Top 10 Scariest Judges

This list is made just for fun and is meant to make fans of these judges feel a sense of fear toward them - just like creepypasta!

Many judges are known to be angry, cruel, or prone to giving harsh punishments. Sometimes, they can even be quite annoying or, in contrast, surprisingly nice to people in the courtroom!
The Top Ten
Judge Judy Sheindlin (Judge Judy) Judith Susan Sheindlin, professionally known as Judge Judy, is an American prosecution lawyer, former Manhattan family court judge, television personality, television producer, and author.

She's the creepiest judge in real life, but she doesn't give cruel punishments like her twin in The Simpsons, Constance Harm! Judge Judy is always yelling and scary, but fair and the best judge of all time. She's not the number one creepiest judge because she's not as cruel as Judge Constance Harm in delivering punishments. Judge Judy is my favorite judge, alongside Constance Harm and Marilyn Milian. These are my top three favorite judges!

Judge Constance Harm (The Simpsons)

She's my favorite judge, like Judge Judy and Judge Milian, but the creepiest for me because she gives very cruel punishments to criminals and guilty people. Her anger intensifies with each case, similar to Judge Judy, but Constance is not as kind and acts like a punishing machine! Judge Constance is voiced by Jane Kaczmarek, who makes me laugh and scares me with the judge's harsh words and punishments. She's a really good judge and better than Roy Snyder and the Female Judge. She should be the goddess of judges, along with Judge Judy and Marilyn Milian!

Female Judge (The Simpsons)

The Female Judge appears in The Simpsons as the first judge in Springfield. She had a shorter screen time compared to Constance Harm and Judge Roy Snyder because many people dislike the Female Judge more than Constance Harm and Roy Snyder. The Female Judge is quite creepy with her punishments and is creepier than other judges who are lower in the top three.

Judge Marilyn Milian (The People's Court)

She's my favorite judge, but she's in third or second place because she's not always aggressive, angry, or hot-tempered. She's very nice but talks too fast! She has been appearing in The People's Court since 2001 and has been a judge there for 13 years.

Judge Mills Lane (Celebrity Deathmatch)

He was on the show Celebrity Deathmatch. He's a judge like the others, but he has fewer fans than Judge Judy and Judge Mathis. He has a funny voice when he talks. He's not cruel, and he's not creepier than those above the top five.

Judge Joe Brown (Judge Joe Brown)

He was arrested in 2014, and he no longer appears on TV, but a lot of people like to watch him on TV or the internet. I haven't watched him on TV or the internet, but I know about him. He looks like Judge Mathis, but he is a bit creepier.

Judge Greg Mathis (Judge Mathis)
Judge Larry Bakman (Hot Bench)
Judge Tanya Acker (Hot Bench)

She seems to have several chips on her shoulder. She waves her hands and smirks when she's outvoted in the back room, laughing at how some people express themselves in an unfamiliar setting. She calls them names like "You're a total idiot!" and "You two are so full of it." If a judge demands respect, they should set an example and display some themselves. However, such behavior doesn't make for good television. I find her haughty, disrespectful, and overly mouthy for someone in her position.

Judge Patricia DiMango (Hot Bench)
The Contenders
Judge Roy Spleen (The Grim Adventures of Billy and Mandy)

He's scary because he looks so ugly!

Judge Dredd (Judge Dredd) Judge Joseph Dredd is a fictional character created by writer John Wagner and artist Carlos Ezquerra. He first appeared in the second issue of 2000 AD, which is a British weekly anthology comic.

Judge Dredd is the ultimate ass-kicker! Criminals cower in fear when Dredd is nearby!

BAdd New Item