Best Phantoms In Phantom of the Opera


The Top TenXW

1Ramin Karimloo

Ramin is totally the best! Well, maybe that's because I haven't seen Michael Crawford yet. Anyways, Ramin has that seductive touch, even with a hideous face, something that the Phantom SHOULD have. His voice is incredible as well, angelic, and a little demon-like scary when offended, like Phantom. His acting is also off the charts! He can shift from abusive to soft, from angelic to mean. He is totally BADASS. Plus, his voice fits the role perfectly, something that has a hypnotic quality that can actually bend the listener to his will- another noticeable characteristic of the Phantom. He is without a doubt the best so far. Scratch everything I've said- Ramin is Phantom. :))

I've only been able to watch Ramin Karimloo on DVD and you tube, but I have to agree that he is the best Phantom out there, toppling even Michael Crawford. Crawford gives a classical, stylized performance, while Ramin definitely delivers the emotion, which coupled with an amazing voice, really makes you believe he IS the Phantom. Perhaps too, I am speculating that Ramin's success is partly due to the fact that he is the only performer compared to the others who has aspired to be the Phantom since childhood. I read that he skipped school and saw the Phantom at age 12, and life changed ever since. Gerard Butler delivers a brave, anguished performance, however his voice simply pales in comparison to Ramin.

I have never seen Ramin live but I still believe that he is by far the greatest Phantom. The only times I've seen him as the Phantom was on Netflix and YouTube! Every single time he sings I get the chills. His singing is spectacular and perfect for the role. He gets into character so well, building so much chemistry with his costars, and just giving me goosebumps. His acting is also superb and he can become the phantom so well whether it be soft or harsh. I don't think any other Phantom will bring me to tears and with that I give Ramin my vote.

He is perfect. Not more to say.

V32 Comments
2Michael Crawford

He is the phantom I listened to when I was little, and he just is phantom! He portrays so much emotion in his voice and is just fabulous! He and Sarah were the dynamic duo, and I personally think he is better than Ramin!

The Original. They went through 1 other Phantom and I can see why. For the same reason Sarah Brightman is number 1 on this site I feel Michael should be too, in my opinion he out shined even Sarah

I saw him first, and no one else comes close to his riveting, heart rending portrayal. He didn't just play the phantom, he WAS the phantom.

The best phantom singer above all others!

V16 Comments
3John Owen Jones

One of the most beautiful voices to ever play the Phantom - no one can compare to him in theatricality.

In think everybody in the theatre stopped breathing when he hit "that note". Amazing!

Best phantom by far.

V5 Comments
4Colm Wilkinson

To me, Wilkinson's amazing voice is the one that truly captured the complexity of the Phantom.

The first and the one with the most beautiful voice

Easily the best. That voice!

V4 Comments
5Hugh Panaro

He's the first and only Phantom that I've seen on Broadway, ans his voice is just fantastic. He nearly brought me to tears when he sang The Music of the Night. I think that he's so much better than Ramin Karimloo, Michael Crawford, and Colm Wilkonson. He also portrays the Phantom with perfect wit and sarcasm.

In my opion he is really good and made a standout performance

6Anthony Warlow

Sublime. His portrayal absorbs you into the performance with power and strength along with softness and emotion. The word brilliant isn't strong enough.

I have heard others but know one else comes close to Anthony Warlow

The ultimate phantom of the opera!

7John Cudia

He was my first Raoul and second phantom. So awesome. God bless john

8Norm Lewis

His exceptional baritone voice gives the character an even more vivid depth

Loved Norm as the phantom

What a voice! Inspiring.

9Robert Guillaume
10Gerard Butler

He was the phantom, his eyes showed the pain and loneliness that the phantom felt of being an outcast for his looks, and the love he felt for Christine, his voice was amazing, its not perfect but that's good. It made me feel the pain and sorrow of the phantom and he made me feel like I was in the movie

He did just as well without as much training as some of the others. He was raw which is perfect for the role and it was as if you could feel the agony and want and lust and everything through his voice.

Gerard should be top 5. The move wasn't great but Gerard was fantastic. He played it perfectly. His voice, he was dark yet emotional and just perfect for the role.

I think that Gerard Butler showed when he was singing that he really loved Christine.

V8 Comments

The Newcomers

?Geronimo Rauch
?James Barbour

He is the first phantom I ever saw, but he is wonderful.

BAdd New Item

The Contenders

11Peter Jöback

Peter have the most unusual voice of the Phantom's, he dosen't sound like all the others. He also have a level of passion that all the other seems to lack.

He's the all time best with emotion and pation plus he as an amazing voice in all he uplayed all the phantoms at the 25th anniversary grand finally, also he had the only voice that popped out when they all sung together.

12Anthony Crivello
13Brent Barrett
14Peter Karrie

Peter Karrie is, without question, the best Phantom ever.

15Gary Mauer

The most underrated phantom. His clarity is stunning and his highest notes seem effortless. I get chills every time.

16Ben Lewis

Ben Lewis is amazing! I'm not saying he's the best but he is at least number 3! Have any of you seen him in Love Never Dies! He has an amazing voice and just like Ramin, he can be strong and sexy and times, but also weak when the phantom should be weak.

17Earl Carpenter

Guys, you are putting everyone else first mainly for their voice. Earl really gets into the essence of the character. He is so gently with every Christine he plays, it is beautiful.

18Davis Gaines

Davis Gaines if by far my favorite phantom. His voice is perfect for the roll and is stunning. Wish I could have been there to see it/

19Cooper Grodin

Cooper Grodin's Phantom is not only sexy, but tortured as he sings and acts out his love for Christine whom he needs for his music. Cooper's voice in "Music of the Night", and duets with Christine on "Point of Return", and "Angel of Music", knocked me out of my seat! He plays Phantom with a feeling and depth that reach right into your heart so you find yourself rooting for him to get the girl. His performance is that heart rendering and touching.

I just saw Cooper Grodin in Boston on Opening Night, and his voice truly took my breath away. There is this velvety nuance in his voice that strikes a chord with me. I have scoured the other recorded versions of this musical, and as wonderful as the other Phantoms have been, I truly prefer Grodin's voice over the rest.

Phantom for the West End Production. Saw him in Chicago. Cooper is marvelous! Especially impressed since he stepped in after the original Phantom left the production. I fell in love with his voice right after "Music of the Night." Truly portrays the "Angel of Music" perfectly.

One of the best Phantoms I have seen! And I've seen this play 14 times. So touching and yet so forceful. Touched my heart throughout his performance! His voice and his range were beautiful! Brought me to tears!

V21 Comments
20Rob Guest
BAdd New Item

Related Lists

Best Christine in Phantom of the Opera Most Beautiful Songs from the Phantom of the Opera and Love Never Dies Best Things About the Phantom In The Phantom of the Opera Top Ten Greatest Female Opera Singers Best Songs from Queen's "A Night at the Opera"

List StatsUpdated 13 Oct 2015

300 votes
24 listings
2 years, 245 days old

Top Remixes (4)

1. Ramin Karimloo
2. Michael Crawford
3. Colm Wilkinson
1. Ramin Karimloo
2. Norm Lewis
3. Peter Jöback
1. Michael Crawford
2. Ramin Karimloo
3. John Owen Jones

View All 4


Add Post

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.