy Rose sure can flatten a Goomba in Mario X with her Piko-Piko Hammer.

He is ghetto because he just stomps around.

12 Cream the Rabbit (Sonic)

Cream the Rabbit is a mistake of a creation who is overall low-rated, and she shouldn't have lines nor be in Sonic X anyways!

Also, she is similar to Toad for sure.

She's the cutest character in Sonic! How can you say that?!

She's dumb because she's five dude.

If I had a choice between hearing her voice or living in South Sudan, I would buy a ticket to South Sudan before you could blink

13 Dr. Eggman (Sonic) Doctor Ivo "Eggman" Robotnik is a fictional video game character and the main antagonist of the Sonic the Hedgehog series, created by Sega.

(to the people that ask ''why can't he beat sonic if he has an IQ of 300) their is BIG difference between book smart and common sense. eggman has the book smarts and sonic has the common sense and both need the other thing they don't have. sonic, has friends to help him out with his week points when all eggman has him and the robots that were created by him. in the end, sonic has and will always win because sonic has people he can depend on and the only person eggman can depend on is himself. thanks for reading.

Aw come on guys! He isn't my favourite (Shadow and Sonic are tied 1st place in my opinion) however he's funny in a way and yes, he's stupid, but his stupidity is so hilarious!

Dumbest looking villain. His head is stupid. What's up with the legs. Dumb mustache. At least Peach is hot in a soccer outfit. This guy is dumber than Team Rocket.

A lazy excuse for a villain. Not menacing, has dumb cheap minions, and always does the same thing

14 Omochao (Sonic) Omochao is a character in the "Sonic the Hedgehog" series. It is a small robotic Chao that provides tips, guidance, and commentary to players throughout the games. Omochao's role as an informative helper has made it a recognizable presence in the franchise, assisting players in navigating various challenges and obstacles.

You got the magic hands! There useless though, so ignore them. You got a ring! You got another ring! (MY GOD SHUT UP! )

I don't know what to say about this guy. In sonic genrations omochao talked thru bosses and that's very disturbing o_o

15 Wario (Mario) Wario is a character in Nintendo's Mario series who was originally designed as an antagonist to Mario. His motives are driven by greed and he will take the side of whoever will give him the most pay. Although he may seem like just a mean man with no heart, he does have a very tragic past.

Hey Wario, why did you take Diddy Kong's spot at the Vancouver Olympics?

Mario & Peach don't like nor love each other anyways. They had more than one major breakups.

This guy is so annoying because his rival is Knuckles the Echidna instead of Miles "Tails" Prower. Shouldn't Knuckles the Echidna be King Bowser's rival?! Yes.

Imagine if Wario strangled Amy Rose for forcing Sonic the Hedgehog to love him.

Replace this with Mario. He's disgusting, rude, and greedy.

16 Rouge the Bat (Sonic)

Imagine Luigi, Amy Rose & Batman all having big fights w/ Rouge the Bat.

Also, Shadow the Hedgehog is like an older brother brother towards Rouge the Bat.

Rouge the Bat will be directly the same height as Batman & Axel Chains (her future arch-rival) at 6'2" (1880 millimeters).

Luigi will be 6'3" at height & become a more lanky person.

Amy Rose will be 5'10" with a ginormous hip size.

Shadow the Hedgehog will be 9'10" (3 meters) tall & 1 foot wide proving him to be overly lanky.

Amy Rose & Luigi: Superstar Saga

I'll bet Rouge's black pants are covering her wide, feminine thighs to make then look more skinny as well as Rouge the Bat has more of a cello figure than an hourglass figure.

Imagine Rouge the Bat with a deep, sexy & feminine Russian accent & Knuckles with a higher, more Ray William Johnson like voice whereas RWJ actually voices Knuckles the Echidna.

She is basically the hooker of the Sonic Universe. She always strutting about, her cleavage all over the place, AND she has a crush on pretty much every male character. Why Sega? I get your trying appeal to the older crowd, but why?

Again! A brilliant, attractive (I can't really say that because I'm a girl) and sexy (I'm still a girl! ).

17 Fancy Pants (Mario)

She claims she's the smartest character and raises annoying carnivore bears.

18 Sonic the Hedgehog (Sonic) Sonic the Hedgehog, trademarked Sonic The Hedgehog, is the title character and protagonist of the Sonic the Hedgehog series released by SEGA, as well as numerous spin-off comics, five animated shows, and an animated OVA.

Sonic's pretty cool. He's not spoiled ( tell me you're not stubborn once in a while.) He's not annoying or bad tempered unless you're messing with family. He's childish sometimes, but in a good way. He's not cowardly! What the hell are you talking about? He beat Eggman's robot's asses and you call him a coward? How many people has he saved? He's not blue-obsessed or babyish. Once in a while he can be fussy, but honestly?

Why doesn't Sonic like Amy? I'll make her love Amy. I'll even force him to remember her birthday & to also remember her date.
Sonic also has a small rivalry with Princess Daisy.
& besides, his voice sucks. That's why I'd like Jaleel White's voice of Sonic & EpicLLOYD's voice of Sonic.

He's an original, if he wasn't in the game world the main character would be Tails or even Amy. If Amy Rose was the hero and Sonic is chasing Amy, that would be ridiculous so take Sonic, Blaze, Tails, Eggman, and Amy off the list.

Let's describe Sonic the Hedgehog. He is spoiled, bossy, stubborn, annoying, bad-tempered, childish, gruff, masculine, tall, slender, stupid, cowardly, blue-obsessed, babyish & fussy.

19 Blaze the Cat (Sonic)

Even w/ mixed to positive reception to Blaze the Cat, she is overrated (yet okay for a Sonic character).

Blaze the Cat vs. Bowser Jr.

Blaze the Cat vs. Pac-Man Jr.

Blaze the Cat vs. Axel Chains.

Blaze the Cat's new size: 6'0" (182 centimeters) tall & 3'1" (95 centimeters) wide.

All she does is fire up everywhere and act like a boy like Daisy and Rosalina. But why is Birdo on the list? Birdo is awesome.

Blaze still doesn't know the meaning of friendship well!

20 Shadow (Sonic)

Shadow is such an overrated character! Screw his rivalry w/ Sonic the Hedgehog! His rivalry w/ Luigi is MUCH better!
Imagine Luigi w/ Chaos Control, the fastest running speed ever, Shadow the Hedgehog's hairstyle & even rivalries w/ Shadow the Hedgehog (yet he has partnerships w/ Princess Daisy alongside Pac-Man) everywhere in Western Canada.

Screw Shadow the Hedgehog! He is bossy & an idiot (only due to his amnesia).

NO I LIKE SHADOW! His story is so sad and technically Sonic is the faker. Shadow was made about 50 years ago which means he's older than Sonic, so he was first and Sonic is the faker. Don't get me wrong, I like Sonic too, but sometimes you need to turn your hate onto the characters that really deserve it like Elise

Correction people: Didn't Sonic call Shadow the faker first? It's not like he says it every single time he sees him. Shadow is one of the most powerful, coolest, and darkest Sonic characters. And Shadow is like over 50. Pretty sure that's before Sonic was born. Don't get me wrong, I love them both. ;) But don't hate Shadow

Shadow is a pretty good character, but if we're talking about "Friends make you a weakling! " Sonic Boom Shadow... Yeah, put him higher on the list.

21 Luigi (Mario)

Daisy + Luigi = best couple ever!
Peach + Mario =...

In Mario games he's weak and annoying!

Daisy is Luigi's stalker.

22 Bowser Jr. (Mario) Bowser Jr., or sometimes simply Jr., is a video game character who appears in Nintendo's Mario franchise as the secondary antagonist. He is the youngest son of the series' primary antagonist, Bowser.

Diddy Kong should've taken Bowser Jr. 's spot just like how Rosalina could've taken Princess Peach (a character who shouldn't have even existed because she cut out Princess Daisy a lot)'s spot at the Vancouver 2010 Olympics.

Bowser Junior is a spoiled brat. He has major temper tantrums when he loses.

Bowser jr is cool

23 Super Sonic (Sonic)

He is just another STUPID Sonic. Sonic, Metal Sonic, Shadow, Werehog, and now Super Sonic. Sonic is already the most impossible character to beat.

Super Sonic is blonde.

I mean, there could be a "Mario Unleashed" & a short film called "Mario Unleashed: Night of the Wereman".

Super Sonic is kind of a haole despite his green eyes.

Super Sonic is so annoying & always pissy!

24 Wendy O. Koopa (Mario) Wendy O. Koopa is a female villain in the Super Mario Bros. franchise. She is the only female member of the Koopalings and is usually found assisting Bowser on his wicked plans with the rest of the Koopalings. She first appeared in Super Mario Bros. 3 in 1988 and since then has been a reappearing foe in the Super Mario Bros. and New Super Mario Bros. series. She has also appeared as a villain in the Paper Mario series and similar games. She is a playable character in the Mario Kart franchise and other spin-off series and can be played as an alternate skin to Bowser Jr. in Super Smash Bros. for Wii U/3DS and its sequel Ultimate for Switch.

Furious, Amy Rose would kill Wendy with her Piko Piko Hammer, especially because of her aggressive behavior in The Adventures of Super Mario Bros. 3.
Amy Rose would even be very pissed & use "Kootie Pie Koopa" as Wendy's name.

Wendy O. Koopa should've taken Bowser Jr. 's spot as Tails's rival at the Vancouver 2010 Winter Olympic Games.

She is an annoying spoiled brat. I hate her.

25 Donkey Kong (Mario) Donkey Kong is an arcade game released by Nintendo in 1981. It is an early example of the platform game genre, as the gameplay focuses on maneuvering the main character across a series of platforms while dodging and jumping over obstacles.

The guy who said that DK is stupid fat and short is wrong. Yeah he is stupid and dumb but he is not short and fat because he is 6 ft 1 and he is muscular.

Donkey kong is stupid, fat, short.

8Load More
PSearch List