Top 10 WrestleMania Matches Where The Wrong Superstar Won

egnomac
Basically these are the matches from WrestleMania where the wrong super star won.

The Top Ten

1 Triple H vs Sting - Wrestlemania 31

Possibly the most unexpected moment in fans eyes was seeing WCW legend Sting in the WWE even more so challenging Triple H at WrestleMania sounded great until once again Mr. McMahon had to bring back the whole Monday Night War feud again which meant that the WWE guy Triple H was going to win over the WCW guy Sting once again Vince can't stop let up that he won the war over WCW. - egnomac

2 Triple H vs Booker T - WrestleMania XIX

After all of Triple H's controversial promo's against Booker T leading up to WrestleMania it could have all been forgiven if only Booker T had won the world title from Triple H but of course Triple H had other plans and got the win after hitting the pedigree on Booker and very slowly making the cover. - egnomac

3 Roman Reigns vs The Undertaker - Wrestlemania 33

Sorry Roman Reigns winning no matter how much you hate him wasn't a mistake, Roman Reigns is a very hard working wrestler that gets no respect and has the right to be the face of the WWE, I'm pretty sure this is the person that the WWE GM wanted to beat the streak, since Brock Lesnar beating the streak was just a character ploy - germshep24

This was a very hurting loss for the Deadman to take, even worse than the streak snapping to Lesanr. - htoutlaws2012

Roman Reigns sucks

4 Charlotte vs Asuka - WrestleMania 34

Although Charlotte beating Asuka ending her undefeated streak was a truly shocking WrestleMania moment unfortunately this would send Asuka into a near downward spiral as days later Charlotte would lose the title to Carmella and would go on to feud with Asuka who ended up losing to her again and again in ridiculous fashion. - egnomac

Charlotte is like the female version of John Cena. Pushed to the limit even though the fans have grown tired of it. - RustyNail

Ended asuka's streak was a bad move for wwe keeping her on raw and having her win the raw women's championship was the better move so ronda could beat her on a main event pay per view possibly evolution and have charlotte face her at wm 35

5 Bret Hart vs Yokozuna - WrestleMania IX

They should have just had Bret Hart win that night but of course they chose to have Yokozuna win and have Hogan come out for no reason and beat him for the title with the plan to have him drop it to Bret Hart which never happened because of Hogan's giant ego and was unwilling to lose to Hart as he instead dropped the belt back to Yokozuna at King of the Ring and left WWE to go to WCW. - egnomac

6 Shawn Michaels vs Diesel - WrestleMania XI

While it was an okay match but having Diesel win over Michaels was a huge mistake as the fans ended up booing Diesel and it just shows just how bad it was having Disel as the WWE champion. - egnomac

7 Triple H vs Randy Orton - WrestleMania 25
8 Brock Lesnar vs Undertaker - Wrestlemania 30 Brock Lesnar vs Undertaker - Wrestlemania 30

Brock Lesnar has beaten Undertaker in every match leading to their Wrestlemania bout, having Lesnar win this match was just a terrible mistake. If the wanted Brock to win they should have had him lose to undertaker in the previous bouts or just didn't have them go at it until Wrestlemania - germshep24

It was predictable, but I didn’t want Lesnar to win. - MrCoolC

9 Money in the Bank Ladder Match - WrestleMania XXVI

Jack Swagger was porobably the least deserving to win the MITB contract as after cashing it in on Chris Jericho he pretty much got buried as champion and eventually lost the title to Rey Mysterio. - egnomac

10 Hulk Hogan vs Randy Savage - Wrestlemania V

The Contenders

11 25 Diva Battle Royal - WrestleMania 25

Why even have a 25 Diva battle royal if your not going to have an actual diva win the match and instead have it won by a man in drag. - egnomac

12 Michael Cole vs Jerry Lawler - WrestleMania XXVII Michael Cole vs Jerry Lawler - WrestleMania XXVII

Jerry Lawyer should have won, a non wrestler should never win a match, it just makes wrestling look ridiculous - germshep24

Jerry Lawler winning over Michael Cole would have at least made up for this train wreck of a match not only did Cole win but he won only because the anonymous GM reversed the decision after Stone Cold over stepped his boundary as referee. - egnomac

13 John Cena vs Bray Wyatt - Wrestlemania 30
14 John Cena vs CM Punk - Summerslam 2011

Why is there a Summerslam Match on this Match - WWEWBMortalKombatFan

CM Punk should have won, why would they kill the best promo ever with have John Cena win - germshep24

John Cena should have won - ItzYaBoyMichael123

15 Pillow Fight - Wrestlemania 19
BAdd New Item

Related Lists

Top 10 Royal Rumble Matches Where the Wrong Superstar Won Top Ten Things That Could Go Badly Wrong at WWE Wrestlemania 31 Top 10 Superstars Undertaker Never Faced at Wrestlemania Top 10 Unluckiest WWE Superstars at Wrestlemania Top Ten Biggest WWF/E Superstars Who Never Headlined a Wrestlemania

List Stats

15 listings
27 days old

Top Remixes

1. Roman Reigns vs The Undertaker - Wrestlemania 33
2. Triple H vs Sting - Wrestlemania 31
3. Michael Cole vs Jerry Lawler - WrestleMania XXVII
htoutlaws2012
1. Triple H vs Sting - Wrestlemania 31
2. Triple H vs Booker T - WrestleMania XIX
3. Bret Hart vs Yokozuna - WrestleMania IX
egnomac

WRemix

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.
P