Top 10 Scariest Creepypasta Characters

There are lots of scary looking creepy pasta characters out there.

Here are the top ten...
Don't agree with the list? Vote for an existing item you think should be ranked higher or if you are a logged in, add a new item for others to vote on or create your own version of this list.

The Top Ten

Jeff The Killer
Jeff the Killer is without a doubt THE scariest Creepy Pasta character. He climbs through your window at night, stands beside your bed, waits until your wake up, when you do wake up he smiles at you with the most horrifying face ever, says, "GO TO SLEEP" and kills you with his knife. ULTRA MEGA SCARY!
Wait if Jeff has no eyelids, then what would pepper spray do to him. Also if you don't blink for that long your vision gets REALLY blurry so unless Jeff uses eye drops every minute or so, then he can't see, also what would protect him from getting his eyes poked out. This is one flawed character swimming in the garbage section of the creepy pasta website known as "crappy pastas". 3/10 Bad
THE FACE I TELL YOU! THE FAACE! The face is extremely terrifying, his smile goes to his cheekbone and his eyes are bloodshot and tiny! He has NOO nose! Then, in the story, he climbs through your bedroom window and whispers "Go to sleep" While smiling like the Joker but a thousand times scarier! Then he kills you! (But don't worry, it's fake)
[Newest]Jeff the killer is sexy

2Slender Man
Slender:The Eight Pages is probably the scariest game I have ever played (besides Amnesia) because your in a forest trying to collect pages but when you least expect it.. THE SLENDER MAN POPS UP AND KILLS YOU WITH HIS BLANK FACE! He is terrifying.
Slender is the scariest. He stalks you for an eternity. He is always there. How do you know he is not behind you right now when you are reading this?
Truly terrifying. He's just as scary as Jeff the Killer seeing that Jeff is just a man with a knife and Slender is a supernatural being.
[Newest]Slender is great for being scary but not as much as Jeff... My opinions on Slender is that he is the stalker of the night...

3Eyeless Jack
I say Eyeless jack is the scariest creepypasta for 3 reasons; 1: He cuts open your body and eats kidneys while you sleep, 2: He is anonymous having it where no one knows his true face and the only thing you can look at his is deep, black, eye sockets 3: Jeff the Killer has become a lover from fan girls :/
Eyeless Jack is freaky for many reasons. He's able to sneak into your room, practically unnoticed and then eat your kidneys while you're asleep. He's by far the one I'm in the middle of the night, being paranoid beyond belief for.
Yes this should be the very best number 1 the big king the most scariest it is better then jeff the killer it is better then all of them
[Newest]The most creepy, horrifying, and mysterious creepypasta I've ever drawn

4Laughing Jack
Laughing Jack definitely deserves a higher spot than 5. He's a psychotic, monochrome clown who makes people kill their loved ones, mainly children, and then they go insane. He's one of the scariest and most popular creepypasta characters and for a very good reason. I'm not a huge fan of clowns but I love this one. However, I'm NOT a Fangirl. He and Jeff the Killer are my favorites, but I'm not obsessed with them and I don't call them my boyfriend.
Unlike most of the other creepypasta's, he was created to be good and a friend to lonely kids. But he was changed when he saw the boy commit murder. His story is actually unique and extremely scary.
He makes you go insane after making you kill your loved ones
[Newest]He deserves a higher spot, I don't know why Jeff is winning I honestly don't, he needs to trade places with Laughing Jack.

5The Rake
This is no doubt THE scariest pasta there is, I am an avid horror reader and fan. This is one of the few stories that made me want to sleep with another person in my room, check all the corners in my room every 30 seconds, AND stay up until 3 AM being paranoid about it having been/being in my room watching me while I slept.
Stare into his eyes for 3 minutes strait at night and sleep great and I will give you 1000000000000 dollars. I'm not scared cause I live with creepy pastas (I'm only 12. slender is my favorite. )
Only really kills kids, so if you are 18 or older then you are safe
[Newest]The rake kills kids and he is ugly

SO SCARY THIS IS THE MOST SCARY THING I EVER WATCHED. By the way it's called sonic. Exe not hod sonic
I had no idea god was a red-eyed blood coated blue hedgehog...
This is scary I don't have the game downloaded but I watched the video
[Newest]He's not that bad but his eyes are kinda scary

7Smile Dog (Picture)
A smiling Siberian Husky in the dark is truly an artwork by the devil
It must be scary if people have killed themselves over the picture. A Husky with human teeth and a bloody hand in the background.
My friend told me about this one and it is scary.

8Smile Dog
After you look at the smiling husky picture, this satanic freak of nature appears in front of you whispering, "Spread the Word" meaning, show everyone my picture. SUPER SCARY!
Smile dog is the coolest one ever made
Smile Dog, by a lot.
[Newest]I couldn't sleep and kept checking my email for the next week.

9Bloody Painter
Bloody Painter is one of the most original human creepypastas out there. He wears this creepy mask with a smile made of blood, and will stop at nothing to kill you. In his origin story, he even breaks down a locked door within seconds, without a weapon.

10Ben Statue
If you play majora's mask and have read BEN DROWNED you will agree it should be in the top 10
This was one of the first creepypastas that I heard of it scared me badly because I have nothing but technology in my room.
Who the hell is ben and how can a statue be scary


The Contenders

11Mother's Call
Some of the scariest creepy pastas let your mind do the work, a WONDERFUL example of this is Mothers Call. I have only read it once but I get chills from just thinking about it. What was in the kitchen? Was it a kidnapper? Was it a monster? Was it a spirit? We don't know and that's why it's so scary.
DEFINTELY top 10 worthy. I mean a little girls hears her mother call her name. As she walks down the steps a hand reaches out of a closet and grabs her. Its her mom and she says "Don't go I heard it too." I mean that's DEFINTELY scary.

12Ticci Toby
My favorite he is way beyond better than Jeff he is just winning because of the fangrils, but Ticci Toby tells a story I can relate to, and that's why he deserves to be on this list!
Ticci is one of the best pasta characters out there. Just read his story. You'll see why.

13Seed Eater
Oh, Eyeless Jack eats your kidneys? How about the Seed Eater eats your children.
A bird-human hybrid that feeds on children. Definitely deserves to be in the top ten.

14The Girl in The Photograph
She may not look scary, but when she's tapping on your window at night giggling you can't decide whether to scream or pass out.

15Tails Doll
I was under the curse

Not even the slightest bit scary, but it was when I used to play Minecraft.
He's not too scary, but it is creepy for Minecraft fans.
This isn't a creepy pasta. It's just a bunch of morons and noobs

17Happy Appy
Same as Seed Eater but instead KILLS children

18Abounded by Disney Mickey Mouse Costume
He Has The Opposite Colored Mickey And He Pulls Of His Head! ABANDONED BY GOD!
Its not the story that scares me, it's the PICTURE
This is why I'm scared of mascots.

19SpongeBob (Bootleg Episode)
Try looking at the picture and sleep just fine the following night.
Hi SpongeBob is creepy
His eyes are all bloody, my god

20Squidward (Squidward's Suicide)
He may not look creepy even with his eyes but if you stare at him long enough then you will know he is beyond creepy but I still like him and his creepypasta story.
He is the ruler of the creepy pasta while sonic exe. Is the slave
His eyes are so scary

Comments About This List

Featured Lists
Popular Lists
New Lists

Top Remixes of This List




Posts About This List

List Info

This list was created 1 year, 348 days ago and has been voted on over 300 times. This top ten list has been remixed 3 times.

Updated Wednesday, May 27, 2015

List Error Reporting

See an item on this list that's misspelled, duplicated, or doesn't belong? Let us know. Click here to report the error.