Best Songwriters Everqaz9999
The Top Ten
Freddie's lifetime songwriting output does not equal one good year of Paul McCartney's.
Clever ploy by whoever put this list together, to "split" the Lennon-McCartney votes. This allows someone much less deserving to possibly be at the #1 spot, although either John or Paul should be at the top regardless. It is nice that George Harrison is at least recognized by the list though. Simply put; Lennon-McCartney songs have outsold and out-charted everybody else on this list COMBINED. Paul McCartney himself is the most successful musician of all time, period.
Across The Universe, Rain, Strawberry fields, Walrus, Dear Prudence, Sexy Sadie, Revolution, If I Fell, Your Bird Can sing, This Boy, Lucy In The Skies, A Day In The Life, You're Gonna Lose that Girl, Imagine, All You Need Is Love. He is number one in every sense of the word!
It appears that the vote-splitting is exactly what has happened, but if you combine Lennon/McCartney's percentages they become #1.
Freddie Mercury should in no way, shape, or form, be anywhere near the top ten of this list, though the list itself is poorly done.
Why would anyone split up Jagger/Richards, and where are Holland/Dozier/Holland?
Paul has written over 100 great hits. Nobody can equal him in this respect.
Related ListsTop Ten Best Singer/Songwriters Best Songwriters In Metal Most Influential Songwriters of All Time Top Ten Most Talented Singer/Songwriters Top 10 Greatest Female Singer/Songwriters of All Time
6 years, 160 days old
2. John Lennon - The Beatles
3. Paul McCartney - The Beatles
2. Roger Waters - Pink Floyd
3. Rik Emmet - Triumph