Top Ten Worst Survivor Players

The Contenders: Page 6

101 Jaime Dugan - 10th place - Survivor: China

I hear that she is a South Carolina University honor student but the entire 7 episodes she was on she acted dumb

"I'm not as dumb as I look"...Yes you are

102 Woo Hwang - 2nd place - Survivor: Cagayan

His strategy to be under the radar and let Tony to do all the dirty work was a smart move. However, he never made a move against Tony. At some point he should have gotten rid of him. Even though you can argue that the hidden immunity idols and special idols protected, him, he could have at least flushed them out, and the f3 was his perfect chance to get rid of him because he could not use the special idol. He should have taken Kass to the end because everyone hated her. He would have won. However, he decided to make the dumbest move ever and take Tony to the end. He basically handed him the money. He basically quit the game after he eliminated Kass. In my opinion, he should be at the top of the list because he handed Tony the money.

His reasoning for taking Tony to the end was so stupid. In his interviews he said that he believed that if he took Kass to the end, the jury wouldn't respect him and would think that he was trying to take the easy way out so they would vote for her ...more

He knew he was risking it, he wanted to. He wanted the better opponent and got him. Stupid would be if he thought it was just a better strategic move, but he still didn't regret it after he lost. Not stupid, not smart, just how he wanted to win was against the best and he couldn't.

It was just crazy his strategy. I wish in a count used state when he said he was going to do what he did in martial arts. This is not martial arts, this is survivor!

Woo was a nice guy, but he never made a lot of big decisions, and lost because he took Tony to the end instead of Kass. - naFrovivuS

V 12 Comments
103 Matt Quinlan - 16th place - Survivor: One World

Was arrogant and thought he had a good shot at winning, when in reality he didn't stand a chance. The fact that his own alliance members voted him out over COLTON shows how much of a dumbass he was (although he wasn't nearly as bad as Colton was obviously).

He had an alliance of 4 in a tribe of 9 men. He's an idiot - DGKay

Matt should've brought in Jonas or something... then he would have been decent-ish. - Turkeyasylum

104 Ryan Aiken - 16th Place - Survivor: The Amazon

The dude couldn't even cross a simple balance beam. No wonder he's in last place.

105 John Raymond - 16th place - Survivor:Thailand

Tricked his tribe about the water supply, what a great way to get voted out first!

This guy was way too cocky and arrogant. And his prank on the tribe was very stupid and he ended up sending himself out first instead of someone like Ghandia or Tanya. - DGKay

106 Gillian Larson - 17th place - Survivor Gabon

I'm surprised this Grandma Thora chick made it further than Michelle

107 Michael Snow - 11th place - Survivor: Caramoan

Floated the entire game and then got pissed and flipped the bird when he got outplayed. Most undeserving jury member of all time.

108 Bret LaBelle - 5th Place - Millennials vs. Gen X

Bret was salty and arrogant. He had a disgusting attitude towards his rivals, going as far as making fun of David for his anxiety. He only had one target the entire game, and not even coming out to Zeke was "heartwarming" for me. - naFrovivuS

109 Chicken Morris - 16th Place - Survivor: China

Wow this far down he is worse than Courtney Yates Parvatti Richard Hatch James Clemets He is even worse than Erik and Ashley the wwe woman from china

DAMN! - dilkay97

110 Bobby Jon Drinkard - 9th Place - Survivor: Guatemala

If the goal of the game is to look like a psycho, there's no other champion of this than Bobby Jon. - naFrovivuS

111 Andrew Savage - 12th place - Survivor: Cambodia

Well, you wouldn't expect a guy who's last name is "Savage", that's for sure...

112 Lillian Morris - 2nd Place - Survivor: Pearl Islands

Stupidest and most annoying and most undeserving to be there player

Lillian is probably the single most hated person in Pearl Islands. And considering this season also had Jonny Fairplay, that's quite an acheivment

Too much into herself

Terriable player; Lil went along with whoever made her feel the most wanted, was voted out twice in one game, waited to be told what to do and was utterly unable to stratagise. On top of that she didn't perform brilliantly in any challeges and seemed to talk about providing at camp more then she appeared too. She was also annoying as hell.

V 2 Comments
113 Sandra Diaz-Twine - 1st place - Survivor: Pearl Islands & Survivor Heroes vs Villains Sandra Diaz-Twine - 1st place - Survivor: Pearl Islands & Survivor Heroes vs Villains Sandra Diaz-Twine is an American television personality who became known for her appearances on the reality game show Survivor. She's well known for being the only person to win twice.

I've never seen Pearl Islands so I won't comment on that (though I did hear that her personality was even worse there than it was it HvV so that's something to look forwards to *sarcasm*). However she did not deserve to win Heroes vs Villains. The only reason she won is due to the mistakes made by Russell. She only beat Parvati because Parvati aligned with Russell (which was the only choice she had as the entirety of Rob's alliance wanted her gone so Parvati was screwed from the beginning). Had Sandra gone up against Jerri (or any of the Heroes) she would have been screwed. She does nothing on her own aside from rely on everyone else screwing themselves over. She failed to convince the Heroes not to trust Russell (and sided with the Villains anyway), failed to eliminate Russell, and failed to show me why she deserved to win. She's my least favorite winner so far (still need to watch Seasons 1-12 and everything after South Pacific but of the seasons I've seen Sandra's my least favorite ...more

Absolutely useless player. She is horrible at challenges, never makes strong, strategic moves, and she doesn't have a good social game. She only won the first time because she was sitting next to an outcast, and the second time because of a bitter jury. Her whole strategy was to vote Russell off, and Russell was in the finals. She failed at the only thing she tried to accomplish, and it's annoying that the jury rewarded her for it.

But, you have to admit, she is the only player to ever win TWICE!

Meh, she had loads of strategic gameplay in Game Changers. Not the worst. - naFrovivuS

V 14 Comments
114 Marty Piombo - 11th Place - Survivor: Nicaragua

The most overrated player in that whole season. He was switched over to the other tribe, was outnumbered, and TOLD EVERYBODY "I've got the immunity idol". All he did was put a target on his back, and then he gave the idol away.

Let me correct you: He was not the most overrated player in that season, he was the only one who was not pathetic in that real Survivor parody that Nicaragua was.

He's pretty much what Bam Margera from Jackass will look like when he's in his 50's

He's pretty much what Bam Margera will look like when he's in his 50's

115 Erik Cardona - 12th Place - Survivor: Samoa

His whole tribe hated him so they voted him off before attacking the other tribe. He didn't even play his idol, and he kept saying "Galu to the end". Fool. It's not a team game, it's an individual game. And then he was bitter and voted for Natalie to win, even though Russell deserved to.

If he didn't make that jury speech, someone ACTUALLY DESERVING would have won. Thanks a lot Erik.

116 Amber Brkich - Winner - Survivor: All-Stars

She rode coattails more than anyone else. She was Jerri's puppet the first time, and Rob carried her to the end on All-Stars. She never made any strategic moves, didn't deserve to be brought back, and didn't deserve to win.

Amber was basically playing a lottery when she played Survivor, she even admitted that luck was her main way of getting to the end

How did she get on all stars you know where's Colleen Where's Elisabeth where's Vecepia where's Sandra

From what I heard is that Sandra was recovering from parasites, Elisabeth wasn't chosen and Colleen chose not to come back for all stars. They never said they'd never come back overall though. I wonder what they'd do if they brought back Linda from survivor Africa, she was one of my favorites

According to interviews, Amber had a pregame alliance with Tom and was in the power position on her tribe. That means if she wanted to keep Rob C over Rob M, they voted out Rob M. Rob will be the first to tell you that he and Amber made decisions TOGETHER. So you ldiots can stop saying she rode coattails when in fact Rob M rode HER coattails through the first vote and she controled the rest of the game with him but was able to remain utr at the same time and let dumbass antagonistic Rob take all the heat. She is not even close to the worst player ever.

V 1 Comment
117 John Carroll - 9th Place - Survivor: Marquesas

How could he not realize that blatantly revealing the pecking order would result in him being overthrown? Not that it mattered. He wasn't going to win anyway, his social game was too bad.

118 Alex Bell - 7th Place - Survivor: The Amazon

The dude told Rob that when they got to four, he would vote him off to prevent a tie with the girls, after that Rob elminated him from the game.

119 Rob Mariano - 1st Place - Survivor: Redemption islands Rob Mariano - 1st Place - Survivor: Redemption islands Robert Carlo "Rob" Mariano, known by the nickname Boston Rob, is an American television personality, widely known for appearing in several reality shows, including Survivor, and The Amazing Race with his wife, Amber Mariano.

How is he on this list?

Absolutely the worst Survivor player ever. Horrendous social game. Needed to play 4 times and have a season fixed for him by CBS to finally win. A huge jury goat, would have been crushed by everyone except Phillip and Natalie, the 2 biggest goats ever, on his so called winning season. Has ruined countless friendships like Lex and Grant since he is too weak a player to win without voting them out.

Terrible and crazy overrated player. Aside from the 100 other reasons he is overrated, it needs to be reminded he would have lost a jury vote to EVERYONE except Phillip and Natalie Ten, the 2 biggest goats in Survivor history, on his so called winning season.

The main reason he got far was because he was great at making alliances, stirring up trouble, and outsmarting the enemy. - naFrovivuS

V 11 Comments
120 Garrett Adelstein - 17th place - Survivor: Cagayan

His very little knowledge of the game were what screwed him. He had a pre tribal council, and apparently the actual one was nothing like the practice one. Why didn't he wait for summer to play Big Brother

Blindsided with an idol in his pocket (or rather at camp) after only 6 days, a record.

The funny part is that if he went on Big Brother, it would probably be the same result, 2nd evicted

You know somebody is a bad player when watching them play is emotionally draining.

That's Garrett's gameplay in a nutshell.

V 5 Comments
PSearch List

Recommended Lists

Related Lists

Best Survivor Players Top Ten Greatest Survivor Players Never to Win Smartest Survivor Players Best Survivor: Blood vs Water Players Best Male Survivor Players

List StatsUpdated 24 Sep 2017

2,000 votes
159 listings
8 years, 254 days old

Top Remixes (13)

1. Francesca Hogi - 1st person voted out, Survivor Redmption Island - 1st person voted out, Survivor Caramoan
2. Ben Browning - 18th Place - Survivor: Samoa
3. Matt Elrod - 7th place - Survivor: Redemption Island
1. Francesca Hogi - 1st person voted out, Survivor Redmption Island - 1st person voted out, Survivor Caramoan
2. Naonka Mixon - 9th Place - Survivor: Nicaragua
3. J'Tia Taylor - 15th Place - Survivor: Cagayan
1. Colton Cumbie - 13th Place - Survivor: One World
2. Naonka Mixon - 9th Place - Survivor: Nicaragua
3. J'Tia Taylor - 15th Place - Survivor: Cagayan

View All 13


Add Post

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.