Top 10 Animal Jam Rares

Here are the top ten Animal Jam rares! Please note that this list may not be completely accurate. Also, there is only one of each item in this list. For example, I'm not going to list every color of the beards. Hope you enjoy!
The Top Ten
1 Beta Creature Mask

This is probably the rarest in the game. I wouldn't count unreleased or deleted items as rare. There are none in the game, except for the ones people hack in. People like Batwing157, for example. Green top hats, skullies, mace tails, staffs, and horse coins should not be on this list.

And once more, spike collars are seen like, ALL THE TIME. That drops their rarity, in my opinion. But yes, I agree. Beta creature masks are one of the rarest things in the game.

This is the rarest item in Animal Jam as of 2015, and only 2-3 people have them. Black longs are NOWHERE near the rarest item in the game. YOU CAN GET THEM IN AN ADVENTURE! Green and blue top hats, Skullies, and Alpha healing staffs aren't even released yet, so they can't really be on this list.

2 Pearly Tiara

Rare or not rare, this item can't be found easily around the game, meaning that it's technically a rare.

Man, these are extremely rare!

3 Orange Beard

I have an orange beard, and I did lots of research on it. I found it was worth 4 black longs! I tried to trade for that, but everyone started reporting me for scamming! In my opinion, they are super rare and should be rarer than black longs.

I just traded a rare eyeball hat and a rare spider mask for one. Best trade I ever made. People tell me it's only worth a small beta, but I'm pretty sure it's worth more!

This rare definitely deserves number one! There is only ONE known orange beard in AJ, owned by Visualeffects. The other beards are pretty rare too, but the orange beard is the rarest of them all!

4 Beta Eyeball Hat

Somebody traded me a neon bow, a short yellow spiked collar, nerd glasses, and a New Year's celebration hat (not a party hat).

I don't know what my magenta eyeball is worth. Can someone tell me, please?

I don't know if mine is beta.

5 Headdress

Headdresses are really rare, mainly because only the rare one can be won in Forgotten Desert. Jammers with any type of headdress will most likely only have theirs up on trade to show off. They get attention mostly because they're pretty. Items like glitched rings and eyeball hats aren't nearly as sought-after because it's hard to make a look with them. Headdresses are good items, but I think that they don't deserve #4.

I think this item is very rare because I don't see a lot of people wearing these, especially the rare one. And apparently, these are so rare to be won in the forgotten desert. In fact, I have only seen one person who has won a headdress in the forgotten desert, and that was on YouTube.

Yes, headdresses are very rare, and I really want one. However, I think that they should be maybe in 5th or 6th place because there are much rarer items, like the Magenta furry hat. By the way, if anyone is willing to trade me any headdress for all my trade list and way more, please just search up my user, Littlefoxyloxy. Thank you.

6 Magenta Furry Hat

The Magenta furry hat was sold and immediately taken out of stores. They are the rarest item in the game, besides the Milky Tiara, a white tiara with a pink gemstone.

Magenta Furries are rarer than this. I've seen people trading black longs for these, and the longs are in second. No offense, people, but this list needs updating!

The magenta furry is the rarest item in Animal Jam, next to the beta hood. It is worth 34 to 35 black longs!

7 Black Rare Spike

Tophats, spikes, headdresses...these are all hard to get by means of rarity/quantity/date, but their worth is over-exaggerated by famous AJ YouTubers as well as scammers/traders. Even popularity is what makes these things seem "rare".

Ignore popularity. Focus on quantity. That means the lesser amount of a cosmetic/wearable item there is, the more worth it has because it will be harder to get due to the fact that there won't be any more produced.

Keep your paws away from the spikes...you might cut yourself on that edge, you know.

I love these, but I can never get one. I mean, I see people that have so many, but they won't trade. It just bugs me so much. Can't they spare just one? I have tried a rare claw, rare headdress, short rare spike, and beta floors, but NO one will accept! By the way, my user is madmomogirl (please don't make fun. I have had it since I was 4).

Wow, I totally agree! I saw someone with a trade that was all black rare longs, and she would not trade it for: red rare spike, blue rare spike, rare claw, and (you won't believe this) a FOUNDER! People these days won't accept anything.

8 Founders Hat

The rarity has changed. These have dropped down. I never understood why these were so rare. If they were in the beta days, they only cost 40 gems. Now, though, Scullies only cost about 10 gems, I can see why they are very rare. They were deleted from Animal Jam, so basically, no one has them. But founders, I don't even know how these got to be super rare then dropped down all of a sudden. How does that make sense?

I get it, these possibly were in the beta days. I wasn't in the beta days, so what do I know? There were a lot of beta days items, and for some reason, if this was a beta item, someone randomly decided these should be super rare. Items deleted from the game, in my opinion, should be really rare because there were a lot of items deleted never to be seen again. There are also items like headdresses which are common in the eagle adventure and should not be on the list.

Magnetas, glitched stuff, elf helmets, those are very rare for some reason. I don't know how all these items got their rarity in place in the top tens, but founders are low in rarity right now.

9 Milky White Tiara

These cannot be bought in Jam Mart Clothing. The Milky Tiara is a milk color but with a PURPLE gem. The fake in Jam Mart Clothing has a BLUE gem. I have only seen one in the game. Feel free to add me. I'm lightEningwolf62 (sorry if I have no buddy space or am not accepting). Jam-A-Gram me if you want to, though my inbox is always full. So, just post on my Jammer Wall if you can't buddy or Jam-A-Gram me.

You can buy these in the Jam Mart Clothing Shop.

Very few left in the game!

10 Tan Tiki Mask

Really, 29, 2 places below orange spike! I have one and get offered 20 black longs. Spikes aren't even rare. 1 out of 5 people have it, but nearly no one has beta hoods, tan tikis, magenta furries. Even headdresses are super common. People just think they are pretty :/ This list was made by complete noobs.

I think that this should be higher on this list, at least 5th. I'm not sure how many there are in the game, but you don't see many around at all these days! Most famous YouTubers have them and really rare people!

I totally agree. I have NEVER seen a tiki mask (or I just can't remember >.<) because no one would buy them as they were not very fashionable. Tikis themselves are worth good stuff, but the tan tiki is on a whole new level.

The Contenders
11 Beta Elf Helmet

Only less than 20 exist. Most people consider it in the top 30 for sure.

This should be in the top 10!

12 Horse Coin

I have never seen anyone with a horse coin in my life! I have played AJ since the beta days. I couldn't find it in shops anywhere! But around 2012, they removed it because people scammed items for horse coins. This was because they went crazy about seeing one, so they took a chance, and AJ removed it. Still, they may show on people's trades, which means they had one before they got removed. They are now an item not able to go in dens, just a show item to trade.

I really love horse coins, to be honest! If I ever got one, my head would explode. Also, I think that this and river race should be number 1. Yes, today, I have seen someone with the game river race! It is a very original and cool game!

Horse coins should not be on the list. They're unreleased. Well, they were out for a short time, but they were taken out of the game. They're not an item anymore and shouldn't be on the list.

13 Skullies

Yes, Skullies are truly the rarest items on Animal Jam, simply because they are like necklaces, an item that wasn't used much and was the cheapest in the dress wear items. However, they were highly inappropriate and thus, were removed, unlike our very 'sought-for' necklaces.

In a few years' time, I'm sure necklaces will be as needed as Skullies, but I'm also unsure. The fact that the Skullies were removed due to their 'dirtiness' makes them more rare, and they are barely ever seen. If any jammer had these, they'd probably be taken away, for obvious reasons.

The Skullies are the rarest item in AJ, and I'm sure that their rarity won't die out... Not until pandas are fixated, anyway...

To be honest, Skullies are the rarest, along with the Green Top Hat, which was taken out after Beta Days, right after. Probably no one has either of these greatly desired items. Skullies are probably worth like 10 Beta Blankets, same with Green Top Hat, as it has never been spotted.

14 Cami's Frog

I have a lot of Camis, and I'm never trading them. But I didn't trade much at all for them!

I traded a beta floor I got in eagle adventure for it,
and I got ice Mira with it!

I love Camis, the one item that has a story!

So rare, I've been trying forever to get one. I offered four spiked collars, and the person declined. So, they should be before spiked collars on this list.

I used to have one. It was a part of my non-member apocalypse stockpile.

15 Alpha Healing Staff

Only about 2 people have this! Wootmoo and a couple of other VERY rare players, also the hacker X I think. These are worth more than 12 black longs because they are VERY VERY RARE! I'd say almost as rare as a tan tiki, which should be first on the list while this should be second...

Never seen one in my life, except on a YouTube video. Search up on YouTube: Animal Jam Unreleased Items.

I've never even HEARD of this before. It should be at the very top.

16 Beta Tiara

I have the white one with an emerald diamond thingy. People said I was trying to scam. Why would I want to scam pixels? But, I KNOW it is the Beta one, and no one can stop me from asking for offers. If I think it is fair, I will accept. And then someone would say, "SHE SCAMMED (scammed, but you can't say scammed) ME! I TRADED 4 BLACK LONGS!"

This tiara looks much like the one sold today. Many people mistake this rare for the common one sold in stores today, but it is much rarer. It comes in green and white, with white being the rarer of the two.

They should try to sell it for one day, then see. They are worth a lot too and should not be in stores because their value will be as bad as a necklace. Whoever traded for one would lose a lot.

17 Beta Arctic Hood

I have one, and nobody wants it! People try to trick me by trading old hoods for it. But I'm just like: I have a brain. I'm not stupid! Anyway, I have a blue-ish one. Any den or clothing beta for it, my username is Rainbowkittens1015. (Subscribe to me on YouTube! I love my subbies, and I'm on Facebook @ Rainbowkittens AJ on YouTube and Facebook) =D

Only about 30 in the game. Should be number 6, not 25.

I had one, but I got traded a rare orange spike for it. I should have declined lexib07.

18 Spikes

I have played Animal Jam since 2011, and I still haven't got a spike. It's my only goal. (No, I don't just play for the items.) I have attempted to trade something for a spike about 700 times. There are people with like 10 spikes, and I ask them if I can trade it for four nice, rare, beta items and their response is always, NO. So selfish... You won't trade 1 spike to someone who has none and is offering their best items. This has happened numerous times to me.

To sum this all up, spikes are EXTREMELY high in demand and are VERY challenging to obtain. My user is miahappyheart.

Spikes are another high-demand rare. There are three types of spikes, including the long spike, the spiked wristband, and the diamond shop spikes. The diamond shop spikes are not as rare as the other two types. Spikes are another popular rare like the headdress that everyone thinks are super rare. They aren't THAT rare, but the spike earned a place on my top ten list.

19 Light Purple Gazelle Horns

Coming in second place for this top ten list would have to be the light purple gazelle horns! There are many other types of gazelle horns, like the rare gazelle horns and scary antlers, but the light purple gazelle horns are coming in second in this list, with only 2-3 people known to have them.

They are in stores now.

20 Creature Mask

Tiki masks are not rare at all. I have one, a white one. But they come out every year. Only the BETA creature mask is rare. It's black with dark blue eyes. No offense, but I think a lot of these items are in the wrong places. The headdress is NOT of lower value than a spike.

Just wait for Halloween. You could get one then. You can also get them in adventures. So yeah, not so rare. I was excited when I got an actual rare creature mask, but then I got hacked, so that was gone.

In third is the creature mask! There are many colors of this mask, but the rarest is the black one with blue eyes.

21 Wood Flooring

I used to have wood flooring. I think you can get those in the eagle adventure since I got brick walls and a beta flower carpet from it. I'm not saying you can get it just like that. I'm saying that you can give it a shot, though.

Coming in sixth is the wood flooring! The wood flooring is high in demand for non-members because it is the only non-member flooring in aj! This flooring is uncommon, and you probably won't see it too often.

I love the way the wood flooring looks. I'm a non-member, and it is my dream item. Sadly, I don't know what it's worth. I traded someone two fox hats for it, and they declined. *Facepalm*

22 Glitched Brown Cupid Wings

From people recycling them, not many are left!

23 Rare Fox Hat

Fox hats are rare, but this shouldn't be in seventh place. People these days don't always know their rarities, and I totally understand. All I'm saying is that fox hats are nowhere near the rarest thing in Animal Jam. In fact, a beta eyeball is one of the rarest things of all! This top tens list is incorrect, no offense. These items are nowhere near the rarest, not even a spike. And yes, a lot of people in Animal Jam have these.

I'm not putting the rarest things in order, but the rarest things are elf tail armor, magenta hat, glitches ring, milky tiara, and a beta eyeball. Trust me! No offense that this list is incorrect!

I don't think the rare fox hat is THAT rare because I have all the colors except dark orange (the least rare color), light blue, and dark blue. I have all the other colors, including red (the rarest color). They are not worth spikes but are still very rare.

Uh-oh, I had a white fox hat, then I traded it for a peach one, and in the end, I traded it for an orange one.

Anyways, someone gave me a tan carpet for a fox hat once! They rock!

24 Rare Headdress

This, in my opinion, is the rarest! Please comment what you think.

Is this a good rare?

25 Moon Dirt

I have never heard of moon dirt, but I know for sure a non-rare headdress is the rarest thing. It's true.

I know that I don't know how rare moon dirt is, but I know for a fact headdresses are rarer.

Moon dirt is a very rare flooring for dens, sold in the beta times of AJ. This is probably the rarest flooring in Animal Jam. If you have one, I recommend you keep it!

In my opinion, it's the rarest item. You heard me, THE rarest item. If you have one, do not trade it.

8Load More
PSearch List