Top Ten Best Metal Lyricists

The Top Ten

James Hetfield - Metallica

James Alan Hetfield was born on August 3, 1963. He is an American musician, singer, and songwriter known for being the co-founder, lead vocalist, rhythm guitarist, and main songwriter for the American thrash metal band Metallica. He helped form the iconic thrash metal group in 1981 after answering... read more

From 'Ride the Lightning' up to and including the 'Black' album, James, as a very young man, penned some of the most poignant and poetic lyrics any metal musician has ever concocted. From capital punishment, child abuse, corruption, perception, addiction, and religion, the master did it all.
Even the great Maynard James Keenan has acknowledged how great Metallica's first five albums are. People consider Hetfield a drunkard, but despite his issues with the drink, he spoke for a generation of kids, as a kid, for a decade. I was barely learning how to talk to a girl while this genius was busy critiquing the world.

He's my favorite, but I'm surprised that Geezer Butler isn't in the top 10. He did write a substantial portion of Ozzy's lyrics in Black Sabbath.
DIO - Rainbow

Dio didn't write lyrics, he wrote poetry and poetic philosophy.
"For every moment of truth, there's confusion in life" (Heaven and Hell, Black Sabbath)
"Don't write in starlight 'Cause the words may come out real Don't hide in doorways You may find the key that opens up your soul Don't go to Heaven 'cause it's really only Hell Don't smell the flowers They're an evil drug to make you lose your mind" (Don't Talk to Strangers, Dio)

"They say that life's a carousel, spinning fast, you gotta ride it well!
The world is full of kings and queens who blind your eyes and steal your dreams, it's Heaven and Hell!
And they'll tell you black is really white, the moon is just the sun at night, and when you walk in golden halls, you get to keep the gold that falls, it's Heaven and Hell!"
Geezer Butler

Terence Michael Joseph "Geezer" Butler is an English musician and songwriter. He is best known as the bassist and primary lyricist for the pioneering heavy metal band Black Sabbath. Butler's lyrics often explored themes of religion, politics, and fantasy, helping to define the band's dark and brooding... read more

"Generals gathered in their masses, just like witches at black masses." - War Pigs
"The blood runs free, the rain turns red, give me the wine, you keep the bread." - God Is Dead?

He wrote pretty much every song before Dio entered the band.

Main lyricist in Black Sabbath. Do I need to say anymore?
Dave Mustaine - Megadeth

David Scott "Dave" Mustaine (born September 13, 1961) is an American musician, singer, songwriter, actor, and author. He was the original lead guitarist of Metallica before being dismissed in 1983. Afterward, he formed the band Megadeth, where he became the lead vocalist and primary creative force.... read more

Just look at "My Last Words." He should be at the top of the list.

The most politically and socially aware lyricist, much better than the ones above him on this list.
Steve Harris - Iron Maiden

Stephen Percy "Steve" Harris is an English musician and songwriter best known as the bassist, occasional keyboardist, backing vocalist, primary songwriter, and founder of the British heavy metal band Iron Maiden. He's led the band since its formation in 1975. Outside of his legendary work with Maiden... read more

Listen to anything from the 80s. He is the best lyricist in the band, but sometimes he wrote questionable songs like From Here to Eternity and The Angel and the Gambler. Iron Maiden's lyrics and musical style would be nothing without Steve. He deserves more recognition than Hetfield, whose lyrics nowadays are dry, plain, and uninspired.

Very amazing lyricist. Try "Hallowed Be Thy Name," "Dance of Death," "The Final Frontier," "When the Wild Wind Blows," and other great lyrics written by Steve Harris.

Top 3 are Harris, Hetfield, and Mustaine.
Chuck Schuldiner - Death

Charles Michael "Chuck" Schuldiner (1967-2001) was an American guitarist, singer, and songwriter. He was the founder and leader of Death, a band widely considered one of the pioneers of the death metal genre. Schuldiner died from brain cancer on December 13, 2001, and is often referred to as the "Godfather... read more

Very amazing lyrics about society and humans. He is my favorite lyricist. Try "The Flesh and the Power It Holds," "Crystal Mountain," "Empty Words," "Symbolic," "0 Tolerance," "Lack of Comprehension," and "Suicide Machine."

Lyrics were deep and meaningful. Every word meant something and contributed to the story perfectly.

The album "Symbolic" has the best lyrics in all of extreme metal.
Hansi Kürsch - Blind Guardian

Hansi Kürsch (born Hans Jürgen Kürsch on August 10, 1966) is the lead singer, lyricist, co-composer, and former bassist of the German power metal band Blind Guardian. He has cited Freddie Mercury as a major influence and often creates rich, overlapping choir effects by overdubbing his own voice multiple... read more

Some of the most intelligent lyrics out there. Dark, hopeless, or aggressive, Hansi's lyrics always create vivid images in your mind, strong emotions, or unexpected turns and different viewpoints.
He wrote the lyrics to 12 albums: 10 with Blind Guardian and 2 with Demons & Wizards. His early lyrics for Blind Guardian were aggressive and violent, while his later lyrics were reminiscent of Dio's fantasy style. Lyrics for Demons & Wizards focused more on personal struggles, fears, painful memories, depression, and unhappy life events (death, suicide, baby born with Down Syndrome).
"Nightfall quietly crept in and changed us all" (Nightfall / Blind Guardian)
"Taste no evil, touch no evil... All I think and feel is evil" (My Last Sunrise / Demons & Wizards)
"When the moon child is crying and silence has broken the darkest truth" (Time What Is Time / Blind Guardian).
Mikael Akerfeldt - Opeth, Bloodbath

Lars Mikael Åkerfeldt is a Swedish musician best known as the lead vocalist, guitarist, and primary songwriter of the progressive metal band Opeth. He was also a vocalist for the death metal supergroup Bloodbath, contributing to three albums before leaving the band in 2012.... read more

He writes beautiful lyrics about nature, relationships, life, and inner struggles with Opeth.
David Draiman - Disturbed
Andrew Schwab - Project 86

The Newcomers

?
Scott Ian

Scott Ian is an American musician, best known as the rhythm guitarist, backing and occasional lead vocalist, and the only remaining original founding member of the thrash metal band Anthrax. He is also the band's primary lyricist. In addition to his work with Anthrax, Ian has been involved in other... read more
?
Lacey Sturm

Lacey Nicole Sturm, born Lacey Mosley on September 4, 1981, is an American singer and songwriter originally from Homestead, Florida. She was raised in Arlington, Texas, and became known as the co-founder and lead vocalist of the alternative rock band Flyleaf... read more

The Contenders

Till Lindemann - Rammstein

Till Lindemann is a German singer, songwriter, musician, actor, poet, and pyrotechnician. He is best known as the lead vocalist and frontman of the German Neue Deutsche Härte band Rammstein. Lindemann is also known for his solo work and his provocative, theatrical performance style.

There are probably very few visitors to this website who understand his German lyrics. Being German, I'm amazed by his often allegorical lyrics. "Reise, Reise" and "Deutschland" are great examples of his songwriting.
Tobias Sammet - Edguy

Tobias Sammet (born November 21, 1977) is a German metal musician, songwriter, and producer best known as the vocalist and primary songwriter for the power metal band Edguy. He is also the founder, lead singer, and principal creative force behind the metal opera project Avantasia.... read more

Very rich vocabulary, despite English not being his mother tongue.
My favorite lyrics (not typical for him - it's a bonus track):
"Vienna has got Mozart Chopin they had in Paris (kind of) The Catholics got the Pope England's got the Beatles And even more so: England's got Steve Harris England's got Steve Harris And if that wasn't enough for you England's got Bruce Dickinson And on top of it - the other ones In Iron Maiden too, yes it's true" (Edguy - England, 2014, bonus track).
Aaron Lewis

Aaron Lewis is an American musician who is the lead vocalist, rhythm guitarist, and founding member of the rock group Staind. With the band, he has released seven studio albums, and he has also pursued a solo country music career, releasing albums such as Town Line and Sinner.... read more
Jon Schaffer - Iced Earth

Jon Ryan Schaffer is an American heavy metal musician best known as the guitarist and only remaining original member of the Florida-based band Iced Earth. He formed the band in 1985 under the name Purgatory. Schaffer has remained the group's principal songwriter and driving force throughout its history... read more
M. Shadows - Avenged Sevenfold

Matthew Charles Sanders, better known by his stage name M. Shadows, is an American musician best known as the lead vocalist, songwriter, and founding member of the heavy metal band Avenged Sevenfold. He is recognized for his versatile vocal range and for helping to shape the band's evolving sound, which... read more
Ville Valo - HIM

Ville Hermanni Valo is a Finnish singer-songwriter and multi-instrumentalist. He is best known as the lead vocalist and main songwriter of the gothic rock band HIM, which was active from 1991 to 2017. In 2023, Valo released his debut solo album Neon Noir under the moniker VV.
Ronnie Radke - Falling In Reverse

Ronald Joseph Radke is an American singer, songwriter, rapper, musician, and record producer from Las Vegas, Nevada. He is best known as the lead vocalist of the rock band Falling in Reverse... read more
Maynard James Keenan - Tool

Maynard James Keenan, often referred to by his initials MJK, is an American musician, record producer, winemaker, and actor. He is best known as the vocalist for the Grammy Award-winning progressive metal band Tool.
Keenan is also the lead singer of the bands A Perfect Circle and Puscifer, which... read more

"But enough about the collective Judas, who could deny you were the one who illuminated your little piece of the divine."
Maynard should be celebrated along with Whitman.

As below, so above I imagine. Drawn outside the lines of reason. Push the envelope, watch it bend.
An amazing lyricist with a powerful voice backing it.

Anyone who knows anything about writing will tell you how good Maynard is as a lyricist.
Tom Araya - Slayer

Tomás Enrique "Tom" Araya Díaz is a Chilean-American musician best known as the bassist and vocalist of the American thrash metal band Slayer. He joined Slayer in 1981, remained with the band until its farewell tour concluded in 2019, and returned for reunion performances beginning in 2024. Araya is... read more

"Skeletons of Society" has great lyrics. I noticed that the initial letters of the words of the title read together as SOS (distress signal).
Corey Taylor - Slipknot, Stone Sour

Corey Todd Taylor was born on December 8, 1973. He is an American musician, author, and actor best known as the lead singer and lyricist of the nu-metal band Slipknot and the hard rock/alternative metal band Stone Sour. Taylor has also published books and appeared in films and on television.... read more

Stone Sour and Slipknot lyrics can be felt when they're said. Whether it's the emotional rage of Iowa, or any individual song, Corey has a writing style like no other.
From something sad like Bother to something enraged like Heretic Anthem. Not to mention his huge vocal range, the second biggest in popular music.
Jeff Waters - Annihilator

Jeff Waters (born February 13, 1966) is a Canadian metal musician best known as the guitarist, primary songwriter, bandleader, and founder of the metal band Annihilator. He's recognized for his fast riffs and solos and has frequently taken on roles as lead singer, bass player, engineer, and producer... read more
Dani Filth - Cradle Of Filth

Daniel Lloyd Davey (born 25 July 1973), known professionally as Dani Filth, is an English singer, songwriter, and the lead vocalist of the extreme metal band Cradle of Filth, which he co-founded. He is renowned for his unique vocal style, which features high-pitched screams and a wide range. In 2011... read more

Honestly, I feel that Dani Filth should be at the very top of the list. He has a very high intellectual ability when it comes to writing poetry. I feel that he has the most complex writing ability of anyone in the metal music industry.

Dani Filth is the best lyricist I've ever heard, better than all metal, hip hop, or poetry writers I've ever heard. The way he delivers the gothic stories, the imagery, and the complexity in his poetry is just perfect!

Dani Filth is number 1, and it's not even close. There are two classes of lyrics in rock/metal: Dani Filth and everyone else. Period. He is a god of word usage.
Henrik Fevre - Anubis Gate

Great singer and lyricist who writes pure emotions! Once you hear it, you will be addicted.

Fantastic lyricist! One of the best out there.
Randy Blythe - Lamb of God

David Randall "Randy" Blythe is the vocalist and lyricist of the American heavy metal band Lamb of God. He is also involved in the side project Halo of Locusts. Blythe is known for his intense vocal style and dynamic stage presence.

Very amazing lyricist. I think he is the only lyricist who can come up with double-meaning songs and sometimes hidden meanings. Try "11th Hour," "Omerta," "Laid to Rest," "Walk with Me in Hell," "Descending," "Ghost Walking," "Hourglass," and "Vigil." (Some people view "Vigil" as an anti-Christian song, but look deep and you will find it is about the Iraq War, politics, and George W. Bush.)
Alice Cooper

Alice Cooper is an American singer, songwriter, musician, and occasional actor whose career spans more than six decades. Known for his distinctive raspy voice and theatrical stage shows, Cooper is often referred to as the Godfather of Shock Rock. He was inducted into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame in... read more