Top Ten Worst Warrior Cats Moments

Anybody here feel the same way about these moments? There are the ones that seem to drag on and the ones that are so sad you almost cry every time. If there are any sad ones here it's because its sad, not that it's stupid or bad or THE WORST! They are just so sad I almost cry. Not that I have anything against these moments, I just don't like them too much.

The Top Ten

1 Firestar dies

Firestar didn't die because of a tree, that's a myth. Ask the writers. Dovewing saw it as a vision and Firestar was actually killed by his wounds from Tigerstar. - TheGrayDude55

Anyone who hates forester's death is just a idiot kittypet.

Firestar, one of the most powerful leaders in the forest and defeats enemies such as Scourge and Tigerstar, dies an incredibly stupid death. I mean what would be a worse way to die than from a stupid tree?! I did like how Brambleclaw became leader but why is he choose his mate to be his deputy?

Just to clear something up, Firestar did NOT die from the tree. The tree happened to fall, yes, but he didn't die from it. He died from the wounds Tigerstar gave him while they battled, not a tree. Erin Hunter isn't stupid, and Firestar didn't die from a stupid tree.

V 13 Comments
2 Snowkit's death

I really thought that he could be someone special in the book, like someone prophesied or something, maybe a medicine cat since he was deaf. I can't believe that he died!

It was so sad, it bit right through my heart! I watched a video about snowkit's death that made me wanna cry! I think it really added something to the book for you to think about a lot. It really made the book sadder. It did the book some good but didn't do any good for snowkit or the super sad feeling thinking about him. It's not the worst, it's the SADDEST! - Kittensarecute

This was one of the saddest moments! It broke my heart when the eagle grabbed him taking him away. He didn't even know what was going on because he was deaf! I wish that he could be reincarnated or something! Poor Snowkit.

He was deaf, needed to go.

V 3 Comments
3 Hollyleafs announcement

I thought Hollyleaf's announcement was pretty important because, if she hadn't, she probably would've ran away anyway because she couldn't handle her birth breaking the warrior code, which was everything to her. And yes, there were whispers about Leafpool, Squirrelflight, Brambleclaw, Jayfeather, and Lionblaze, but it didn't haunt them. By the time Hollyleaf came back, everyone had pretty much gotten over it. Also, Ashfur was going to reveal it just to spite Squirrelflight Hollyleaf did it because she thought she was doing the right thing. Quote unquote "I thought I was doing the right thing, but no one understands! "

Hollyleaf had horribly told them ALL ABOUT her secret of being half clan and having a fake mother. It's horrible that she did it because she haunted their lives for the rest of their lives. She kinda ruined their lives. Not blaming her. - Kittensarecute

I admit, Hollyleaf shouldn't have blabbed at the Gathering, but I still love her.

Hollyleaf is best I hat jayfeather he is the worst and I want him to die

V 2 Comments
4 The great journey

This was probably the part that dragged in the most. It just got boring, that is until they killed sharp tooth and did all that but after that, it kinda just got boring. I would've skipped it if I didn't care if I missed an important part. That's why I put this on the list. - Kittensarecute

I actually really liked the great journey. It wasn't just important in the storyline, it was also important for character development. - Flamesofsilver

I know it was, this is just by my opinion. I do not mean to offend anyone. - Kittensarecute

The great journey shouldn't have happened. They should have stayed in the forest all along and Power of Three should have taken place there.

Yea, this got very boring and I didn't really like reading about it.

V 1 Comment
5 Jayfeather breaks his stick

*Breaks stick*
Jayfeather: DA ECK - TheGrayDude55

Jayfeather destroyed the only memory of before the tribe of rushing water had been made. That stick was definitely important! The ancients may still be able to contact him along with the other ancients but now the memory isn't strong anymore. - Kittensarecute

I actually thought of this as a sad moment, if you think about it Jayfeather doesn't really have friends. He thought Rock was his friend... But... No - TheJinxedJay

My ship was ruined that day

V 4 Comments
6 Firestar loses a life and russet fur dies

That battle shouldn't have happened! I really hated ivy paw/pool!

I just remembered. It was ALL HER FAULT THE BATTLE HAPPENED. I still like her character though! - Kittensarecute

Two deaths in one battle? It went in this order: russetfur starts an attempt to kill Firestar (what a butt), lionblaze accidently kills russetfur, Firestar loses a life, shadowclan hates lionblaze mostly but thunderclan is also hated and flametail becomes an annoying bratty character. Just saying, it's true. - Kittensarecute

7 Skyclan gets chased out

I don't like skyclan to be honest so I'm kinda glad.

SkyClan is best in the gorge.

Yas it made me so mad

That's so sad

8 The thunderclan fire

It was very sad! Also that YellowFang and two elders die cause of the dumb fire! It was very 😭 - WarriorFlameFur

9 Windclan gets chased out

Yeah, I guess this would be my second choice...But they do come back, so not that much...

10 Scourge enters forest

Scourge is the best bad-guy in a series that is seriously lacking villains with motivations. - TheGrayDude55

I actaully feel bad for Scourge. If you guys have ever read "The Rise of Scourge" you would know what I mean.


The Newcomers

? When Scourge Kills Tigerstar, He Strikes 9 Major Organs Causing Him to Lose More Than 1 Life

The Contenders

11 Graystripe is kidnapped

I was so angry about this! If he hadn't been kidnapped then Brambleclaw would never be leader and I would be happy

Graystripe should have been kidnapped. If he hadn't he wouldn't have met Millie, and after all, he came back...

This part was so sad! I loved Graystripe. He was so brave

I totally missed Graystripe

V 2 Comments
12 Hollyleaf fake death and the real one

Hey! Remember that female character who died a while back?
You know, the one that everyone accepted, since bad stuff happens all the time in the wild, and they quickly replaced her with a better team member?
Guess what? SHE'S ALIVE
Hollyleaf's death was believable, and the clan lost nothing by losing her. She had no impact on the plot before she died, except being a side character. They just did this to get another girl in there.

Me: Oh no Hollyleaf... probably isn't dead...
4 books later...
Me: She is defiantly dead...
*comes back*
Me: Oh okay that fine I liked her a lot
2 books later

This was just stupid. They brought her back after 2 books just to kill her again!

Hollyleaf fake dies, and dies for real. It's just sad! This is the second saddest death I know of. - Kittensarecute

V 5 Comments
13 Treecutters come and ruin forest

Why couldn't they have left the poor little kitties alone?

14 Briarlight breaks her backbone

Briarlight is overrated

Briarlight is stupid I hated this too because Millie stopped paying attention to poor Blossomfall for stupid Briarpoopbutt. Sorry but I really hate Briarlight!

That's just horrible! She can't walk! I would HATE having to have everyone start being sympathetic and I would be happy when they stopped! - Kittensarecute

She couldn't even save Longtail and she broke her back...

V 4 Comments
15 Bluestar dies

Aw it was so sad but really nicely written! - TheGrayDude55

Bluestar needed to die. She was a great character, but Firestar would never have gotten to be leader, so it kinda needed to happen.

Why Bluestar? Tigerstar the brat!

*Bluestar licks her chest self-consciously*
Thanks guys!

V 2 Comments
16 Dogs are let loose (by tigerclaw)

Why does Tigerclaw have to e so evil?

17 The great battle

But it led to so many dramas! It's also my favorite book. I'm so sorry for the ones that don't like the battle. - Hollymint

18 Feathertail's death

Why is Feathertail such a loved character, heck, she hardly did anything throughout her appearances. Her death wasn't sad in the slightest, dunno why everyone loved her so much. - TheGrayDude55

This made me REALLY cry.😿
I feel really bad for Crowfeather and Graystripe. - WitheredBonnie

19 Ivypaws hatred of Dovepaw

I would've put this at the top somewhere if I had thought it through... - Kittensarecute

Yes, I didn't like reading this... - keycha1n

It's not ALL Ivypaw's fault. I mean, everyone was treating her sister specially. - AnonymousChick

They did NOT hate each other!

V 1 Comment
20 Mapleshade chain


21 Discovery of leafpool's kits

I wish they never found out, just so they could live a happy life.

22 Stormkit's accident and when his name changes to Crookedkit

He was a kit for Starclan's sake! That was emotional abuse..

This made me cry. A mother disowns her kits and gives him a rude name. ~ Goldenfeather

23 Cinderpelt dies

This was my saddest cat death, I felt joy when he came back as cinderheart

*Cinderpelt dies*
Fans: D;
Erin Hunter: HA - TheGrayDude55

I personally LOVED her and cried buckets when she died. It was so sad! I prefer the original to CinderHEART.

Any cat but Cinderpelt!

V 1 Comment
24 Tigerclaw becomes tigerstar

So I was reading the books, everything going as normal, then suddenly, Tigerstar is apparently the leader of ShadowClan? I wanted to bang my head against a wall. ShadowClan is smarter than to put a murderous traitor as leader out of the blue. No, just no.


25 Jessy returns

Oops spoiler

Oh if she returned she'd become Gempaw and become Firestar 2.0 x 100 and bramblestar would be her mate THANK GOODNESS THIS don't EVER HAPPEN WOOHOO

26 Graystripe leaves for Riverclan

Yeah, this was too sad. I was saddest in that moment

27 When Icepaw dies

IceCLOUD never died.


This is made up, my made up cat, but here is the story__
she is a white apprentice with iceblue eyes and she lost her nose in a fight. she wasone of the really old cats, leader was Sunsetstar of ThunderClan, who was the leader after Owlstar. her mentor was fighting with her but a cat ripped open Icepaw's back and Icepaw died. she was noble, if a little battlehungry, but she was a perfectly good cat. in a cruel twist of fate her mentor was killed by the same cat, defending Sunsetstar from the evil cat. please, avenge Icepaw's death, vote for her. oh, and the evil cat was named Spiderstrike. he is in the dark forest. please don't use her for your own character. she is mine.

28 The dark forest kills Beetlewhisker

He was a great character. - AnonymousChick

29 Swiftpaw's death

It was so terrible

30 Squirrelpaw and Leafpaw separate

WHY! They were ment to be together! I mean, Squirrelpaw didn't even have to go! WHY! WHY! WHY!

31 When Firestar Dies

This was already on here...

But he never should have died.

32 Jessy takes over the clans and forms them into "PerfectClan"
33 Gray Wing dies
34 Storm's Death
35 Stonefur's Death

He was so brave, standing up for those poor kits of Graystripe's! I loved him so much. I CRIED ALL OVER THE FLOOR! - Hollymint

36 Stonefur Dies

He was so brave, standing up for those poor kits of Graystripe's! He was one of my favorite cats. I CRIED ALL OVER THE FLOOR! - Hollymint

37 Brightheart getting attacked by dogs
38 Mothwing becoming friends with Leafpool
39 Millie yells at Blossomfall
40 Dovewing being born


41 Breezepelt lives

He should’ve died...

42 Firestar crushing on Spottedleaf in the later series after he knows and barely acknowledges her in the same book he knew her in
43 Stick's death
44 Leafpool's Death

I felt as though she should have lived this guilt shrunken cat had much more to live for, even though her daughter is dead and her mate ignored her, she still was a beautiful cat.

BAdd New Item

Related Lists

Top Ten Saddest Warrior Cats Moments Top Ten Warrior Cats Top Ten Warrior Cats Names That Do Not Exist Top Ten Saddest Warrior Cat Deaths Best Warrior Cat Characters (Book by Erin Hunter)

List Stats

100 votes
45 listings
4 years, 137 days old

Top Remixes

1. Skyclan gets chased out
2. The thunderclan fire
3. Windclan gets chased out
1. Firestar dies
2. Bluestar dies
3. Firestar loses a life and russet fur dies
1. The great journey
2. Snowkit's death
3. Hollyleafs announcement


Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.