Top Ten Worst Medicine Warrior Cats
Its all about their history and lives. Mary Sues and cats who even don't believe in star clan. Unpopular medicine cats who we are like, 'nuuu.'He is the worst, why did he even choose to be a medicine cat?
Hawkheart was a WindClan medicine cat under Heatherstar’s leadership in the forest territories. He originally served as a warrior before becoming a medicine cat. He was said to have an unusually strong and rough personality. During an attack on WindClan's camp, Hawkheart violently defended his... read more
Okay, everyone here is saying "Oh! He killed Moonflower! He sucks!" or "Oh! Medicine cats are supposed to heal, not kill!" But in truth, I actually like Hawkheart. Take a moment to come at me with your pitchforks and lit up torches or do whatever you want, I honestly don't care. If you hate him, fine, but don't hate me for liking him. Anyways, you're now probably wondering WHY I like him, right? Yes? Okay, I'll explain: He wasn't trying to kill Moonflower. He just wanted to injure her and make her leave his herbs alone. I don't even like Moonflower if I'm being honest... Anyways, take a walk in his paws! You're a medicine cat in the middle of a battle and some random cat comes into your den and starts trying to destroy your herb store, which you're going to need to help save your injured Clanmates. What would you do? Probably fight them, correct? Ya, exactly. So can you really blame Hawkheart? I mean, I guess you could hate him if Moonflower was your favourite character but that's your own problem, not Hawkheart's. He was loyal to his Clan, and him killing Moonflower was 100% an accident. He may not have shown any remorse or guilt, but he was probably upset about it, he just couldn't let his Clanmates see. I feel pity for Hawkheart, having to live with the fact that he killed a cat with six moon old kits. It's not his fault Moonflower tried to destroy his herb store! And if anything Goosefeather or Pinestar are the one's to blame. Sure, Hawkheart may have killed her, but Pinestar and Goosefeather sat by and did nothing to stop him. Moonflower is to blame, as she's the one who tried to ruin his herb store. Hawkheart was just defending his herbs and protecting his Clan, Moonflower was in the wrong, not Hawkheart! Cut him some slack! No one would be this upset if Jayfeather had've been the one to kill a cat! It's only because Hawkheart's personality wasn't the best so everyone hates him. Not fair... AT ALL! -FeirceheartOfThunderClan
I think she's pretty misunderstood, I'm working on a list about my favorite characters and how there misunderstood. I'm not done, but u may read this in the future. I may revise this later when I decided the title
I think she was a great medicine cat.
I hate him! He's #6 on my Top 10 least favourite characters list. He's just rude and bossy and grumpy and he's a big jerk to everyone, he also caused Moonflower (No, I don't care for her, but still), HIS OWN SISTER, to die! He's cursed, and like, possessed by a demon or something... -FeirceheartOfThunderClan
NO HE'S THE BEST! He's one of my favourite characters! How is he a bad medicine cat, is it just because he's grumpy? Because that's not a reason to be a bad healer, it just means he has a bad personality... Even though his grumpiness is the best! -FeirceheartOfThunderClan
He's such a terrible medicine cat! For one, he wasn't even fully-trained but was still made a full medicine cat with no hesitation, and for two, he SUCKS! How can you expect to heal injured or sick/dying cats if you can't even heal your own cold? Jeez, whoever apprenticed him must be brainless... -FeirceheartOfThunderClan
Alderheart! My little worrier
I don't really care for her, but just because I don't really like her personality and her story is kind of vague as we already had Cloudtail who didn't believe in StarClan. So what she lacks faith in them? She can still do the healing, and Willowshine can take in prophecies and omens. Between the two of them RiverClan's in great paws! -FeirceheartOfThunderClan
What's wrong with Puddleshine? I'm currently only on Shattered Sky, so he might do some bad things later on, but he seems fine right now... I actually really like and I feel like he's super underrated. He's also not a Gary Stu, as people like to say. He only got 2 moons of training, so he may not be as skilled as other medicine cats. If that's not a flaw I don't know what is. -FeirceheartOfThunderClan
I actually admire him. He barely got any training and is still a loyal medicine cat.
Worst medicine cat ever! Boring, Weak, Stupid, and did not deserve to be in the story. I was happy when she died even know you might not of. What was the point of having her come back to life? To make the story more interesting? NO IT DID NOT HELP. Even when she was cinderheart she sucked. I have no idea why she is the best Medicine cat ever. She did nothing!