Worst Things About FanFiction.net

The Top Ten

1 Mary Sues

I 100% agree. I think the best characters in any sort of media are the ones who are flawed to an extent. My comparison is Batman and Superman. (Spoiler, I like Batman more and no I'm not saying Superman is a Mary Sue). Batman is seen as a damaged individual who uses his anger to fix the streets of Gotham. Batman is far from perfect, he's a mere mortal who has much room to improve himself. He is not a pure soul. Superman is seen as a perfect individual. Nothing can TRULY stop him. he's way too OP for me to enjoy. He's always this Goody two shoes guy. Mary Sues are like a crappy bootlegged Superman. I'm not saying OC's should be like Batman, but they should have their own identity. It's hard to make a unique character since every type of character has been written.

Damn, Mary Sues are the most annoying little things ever. And the worst thing about them is, usually the authors who write them all defend them vehemently with stupid comebacks like "SHE IS NOT A MARY SUE SHE IS JUST PERFECT! 1! " and "loollz you're just jealous".

They base the Mary sue off of the author. THEY MAKE THEM PERFECT FOR THE FANDOM. A good character has flaws, something the bad guy can take advantage of and something the character has to overcome or accept. But Mary Sues/Gary Stus don't do that, making the audience hate them.

Mary sues usually leave no room for the other characters, are "romantically" obssessed over a male protagonist, could be also a recolor of a etablished character..

what I hate the more, is the RPs versions, treating other people like trash, using a sad biography as a victim-card, claiming that everyone that hate them are jealous, are plainly creepy (stalking their lovers to death).

this kind of character offer no materials to work with, it can be a lost cause.

V 4 Comments
2 People Making Crossovers of Nickelodeon and Disney

They belong together. Nonetheless, that is quite a nuisance. - bugger

"Now I've seen everything..." -Engineer - iRocketGamer52

Indeed. Only the biggest of the biggest losers do this. - Johannes9

Ugh. The one I hate is mlp to sonic. Just why? Crossovers are so annoying.

V 1 Comment
3 So Many Love Stories

This should be number 1. Every love story is the same. It is the most overrated genre of all time. And when they are lemon they are sick. - Chico123

Nothing wrong with them, there's just an overabundance. - Lasvegasxavier

I like love stories, but it is when it turns into a lemon that it is gross. Look it up.

The love story's are to unrealistic for example: girl blushes guy blushes,surprise kiss you like (even though your not dating and don't know each other),crazy guy likes you you like him, there's just no realistic love fanfics I mean would you be cool if someone just kissed you no! You'd file a lawsuit or something at this point I'm gonna start writing my own through I will not be able to post itt sorry but yah can someone just make a realistic one please

V 5 Comments
4 Bad Spelling and Grammar

Oh my God the guy who added this spelled grammar wrong. - Pikachulover1

I have good spelling but I'll admit that my grammar is terrible. But hey just because my grammar is not that good it doesn't mean that I'm lazy. I'm not lazy. I just don't know how to do great grammar.

Grammar is spelled with an A. Jeez, if you're complaining about spelling, please prove you know what you're doing!

"She LOCKED at the sky"
warriors fans will understand

V 3 Comments
5 Your Parents Won't Let You Do It Even Though You Really Want To

Why the hell would you tell your parents about this? That doesn't make any sense! - iRocketGamer52

I write on Fanfiction.net, and my parents know and are very supportive.

6 People Making Stories That Are Rated M

Really? It's that bad? I don't think so because there are some good ones that I've read. - iRocketGamer52

I wouldn't view this as annoying. There are people out there who are always up for reading some quality smut.

Ever read a troll fanfiction? The M rated ones are extremely funny

I've written an M-rated story, but maybe it could've been T.

7 Crossovers of Things You Love With Things You Don't Care About

Agreed. I hate it when people make crossovers of whatever the heck they want with Kingdom Hearts and everything that has to do with it. They never make sense.

I will admit, if it weren't for crossovers like these, I would have never known about some of my favorite fandoms today. - alphadan12

There was not a single Rugrats crossover of something I cared about until I made a Spongebob and Rugrats crossover.

But see, the thing is that when it's a crossover of two things you LOVE it is the most magical thing.

V 2 Comments
8 Stories That Don't Stay True to the Theme They're Based On

You know the point of fanfiction is to 'UNLEASH YOUR IMAGINATION' right? - ImJustSaiyan

9 Incest and Beastiality

It's horrible when people make characters commit things like incest and beastiality when it is not a part of a character's personality.

You know, it might be interesting to read an incest story where the characters would have to deal with the consequences of having such a relationship. - alphadan12

I hate that so much. For instance, on the Thundermans archive, like 70% of them are max/phoebe and I'm just like "No, THEY ARE TWINS AND THEY DON'T LIKE EACH OTHER"

No, doing it with Gardevoir is something that doesn't belong to the web. - Swellow

V 5 Comments
10 Really Good Stories That Are Discontinued

I really hate this. You're reading a really good story, and then next thing you know, the author posts that they are discontinuing it. WHY?!?

I hate this. Especially when the person who made it is not on that much.

I wished that if they are going to start a story, end it in some form just don't let everyone hanging.

A major problem on the site. Most writers tend to bite off more than they could chew. - alphadan12

V 1 Comment

The Contenders

11 Not Enough Interesting Stories Already Posted

You should go and read mine. Some of them are great! And others are quite normal. I hope you enjoy them! - keyson

I write fanfiction and have done so for nearly five years and I have noticed half of them are self-insert, songfics, or poorly written fanfics that are a pain to read. The new stories are simply just not interesting enough...it feels like anytime I find a good story, it's buried beneath a bunch of rulebreaking songfics, challenges, SYOC's, and non-stories. Please, people, have more originality.

Fanfiction.net is like a massive tub of diarrhea with a few gold coins in it.

12 It's Hard to Think of Plot Ideas

You're tied down to a specific universal law you don't know completely that could change, ie twilight lives at golden oaks 1000yrs and tries to deal with loss but is blown up in canon universe. Plotline irrelevant and now no post s4 fans will read it with same context or they say "but castle thing now exists downvote"

13 Most People Have Never Heard of It

Sad but true. All I have to say.

I'm the only one in my circle of friends who actually cares about it.

14 The Ads That Pop Up When You Least Expect It
15 POP (A.K.A. Porn Without Plot)

I hate it when people write fanfiction just for the sake of having two characters screwing around. That's not a story; that's porn.

What is the point of this? I don't want to read about two characters' sex life, I want to read a story that has effort put into it.

Like, dude, if there's no plot, it's not a story. If you just want to write porn for the sake of writing porn, I think you're going to the wrong site.

Wouldn't it be PWP?

16 My Immortal

This has to be a troll. No one could possible write something this bad. I personally think it's very funny.

I don't understand why this isn't at ONE.

Everything wrong with fanfiction rolled into one fanfic.

My immortal isn't written by an idiot - it's written by a comedy genius. I burst out laughing at sooo many parts. It has a certain charm to it that no other fanfictions have achieved.

V 2 Comments
17 My Little Pony Crossovers With Everything

The show is already to popular with it being overrated. (THE ANIMATION AND CHARACTERS ARE BLAND) Yet people need to make pony crossovers with every show that doesn't even have anything to do with it. JUST WHY?!

I hate these. Honestly, people write the stupidest crossovers with my little pony. WRITE A CROSSOVER THAT MAKES SOME SENSE. I don't care if it makes sense, but most crossovers with mlp don't make sense. It's sad.

I heard people are shipping Twilight and Mordecai!

My little pony and Assassin's Creed. A true nightmare.

V 3 Comments
18 The Eliminators and Critics United

These two groups have to be the Nazis if the fanfiction world. If just one thing is against the rules, they either paste this huge speech about it, list everything that's wrong, or report it then and there. If you complain, the admins in Critics United will use your words against you and make you look like the bad guy. In the Eliminator's, there's an entire section for group members to post links to fanfictions that break the rules so everyone can report it at the same time. That, everyone, is why I steer clear of that site these days.

Ironically for a critiquing group, they can't handle criticism towards themselves. - alphadan12

They are horrible! I agree with whoever said they're Nazis, because they are!

19 Not being able to edit or delete your own comment.

Out of all the options here, this is the funniest - WoolenArale

20 Authors Who Write Characters "Out of Character"

Yeah this sucks

Karel from Fire Emblem comes in mind... The fandumb makes him a villain when the truth is that he's one of the heroes in the game.

PSearch List

Recommended Lists