Top Ten Most Overrated AthletesIt's not that they aren't great players, they just aren't everything we've been led to believe.
The Top Ten
Totally overrated. He was a fine player but come on, he never had any superstar runs like they said of him as. He couldn't play like pele or any dominant soccer superstar. Compare him to the soccer legends and living legends like Messi'. Beckham doesn't stand a chance against anyone in legacy or greatness. - NBASuperstar35
Saw an article in People magazine that mentioned him, his epitaph was "king of soccer. " I'm sorry, but from the games I've seen, while he's a decent player, he is not among the best, and is FAR from being "king. " He's had 17 international goals, which isn't shabby, but then there's Messi who has had 32 international goals, and doesn't allow himself to be bought and sold amongst teams. He's filthy rich and dated an American pop singer, so I can see where the affinity comes from, but at the end of the day he's an average player, and it upsets me that anyone would think to call him the king of soccer. PSG would be fine without him.
His goal/game ratio for England is appalling, Argentina was the only big team he scored against with a lucky penalty. Lucky because he missed his next three, against Turkey in 2004 Euro Qualifying, then France/Portugal in the Finals. Real Madrids worst period for years happened after he joined them. They didn't qualify for the Champions League knockout stage whilst he was there. He only got a LaLiga medal because Reyes scored a lot of goals whilst he didn't play. Then went to PSG because Leonardo must have been in love with him, even the French fans voiced their displeasure.
Not really a goal scorer, but he was hella good at free kicks and assists. - thomwimV 38 Comments
He's awesome! Why is he on here? - Alpha101
Shaq Daddy is a 7'1", 325 pound dunk machine. In the paint he is an absolute beast, but outside of seven feet he is all but worthless. We all know of his free throw woes over the years. And don't tell me about how big his hands are compared to the ball. All NBA players have large hands. Shaq has hit less then 3 game winning shots in his career and can't shoot free throws. So in a close game in the fourth quarter he is more of a liability then an asset. He has never won a championship without a superstar guard to compliment his game.
Shaq is legit, he was good with his skill set. Sure he could have built a city with all them bricks at the free throw line but he knew his strengths and maximised them. He ain't top 10 in scoring for being a chump.
Terrible at three pointers. - thomwimV 8 Comments
So overhyped. Famous for her long drives but not even close to being number one on the tour - and what is the difference if you can drive the ball a mile but it doesn't go where you want it. Like the pilot to the passengers good news and bad - the bad news is that we are lost - the good news is we are making good time. After the win at the 2014 open she goes on tour to all the shows - hasn't come close to winning again - probably should have stayed home and work on her game. Finally, she always seems to have an excuse why things don't go well. Hip problem, ankle injury, bee sting, heat exhaustion, wrist injury - should include fading talent. It's very possible that, with the current talent on the tour, she may never win again. But the sponsors still line up.
Michelle Wie is famous because of her age and the fact she can hit the golf ball an impressive distance. People followed her the first few years because she could hit it as far or farther than many men (not all women are weaklings some are quite strong) That is indeed impressive but other than distance she has proven nothing. I have no problem with her competing against the men if she chooses but wouldn't it make sense to actually win a few tournaments against other women before you do that. - hardrockfanatic
Definitely M Wie is overrated. There any number of female golfers who have outplayed her over the course of her career. I also think there are a number of golfers who, given the huge advantages the MW has been given, could have played just as well if not better. I think that one of the biggest problems with MW is has been that she has never been in full control of her game, there has always a team of people with her even when she was an amateur. Watch what happens when she gets in trouble on a hole, it takes her forever to figure it out what to do and usually her caddy has to be the one to decide and take the blame if it doesn't work.
I'm sorry but who? I'm not the golfing person here but #2? - htoutlaws2012V 4 Comments
Surprising to see pele at number 2... I mean, have you ever seen a more self-professed legend ever laugh out loud! He should be ahead right at no. 1 on this list... Agree to most of the comments about him about him playing in the days when soccer was not of as high a quality as what it became late - oldcorsair20
I think Pele was the best footballer of his time but he is for sure not the best footballer of all time. All of these guys (Zinedine Zidane, Lionel Messi, Cristiano Ronaldo, Ronaldinho, Johan Cruyff), they were professional footballers when the level of football was too high. Also, all of these played in great clubs like Barcelona, Manchester United, Real Madrid, something Pele didn't. Pele was part of Santos a team where you can make the difference if you have a talent. Just overrated!
Definitely... This guy is extremely jealous of Maradona's popularity among football fans all over the world... Always coming to hide under the protection of the all mighty and all corrupted FIFA organization
He was a very good player. But there are other footballers who have better technique. More skills. - zxmV 41 Comments
This is overrated athletes, not annoying celebrities/athletes, if you base off what he thinks of himself, yes he is over rated. But if you base off what people say about him, he isn't. He is an amazing athlete, or was in his prime, but he shouldn't be on this list. And shaq isn't over rated. He isn't the best of all time (no one said he was) but he is an amazing player. People are just jealous of the fact that he was born big.
All talk. If it wasn't for his attitude and drugs maybe he wouldn't have made it on this list, but an athlete's most important body part is his brain, followed by his heart, and then his other muscles. TO is KO'd.
This guy is a loser who has nothing to do but dump popcorn on his face & show off! He annoys me so badly... I'm glad that the cowboys got rid of him! What I'm wondering now is where he is now?
Bruh he was not even close to overratedV 10 Comments
Eli Manning is overrated because the only reason he won two Super Bowl rings over the Patriots is because their defense sucks. He couldn't even beat the Redskins and only shows up in the playoffs. I would like to see him face a defense like the Ravens and see how bad he plays. - redsox123456789
Getting to the playoffs doesn't mean anything? And as for his Super Bowl rings, he beat his opponent. That's what you're supposed to do to earn the reward. - Billyv
Sucks in comparison to Peyton and won 2 super bowls. Rings don't show how good a player is it's how good the team is. Football is a team sport if you haven't noticed.
His two superbowl wins were a fluke won on crazy plays, and the only reason he ever got to two of them was because of that sick defensive front.
Without that Giants defense Eli has zero titles.V 13 Comments
Over-hyped and can't carry a team the way Michael Jordan, Shaq, Tim Duncan (although Duncan had help with David Robinson/Ginobili/Parker), Allen Iverson, Charles Barkley, Hakeem Olajuwan, Dwyane Wade, or LeBron James, or even Patrick Ewing to Finals appearances. But wait, he has 5 rings. Every one of those rings Kobe was the sidekick. He won those MVPs because he got a lot of points off of single coverage because the #1 option was Bynum/Gasol down low. Their length was the main strength of the back to back titles. When they didn't have Bynum in 2008, they got crushed by the Celtics. Also, Kobe doesn't have a signature playoff series. You can't compare a player to Jordan when he has Shaq, and old Karl Malone and Gary Payton, and he still loses to the Detroit Pistons. Kobe led teams also get beat by 25-35 points multiple times in playoff series. Because he gives up on his team, and his team gets sick of playing with him because he wants to put up numbers and get all of the glory. It's ...more
You needed to single out Duncan as having help as if the others you mention didn't? Nonsense. - Billyv
Shaq won 3 for him. Paul Gasol never got the credit he deserved, even though he was in his prime when He and Kobe won the titles. Always was the right-hand man during the lakers' championship runs. Whenever he had no help, the lakers were terrible. Also I don't think Lebron is better than Kobe, but stats say so. Lebron is better in almost every scoring stat. People think Jordan vs. Kobe is a great matchup. If they think Jordan destroying Kobe is a great matchup, then they're wrong. Everyone says Kobe is in the top ten, he probably barely makes the top twenty. If I made a typo, it is because of auto correct.
One dimensional scorer, who doesn't have a signature playoff game. His team has plenty of playoff wins, but Phil Jackson, Shaq, Gasol and Bynum have always been the main reason the Lakers won titles. He has relied on ESPN to make his case for him, as the NBA cannot run away from the Jordan comparison when it comes to shooting guards with any sort of similarity.
He is a guard he can not be goodV 7 Comments
LeBron James should have been number one because even people who don't even like basketball know who he is. I'm not saying he's a bad basketball player but everybody makes him seem like a god.
Has always played with at least 2 superstars! He played with Wade, Bosh, AND Allen! Now he's with Love and Kyrie and still can't win a championship with them...seriously? Turn down a notch with this guy
Ridiculous. Cleveland had other superstars with him? And which players were superstars while with him on the Heat? None. - Billyv
Espn practically worships him
Absolute freak of natureV 21 Comments
Not strong enough to handle the heavier car and the contact in sprint car
Her career is basically built on the fact that she's pretty and can get sponsors.
If she was ugly you would never have heard of her. She is just a marketing tool.
When will NASCAR ever have a female driver that is good? - htoutlaws2012V 5 Comments
The answer to your question is that Michael Jordan was so great that he earned two spots on the NBA's 50 greatest players list, one for himself and one for Scottie.
He is overrated he got on the dream team instead of Isaiah Thomas.
He was pretty good with the blazers after the Jordan era. Although Sabonis was also good on the Trail Blazers. He had great defense and was pretty good on offense. Not overrated.
He shouldn't be on this list - SabbathV 5 Comments
173 TD passes, 220 INTs, completion percentage of 50.1%. Hardly the career stat line of a football legend.
Terrible stats. Screw the guarantee, he should not be in the hall of fame because of that game. - SgtPeppersz196715
Terrible from a statistically point of view. He's known for beating the Colts in Super Bowl 3. I say so what? The Jets defense won Super Bowl 3! Namath did not throw a touchdown and the Jets only scored 16 points.
Stephen curryV 8 Comments
Scores a few goals against crappy teams but doesn't do anything other than lose the ball when his team needs him
He is best in scoring goals but he is not good as Messi. Well he is so good in taking chances but Messi creates chances and takes chances brilliantly. He is best but I think he is overrated.
He's not arrogant or bad I mean how many ballon does has he won I bet it's more than you who plays for Real Madrid who do you play for Barcelona I bet but on FIFA
Not as good as messi.. But who is?
Still a great footballer although he probably should have won the ballon door yet... Again, because of messi
714 home runs is nothing to BS about, but the guy was a fat drunk who could hardly run. Sure, he was pretty dang good when he pitched, but then the stardom got to him. For his time he was God, and some still see him that way, but the time have changed folks.
He isn't underrated he hit 714 home runs and the balls back then were squishy so its was way harder to hit the ball
Played against only white players who had other jobs in the winter and didn't even work out. Please. Good for his time, but one of the most overrated. Old people just can't get over the fact he played against mostly just average white guys.
Athletes need to be compared to the competition and in their time period. The Babe out-homered teams. - Billyv
I'd be shocked if someone HAVEN"T heard of him. - 906389V 7 Comments
His poor mother was chucked down the stairs and he bit of someones ear off this guy is mad and annoying.
Mike was great, really, he was. But he was massively overrated. The excuses his fanboys make over him losing:
Buster Douglas: He wasn't focused, he was on drugs!
Evander Holyfield: He went to prison, he was high!
Lennox Lewis: He wasn't in his prime, Lewis ducked him for years!
He just lost, deal with it.
Great puncher, yes. Great boxer, no. Tyson wouldn't have stood a chance against the best boxers in their prime.
''Gotta go bite Holyfield ear off! '' - htoutlaws2012V 8 Comments
He's slow but probably the best skilled player ever.
I don't see any reason why ronaldinho is on the list
I think in 2007 he was at his best and was the best but than he started loosing his skill
Back at then, not overrated. but became in his last days (before become this). - zxmV 7 Comments
Overrated? Probably. Mostly because boxing is in a lull right now and no one really cares about boxing in general. The only decent fighters out there for him are all over 30. Plus, the stigma of possible PED usage seems to be a real one. I really don't like Floyd Mayweather, but if Manny is a good as he says he is, why does the blood test matter? Someone's covering something up.
MANNY PACQUIAO HAS GOTTEN AWAY WITH MURDER IN BOXING NO ATHLETE IN THE HISTORY OF THE SPORT HAS REFUSED TO BLOOD TEST... HE SHOULD BE STRIPPED OF ALL HIS BELTS.
He is waay overrated! He robbed Marquez... more then three times? How does that show integrity and honor? What a fake!
Good runner, great offensive line. Most running backs would be happy to line up behind four different pro bowl linemen in a career but in the 1995 Super Bowl Emmitt had four pro bowlers in front of him at once. And that doesn't count the pro bowl full back blowing up the holes, the pro bowl tight end drawing the attention of the linebackers, or the pro bowl quarterback and wide receiver keeping the secondary honest. Half the backs in the league would have put up hall of fame numbers in a setup like that.
He has to be the most overrated running back of all time. Imagine Barry Sanders behind that line or Walter Payton... I mean come on anybody could break records with 4 all star caliber lineman blocking for you.
Has no highlight reel. Watch Earl Campbell footage for comparison. Emmitt was slower and smaller than most running backs in his combine class. He had good vision and awareness.
Nope. Emmitt smith is LEGENDARY. Enough said.V 5 Comments
He prays to Jesus all the time and everyone thinks he's God! Come on people! He's not 'superman' either. Come on people! Peyton Manning and Brady are the greats-this guy is an over rated bible basher!
The reason he was popular because tebowing are you kidding he can't even make a 10 yard pass
his nickname is Superman people. Come On!
Not in the NFL anymoreV 7 Comments
He is one of the best players. Seriously? Why is he even on this list? ///
This is a cruel joke right? - htoutlaws2012
When you sneezed in his directions, refs gave this bastard two free throw attempts.
Put Kareem, Wilt, Bird, Russell, James, Bryant, Magic in the same era, and MJ wouldn't dominate.V 5 Comments
You can't say someone's your favourite basketball player just because they're the point guard of the team that just won the championship. That's stupidity. - yaygiants16
Yeah so true
The kids in my 5th grade class have started a Steph Revolution. Slogan? "Eat Curry! "
Related ListsGreatest Athletes of All Time Most Overrated Actors/Actresses Most Overrated Rappers of All Time Most Overrated Bands of All Time Most Overrated Video Games
List StatsUpdated 26 Jun 2017
11 years, 128 days old
Top Remixes (6)
2. Michelle Wie
3. Shaquille O'Neal
2. LeBron James
3. Eli Manning
2. LeBron James
3. Tony Romo
View All 6