Top Ten Worst Warrior Cat ParentsThis, In my opinion, Is my list of the cruelest, Twisted parents in warrior cats
The Top Ten
Shouldn't this be like, number one? I understand that Rainflower is a terrible mother but unlike Lizardstripe, she still loved one kit at the very least. Lizardstripe hated all her kits in general! Brokenstar would have been an amazing cat if raised by Yellowfang! I admit, I am upset with how Yellowfang didn't keep her kit, but oh well. Who agrees with me?
Lizardstripe is an irresponsible cat! She isn't fit to be a mother and she has no rights! It's HER fault that Brokenstar is evil, not Yellowfang! - Sumwantin
Yes, Lizardstripe tried to take care of Brokenstar when Yellowfang couldn't. She was rude and didn't seem to care. At all.
I HATE RAINFLOWER AND LIZARDSTRIPE! DIE IN A HOLE!V 22 Comments
I vote 100% here. I felt so bad for Crookedkit when his mother hated him. Like seriously who does that to their own kit? She loved him so much before the Goosefeather scared him off then he fell and broke his jaw (I kinda blame Goosefeather for this) Rainflower was a terrible mother and I would hate having a mother that hated me and didn't care about me. She even give him one of his nine lives! And when she made his name change to Crookedkit! Seriously, Rainflower? No kit deserves to be treated like this! If I were Rainflower I would take care of both my kits with all my heart, not by what they look like. It's the inside that counts not the outside! Rainflower may look like the prettiest cat on earth but her inside is cruel! Crooked star may look ugly ( I honestly still think he looks perfect) but his inside is kind and sweet. I felt so bad for him when he was abandoned and when his mate Willowbreeze and his kits, died! (I may have some errors because I type really fast and there ...more
I felt so bad for Crookedstar when he got that name because of RAINFLOWER I mean just because his appearance changed doesn't mean that his personality did.
Rainflower is horrible, and she deserved the death she got. She judged and favored her children. She shouldn't have changed Crookedstar's name. That was just evil. She the worst mother there ever was and Shellheart was way to good for her. I'm glad Shellheart got rid of her. - Pebblepaw
So you put Rainflower at number two for top ten worst warrior cat mothers and Lizardstripe number one really? Rainflower was awful. She made Stormkit into Crookedkit. Who can beat that for the word warriors mother?V 48 Comments
He was so stupid! I mean, He never spent time with his mate or kits, And when Moonflower died, He shown NO emotion and went for Dappletail! He also told Bluestar to stop grieving for Snowfur!
Stormtail was never there for his family like a proper tom should be. I don't know what Moonflower saw that was so great in him that she had to become his mate. Stormtail never seemed to care about Moonflower, he didn't love her. When she died he was like "yeah, whatever, now I can go after Dappletail and not feel bad". A terrible parent.
Stormtail has to be the WORST father in history! When I first read Bluestar's Prophecy, I was triggered at Stormtail 98.7% of the time. He didn't even care about Bluestar or Snowfur! He didn't even care abut Moonflower either! Stormtail just spends all his time with Dappletail, and when Moonflower dies, he acts like he just met her yesterday! Like they weren't even close! Moonflower should have ditched Stormtail a long time ago! If I could change something in the series, I would make some other cat that actually cared about Bluestar and Snowfur their father. Heck, I'd rather have a kittypet be their father then this cold hearted mouse-brain! Stonepelt treated them better, and he wasn't even related to them! Stonepelt would have made a great father, but nope! Stormtail has to be their father! I feel bad for Bluestar, Snowfur, and Moonflower.
Stormtail was mean. He never paid any attention to his kits. I guess that Bluestar still cared about him and stuff, but still... - PebblepawV 12 Comments
He abused his mate, then rejected his kits. However, when he decided he wanted them, he went to the forest, got rejected, went back to the forest, stole them, lied to them and the forest cats, and took them to a dangerous place that they weren't allowed to be in. Then, when Turtle Tail went to find them, she was killed and he didn't even care. Then, once they were safely home, he waltzed back into the forest like nothing happened. He was a jerk that didn't deserve to have kittens.
He stole his kits from Turtle Tail. Just so they would be taken from the twolegs. First he flirted with her, then he attacked Turtle Tail, insulted her, and stole the kits.
Mate: Turtle Tail
Daughter: Sparrow Fur
Sons: Pebble Heart, Owl Eyes
Clan: Sky Clan - CreamstripeOfButterClan
Literally he said "Keep the DUMB KITS, let them grow up to be wild I don't care." Like srsy bruhV 5 Comments
I agree that Millie deserves this place on this list. She was a fine character and mom before Fading Echoes, even if she could be a little obsessive/overprotective of her kits. But when Briarlight became paralyzed, she changed. And for the worse. We barely see her with her other kits, and she was to the point /obnoxious/ with Briarlight. I don't believe she abused Blossomfall and Bumblestripe, but she neglected them. Not even Graystripe was as insane about his daughter. And remember when Jayfeather and Millie got into a fight over pushing Briarlight too hard? And Millie whined about how Briarlight will never "run through the forest, hunt with her siblings, oh, what a sad, sad life! "? Honestly, I just thought that proved how psychotic Millie had gotten about her kit. And you don't yell at your kit who just came out of a underground tunnel that your other paralyzed daughter would make a better warrior than her.
Wow... wow Millie, you jerk, you neglect your kits then fuss over only one. It was your fault that blossom fall was in the Dark Forest.
I hate Millie. I would have preferred for Silverstream to stay alive and have more kits.
Boy,Do yall know how much I hate millie?V 25 Comments
Spiderleg mated with Daisy and neglected her kits I mean come on
Spiderleg and Daisy would have never worked out. Spiderleg's alway's been harsh. - Pebblepaw
How is he lower than daisy?! He wasn't in his kits lives!
He seriously doesn't even care for Rosekit and Toadkit.V 4 Comments
Crowfeather's kind of odd for me. I do not in any way condone some of the absolute jerk-face things he's done (ex: ignoring Breezepaw and praising Lionpaw instead), but I also feel like he's capable of being a good father.
In Omen of the Stars, he defended Lionblaze from Breezepelt, and informed Breezepelt that he did not hate him. It was Nightcloud who made him think that way. Still, it's very much obvious that, somewhere along the line, Crowfeather just gave up on Breezepelt. That, or he simply never felt connected to him.
And on another note, he's deputy now. Harestar seems like a reasonable cat, and I'm sure he would not have made that choice if Crowfeather were really a dumpster fire. But who knows? Maybe it was just a choice of sympathy.
Now, obviously, we've never seen much from Crowfeather's point of view. It's one of the reasons why I'm looking forward to "Crowfeather's Trial". In this book, we'll finally see how Crowfeather really views his family and ...more - 9Lives
He treats Nightcloud like garbage, And is the reason Breezepelt went to the Dark forest! Crowfeather led them to believe he hated them, If Nightcloud tried to talk to him, He would snap. Crowfeather never liked Breezepelt
I actually really dislike Crowfeather. WHY DID THREE CATS LOVE THAT JERK?! Yeah I know his first love was Feathertail and she died, but that doesn't give Crowfeather the right to treat Nightcloud like garbage and act like he wasn't the father of Leafpool's kits and crap on her! I mean seriously he is the reason Breezepelt is a giant butthole and went to the Dark forest.
Crowfeather has three mates. He acts all sad about Feathetail. but then become's Leafpool's mate. Then, just so he want his Clan to like him, he become's Nightcloud's mate. And he bullies and abuses his son, making him evil. I'm shocked any one loved him at all. - PebblepawV 11 Comments
Okay. He stole his brother's mate, Gray Wing's true love (Gray Wing is AWESOME, by the way). When his mate died (and two of his kits, I believe? ) he literally abandoned Thunder, and Gray Wing RAISED HIM AS HIS OWN SON AND LOVED HIM LIKE A FATHER, and then Clear Sky is like "Oh, hey, because you're MY son, you should come live with me? " Um, WHAT? Kind of ridiculous. And then Thunder fell in love with Star Flower, and Clear Sky literally swooped in and took her. I don't like Star Flower at all, and I think she'd be a terrible mate for Thunder or Clear Sky, but really, dude? Fox-hearted jerk.
This should be higher in the list. He stole his brother's mate and when his Gray Wing came back to him with Thunder, he refused to take him! And don't forget the countless cats he murdered. He even killed Bumble! I know that he claimed not to but I swear he must have! Bumble! Who would kill Bumble?! Afterwards, once the fire was over, he said he wanted to have Thunder back and then just EXPECTED TO HAVE HIM BACK! Who does he think he is?!?!?! I hate him! - MidnightflareOfRiverClan
I hate him! I know he lost his two mates, unborn kits, and a little over half a litter, but he neglected/abandoned his two brothers, abandoned his only son, and was obsessive over storm! He needs to chill and think of his family first! CROWFEATHER is a better father then he is ):(
Hate him so much. He's annoying. And he neglected his kit then wanted him back again and started lying. - PebblepawV 15 Comments
I disagree. Tigerstar, for one, treated his two ThunderClan kits very well. He didn't force them to join him, and Brambleclaw ended up becoming ThunderClan leader. Tawnypelt wasn't forced into ShadowClan by her father-- she chose to go there of her own accord because she didn't want to fight against her Clanmates for being Tigerstar's spawn, like Brambleclaw did. Brambleclaw was willing to prove his worth, while Tawnypelt didn't want to fight that fight. The other litter, Hawkfrost and Mothwing, was mothered by Sasha, as we all know, who left Tigerstar to escape his regime. And he let her leave. He didn't want anything to do with them (maybe he did, but he didn't pursue them) until Hawkfrost found him and trained under him, pulling Brambleclaw down with him until Firestar was injured. Mothwing was fine without him, and so was Hawkfrost. I can understand why he wouldn't want to speak with them, since their mother (and his ex-mate) ran and returned to her loner life. Tigerstar was not a ...more
I don't think he was a terrible PARENT. He may have been a bad mate, but at least he was nice to his kits! He didn't mistreat any of them, he just, you know, helped shape Hawkfrost's ambition a little... and yeah! At least he paid attention to them, unlike some of the cats above. I was really sad when he was killed the second time, to me he was an awesome villain and one of my favorite Warriors. This is my opinion, okay, so back off those who disagree with me.
Well, I'm sure everyone agrees that Tigerstar is a terrible cat. But I don't think he deserves to be on this list. For the most part, he wasn't a terrible parent to his kits. I mean, he killed a lot of cats and is NOT a good cat, but he wasn't a bad parent.
Nah; this was only put on here because almost everyone thinks he's evil. He was actually sweet with Tawnykit and Bramblekit when Darkstripe brought them to meet him. He gets all the criticism from when he tried to train Hawkfrost, Brambleclaw, and Tawnypelt. Even though Tawnypelt refused. I think he took turns with favoring them both... And when Firestar was caught in the fox trap, I'm pretty sure Tigerstar was telling him to kill Firestar but he chose not to. I know he had one other kit besides Tawnypelt, Bramblestar, Hawkfrost, and Mothwing; his name was Tadpole.
He stopped caring about Tallstar just because he didn't want to be a tunneler and he practically disowned and called him "our apprentice" instead of his own son
Sandgorse wasn't that bad. He wasn't the best parent there ever was, but still he was okay. He should have let Tallstar do what he wanted, however. - Pebblepaw
Sandgorse was a neglectful parent, but not really BAD.
I mean sandgorse u need to loose upV 2 Comments
Why do people think Silverstream is a bad parent? Clearly she's dead, so she can't even talk to her kits.
This is ridiculous! Silverstream? She was an AWESOME parent. She died and told Graystripe to take care of their kits! Afterwards, she told him to find another love because she was gone. She told him to move on! The people who said she is a bad parent are ridiculous! - MidnightflareOfRiverClan
Silverstream is not a bad parent. How is she number eight? She died kitting and her last words were 'take care of our kits'. When Feathertail died they were together. It isn't like she could come back alive. She shouldn't even be on this list.
She would have been the BEST mother I mean in star clan she's always with feathertail caring for her and loving her and when she was going to die she told graystripe take care of are kits?! SHE WOULD BE THE BEST MOM!
She didn't get to take care of her kits why is she on here?V 18 Comments
Okay, guys, she wasn't a bad mom. At least, not in the purposeful way that Rainflower and Lizardstripe were. She had postpartum depression, something that is extremely difficult to deal with. If you've ever seen those news stories of moms killing their babies, this is often the cause. It's a serious mental issue that obviously wasn't helped with when Finchkit and Sandgorse died.
There are times when she tried to be happy, but couldn't. People who've suffered from this mental disorder often cannot bring themselves to feel truly happy, especially when it comes to their children. And it's not like they WANT to be that way either, they have no choice about it.
Obviously, Tallstar wasn't paying a lot of attention to what his mother was doing while he was out plotting murder. Woollytail stepped in at some point and started to help Palebird work through what she was dealing with. By time they had kits, Palebird was doing much better than she was before, and had obviously ...more - 9Lives
She isn't a jerk to her four kits, but she is to Tallstar? What a stupid queen! I read Tallstar's Revenge, and CRIED AND BAWLED when Tallstar left! Palebird didn't even care! Sandgorse was a WAY better parent! Palebird can't grieve forever! BIG WHOOP! ONLY ONE KIT DIED. YOU STILL GOT ANOTHER WHO FEELS UNLOVED! How Palebird neglected Tallstar, was very upsetting. I will never forgive Palebird of her nonsensed brain. Sandgorse even paid attention to Tallstar, but Palebird paid not a single attention span to her son. And oh, I'm sure Sandgorse was mad when he found out that Palebird was mating Woollytail in about 18 hours after death. SHE DIDN'T EVEN GRIEVE! What a poor, poor mother. She was a fine mother to her four other kits, but she really took a hard number on Tallstar. Never will she ever be forgived. What a harsh cat. If I were Tallstar, I would've run away and e=never returned. And if I were ever spotted, I would say that it was all Palebird's fault!
She only cared about 4 of her kits and not tallstar
Why is Palebird up here? In my opinion, she was a fantastic parent to her other four kits, but sadly, not to Tallkit/paw/tail. The Erin’s have confirmed that she was suffering with depression, and losing Finchkit only made it worse. When she met Woolleytail, her depression was overcome and she got to have another chance to raise a family and be HAPPY.V 6 Comments
He didn't even want to LEARN THEIR NAMES! I cannot understand why he's lower than Maple-shade, at least she loved her kits! She loved them so much that she literally KILLED for them. I mean, COME ON PEOPLE if you love your kits that much, you SHOULD NOT BE ON THIS LIST! But back to Apple-dusk; he was cheating on Maple-shade! How's she not supposed to be pissed off? I love Maple-shade and think that Apple-dusk should've went to Dark-Forest instead of Maple-shade.
True! He didn't even learn the kits names and didn't even grieve for them when they drowned in the river when Mapleshade was trying to bring them to a better life. He just got mad at Mapleshade and completely forgot about the kits. And then he died. :3
HE TOTALLY DESERVED TO DIE. He is more evil than Mapleshade. At least she had a reason. He called Mapleshade, and their DEAD kits a mistake. If Mapleshade didn't kill him, I would have.
I wanted to state that when people bring up this kind of argument we usually only hear from Mapleshade’s persepcrive, not Appledusk’s. Keep in mind that Mapleshade(cannonly in the books) chose to kill Ravenwing, Frecklewish, and Appledusk. She even tried to kill a pregnant queen! While Appledusk, he did cheat on Mapleshade, but a lot of cats cheat on their lover(Squirrelflight and Bramblestar). So, if Appledusk goes to the dark forest, shouldn’t Squirrelflight be there to.V 11 Comments
For me,Daisy it's kinda annoying but she was a great mother. - cassiabez
Daisy's cool. - Pebblepaw
No, daisy was a awesome mom... what r u talking bout?
I have mixed feelings on Daisy. She was being all flirty and slutty to Cloudtail when she first joined ThunderClan, and was really mean to poor Brightheart about her scars. Cloudtail gently but firmly rejected her efforts to mate with him. She realized that he really didn't love her and instead loved Brightheart. She backed off, and started treating Spiderleg like she had treated Cloudtail. Spiderleg fell for her, and they had Rosepetal. I never read the second series or third series after book 1 (which I did enjoy as much as the first series and Firestar's Quest), only heard about the second series and read some excerpts and I hated Daisy at this point because of every reason that I've voiced. After that, I read Bramblestar's Storm, and felt that she had really matured because she became a great mother in that stand-alone and was secure with one mate. I like Daisy now!V 4 Comments
She had no choice, she loved her kits very much I bet if she had the chance to raise her kits she would have been a great mother. - cassiabez
I love Leafpool, she would have been a good parent if a warrior, but I think that Squirrelflight should have kept the Three.
I absolutely hate Leafpool. Don't try to change my mind or tell me I'm dumb because I just don't like her. She was stupid and I think Crowfeather would have been better off with Feathertail.
Okay, just because a medicine cat disowns their kit, DOESN'T MAKE THEM A BAD PARENT! She they have to in order TO STAY A MEDICINE CAT! - BrokenwingV 7 Comments
Well, she had no other choice, she got exiled from her clan and what would you do in that situation? I mean I would do exactly what she did.
No, she didn't kill her kits. Her kits were swept away by the river, not Mapleshade. - IcetailofWishClan
She just grabbed all her kits and carried them across a stream and then they get swept away but Mapleshade
Why is on this listV 6 Comments
Because she encouraged her son to do wrong. Oh, Breezepelt, you could've been a hero
Nightcloud was so selfish and prissy, and terrible parent. All she cared about was herself.
Nightcloud couldn't get Crowfeather to love her back, because he sucks. So she resorted to what probably a lot of people would do. If the father of your child is not in his life, you SPOIL THAT BABY! She didn't turn him evil! She made him arrogant yes, but not evil, THAT was crowfoods fault.
Nightbrat is such a flawless, whiny Mary-Sue! She encourgaged her son to be a dirtbag ()! She's so selfish and she's like a little princess. ''Oh Crowfeather! Why don't you love me? I'm such a good mate to you and our son is perfect." OF COURSE SHE'S ON HERE!V 2 Comments
Berrynose wasn't a bad father, and he genuinely loves Poppyfrost (likely more than he loved Honeyfern). Since becoming a parent, he's mellowed out, and made the conscious decision to do what he could to be a good mate and father. Really, the only thing he's guilty of is being overprotective. - 9Lives
Not the best warrior, but a great father (am I the only one who thinks Berrynose is a kinda good character? ) - Aquastar_of_DewClan
He IGNORED Poppy frost and only wanted to be with honey fern
Berrynose is arrogant, I don't know why Honeyfern was so taken with him.V 1 Comment
He wanted to make Whitestorm evil, he failed and made Tigerstar evil instead
To all those people saying Thistleclaw made Tigerstar evil, he did not. He exersised his ambition, but he never made him evil. What made Tigerstar evil was the ambition to become a strong warrior, since his father left to become a kitty pet. Tigerstar wanted to prove himself, which he did, in the wrong way.
Bad parent through and through!
I don't know me just want to vote :DV 1 Comment
"He was just terrible, especially when it came to being a father."
Dustpelt was a great parent to all his kits, especially Foxleap and Icecloud. They are the only two of his kits I like anyway.
I think he was bad.He was there when they were tiny and left as they grew.
He was horrible to brichfall ecspeciallyV 1 Comment
She gave up her kits so Thistleclaw wouldn't be the deputy. He was evil and she knew it. She had no choice. Thistleclaw would've turned ThunderClan evil. She loved her kits. Why is she on here?
Thank God Bluestar is on here. I hate her so much, and she was a terrible mother. I actually made an angry rant about it on the Top Ten Best Mothers in Warriors
Finally people understand the BlueStar is a horrible cat!
What da heck? Why is BLUESTAR up here?! She wanted her kits so badly, but she had to stop Mr Mousebrain Thistleclaw. Then Mosskit died and she was so grieved. AND THEN, her kits nearly didn't forgive her! Why./.. - Aquastar_of_DewClanV 4 Comments
Pinestar, Pinestar, Pinestar...oh boy. Now here's an issue in the form of a cat. Okay--I learned about him in the book about Ravenpaw's death and Spottedleaf's Heart (uugggh...) and he just...UGH. Okay. Let's take a look at this. He grew up to be the leader of Thunderclan. He mated with a she-cat named Leopardfoot (who was WAY younger than him, by the way...#creepo), he had three kits (I think) with her, two of which died, while one lived--Tigerkit, later to be Tigerstar, one of the greatest villians in the whole Warriors series. Pinestar later found out that Tigerkit would grow to be horrible--a murderer, a liar, a heartless cat. During this time, he would often pay a visit to Twoplegplace (which is AGAINST THE RULES...), and eat kittypet food (which is ALSO against the rules...). Finally after a long time of following this routine of his, he called a clan meeting, saying he would leave the clan...because he wanted to live his "last life in peace". Now, THAT PHRASE ALONE HAS A LOT OF ...more
One of the worst parents! I mean, he just up and left when Tigerkit was just a baby! What good parent does that?! He was also a coward for not wanting to lose his last life! What's better than dying for your Clan?! He would have walked with StarClan and been honored in memory!
Does no one remember? He didn't come to the birth of his kits.Never visited them or loved I'll on Leopardfoot.He just left to be a kittypet.The only reason he had those kits is to pass on his genes.
And we know how that turned out (Looking at Tigerkit )
Are you people crazy? Moonflower was a wonderful parent!
Hey Moon flower was a great mom! She loved her kits!
I voted for her just because... why is her name Moonflower? I thought that moon shouldn't be used in warrior names!
This list is full of false stuff. Moonflower was AWESOME! She took rlly good care of Bluekit and Snowkit, and she died because (stupid) Goosefeather told them to attack WindClan and Hawkheart killed her! Not that Hawkheart is bad, but it was Goosefeather's fault! - Aquastar_of_DewClanV 5 Comments
He was a rouge, and he was mates with Velvet, but abused his daughter, Red. (Not russetfur)
Who in the name of StarClan is Stick?
He didn't mean to kill Red. So, Dodge's group(Dodge is a rogue) were going to attack rogues(Stick, Percy, Shorty, Cora, etc) that weren't hostile. Red betrayed her group and mated with Harley(A rogue from Dodge's group). When the battle between the two rogues was about to start, Stick was gonna kill Harley. Red blocked Harley, and Stick accidentally killed her. - HollyleafOfThunderClan
Stick is a cat in the Super Edition "SkyClan's Destiny" that goes to SkyClan for help with rogues in the area that he lives in.
Why is Hawkwing on here?! It wasn't his fault he didn't raise his kits because he thought they were DEAD!
I love hawkwing
I think Twigpaw and Violetpaw are his long lost kits sooo he wouldn't know about them so he doesn't really count. Also I think that Pebbleshine should be on here because she gave them up! She could have at least carried one in her mouth or tried to get a couple of other cats to help.
Hawking wasn't a bad parent, but... what if Twigpaw and Violetpaw are his long-lost children?! Pebbleshine could have escaped from the Twolegs and given birth in the tunnels where Alderpaw and Nettlepaw found those kits! And Twigpaw looks just like Hawking! Skyclan might meet the kits when they return to the four warrior Clans. They will help them... after all, they are what will clear the sky!
Why is she even a bad mother? It was not her fault that Snowkit died. - cassiabez
I agree. Brambleclaw was a great father. He loved his adoptive (and biological) kits greatly, encouraged them, and was always there for them. Without a doubt, a great cat.
Brambleclaw was a great parent! Why is he on here?
Brambleclaw has no kits...
How is Brambleclaw (should be Bramblestar, by the way) a bad parent? Alderpaw and Sparkpaw love him. He is so kind to Alderpaw when Alderpaw is struggling with warrior apprentice duties because he offers words of encouragement and tells that the perfect Firestar wasn't the best apprentice either. Lifts his son's spirits up by so much!
Graystripe was a good and caring parent! I disagree with this!
He's not as bad as Millie but still...
Oh I hate graystripe I wish he would die
I don't like assuming and this could just be called a "headcannon", but I personally believe one of the main reason he even become Millie's mate in the first place, is because she looked like Silverstream.
When Greystripe choose to have another family, he needs to take reasonability for it instead of being rapped up with Silverstream all the time. How would you feel if your father use to have another wife and wouldn't stop fussing over her despite being died for years and having a new family who needs him. It would make you feel only 2nd best, to another family you barely ever knew. And think how Millie must feel as well. Constantly being compared and being considered the replacement to a cat she didn't even know, being in Silverstream's shadow. Instead of being treated like her own person, she's just seen as Silverstream's worse replacement. (I'm not saying Millie isn't at fault as well. She still neglected her two other kits. However she did have to deal with the stresses of ...more - Mellowix
Well...I mean... to Scourge, Ruby, and Socks that it. He was good to Nutmeg's litter.
He is the mother of mistystars kits and totally didn't encourage them. 3 of them died
Agreed person below
I HATE HER - Fadingwish3089
I HATE absolutely HATE her! she is sooo stupid and annoying. She should have died, I mean I don't really like Appledusk either but... Still, she was worse! - Willow12
If not a bad parent, certainly a bad cat. I do not like Mapleshade, and I disapprove of Appledusk's taking a ThunderClan mate, but it was her ATTITUDE I disliked. She always seemed so affectionate towards Appledusk, when Appledusk already had a mate. (Fun Fact: Reedshine is Silverstream's great-grandmother, and Mapleshade is her step-great-grandmother.)
He's not a parent yet...
Just didn't jump in to save tadpole
She would have but she had to save Mothwing and Hawkfrost.Why is she even on here!
Why is Firestar on here? He was trying to be leader and a father at the same time. Seriously people, give him a break.
Both Firestar and Sandstorm were great parents. - cassiabez
Why is firestar on here?
Firestar is a WONDERFUL WONDERFUL WONDERFUL parent!
1) He totally belongs with Sandstorm, and they're great together
2) That is my favorite warrior cat couple
3) He loved Squirrelflight and Leafpool equally, in case no one noticed
She loved her kits. She knew her kits would be taken away, so she gave Firestar one kit to be together with Firestar's kin. She shouldn't be on here. She loved her kits.
How did we know if she was ever a truly loving parent or not? We don't, I don't even know why someone put this on here.
We don't know if she's a good parent or not, but I'm sure she was.
She was just too... MUSHY w/ Cloudkit/paw/tail.
He wasn't a true father to mistyfoot and stonefur! (Revealed in mistystar's omen)
Sandstorm was a wonderful parent, just like Firestar was!
I never really liked her.Firestar was more of a parent to his kits.She snapped at them.And I don't think she was a good mother at all.
This cat is good at first when she tells Sol and other cats about the sky warriors, but turning bad and unresponsive when she meets Sol's father. She abandoned Sol and other kits!
Cinders was bratty and ungreatful and made her kits live with two legs and left them
I love Yellowfang...
Related ListsTop Ten Best Warrior Cat Parents Top Ten Warrior Cats Best Warrior Cat Characters (Book by Erin Hunter) Top Ten Saddest Warrior Cat Deaths Top Ten Warrior Cats Names That Do Not Exist
3 years, 322 days old