Top 10 Scariest Creepypasta Characters

There are lots of scary looking creepy pasta characters out there.

Here are the top ten...

The Top TenXW

1Jeff The Killer

Jeff the Killer is without a doubt THE scariest Creepy Pasta character. He climbs through your window at night, stands beside your bed, waits until your wake up, when you do wake up he smiles at you with the most horrifying face ever, says, "GO TO SLEEP" and kills you with his knife. ULTRA MEGA SCARY!

Just to say Jeff the Killer is the best he is the Creepypasta King and I love the way he killed people at night he is very cool better than any other Creepypasta even better than Slenderman the way I remember it is when he killed his mother father and brother then that's how you found Jane and killed her mother and father and her best friend she became a killer too and she wanted to get revenge on Jeff the Killer but if you read Janes story and Jeff's story you will understand why they both go together

Wait if Jeff has no eyelids, then what would pepper spray do to him. Also if you don't blink for that long your vision gets REALLY blurry so unless Jeff uses eye drops every minute or so, then he can't see, also what would protect him from getting his eyes poked out. This is one flawed character swimming in the garbage section of the creepy pasta website known as "crappy pastas". 3/10 Bad

I love Jeff the Killer, his the most beautiful person ( in fiction) that I always wanted to meet and touch. Killing, laughing and losing my mind when I look at him.

V84 Comments
2Slender Man

Slenderman goes around and stalks people, has no face and has tentacles, is as tall as the trees, and he kills children. He is a scary dude. He can get into people's minds and can be watching at all times. Slenderman truly is terrifying! This probably my exact reasoning for loving him. I'll tell you what though. Slender is DEFINITELY an eerie creature, but he is truly TERRIFYING when he's mad! This coming from one of his proxies. Don't tell him I said that! Yes, Slender, you are absolutely a scary creature.

Slender:The Eight Pages is probably the scariest game I have ever played (besides Amnesia) because your in a forest trying to collect pages but when you least expect it.. THE SLENDER MAN POPS UP AND KILLS YOU WITH HIS BLANK FACE! He is terrifying.

Slender is the scariest. He stalks you for an eternity. He is always there. How do you know he is not behind you right now when you are reading this?

Slenderman is scary but he's awesome and my BFF

V33 Comments
3Eyeless Jack

I say Eyeless jack is the scariest creepypasta for 3 reasons; 1: He cuts open your body and eats kidneys while you sleep, 2: He is anonymous having it where no one knows his true face and the only thing you can look at his is deep, black, eye sockets 3: Jeff the Killer has become a lover from fan girls :/

Eyeless Jack is freaky for many reasons. He's able to sneak into your room, practically unnoticed and then eat your kidneys while you're asleep. He's by far the one I'm in the middle of the night, being paranoid beyond belief for.

Yes this should be the very best number 1 the big king the most scariest it is better then jeff the killer it is better then all of them

Eyeless Jack is just downright scary! The way he eats you're kidneys while you are asleep, talk about cannibalism.

V24 Comments
4Laughing Jack

Laughing Jack definitely deserves a higher spot than 5. He's a psychotic, monochrome clown who makes people kill their loved ones, mainly children, and then they go insane. He's one of the scariest and most popular creepypasta characters and for a very good reason. I'm not a huge fan of clowns but I love this one. However, I'm NOT a Fangirl. He and Jeff the Killer are my favorites, but I'm not obsessed with them and I don't call them my boyfriend.

Laughing Jack is the best! He has a cool story, lots of cool art work! And is very scary! The creativity behind this creepy pasta is the best every! From Isaac, to laughing hysterically, to little kids, and finally to candy!? It's awesome! Best creepy pasta ever!

Let's just point out that Laughing Jack loves torture. He loves to cut you open and play with your organs as you watch and he won't let you die till he is finished. I'd much rather be stabbed to death by Jeff, impaled by Slender, or lose a kidney by EJ then be slowly tortured to death. This is why Jack is the scariest creepypasta in my opinion. Also he isn't really a real person he is just an "imaginary friend"

I will be scared of clowns forever now

V28 Comments
5The Rake

This is no doubt THE scariest pasta there is, I am an avid horror reader and fan. This is one of the few stories that made me want to sleep with another person in my room, check all the corners in my room every 30 seconds, AND stay up until 3 AM being paranoid about it having been/being in my room watching me while I slept.

Just looked up a pic of the rake, and I'm a horror kind of person. It is midnight here and now I'm unbelievably scared out of my mind. I think that the rake is the scariest creepypasta on this list. I could watch the conjuring and I wouldn't be as scared as it is to look at this one pic.

Stare into his eyes for 3 minutes strait at night and sleep great and I will give you 1000000000000 dollars. I'm not scared cause I live with creepy pastas (I'm only 12. slender is my favorite. )

Never herd of him

V18 Comments
6Smile Dog (Picture)

A smiling Siberian Husky in the dark is truly an artwork by the devil

It must be scary if people have killed themselves over the picture. A Husky with human teeth and a bloody hand in the background.

My friend told me about this one and it is scary.

This sounds like the perfect pet for me!

V6 Comments
7Ticci Toby

Ticci Toby is a pretty scary character, I guess. He has a story that I can kinda relate to and he kills people with hatchets! That's pretty cool. I think of Toby as my Creepypasta brother. I absolutely love his story and his design. But will someone PLEASE tell me where the heck the waffles thing comes from? What the heck? Ticci Toby is truly an awesome Creepypasta.

My favorite he is way beyond better than Jeff he is just winning because of the fangrils, but Ticci Toby tells a story I can relate to, and that's why he deserves to be on this list!

Ticci Toby is my favorite creepypasta character because he kills people with axes and wears a mouth guard. I am like in love with this character!

This, my friend, is the one and only, true human creepy pasta that is scary, aside from Jeff, bloody painter, and eyeless jack

V28 Comments
8BEN Drowned

This was the first creepypasta I read and its also what got me hooked into it. It creeped the hell out of me and I was 12 when I first read it, and the fact that there is evidence just freaked me out more.

Ben is definitely my favorite creepypasta yet because I'm such a gamer. I'm in love with his story and him just in general... It's amazing

BEN is my bro bro. Like really. He is. BE NICE TO HIM!

I love Ben Drowned.

V17 Comments
9Smile Dog

Teens and younger looking at the picture of the smiling husky will have nightmares. I don't advise looking at it unless you are 100% sure that you love horror pictures and movies and can handle this. The minute I saw that picture I turned away. That picture is scary. (Yes, I am not that into creepy pictures) This is a picture, you will not forget for a very long time.

After you look at the smiling husky picture, this satanic freak of nature appears in front of you whispering, "Spread the Word" meaning, show everyone my picture. SUPER SCARY!

Smile dog is the coolest one ever made

This guy is absolutely scary. I mean, I am not afraid of him, but most people will take one look at hi, and scream and/or pass out

V11 Comments
10Bloody Painter

I can relate to him as I was once bullied until I did something and it stopped and I also love to draw. I regretted it though as soon as I reached year 8 in senior school it started up again so I'm like him in a way. But his story did make me feel for him.

He's an interesting character, he's slowly losing his mind because of the bullies he had. The fact that he wears a mask with a bloody smile makes him extremely disturbing and his catchphrase adds more to that.

Bloody Painter is one of the most original human creepypastas out there. He wears this creepy mask with a smile made of blood, and will stop at nothing to kill you. In his origin story, he even breaks down a locked door within seconds, without a weapon.

His story's an enjoyable read, and he's in my top 3 favorite Creepypasta characters for sure.

V12 Comments

The Newcomers

?KagekaoV1 Comment

The Contenders

11Happy Appy

Happy Appy is terrifying! Just to look at! Yes, Jeff is creepy-looking (hence the name "Creepypasta"), but this...this THING is absolutely (what word shall I use? ) CREEPY. It takes a lot to scare me. I mean, I read Creepypastas at night during a storm and can still sleep peacefully, but this dude is just...I don't know what to say. I'm sorry, but Happy Appy, you take the poisoned cake, my friend.

I am Happy Appy, My first victim is YOU!

Same as Seed Eater but instead KILLS children

Super mega creepy coming from an 8 year old!

V1 Comment
12Mr. Bear (1999)

Very creepy... More of a mystery though. Loved this character, as well as the creepypasta - SammMinajj

Wow how could this come out of the mind of a sane person? I just loved it MUCH better then jeff the killer and bloody painter for sure!

Now THIS was the creepypasta that had me most scared. I couldn't stop thinking about it!

1999 is easily my favourite creepy pasta, but I honestly didn't find it that scary.

V5 Comments

He really scary me I played a lot of video games I ever played sonic but when I heard about his creepypasta story I stop playing that video game

I had no idea god was a red-eyed blood coated blue hedgehog...

SO SCARY THIS IS THE MOST SCARY THING I EVER WATCHED. By the way it's called sonic. Exe not hod sonic

Love sonic but this AAH!

V11 Comments
14The Girl in The Photograph

She may not look scary, but when she's tapping on your window at night giggling you can't decide whether to scream or pass out.

Who is she? she makes me wonder if she is not related to the creepypasta, Sally williams.

V2 Comments

Hoodie is originally from Marble Hornets and I think he is just awesome. He is silent usually and is very loyal to Slenderman. He only kills when told and he is pretty creepy. He's a little scarier without the mask though, just saying'. Please don't be mad Brian! It was a compliment!

I find him to be a silent killer. In the story I read, he only kills when told to do so by Slender Man and he he will not fail him. He is not the creepiest, but certainly one of the deadliest.

He may be shy except don't be fooled he will not hesitate to kill you

*thinks to self* hoodie

V9 Comments
16Frank (Donnie Darko)

Oh my god. The creepiest rabbit ever. I'm surprised nobody thought of him.

V2 Comments
17Rap Rat

I can't play board games because of this creepypasta :( so much for family game night - Setwing55

Scariest thing ever. I didn't sleep for 3 days cause of rap rat

V4 Comments
18Abounded by Disney Mickey Mouse Costume

That thing is really creepy. What could be under the costume? What we only know, is that it was abandoned by Disney... and by God - hansoharrigen

I really got the chills while reading this, I made some of my friends read it too and they also got the chills!

He Has The Opposite Colored Mickey And He Pulls Of His Head! ABANDONED BY GOD!

Even my mickey mouse loving sisters were scared of him

V7 Comments

He is...the king of darkness well guess what...i'm THE GODDESS OF DARKNESS HAHAA

V3 Comments
20Tails Doll

When I watched the movie I was worried that my tails toy would kill me

Cute and scary. Not the best but cool

I have a tails plushie, and I am so grateful for it isn't a doll, otherwise I'd have to say goodbye to something I grew up with

I think he looks kind of cute.

V6 Comments
PSearch List

Related Lists

Top 10 Scariest Anime Characters Top Ten Scariest Five Nights at Freddy's 4 Characters Top 10 Creepypasta Characters Top Ten Scariest Looking Animated Characters Top Ten Strongest Creepypasta Characters

List StatsUpdated 28 May 2016

1,000 votes
63 listings
2 years, 350 days old

Top Remixes (5)

1. Slender Man
2. Smile Dog (Picture)
3. The Rake
1. Laughing Jack
2. Eyeless Jack
3. Slender Man
1. The Rake
2. Laughing Jack
3. Slender Man

View All 5


Add Post

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.