Football Players #1: Who's better Donavan McNabb or Kurt Warner?

2storm There has been big discussion at my school who is better Kurt Warner or Donovan McNabb?

First let's just see who these two guys are.

Donovan McNabb
Born: Chicago Illinois Nov. 25 1976.
Height: 6"2.
Weight: 240 pounds.
High School: Mount Carmel.
College: Syracuse.
NFL Draft: 1999/Round 1 second pick.

Kurt Warner.
Born: Burlington Iowa June 22 1971.
Height: 6"2.
Weight: 214 pounds.
High School: Regis.
College: Northern Iowa.
NFL Draft: 1994/Undrafted.

So that is their Personal information. Here is there achievements and Stats in the NFL.

Kurt Warner.
Teams: Green Bay Packers 1994 (Got cut), Iowa Barnstormers 1995 to 1997, Amsterdam Admirals 1998, St. Louis Rams 1998 to 2003, New York Giants 2004, Arizona Cardinals 2005 to 2009.
Awards and Highlights: Super Bowl Champion XXXIV. Super Bowl MVP XXXIV. 3X NFC Champion 1999, 2001, 2008. 4X Pro Bowl 1999, 2000, 2001, 2008. 2X First Team All Pro 1999, 2001. 1999 MVP (AP, PFWA, NEA, SN, MX). 2001 MVP (AP, NEA). 2008 MVP (NEA). Walter Payton Man of the Year (2008). Bart Starr Man of the Year (2009). At least 100 TD passes for two different teams (Rams and Cardinals). First QB to throw 3 touchdowns in first three games. Holds three records in the Super Bowl.
States:
Pass Attempts: 4070.
Passes Complete: 2666.
Percentage: 65.5.
TDS to INT ratio: 208/128.
Passing Yards: 32344.
Passer Rating: 93.7.
(Never Rushed).

Donovan McNabb.

Teams: Philadelphia Eagles (1999 to 2009). Washington Redskins (2010). Minnesota Vikings (2011).
Awards and Highlights: 6X Pro Bowl (2000, 2001, 2002, 2003, 2004, 2009). NFC Offensive Player of the Year (2004). NFC Player of the Year (2004). NFC Champion (2004). Philadelphia Eagles 75th Anniversary Team. Philadelphia Eagles No. 5 retired. Eagles Hall of Fame inductee (2013). Philadelphia Eagles All-time Leader in Career Wins, Pass Attempts, Passes Complete, Passing Yards, and Passing Touchdowns.
Stats:
Pass Attempts: 5374.
Passes Complete: 3170.
Percentage: 52.
TDS to INT ratio: 234/117
Passing Yards: 37276.
Passer Rating: 85.6.
Carries: 587.
Yards: 3341.
Touchdowns: 28.

So let's see why they retired.

Kurt Warner retired saying I want to spend more time with his kids but he may come back.
Donovan McNabb had way too many injuries and was forced to retire.

Kurt Warner's best game has got to be XXXIV he where he threw 43 passes for 414 yards and 0 INT and two touchdowns.

Donovan McNabb's is 2007 Dolphins vs. Eagles where McNabb played with a sore thumb and Sprained Ankle but still got a passer rating of 138.5

So I think McNabb would win because he was so fast and tough but Kurt would put up a big fight.

Comments

Kurt Warner, Although McNabb is also good. I just feel in the end Warner had more success than McNabb and finished his career stronger as well. - visitor (1/18/2016)