Top 10 Worst Things About Amy Rose

The Top Ten

1 She wears dresses

Sonic girls don't relay have to wear clothes. Its just that they want too. I mean look at Sally Acorn. She doesn't have any clothes on, other that a jacket. Now if girls were to wear only a jacket, they would be covering themselves up, but as for animal girls, especially Sonic girls, they don't have to wear clothes, they just want to. If they didn't wear clothes, they wouldn't have any private parts, it would all be hair.

Dresses suck anyways. Also, Amy Rose deserves to wear a tube top & a miniskirt like in Amy Rose: 2020. However, her legs will be too wide for her skirt as well as she will be too busty for her tube top. Amy Rose will be also with a thin rib cage. She will have a hard, feminine body. Amy Rose's dreadlocks will actually be brown despite her pink fur.

Sorry, but this is a dumb reason. A lot of people wear dresses. - RalphBob

Amy Rose is lame in this case, & has bad appearances in 2D.

2 She Wore Her Dress When Playing Baseball

Yikes! I hope sonic made it clear for her to not wear her dress again.

What?! She did that in 10th episode of Sonic X! WHY?! WHY?! She was supposed to wear a RESPECTIVE baseball attire. Or she shall go in a bikini.

Stop talking about Sonic (whatever) should be replaced by Mario/PAC-Man/Mega Man (whatever). It's off topic. Please keep it on topic. - EspioTheChameleon

We saw the skirt of Amy Rose's dress was underneath her baseball Jersey! ):(

Let's tell Yuji Naka, Sega & Sonic Team & even Nintendo about this. This isn't medieval times, Amy Rose.

3 Her obsession with Sonic

Even in sonic boom shes still 12 and she still wants sonic to love her in ways like when perci liked sonic amy got mad she still is crushing on a 15 year old that's like pedophilia

She's a 12 year old girl who is obsessed with a 15 year old teenage boy. I don't know. It just seems weird to me (I guess this makes me a hypocrite cause my ex girlfriend is 2 years younger than me)

This is why Team Rose in Sonic Heroes is so bad. Big the cat is handicapped, cream is still a child, and all Amy cares about is Sonic.

She is mature now in sonic boom

4 She is better off as Sonic's little sister

Seriously, they have the same eyes. They have the same head (but with fair changes), they have the same eyes, they have the same size, they have the same skin color, they have the same foot size, etc. Amy Rose is supposed to be Sonic the Hedgehog's sister. Both have bad tempers, also.

That's true. Amy Rose was supposed to be Sonic's sister, even at the first place out of the Sonic Underground series.

How come people don't get this comment?!

Can u imagine your sis stalking u?

5 She spends her time with girls (having rivalries with them, being best friends with them, interacting with them, knowing them)

Amy Rose shouldn't have girls as female rivals & greatest friends anyway! Also, Amy Rose's future best friend is Axel Chains (who could actually rival Batman & Batgirl whilst facing the Joker by becoming Batboy). Also, Inky the cyan ghost would be the best boyfriend for Amy Rose, NOT Sonic the Hedgehog who is (besides being like a big brother to her) possibly forced to become a pedophile by Amy Rose herself.

Amy Rose is better off with male rivals such as Luigi, Larry Koopa (her future arch-rival), Waluigi, Donald Duck (who could be better at Piko Piko hammer skills than Amy Rose), Donkey Kong, Annoying Orange, King Bowser Koopa, Blinky the red ghost, etc.

6 Her legs aren't thick & feminine enough

You can't expect a 12 year old to look like Samus Aran (in her zero suit). - Qryzx

Amy Rose's legs are either pink-haired, pink-skinned, pink-painted or pink for other reasons. And at the same time as they are the legs of a stick figure, they are thick and feminine, like a real adult girl's. - The Ultimate Daredevil, who has created this list a quarter-decade ago so bugger's list about hating Amy Rose does not have a point in existing, even though its reasons could be put on this original list.

Amy Rose's legs aren't suppsed to be thin in general anyway, nor average width, but Amy Rose does deserve to be in healthy shape & maybe Justin Bieber, Selena Gomez, Miley Cyrus, Austin Mahone, Mitchell Kuester & the more ordinary (yet becoming more famous) Harrison Stark will have a fierce battle (yet it's friendly) over who gets to voice Amy Rose.

I, the creator of this list was definitely horny when creating this list for sure.

7 Her 2-D appearances

Jesus, they're so scary! Why do people like Amy's 2-D appearances actually by Sega/Nintendo/Capcom/Archie Comics? They're not good. Besides, they sure make Amy Rose look scary & stupid. Also, Amy Rose has the same role as Birdo, not the overrated, barely beautiful Princess Peach (whom Princess Elise the Third plays the role of).

Why does anyone keep using her in music videos anyway?!

Which is one big reason why Classic Sonic beats Dreamcast Sonic & Modern Sonic.

This should be at least top 2! Also, Amy Rose is such a jackass all the time whereas she'd have to face ME with Luigi's Piko-Piko Hammer.

Luigi: Piko-Piko.

Amy Rose: what?!

Luigi: Hmm. *speaks Italian like in Superstar Saga*

Amy Rose: I have the Ultra Hammer! *slams her Ultra Hammer on Luigi's foot*

Luigi: NO! *cries like in the Mario & Luigi RPG series*.

8 She talks a lot

Waited for this one lol

9 Amy never wears her hair up

She’s a hedgehog!

Because her hair is too short, idiots.

So what if she doesn't wear her hair up! Plus Amy has short hair she probably wants to but can't. πŸ˜’πŸ˜’πŸ˜’

10 Her Piko-Piko Hammer

I'm a fan of Amy, but this I agree. Her curling up in her ball is better than Amy rose using her hammer at lesast she can fight back better. Plus sega weren't so strict to not let her ball up she wouldn't have gotten captured in shattered crystal she could've rolled away, but I really like her still.

Imagine Donald Duck & Thor Odinson with a Piko Piko Hammer.

Also, here's a reason why Amy Rose uses her Piko Piko Hammer constantly. It's actually because Amy Rose is weaker & slower than other characters in possession.

First, off the correct name is spin dash. Second off you don't see tails or rouge doing it. Even the other hedgehogs don't spin dash such as Silver. Also each character has their own ability such as Blaze and her fire power. Amy's ability is the Piko-Piko hammer, in which she trained hard to earn. So please don't hate appreciate. One more thing SHUT your MOUTH!

Sega's fault not hers

The Contenders

11 She's extremely annoying

Why does she sound terrible in Sonic X?!

Amy Rose sounds like a female Wendy Whiner version of Donald Duck.

Why does she sound like minnie mouse from mickey

Amy Rose sure behaves like Donald Duck.

I'm okay witht he dresses. I'm okay with the hammer. I'mNOT okay what her being such a stalker! - HeavyDonkeyKong

12 Her best friend is Cream the Rabbit

My point is that it is done sexist because how Amy Rose's best friend is Cream the Rabbit is the female version of how Sonic & Tails are close as siblings. - The Ultimate Daredevil, who finally got the ability to explain.

So? Your point is?

Cream is better off being a leader of her own pack for my reasons. in my opinion I can easily say that Cream is tired of being a sidekick and she wants to be a powerful hero in order to impress Amy and all of her friends.

Cream, you should run.

13 She's bossy

I have no care if Sonic, Tails, Knuckles or Vector are bossy or not, but Amy Rose is ripping off more critical characters every day!

Sonic and Tails shouldn't have to listen to her. She is seriously one of my least favorite fictional characters. - HeavyDonkeyKong

This should be #1!

"Sonic is my boyfriend even if he doesn't say so! "

Shut up

She is very bossy

14 Her Modern Amy design

I was waiting for this one to come. HER MODERN DESIGN IS THE WORST. Actually, who even decided to make up modern sonic?

Modern Amy Rose is the definition of the Modern Era of Sonic the Hedgehog being way more overrated than the Classic Era of Sonic.

15 She is Like a "The Adventures of Super Mario Bros. 3" character.

Exactly! Those are who she sounds like! What I referred to here was Kootie Pie Koopa, and The Adventures of Super Mario Brosm 3 is already a stereotypical and therefore poorly aged cartoon overall. And yet the original Super Mario Bros. trilogy is a cult classic with lots of depth, so that it is comparable to the original main Sonic trilogy for the SEGA Mega Drive!

She is so similar to Veruca Salt, Princess Peach, Donald Duck & Kootie Pie Koopa in temper.

She sounds like Angelica,Donald,Peach,Daisy,Veruca Salt,Princess Morbucks,D.W Reed,Megan Parker,Caillou,and Kootie Pie Koopa throwing the biggest temper tantrum ever

16 Amy Rose is cowardly

You heard me! Amy Rose just gets scared, does nothing & doesn't do the right thing sometimes. what?! Amy Rose: The female, red animal version of Luigi.

Don't you mean pink and Sticks The Badger is more cowardly than Amy and I could imagine Sticks jumping into Amy's arms Scooby Doo style because they are both cowards like Jar Jar Binks

She isn't a coward she uses her Piko Piko Hammer to destroy her enemies.

The prolem is that he's NOT cowardly! She doesn't know when to quit! She just chases after Sonic and gets into trouble. At least Princess p-each knows when to back down! ROGHT?!? She doesn't try to fight Bowser because she knows that Bowser is so much more powerful than her and that Mario will probably save her anyway! - HeavyDonkeyKong

17 Her Quotes
18 She needs to get back to becoming a tomboy

She is tomboy now

I liked it better when she was that way... Sigh

19 Her exentsive voice acting

The whole Mario franchise should have extensive voice acting & etc too.

Also, Amy Rose's main rival in Pac-Man Kung Fu Tournament/Mario Power Karate/Sonic Super Tae Kwon Do/Mega Man Judo Strikers in the Mario series will be Luigi (in the Mario series), her main rival in the Mega Man franchise being Roll Light (with her Mega Man: Battle Network hair rather than her original/Archie Comics hair with more of a healthy, distinct pear figure & a height of 5'8" yet she is still Mega Man's younger sister in adult years) & in the Pac-Man franchise Blinky will be Amy Rose's main rival.

20 Amy Rose is Sonic's self-proclaimed girlfriend

Their not even dating so shut up and get your facts straight-sherklover456


Their not even dating so shut up and get your facts straight

21 She is a ripoff of Princess Peach

Except she is short tempered and unoriginal. - HeavyDonkeyKong

22 Amy Rose should be renamed "Amber Rose".

This wouldn't mater anyway. She's still an annoying spoiled brat. - HeavyDonkeyKong

Amy rose is good I guess

I voted for this because I think renaming her "amber rose" is the worst. I DISAGREE with this ok - AmyRose

23 She's Not Actually Shown as a Drummer Yet

According to Sonic News Network (on the Miles "Tails" Prower Sonic Boom) design, Miles "Tails" Prower can play the drums. Well, Amy Rose would be better. And Yoshi can't play the drums! Why? Very short arms!

Dude, Amy Rose would be best at drums in comparison to all other Sonic characters, including Manic the Hedgehog.

Imagine her drumsticks as mini Piko hammers

I agree.

24 Amy threatens many good characters

She's all like "WHERE ARE YOU HIDING SONIC?!? " Why are they so care dof her? They can probably kick her butt! Tails too! He can fight in Sonic the Hedgehog 2 without his machines! - HeavyDonkeyKong

25 She was a disgrace in Sonic X

You bet! Conceptually, Rose of Lyric had potential to feel free. But execution-wise, unfinished is its key word. - The Ultimate Daredevil to HeavyDonkeyKong

Amy is much more graceful in Sonic Boom.

26 Her dress throughout Sonic Adventure - Super Smash Bros. 4


Oh my god... what?!

27 She hates Sally because Sally likes Sonic

Sally and sonic are together its canon so what if shes a squirrel stfu

Sally is an awful character.

No, Sally and Amy are just friends! That's all.

28 She acts as a crazed child molester


29 She is a Mary-Sue

Too bad no one else is smart enough to see that.

She is way too praised for that. >:(

30 She didn't encounter the Koopalings yet

Sonic has been kidnapped by Kootie Pie Koopa once.

31 She is really annoying

She talks to much and her voice actor should be changed

Before Sonic Boom, Sonic the Hedgehog was usually smarter than Amy Rose.

Amy Rose was worst in Sonic X, Sonic Battle & Archie Comics.

32 She is On Archie Comics Instead of Pac-Man

Sonic & Pac-Man Archie Comics crossovers would be awesome, yet here is still the terrible Sonic & Mega Man. Please don't work on another Sonic & Mega Man crossover, Archie Comics! It's too unfair that there are no Pac-Man Archie Comics yet.

There shall NEVER be Sonic/Mega Man/TMNT Archie Comics anyways!

But Pac-Man Archie Comics? COOL!

When is there ever going to be Archie Pac-Man Comics yet?!

33 Her Attitude

Let's review Amy Rose.

She has a cowardly personality, childish behaviour, is usually ranting, decides to intimidate people, gets aggressive, keeps referring to herself as "Sonic's girlfriend" when, really, Amy Rose is more like a younger sister to Sonic the Hedgehog, she cries too much, she is too thin she doesn't shut her large mouth, she lets herself get kidnapped sometimes, & all kinds of bull besides being a fibber, a bastard, a rapist & a forcible ripoff - SHE IS HAVING BAD RELATIONS WITH MOST FEMALE CHARACTERS LIKE PRINCESS PEACH & IS STEALING SPOTLIGHTS!

It's similar to Luigi's.

Imagine Sonic hedgehog vs. Mario plumber battles.

Sonic the Hedgehog vs. Super Mario

Amy Rose vs. Super Luigi

Shadow the Hedgehog vs. Wario

Silver the Hedgehog vs. Waluigi

34 She is friends with Princess Daisy of Sarasa Land instead of Yoshi

What was Nintendo & Sega STILL thinking?!

No she's not... But Yoshi is still way bette rthan Daisy. - HeavyDonkeyKong

35 Her dreadlocks are pink instead of deep brown

Now you're talking a crossdressing Sonic!

Imagine in the Mario Party 9 picture with Princesses Peach & Daisy standing beside the dice block Princess Peach's face is actually replaced by Sonic the Hedgehog's face facing the left direction as shown in Sonic Lost World w/ Princess Daisy not being changed unless you are talking about being stripped (whereas her big boobs, her big thighs, her big hips & her big rump were actually exposed! :D

JESUS! Why?! Amy Rose should be in a Princess Daisy dress with Sonic the Hedgehog being in a Princess Peach dress next to each other.

Amy Rose is not supposed to appear at us when we aren't thinking about her?!

Sonic & Amy Rose both should've been siblings w/ deep brown hair anyway.

36 Amy Was in Sonic X

How about T-Pain for Yoshi & Iggy Azalea for Amy Rose?

Shaffer Chimere Smith would be an awesome voice for Green Yoshi (who is a filler & needs his big, bulbous & green nose damaged by Thor Odinson's

Why the hell is Amy Rose in that terrible, awesomeness-lacking Sonic X T.V. series?! AUGGH! WHY?! Why is the whole T.V. show named Sonic X?! It's not awesome! It needs to be replaced by Mario X/Pac-Man X.

Thor Odinson w/ what? The Piko-Piko Hammer? Now you're talking!

37 She Befriended Princess Daisy of Sarasaland

Wasn't Princess Daisy of Sarasa Land supposed to be with the MALE Sonic characters since the Vancouver 2010 Olympics? Of course she was! But NOT female crossover characters! Besides, Princess Peach only went to the Vancouver Olympics & Canada itself because she was FORCED to go, for God's sake! Why didn't Rosalina & Pauline replace Peach?! Also, in the opening cutscene, Peach did pathetic in Figure Skating (as she is a coward for sure).

38 Amy has wide hips

Not in general, but in comparison to other characters, yes. I wish Sonic had a Piko-Piko Hammer & damaged Amy's wider hips with it.

Also, Amy Rose sur can rival Luigi.

39 Her boobs are a little bit big for her age

Amy Rose is not a child anymore. By the way, Amy Rose should be renamed "Amber Rose".

Yeah, I guess you're right. Even for her own size/height, Amy Rose has big breasts as she is voluptuous.

40 Her modern name
41 Scratchpad Keeps Saying That Amy Rose Is Princess Peach

Princes Peach beats Amy Rose anday in my opinion! - HeavyDonkeyKong

42 Her rivalry with Princess Peach

It's one of the worst crossover rivalries ever. Also, Amy Rose would have a much better rivalry with Luigi.

Man, I hate catfights severely.

No, Amy and Peach were friends!

Since when did they have a rivalry? Peach is better than her.
I have mixed feelings towards Princess Peach andhe voie too.
I thnk Amy Rose SUCKS! But her voice is okay. - HeavyDonkeyKong

43 Her Teeth

They have never looked nice. Seriously, why is Amy Rose not male? Come on! She ought to be grounded by Sonic the Hedgehog.

They look like toothpicks that came out of guys butt.

She has fangs by the way, I think she has three.

44 She Was On Archie Comics

Why is there Sonic/Mega Man Archie Comics instead of Nintendo/Pac-Man Archie Comics anyway?!

45 Her Wendy whiner attitude
46 Her repeated attitude toward Donald Duck
47 She Doesn't Wear Her Hair in a Ponytail/Bun/Braid/Plural Braids
48 Her face

She's kinda cute, but others are cuter to me. - HeavyDonkeyKong

49 She Does Not Have Relationships With Any Pac-Man Characters Yet
50 She Doesn't Have an Australian Accent Out of Asian Regions
8Load More
PSearch List