Madoka Magica Problems

MLPFan Even Madoka Magica is my favourite anime, It has some flaws and there are things that people are confused with. After some thinking, I found the answers....
1.Why didn't Madoka just wish _______
a.Why didn't Madoka just wish to bring Mami back to life: Because If that happens Homura will have to reset the whole thing again since If Mami survived the witch, Madoka will make a contract with Kyuubey. Plus Homura's mission was to make sure Madoka didn't do It.
b.Why didn't Madoka just wish to make Kyousuke fall In love with Sayaka:Because Kyousuke not being In love with Sayaka isn't the main reason of Sayaka's downfall. Her knowing the truth about the soul gems are. And according to the Production note, even If Sayaka gets Kyousuke, she won't be happy with him.
Besides, If she wished any of these two wishes instead, then the other events after Mami and Sayaka's deaths won't happen(even the two deaths wouldn't happen, then)
2.Why did Madoka chose to wish to erase witches than ask to gather all remaining magical girls to fight Walpurgis with her:Because Madoka witnessed her friend became a witch herself. And look how sad she was. She didn't want anyone else to be one. That's why she made that wish. Choosing the'fight Walpurgis together' wish might lead the story into a Sonic Heroes(the good old days 😄)ending. Making It less interesting
3.Why didn't timeline 1 Homura just wish to bring timeline 1 Madoka back to life:Because Homura that time sees herself as a weak girl who can only tag along, Like what main timeline Madoka sees as herself. She wanted to be a strong Magical girl who protects Madoka, Not a weak girl who Madoka has to protect and save all the time.
4.Why won't Sayaka confess her love to Kyousuke:Because after knowing that her soul has been taken, she found herself as a zombie. That's why she didn't confess, as she found herself unworthy of his love with that state.
5.Why did Hitomi gave Sayaka such short time:Even that I hate Hitomi's guts really bad, I have to defend her on this one. It's because Sayaka knew Kyousuke a lot longer than her, so she has more than enough time to do so and she already settled her own confession day as tomorrow after school, but she wanted Sayaka to confess first, even that she had to gave her such short time.
6.How come that Madoka gets very strong magi powers and became a goddess only after making a contract:Because I think In most cases, a girl's powers Isn't only based on how long she Is a magical girl and the power of her wish. Madoka, wished for a very strong wish that no other magical girl thought of, which is to end suffering with her own hands. Even at early times of the series, Madoka was mentioned to have a very strong potential. It was also because every time Homura resets the timeline, Madoka's wish became stronger and this is maybe the thousand time Homura did, making the power of Madoka's wish at It's strongest.
Please remember this is not made to make Madoka Magica look perfect like what most fans do(make the thing they like look perfect even that nothing Is). This Is to explain others about some thing they're confused with, And about the ending of Rebellion, I'll try my best.

Comments

Yeah, it makes sense - TwilightKitsune (7/27/2016)

Great post answering the dying questions I had with Puella Magi Madoka Magica! I loved that anime! And yeah, I agree with you that Hitomi sucks. - visitor (8/5/2016)

Hitomi sucks a lot - MLPFan (8/25/2016)

I agree I hate hitomi a lot she’s a bitch. But she comes off as mere child’s play. I do think kyousuke is even worse - Greninjafan127 (5/28/2018)

By the way, did you check out my newest list yet? It's called Greatest Anime Series Licensed by Aniplex of America and I featured Puella Magi Madoka Magica on it. - visitor (8/25/2016)