Worst Toppings to Put on Ice Cream

The Top Ten
1 Ketchup

When my brother was little he had this idea that everything tasted better with ketchup ice cream was what disproved it.

Ketchup is my favorite condiment, but it would taste weird on ice cream.

Anything not sweet is a bad topping for ice cream

Spongebob did this
It did not go well

2 Mustard
3 Onions

Spongebob also used this
We all know how that went

4 Olives
5 Pickles
6 Beans
7 Anchovies

Yeah, no thanks. I dislike anchovies in general, so obviously I would hate having it in my ice cream.

8 Ranch Dressing

Don't understand Calamari (I'd like to try that), but ranch dressing isn't a good topping for much.

I'm going to barf...

9 Wasabi

The bigger question here is why would anyone want to put Wasabi on ice cream it just doesn't make sense.

I've seen MasterChef contestants making Wasabi ice cream, so it's not unheard of at least.

Wasabi ice cream is actually a thing in Japan.

10 Sauerkraut
The Contenders
11 Vinegar
12 Hot Sauce

Never mix hot and cold together. They never work together very well.

13 Peppers
14 Calamari
15 Sushi
16 Horseradish
17 Lutefisk
18 Maple Syrup
19 Jelly Beans
20 Barbecue Sauce
21 Liver
22 Chicken Nuggets

I like chicken nuggets I like ice cream but never together.

23 Chipotle Sauce
24 Mayonnaise
25 Gravy
8Load More
PSearch List