Top Ten Worst Warrior Cats BooksMemery24
The Contenders: Page 3
Is this a book, if so, where can I get itV 1 Comment
This was a pretty good book, but it's not as interesting as the other books in Dawn Of The Clans, but pretty good.
It was very boring nothing interesting just... Stuff. Every cat working a bout nothing. WHO CARES IF U ARE CONFUSED! LIFE MAKES ME CONFUSED!V 1 Comment
I hate it so much. Bluestar was being edgy and some random untrained dogs swallowed her then Fireheart threw a tantrum over it and the Clan started whining because they hate him. - Puppytart
This was an amazing book!
The book was rather boring it was just about Bluestar being depressed and being a bitch to Fireheart she was my favourite cat but she got on my nerves after a bit I'm glad they killed her off but her death was so sad stupid dogs.
Actually, there was much more to it than that. I'd say it was a good book compared to Rising Storm. - SpyroZap99
It is basically Omen of the Stars with Dovewing and Ivypool all over again! Twigpaw just has a better personality and does not whine like Dovewing, a full-grown warrior, even though she is an apprentice. Violetpaw is whiny and attacks her sister because her angsty teen mentor begged her to. Needletail did die in later books though so I feel bad for Violetpaw. But who even sent her away from her sister? - Puppytart
This isn't a horrible book. It's just sad, it honestly shouldn't be on here. - IcetailofWishClan
Hey! I thought this was really interesting and exciting!
I loved this book. - CinderpeltandCinderheart
I have evidence that this incredibly bad novella is not canon. It's strongly reccomended to read the actual novella or spoil yourself entirely before reading this or you're going to be confused.
First of all, the entire fact of Thistleclaw and Spottedleaf both being alive in the book is makes a CRITICAL issue. If you read all of Bluestar's Prophecy, you'll know that Thistleclaw died before Spottedkit was born.
Second, both Thistleclaw and Spottedleaf are completely out of character.
Thistleclaw would NOT take any interest in Spottedkit because of the timeline issue, and also because Thistleclaw would still be depressed after Snowfur's death.
In Bluestar's Prophecy, it's stated that Spottedkit has an interest in herbs, so there is absolutely NO REASON for her to become a warrior apprentice in this.
This novella could've been so much better if it wasn't for the nonsensical ThistlexSpotted pairing, timeline issue, and Spottedkit being a warrior ...more - 905384095438053
Related ListsWarrior Cats Villain Names that are Not Used on the Books Top Ten Books Warrior Cats Was Based Off Of Top Ten Funny Warrior Cats Kit Names That Aren't In the Books Top Ten Warrior Cats Names That Do Not Exist Top Ten Warrior Cats
List StatsUpdated 21 Aug 2017
3 years, 57 days old
Top Remixes (6)
3. Rising Storm
2. Tallstar's Revenge
2. Tallstar's Revenge
View All 6