Top 10 Worst Things About the List Called "Top 10 Greatest Sonic the Hedgehog Games"

The Top Ten

1 A modern Sonic game being top 1

Sonic adventure 2 is epic! I wouldn't really consider it modern anymore though, because ti IS over ten year's old!
My top five favorite sonic games:
1. Sonic Adventure 2 9.25/10
2. Sonic Adventure 9.25/10
3. Sonic Colors 9.0/10
4. Sonic The Hedgehog 2 9.0/10
5. Sonic The Hedgehog 9.0/10 - HeavyDonkeyKong

Actually, Modern Sonic is just as quick as Classic Sonic!

Here's something to learn

Modern is faster, classic is slow

And this is bad... how - cdxtreme

2 Sonic Adventure 2 being on top

These people are probably trying to say that Sonic 1, 2 & 3 on the Genesis are bad games.

Just, why? I'm not saying that the modern games are bad at all, not even close, in fact, I picked sonic colors. But, How?
I mean, the game has aged more poorly then a block of cheese on a kitchen counter.
It's probably because they ate said block of cheese then voted out of forceful obligation.
In all honestly I respect their opinions but, there are way more sonic games that are better then SA2.

3 Modern Sonic games being higher rated than classic Sonic games

Seriously? The Classic Sonic games are great, but Modern Sonic is extremely imperfect.

Jeez, people only care if Sonic games are classic or modern. Grow up, kids. Just cause it's classic doesn't mean it's better

What's so wrong with this? Come on, tell me - cdxtreme

4 Sonic Adventure 2 being overrated

You've said this like a million times

This list is ridiculous

5 A crossover not being top 1

Big deal

6 The List Says Classic Sonic Games Are Bad

Sonic 2 as top 4, Sonic 3 & Knuckles as top 5, Sonic CD as top 9, Sonic the Hedgehog (the origianl) vas top 10, Sonic 3 as top 12 and below the mainly poorly-liked Shadow the Hedgehog at top 11, Sonic & Knuckles as top 16, WHAT KIND OF LIST IS THIS?! Classic Sonic is much better than Modern Sonic!

It doesn't say that they are bad! Some Classic Spnic Games scored highly! - HeavyDonkeyKong

No but the classic fanbase is.

7 A classic Sonic game not being top 1

Big deal

8 Sonic 2 on the Genesis not being on top

Sonic 2 is so awesome! Its music, visuals, Classic Sonic rocks! But hey, I don't dislike Sonic Adventure series!

Well I'm so sorry that I have a different opinion than you! Yeah, I must be a real ass! Your listsw are ridiculous! PLEASE STOP TROLLING! - HeavyDonkeyKong

9 More modern Sonic games than classic Sonic games in the top 10

This list wasn't made in 1991 - cdxtreme

10 Shadow the Hedgehog Not Being in the Top Ten

Everyone has their own opinion, okay

The Contenders

11 Racist Modern Sonic Fan-Brats that Pick on Classic Sonic for Being Retro

Screw these people. They act like Pac-Man & the Ghostly Adventures is superior to Pac-Man World (games for home consoles). >:(

12 The Original Sonic the Hedgehog Not Being In the Top 5s

There are about 80 Sonic games so far! And the true original Sonic the Hedgehog deserves the top 10 spot?! This is the game that started the whole Sonic franchise! Sure, there are some flaws like how hard this game is, but this game deserves to be top 1 on the "Top 10 Greatest Sonic the Hedgehog games" list. So, the original Sonic the Hedgehog is 100% perfect.

Sound: 10/10.
Graphics: 10+/10.
Music: 10/10.
Difficulty: 9/10.
Creativity: 9/10.
Worlds: 10/10.
Gameplay: 9/10.
Nostalgia level: 10+/10.
Story: 9/10.
Humor level: 9/10.
Controls: 10/10.

Compare the original Sonic the Hedgehog to Sonic Adventure 2. Sonic 1 is way better.

About Sonic Adventure 2

Sound: 3/10 (8/10 for the Japanese version)
Graphics: 6/10.
Music: 4/10.
Difficulty: 9/10.
Creativity: 6/10.
Gameplay: 7/10.
Nostalgia level: 6/10.
Story: 7/10.
Humor level: 5/10.
Controls: 7/10.
Voice acting: 2/10 (8/10 for the Japanese version).

13 People Defending Sonic Next-Gen
BAdd New Item