Top 10 Favorite Creepypasta Characters

Ever have a favorite creepypasta character? Here are your results.
The Top Ten
Ben Drowned BEN Drowned is a creepypasta character created by Jadusable. BEN is said to have died by drowing and haunts a Majora's Mask cartridge.
Slenderman The Slender Man is a fictional supernatural character that originated as an Internet meme created by Something Awful forums user Eric Knudsen

One of the scariest characters of the age of the internet! Amazing job to the person who managed to think of such a terrifying thing!

I don't know which Creepypasta I first encountered - Slenderman or Jeff the Killer - but heck, he's awesome! Even the game freaks you out.

He is so scary. When you meet him, he makes you go insane.

Ticci Toby Tobias Erin "Toby" Rogers, also known as Ticci-Toby, is the titular protagonist of the now-removed Creepypasta story of the same name, created by Kastoway (also known as GrisGrisDoll)... read more

Toby's story is full of misfortune, and although it has its fictional aspects, the abusive father and tics are very much real and make this character so much more interesting. He will (most likely) forever be my favorite character.

Ticci Toby is my favorite Creepypasta. He had the best story, and he is strong. I like how he uses his dad's axes to kill people. It is just interesting, I guess. I just really like his character. But I am not, I repeat, not a fangirl. I like Ticci, but I know he is not real and that he is made up.

Laughing Jack Laughing Jack is the titular main antagonist of the Creepypasta story of the same name. He is a sadistic killer clown who was originally an imaginary friend to a little boy. That is until the boy forgot about him. Follow his story through being made, forgotten, and becoming a sadistic killer clown,... read more

I love his backstory. It just makes him more terrifying and awesome. I mean, he was abandoned by his owner, Isaac. Once a playmate to him and a colorful, happy clown, Laughing Jack was what every child wanted. But when Isaac abandoned him, his color drained away, leaving a monochrome clown determined to give poisonous candy out to all the waiting boys and girls. Who could beat that?

His backstory is very interesting. He's also a very cool Creepypasta. He's my favorite next to Jeff the Killer. I can't choose between the two of them.

Jeff the Killer Jeff the Killer is a creepypasta usually accompanied by a picture of a white face looking in to the camera smiling in an unsettling manner. The creepypasta is also usually accompanied by the term "Go to sleep".

The story was very well written. However, in certain parts, it feels unrealistic. While the idea of someone getting their face and eyelids burned off, as well as carving a smile into their face and killing their family, is utterly terrifying, it doesn't scare me very much because I don't feel like it could be real. The scariest things are the ones we can relate to.

I think Jeff the Killer's backstory is completely unique, and the thought of cutting your mouth into a permanent smile and/or burning off your eyelids can be terrifying. I love him.

Smile Dog "Smile Dog" is a story about a cursed image file. The image shows a large German Shepard or Husky dog that is smiling.
Eyeless Jack

He is my number one favorite Creepypasta. I feel sad about how he became one.

He's truly one of a kind. I love how he doesn't care what people think.

Sally

I really like Sally. Her childhood was terrible and sad, and I find her story unique compared to the rest of the Creepypastas. And the fact that she's adorable makes her even more interesting.

She's so adorable, but why is her uncle such a monster?

She is my child because she's so cute. She just wants someone to play with.

The Rake

I remember the first time I read this one (shivers). A must-read for those looking for a good scary story, without a doubt.

Seed Eater

The Newcomers

? Bloodshot Travis

Bloodshot Travis is personally my favorite creepypasta. I love his design, and his story is underrated.

? Austin/Corrupted Mii

Austin is Eteled's rival. I love that he's like a robot/Mii hybrid, and his design is badass. Plus, he's a glitched Mii, which is pretty cool.

The Contenders
Judge Angels
Jane the Killer Jane the killer is the main character of the creepypasta story Jane the Killer: The real Story. She is know to be a rival to the creepypasta Jeff the Killer.

Jane The Killer is my favorite because her backstory didn't deal with her first being a killer, but an ordinary person who just ended up being in the wrong place at the right time. Also, in my opinion, she's more like an Avenger than a psychopath. She's like an anti-hero, and a hot one at that.

Jane The Killer is my favorite Creepypasta. I also ship her with Jeff. I mean, Jeff loves her. That's why he did that to her because he wanted her to be just like him. Who knows? Maybe Jeff did have a crush on Jane.

Mr. Widemouth
Zalgo Zalgo is an Internet legend about an ominous entity believed to cause insanity, death and destruction of the world, similar to the creature Cthulhu created by H.P. Lovecraft in the 1920s. Zalgo is often associated with scrambled text on webpages and photos of people whose eyes and mouth have been covered... read more
Homicidal Liu

I like Liu the most because of his split personality, which makes him unpredictable. He can go from being kind and gentle to being a mass murderer. Liu also loves his brother and will do anything for him. He will stop at nothing to get his brother back, blindly following him around, which is dangerous for anyone who comes across him.

The Bloody Painter

I love his story and how he looks.

Sonic.exe Sonic EXE., also known as Sonic exe, is an alleged cursed version and format of the classic game Sonic The Hedgehog. The original story is about a teenage boy named Tommy or simply Tom who suffers supernatural delusions and hallucinations.

Coolest Creepypasta character ever!

Jason the Toymaker

Why doesn't anyone know about him?

Clockwork

Clockwork is my personal favorite because her story is the only one that has ever scared me. After I read it, I was constantly looking over my shoulder in the dark for a green light.

I don't get why so many people hate Clocky. She's a decent character with a flawed story, just like most of them.

I voted for Clockwork because she is beautiful like Jeff and awesome.

Tails Doll

This one is scary as hell! If this were to fight with The Rake, I bet it would win.

The Puppeteer
Masky
W. D. Gaster
Herobrine Herobrine (Pronounced HEH-roh-bryn) is the subject of a community-made creepypasta. He is one of the major community icons of Minecraft, yet Herobrine has not been present in any version of Minecraft... read more

Okay, Herobrine isn't that scary, I get that. But he is most certainly iconic. He himself doesn't scare me, but his story is mysterious, and my favorite type of story is when the character is portrayed as a virus or something that existed before. Read Herobrine's story. Mojang always adds "Herobrine removed" into their updates, and Notch claims to have had a brother who was Herobrine. There are so many mysterious sightings that it's hard to tell if it's fake or not.

Now, with these other Minecraft beasts (Null, Dreadlord...) and even the hacker that claims he's "the new Herobrine," I disagree. If he was Notch's brother, that means he has commands. He could've taken on anyone in the Minecraft world. He's gotten so famous that he had his little spotlight in Minecon too. Good job, whoever created Herobrine...

Lost Silver

For a kid who doesn't have arms, he's pretty strong and pretty darn scary.

8Load More
PSearch List