Best Set It Off Songs

The Top Ten
Wolf In Sheep's Clothing

This is the first song of theirs I've ever listened to, and I LOVE it. I know every word. I didn't really like it at first. I thought it sounded kinda weird. But the catchy chorus got stuck in my head, and now it's my favorite song of all time. It should definitely be #1 on this list. Just saying!

Wolf in Sheep's Clothing is the first (and still my favorite) song I've ever heard from Set It Off. When it was recommended to me, I fell in love with it. I listened to a few more of Set It Off's songs, and now I'm a huge fan.

I'll Sleep When I'm Dead

A song that will truly give you chills. About losing the ability to control yourself, this song's lyrics are catchy and very powerful.

A song that people with sleeping problems might like, depending on what music genre you enjoy. Of course, the song is based on insomnia.

Starts off slow but builds up and doesn't let up. By the end, you might experience super goosebumps.

Nightmare

I LOVE this song! This was the first Set It Off song I heard, and I fell in love with it. I know all the lyrics by heart, and I'm conspiring with my friend to do a cover. It is AMAZING!

This song is super catchy. It's like I've never heard any other songs! I have been looking for a perfect song, and now I've found it!

This song really expresses Cody's fear. I love the first verse and the rest of the song as well.

N.M.E.

Such a catchy, upbeat song. I love the bridge and the guitar.

Great song, and I enjoy listening to it in the shower.

Describes perfectly ex-romantic lives, and its spot is more than deserving!

Why Worry

Certainly one of their more catchy songs. The Fall Out Boy influence is incredibly present in this song. Overall, it has an amazing message with meaningful lyrics. This is what music should strive to be.

It's such a catchy song with great lyrics! I love the part where it says, "Why do we insist on crossing bridges that do not exist?" It's also got a bit of that Fall Out Boy feel to it.

I LOVE the idea of the video - so clever and awesome. I thought this song was more mainstream at first, and it made me mad at the band, but I've grown to love it.

Breathe In, Breathe Out
Partners in Crime

Partners in Crime is based on a true story about Bonnie (the girl) and Clyde (the boy). They were looters during the Great Depression and died together after being shot by the police. It is very catchy, and their best song, only behind Wolf in Sheep's Clothing.

This is by far my favorite Set It Off song of all time. They are telling a story, and the melody - oh my god, the singing is great. To me, this is the perfect pop-punk song.

If you want a song with amazing singers and a chilling duet, this song is for you. As soon as you start up the music video, you know Cody is going to rock, and rock he did.

Kill the Lights

Kill the Lights is so good! It should be at the top for sure! The music is so good that I would qualify it as one of the top 5 songs from the band.

My favorite of them all! Such a catchy tune and cool lyrics.

This song has a catchy tune and a deep meaning! I love it!

Killer in the Mirror

Why is this so low on the list?! This song is amazing! The lyrics are great. It's awesome how some parts of the song are quite easygoing while other parts are aggressive. This is the perfect song to play when someone crosses or wrongs you.

Why is this one so underrated? I love this song so much. It has helped me through some tough times. I want to thank them for that.

Really catchy. Both calming and aggressive. It's just by far one of their greatest.

Dream Catcher

This song is definitely one of my favorites. The lyrics are perfect for how this song sounds.

This song makes me smile every time. I can't get over it!

It's a beautiful song and has helped me remember that I shouldn't give up.

The Newcomers

? Hourglass

It sounds amazing, and I truly love the choice of lyrics. It's one of my favorites. I listened to it on repeat at least five times!

This hits hard and sounds great. Highly recommend!

? Skeleton

Every single song in Elsewhere should be so much higher on this list.

The Contenders
This Christmas (I'll Burn It to the Ground)

Even when it's not the Christmas season, I still listen to this song. It's sinister, the instrumental parts are killer, and the way they incorporate little bits and pieces of other well-known Christmas songs is just incredible.

The second verse is genuinely amazing. Cody doing so many different voices and styles is so cool - probably one of my favorite parts of any SIO song. I could listen to it for ages. Literally, one time I kept rewinding to "sneaking through your chimney," and I'm still not tired of it.

I'd Rather Drown

The chorus is by far the best part of this entire song. I think I have goosebumps.

Swan Song

This definitely deserves a higher spot. The sound and tunes are so hyping that I need to dance every time!

The Haunting

I actually found this song yesterday (I started becoming a fan after three weeks. I wasn't one from the beginning), and I love it!

I can't even describe how much I love this song. There's something special about how it's sung.

This song is put together so well. Good luck finding a better song in their entire discography.

Plastic Promises

Honestly, my favorite song. I love the chorus and the story it tells!

This is an amazing song! I love the chorus.

Very catchy and easy to get into, one of the lyrically superior and storytelling songs by Set It Off.

Lonely Dance

This one is underappreciated on this website. I love this song so much because everybody talks about loneliness as a bad thing, but sometimes you need to be alone.

This song is very relatable. It sounds amazing. It has a cool and metaphorical music video.

The song sounds good, and that's mainly all there is to it.

Freak Show

I love this one, but it seems that it has a very sad meaning behind it. But it's great overall!

This song helped me when I thought I was nothing, and it helped me find who I am. Also, it's a catchy song.

I love every part of the song, but the guitar isn't the best.

Hush Hush

I've never heard it before now, but it's very nice.

Horrible Kids

I never get tired of this song and know every word (though I know every word to most of their songs). The only reason it's ranked so low is because it's so hard to rank their amazing music!

Probably biased, but my childhood was very rough. The lyrics hit hard, and the music is good!

So catchy and yet has such an important meaning. I love it.

Midnight Thoughts

I love it so much. I first listened to it and loved it. It's awesome! The entire Midnight album is the best one yet!

I'm just listening to this at night and thinking, "I could be having midnight thoughts."

The Grand Finale

Lyrics that hit extremely hard nowadays. Relatable and really epic.

This is one of those songs that captures a story of fear, and I love it.

This song is just pretty good. Is it about the apocalypse?

Dad's Song

This is such a touching song. I like the more angry and upbeat songs a lot too, but this one is definitely my favorite. It shows the versatility of Set It Off and conveys the feelings of sadness through loss and the way we are affected by the great people in our lives.

This is the most heartwarming song ever. I literally cried because of a song or movie for the first time, thanks to this song.

This song is truly amazing in how much feeling it portrays. It brings me to tears almost every single time.

@Reply

The most catchy song of all! Very true lyrics!

Hypnotized

Best Set It Off song. Something else I like about it, that not many people know, is that it's about a former band member, Austin Kerr.

As soon as I listened to this, I knew it was going to be one of my favorites. And it is.

Bleak December

I listened to this song once and then had to go out on a walk to listen to it over and over just to appreciate it fully. Truly a remarkable song!

This song perfectly blends all of Set It Off's styles into one beautiful piece.

One of the first songs I listened to. Amazing lyrics and a great song!

8Load More
PSearch List