Top 10 YouTube Movie Critics

TristanMatheny

The Top Ten

1 Chris Stuckmann Chris Stuckmann Christopher "Chris" Stuckmann is an American film critic, author, and YouTube personality. As of June 2018, he has over 1.2 million subscribers and 341 million views on YouTube.

It was a hard choice between Nostalgia Critic and Chris Stuckmann. I think I made the right choice. I watch Nostalgia Critic because he makes me laugh. That's it. I watch Chris because he makes really good points and he makes pretty good jokes a lot. Also, his "Toy Story 4" review made me watch it, and I absolutely loved it. I was amazed at that movie. Thanks, Chris.

I have to say, there’s no other film critic much like Chris Stuckmann. After so many years, he still remains my all-time favourite film critic. I absolutely love his analysis and thoughts on the movies he reviewed.

His journey is truly remarkable.

I found Chris Stuckmanns channel a few years ago on YouTube and he's really good at what he does and I like the film industry like he does we share the same passion and I wrote my own film reviews.

12 Comments
2 Jeremy Jahns Jeremy Jahns Jeremy Jahns (born May 8, 1981 [age 36]) is an American YouTuber that makes weekly movie reviews on the newest film releases. Jahns is known for his traditional suit, with red background and delivering his thoughts on movies.

He's charismatic but also gives biased opinions; he usually gives too good reviews to otherwise mediocre movies, so it's hard to take his opinion into consideration, really.

His impressions of people in films are just...gold!

He is the most awesometacular critic out there. - TristanMatheny

He is very funny and nostalgic.BUT he gives his reviews too fast so u should be very careful.His spoiler talk is really amazing

3 The Nostalgia Critic The Nostalgia Critic

He is not bad, he is just honest and says what sometimes needs to be said. -CandyBlood13

The Nostalgia Critic sucks... - KalloFox34

Nostalgia Critic is the best.

I don't hate Chris Stuckman or Jeremy Jahns but I feel like Number 1 should be The Nostalgia Critic and Number 2 should be I Hate Everything

9 Comments
4 ralphthemoviemaker ralphthemoviemaker

He deserves to be above Nostalgia Critic. - BlueTelegraph

Deserves a place in the top 10's puts a lot of hard work to his reviews. - OfficialSonic

He deserves being #1

5 YourMovieSucksDOTorg YourMovieSucksDOTorg

There he is!

6 Red Letter Media

Their reviews gave me AIDS.

The best out of all these choices

Hacks and frauds

7 Schmoes Know
8 The Flick Pick

Watch his 'Top 10 Most Epic Movies' video - his 'epic trailer voice' is just golden

This guy has so much charisma. Seems like such a likeable guy.

It's a little bit magical and a little bit mystical

9 I Hate Everything I Hate Everything

His microphone is improving - money_face

He still hasn't made a review of Mars Bars!

Not entirely a movie critic, but when he makes his good-lengthed 20 minute long reviews are great! He focuses on TERRIBLE films, and goes into depth about WHY they're bad. New to the channel? Go see his review of Birdemic or Cool Cat Saves the Kids. (That name sounds bad)

10 CinemaSins CinemaSins CinemaSins is a movie-related YouTube channel created by Jeremy Scott and Chris Atkinson. The channel produces the Everything Wrong With...

I personally don't see them as critics. Just expert nitpickers from what I've seen. - CrimsonShark

CinemaSins should be way higher! They show no bias and your guaranteed to laugh at least once!

The Contenders

11 Black Nerd Comedy Black Nerd Comedy

How is this guy not higher on the list? Most of his reviews are evenly balanced (key word is MOST) and he ends all of his videos being very cheerful and happy.

12 Screen Junkies

Recently Screen Junkies News has upped their game. They're focusing more on the mechanics behind Hollywood, a bit political economy-ish at times. As a weekly news source, I'd say they're my favorite. Better and more intelligent dialogue than most panel-based youtube shows. And not so serious that they're not enjoyable to hang out with.

They call themselves professional film critics? Lol... annoying Sci-Fi fanboys as usual..

13 Mark Kermode Mark Kermode

One of the few reviewers looking for craft.

14 JonTron JonTron Jonathan Aryan "Jon" Jafari, best known by his internet pseudonym JonTron, is an American comedian, reviewer, and internet personality.

He’s funny - Ar0nT0pTeNz05

15 Beyond the Trailer
16 The Unusual Suspect The Unusual Suspect

He should be in the top ten. Really underrated.

17 James Rolfe James Rolfe James Duncan Rolfe is an American actor, comedian, filmmaker, film and video game critic, and internet personality, best known for starring in the web television series The Angry Video Game Nerd, a joint production of Rolfe's Cinemassacre Productions, GameTrailers, and ScrewAttack.

He does video games, not movies - Ar0nT0pTeNz05

So good he's on here twice - nickisa

18 The Nostalgia Chick

Also known as Lindsay Ellis

19 BlackCriticGuy

Why does no one know about him? He is bae!

He's a great critic and his rants are hilarious!

20 Bobsheaux

He deserves more subscribers than he has. This guy is an amazing reviewer on YouTube!

HE DESERVED TO TREAT THE ALPHA & OMEGA SEQUELS LIKE PURE TRASH! LET'S MURDER THESE UGLY, RUDE KIDS OF HUMPHREY AND KATE!

21 Cinemassacre Cinemassacre

Like I said, he does video games, not movies - Ar0nT0pTeNz05

22 AniMat AniMat
23 Jack's Movie Reviews
24 Luc Turgeon

Thetoptens is the worst website in the history of ever. So I decided to spam this and get myself on the list. Those comments are all fake lol. I hate this site.

This guy is beast. He makes the greatest videos on the internet.

Makes me laugh everyday. This website is cancer though.

This guy shouldn't be here. Haven't ever even heard of him.

6 Comments
25 Collider
26 That Movie Nerd Kevin
27 CineFix CineFix

It's the best YouTube channel on cinema. The top 10 videos are mind blowing.

28 What The Flick!?
29 Breaking Banter
30 Just Write
31 Every Frame a Painting

I voted for him even though I don't see him as a critic. I believe he is the best film 'reviewer' if you will in the industry. A clear view on things as well as a tasteful one, he never ceased to amaze me. I thoroughly enjoyed his content and learned a lot about film making. 10/10

32 Belated Media
33 Mr. Sunday Movies
34 Film Brain (Matthew Buck)

Very funny guy.

35 TheMysteriousMrEnter TheMysteriousMrEnter

John's not bad you the one whose bad

Up Until his 58th animated atrocity
Then He Went bad

36 Mat Brunet

I want to die.

He had his reasons to hate the Sony Pictures Animation movies, and I hold Sony Pictures Animation to a low standard. But he also likes Frozen, and I respect his opinion.

"He's the bestestestestestestestestestestestestestestestestestestestestestestestestestestest besides for the fact that he should be 2 and Nostalgia Critic should (obviously) be number 1" - A 9 year old

37 Saberspark Saberspark

No. NOO - money_face

38 Reel School

Best kept secret on YouTube in my opinion. Funny, educated and he does all kids of videos from tutorials, criticism and interviews.
YouTube.com/reelschool

39 Say Goodnight Kevin
40 Sams Channel
41 Aaron Dicer (Your Movie Friend)

It's unfair how few subs he has. I look forward to his "5 Things" reviews every week!

42 Angry Joe

He considers his other members opinion in order to get an authentic and reliable criticism about the films and even though his a fan of a certain franchise he is not afraid to name it as garbage. Though he is not that quite funny just like in his video game reviews he still honest in reviewing this films

Not really, he is actually very. He thinks that suicide squad is awesome but that the last jedi sucks? How is that even possible? he does not know about cinema so his opinion are very soft - Ale99

43 Phantomstrider Phantomstrider

WOAT tier youtuber. - BlueTelegraph

His videos are getting better and less pointless and his editing is improving in every video. I also like his personality - money_face

He is cool, awesome and less of a potty mouth then the nostalgia critic

He's awesome

44 CommandoCT
45 cinecreep
46 Flicks and Movies
47 Clift Cinema
48 nickthemusicnerd27
49 Storytellers
50 Movies I Love (and so can you)
8Load More
PSearch List

Related Lists

Top Ten Most Underrated YouTube Movie Critics Best YouTube Music Critics Top Ten YouTube Animation Critics Top 10 Hottest YouTube Media Critics Top Ten Best YouTube Critics

List Stats

300 votes
52 listings
5 years, 142 days old

Top Remixes (8)

1. ralphthemoviemaker
2. I Hate Everything
3. YourMovieSucksDOTorg
BlueTelegraph
1. Chris Stuckmann
2. Jeremy Jahns
3. The Flick Pick
thejamin
1. ralphthemoviemaker
2. Cinemassacre
3. JonTron
batman23

WRemix
View All 8

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.