Top Ten Worst Thomas and Friends Episodes


The Top Ten

1 Wonky Whistle

How can Thomas not hear his whistle OR the animals coming out? He's such an idiot. - Gametoon

I Can Agree With Everyone. This Episode Proves How Sharon Miller Era Episodes Are Bad

This shows how Thomas is blind, deaf, and incomprehensible stupid. - DKartWoomy

While I'm still on the #1 spot, I just want to say that if any official Railroad Series episodes arrives here, SOMEBODY'S gonna get it!

2 Fiery Flynn

"His firebox was on fire" - Gametoon

Thomas had his fire box on fire! Oh no! - DKartWoomy

Flynn is bad at saving the day

3 Ho Ho Snowman

I can't believe Henry fell for this! And even so, why didn't Charlie tell him earlier? - Gametoon

Charlie was a terrible show clown. - DKartWoomy

4 Thomas and the Runaway Kite

This one was really dumb. - Gametoon

Absolutely pointless. - DKartWoomy

5 Up Up and Away

Tying balloons to flatbeds? Try that in real life! - Gametoon

Miller was a godawful writer. - DKartWoomy

6 Henry's Magic Box

Henry's scared of a box. A BOX! - Gametoon

Reminds me how stupid "Waiting" was from SpongeBob - DKartWoomy

7 Buzzy Bees

This was so boring and frustrating to watch. - Gametoon

8 Pingy Pongy Pick Up

It's an okay episode. Emily is just a bit overenthusiastic. - Gametoon

9 Edward Strikes Out

Edward's worst episode, hands down. He's supposed to be the nicest one, not the meanest! James or Gordon should've been used instead. - Gametoon

James was actually supposed to be the main character, but the model broke down (possibly a rumor I don't know) - DKartWoomy

Edward's character was totally out of pace, which is a shame because he is my favorite character.

I don't know how an episode like this was published, it depicts Edward in a way it really shouldn't.

10 Snow

The funny part of an avalanche, is that they were being sarcastic when they said it was funny.

2. How did the crew survive without freezing to death?
3. How is an avalanche funny?
4. What the heck is Gordon's snow machine supposed to be exactly?
5. Gordon could have been dead in the tunnel and the others didn't even bother to help him
So I ask again how is it deserving of a positive rating?  Here is my rant:

What's the Funny part about an Avalanche? NOTHING, people can DIE FROM THEM. and Skarloey doesn't have an Engine, HE IS THE ENGINE! This episode is the worst of the classic era. 2/10 :( - FinnsWorld

The Contenders

11 The Sad Story of Henry

This story is so ludicrous it gets even sadder in Part 2 than in Part 1.

12 Push Me, Pull You

Worst New Series episode. It has to be. Skarloey is once again out of character. He's in a rush for no reason. Rusty is an idiot here too, stops at a crossing? Nobody mentions how BAD this is, and everyone is still triggered over Edward and a crane over THIS STUPID EPISODE. - DKartWoomy


13 Forever and Ever

Yves good episode

Gordon throws a temper about His Best Friend for years Henry leaving Him and misbehaves all day because He is leaving But he learned that just because Henry left Him They’re still Buddies even James learned that the three of them can still be Buddies! And they’re always best buddies even though one of them left

14 The Old Bridge

Would of worked with Ivo Hugh instead of Skarloey.

15 Sodor Surprise Day


16 Happy Hiro
17 Thomas, Percy and the Squeak
18 Thomas' Frosty Friend

Thomas is not blind hit

19 Thomas's Christmas Party

Only episode from seasons 1-4 that is actually bad.

20 Four Little Engines

What? Why? - DKartWoomy

21 Thomas, Percy and the Coal

Not bad but Drip Tank should of been adapted to complete it as a two part episode.

22 No Joke for James

Great plot, but story is fast paced. - DKartWoomy

Not bad just a bit rushed.

23 Rusty to the Rescue

The only bad episode of Seasons 1-4 and Super Rescue should of been adapted instead.

24 Salty's Stormy Tale

Why? - DKartWoomy

Bill and Ben should of replaced Thomas and Percy and BoCo could of helped Salty instead of Fergus.

25 Rheneas and the Roller Coaster

Would of worked with Sir Handel instead of Rheneas.

26 Bulgy Rides Again

Why? - DKartWoomy

Would of worked with Duck and Oliver instead of Thomas and Emily and Bulgy should of been in his grumpy Season 3 personality and remain in his red livery when he became a vegetable bus.

27 The Grand Opening

Would of worked with Ivo Hugh instead of Skarloey.

28 Henry Spots Trouble

The writers HATE Henry. First Duck, Donald, Douglas, Oliver, and Toad, but now HENRY? - DKartWoomy

Why do they have to keep trashing Henry and probably would of worked better with Philip.

29 Goodbye Fat Controller

Just a rehash of Trouble in the Shed and Percy's Big Mistake; also very pointless.

30 Thomas the Babysitter

Another pointless Thomas episode.

31 Gordon and Spencer

Why? - DKartWoomy

32 Henry's Forest

Just because Audrey didn't like it, it does not mean it sucks! - DKartWoomy

33 Too Hot for Thomas
34 Samson Sent for Scrap
35 Henry and the Wishing Tree
36 Thomas and the Rainbow
37 Percy and the Magic Carpet
38 Keeping Up with James
39 Gordon and the Gremlin

The only Season 5 episode I don't care for much. - DKartWoomy

An episode I'm suprised doesn't get much hate. Thomas and Percy act like dumb children (Even more than usual), believing in dumb stuff like Gremlins. The plot says Gordon has bad luck the only bad thing that happens to him is that he screws over someone's ride, but even then it's his fault. The one scene with Thomas and the dog was pointless. Actually, this whole episode was pointless.

40 Whistles And Sneezes
41 Good to Be Gordon
42 Middle Engine
43 Dunkin Duncan
44 Percy's New Friends

Percy wants to play with engine friends. But there are HUNDREDS OTHERS TO DO WITH. HE HAS TO MAKE FRIENDS WITH ANIMALS, AND HE'S DUMB! Very pointless episode. - DKartWoomy

45 Buffer Bother

This ep is annoying. Bill and Ben arguing yes, entertaining it is not.

46 The Way She Does It
47 Don't Bother Victor

Rheneas says that Duncan needs fixing, but after helping Skarloey and Sir Handel, he literally skips Duncan!

48 Muddy Matters

Just terrible.

49 Thomas and the Trucks

Who the heck said "LOOK OUT FOR THE TRAIN" in the early release?!?!

50 Ol' Wheezy Wobbles

Any episode involving Bash, Dash and Ferdinand is bad enough, but this is honestly the worst episode I have sat through with my son. Made zero sense, slow, dull and well, I would say forgettable but I wish I could forget I sat through it!

8Load More
PSearch List