Top Ten Worst Total Drama Island Season 1 Characters


The Top Ten

1 Heather

People like her because she is devoted to winning. I have to admit she kept the plot going and got me into the series when I found it on Netflix, but you wouldn't like it if she did that stuff to you! She messed with charecters and got Trent, ever, Lindsey, Beth, etc voted off by manipulating and lying to everyone! She read Quen's diary, and messed up her relationship with Trent, and after all that Lindsey has done for her she betrayed her. She is exactly all the curse words Lindsey called her. She reminds me EXACTLY of this girl I met in the 3rd grade who backstabbed me, my friends and turned us against each other and permanently wrecked my friendship with a girl, we were perfectly fine until SHE came along, spread countless rumours about me in order to get popularity and sympathy and my expense, she bullied my best friend and many other friends and some people I don't know, all for attention. The only time I routed for her was when she was up against Alejandro, who I managed to hate ...more - ToptenPizza

The way Heather is written in the first season is to have people straight out HATE her. She went from being the antagonist that we all hated for various reasons to the anti-hero we straight out wanted to win in World Tour. She's worked her butt off arguably more than any other character, and she is currently the 1st place contestant in terms of episode count, beating out top dogs like Duncan and Courtney.

You people act like she's a real person. I say this so many times but this show is FICTIONAL. You don't look at it from a standpoint who's nice and who's mean. She's such a well written character that knows how to play the game! That's a fact you can't argue that

I LOVE heather. but I hated in her TDI. much better in later seasons. but in the end, this is SEASON 1. she was a huge jerk and was not as likable and the way she treated lindsay and beth was just annoying. heather doesn't seem to be as annoying in TDA, TDWT or TDAS (then again, no one was really considered a character besides mike, mal and zoey in that season).

V 8 Comments
2 Eva

You guys are joking, right? Ever is the best character on Total Drama Island, I like that she's the strong, independent female of the show. I hope she returns for future seasons, she deserves to win one of them. Not to mention, she has the biggest boobs on the show. That's saying a lot considering how Lindsay is on there.

She was a character I knew was gonna get voted off early in at least first 5 eliminations. She didn't have a good story line. She was a rage. She was very boring. All in all she just was a boring person

To be honest she was very angry and tempermental. She was also very 1 dimensional and flat, her only moment was her comeback and she didn't have enough screen time to actually become a fan favorite. - ToptenPizza

Her name is ever. E-V-A they showed it on the rundown episode and on the wiki. The only place where I see her named spelt with an r is here

V 3 Comments
3 Ezekiel

He is a stupid redneck who is also very sexist and said some rude stuff about girls but I laughed really hard when ever beat him up that was the only moment I liked ever, also he had very little screen time and was fame hungry until he became a feral beast which I guess is metaphorical how people who want to be famous become monsters and loose themselves for fame. - ToptenPizza

Although he gets homeschooled, he is clearly hands down "THE WEAKEST COMPETITOR IN THE SHOW"

Well he must be gay since he hates girls. I hated this character. My personal favorite is sierra from total drama world tour.

I'm a girl. I HATE HIM! He said mean stuff about females (Which I'm pretty sure lots of girls hate him for this) and he's just so stupid. 😡

V 2 Comments
4 Justin

Justin is the hottest guy in Total Drama history. He is gorgeous, and great to look at. He gives the show major eye candy! He should not be on the list. He is the reason I watch the show! He is the best guy character on that show. He is not annoying. He uses his looks to get what he wants, just like people in the real world do. People that look good get what they want in life. Get over it. Nobody likes haters, and Justin has a strong fan base and always will. I hope he is added to future seasons, I would love to finally see him with a love interest.

He's really annoying. He is only notable because of his looks, other than that he has no talent OR personality! And making him an antagonist for a while was the worst decision ever. - ToptenPizza

Justin is EVIL! He uses the girls to his advantage to help him win the game.

5 Sadie

She was whiny and pretty annoying. I liked Katie better because she didn't have a meltdown when she got voted off and had to be seperated from Katie - ToptenPizza

6 Katie

First of all, Katie is not a black girl. I'm not being racist when I say that, but whoever said she is your wrong, leshawna calls Katie a white girl. Next of all, Katie is like the skinniest girl on the show, so calling her fat, all the other girls on the show must be obese. Third of all, they are not exactly the same personality wise. They are similar, but not robots. Fourth of all, your butt is the one that can't fit in a seat, you hater. You just wish you were as pretty as Katie.

She is fat and is not that diffirent from Sadie, personality wise, she's fat and white and Katie is black and skinny, but they wear the same clothes and also she cried too much. And Sadie is right she's too big to fit in a bus seat. - ToptenPizza

You mixed up Katie with Sadie

Katie is white and skinny
Sadie is black and fat

7 Harold

I hate Harold. I'm so mad at him for getting Courtney out by hacking the votes. Duncan and Courtney's relashionship was just getting good. Not cool Harold

I never liked harold to be honest. he was annoying most of the time for me and voting off a innocent character who did NOTHING to you is insane!

His geekiness was funny and he dealt with bullying, and his relationship with Lewshauna was PERFECT, but I don't like how he got Courtney voted off (my favorite charecter) because her boyfriend was mean to him. Like, COURTNEY never bullied you! It isn't COURTNEY'S fault! Get Duncan off! He was the one messing with you! - ToptenPizza

Well Lewshauna is a very stereotypical name for a black girl. - TheMainReason

8 Courtney

UGH! She's SO annoying! She got kicked off because her boyfriend was a total JERK! Duncan is my second least favorite character. Anyway, when OWEN got kicked off because of HER, she didn't care! Owen is one of the best characters which is another reason why I absolutely HATE her!

Courtney is a hypocrite, uses and manipulates people.

Courtney was a little miss perfect who wanted everything her way. I hate that sick puppy with a burning passion! - Catacorn

She is the best why she the worst your minds or b;lowing off

V 2 Comments
9 Tyler

Okay please tell me one thing. Who's idea was it to put TYLER here? Sure he's bad at sport and might brag a little by saying he is but he is super funny and loyal to his friends. In that TDWT episode he keeps his team from getting seriously bad injuries and lets them use them a human ladder. I know no one who would do that. And who is so determined. No one. I love his spirit.

It is cool that he sucks at sports. That's what makes him funny

Who put Tyler here? He is awesome! - Catacorn

Nuuu I love Tyler

V 2 Comments
10 Beth

Beth is totally annoying. When she was introduced I knew I wouldn't like her because she gave off major annoying vibes. Did we forget she cheated on her boyfriend? I don't even know how she scored one with how fluffing ugly this character is. The other characters (excluding Sierra) aren't this annoying and plain unlikeable. There's not one likeable thing about her. Annoying, no good, dirty, cheater... All words to describe her. Even Heather is better.

She didn't Stand out to me at all in Season 1. In Season 2 the show gave her more screen time which I liked. Beth isn't a horrible character. She just isn't really Stand out ish.

She was sort of annoying. - ToptenPizza

Beth has no personality. She is just a helpless nerd(and not the good kind like Harold. In my book, she I'd the 5th worst season one character.

V 2 Comments

The Contenders

11 Duncan

A bullying a-hole

He act like a big jerk!

Ok I love Duncan. I also love Duncan dounuts

12 Gwen

I felt bad for her when Heather read her diary, but I can't believe how she treated Trent! He throws challenges for her and she rewards him by dumping him and getting him voted off! She kisses Duncan, her friend Courtney's ex. I mean how can you steal someone's boyfriend, you don't kiss your best friend's ex! That's just rude! By the way Quen and Duncan is the worst shipping ever! - ToptenPizza

I Hate Gwen! She Deserves to Be Number One! She Wrecked My Favourite Couple ( Duncan and Courtney ) and was So Mean To Trent who deserves better! And I honestly do Care What Gwen fans say about this Post!

Gwen didn't have a good attitude in season 1. In season 3 the show really gave Gwen some attention that was needed to fix her attitude back in season 1.

She kissed Duncan while he was with Courtney, in conclusion that's cheating

V 8 Comments
13 Geoff

Geoff reminds me of an obnoxious frat boy or Spencer Pratt.

Geoff is so crazy all of a sudden.

HE IS SOOO NOT THE WORST! 1 Why is he even on this list!?!?!?

14 Trent

He cheated on Gwen with Heather, it was obvious he wanted to make out with Heather, that two timer.

15 Leshawna Leshawna

WHO would hate Leshawna? She is hilarious!

She is awesome and she can take Alejandro down!

16 Izzy

She's psycho. I don't care what anyone else thinks, I see her as an annoying character, and she's quite mean to other characters in adaptions past TDI. Also, she has a stupid face.

Izzy is way too crazy for her own good.

IZZY?!?! IZZY?!?!?! She's the BEST character on the ENTIRE show EVER!

17 Owen

OWEN IS NOT UGLY! No-one is ugly. Everyone is pretty, cute, gorgeous, handsome, whatever. He's special and unique. That make's him one of a kind.

Owen is so ugly. He got Duncan and Heather eliminated.

I hate this character. he's one note, not funny, annoying, and just plain awful. should have been eliminated after the cooking challenge. - taishisohma

18 Dave

Not in season 1. Just saying

His hair burnt off his head ha ha.

He was good when he was competing, but he was a total jerk in the finale and took sky's boyfriend thing too far. serves him right.

19 Jo

Jo's attitude makes ever seem like an angel. You would be way more likeable and pretty if you wasn't so mean and pushy all the time.

Jo's not in season 1. Just saying

20 Ellody

I just wasn't feeling her vibe.

Wasn't in season 1. Just saying.

21 Noah

He was lazy and didn't help anyone.

Only in Dodgeball he didn't help his team but in World Tour he really did help his team Until Alejandro got him votted off!


BAdd New Item