Top 10 Gaming Creepypastas


The Top Ten

1 Ben Drowned

One of the best Creepypastas out there in my opinion. The one that started cliches, and gaming Creepypastas for the matter. Yes BEN Drowned deserves to be first on this list. It is by far the scariest Creepypasta I have read.

I used to have this game before Ben Drowned Was even a thing and my game would always glitch out like the Ben was there 0_0

Majora's Mask has to be one of my favorite Zelda games next to A Link Between Worlds. Just I love this creepypasta

MM is my all time favourite game, so naturally my favourite Pasta is Ben.

V 14 Comments
2 Sonic.exe

One of the worst Creepypasta's. A highly overrated bunch of words that has an absolute delusional Author with a god complex. - Drewstar

This started a big cliche in Creepypastas. It goes along the lines of, "The title screen was the most deadly, daemonic thing ever, but I thought it was a glitch and played on." - PeterG99

It is a great creepypasta, but it is not scary, but it is creepy

Sonic.exe I relate to Clockwork why? They have very bad stories but have great character designs but Sonic.exe has a good exe game it's scary - spodermanfan1000

V 16 Comments

Gest what I didn't sleep for 10 weeks and 13 days and that demon is going to get a punch in the face...0_0 hehehe... Sorry 0_0 and I'm a girl

I am a huge fan of Mario games and I therefore will jump to read a creepypasta likebthis.

V 2 Comments
4 Herobrine - Minecraft

I love minecraft so I had to pick Herobrine!

Herobrine is not scary I don't care about white eyes guy I am gonna kill him I will name my self herobrine killer or herobrine hunter (if you want my help please give me 2 diamond sword 1 full pack of defense) but first I have to get all of 23 dollars

WHAT? Herobrine isn't scary or isn't a creepypasta either. Some idiot wanted to share his picture then people thought it was "mysterious" so they made a creepypasta. WE ALL KNOW HEROBRINE IS FAKE HE ISN'T SCARY HE JUST KILLS YOU ON Minecraft! OR SETS TRAPS OR what IDC HE ISN'T A GOOD CREEPYPASTA - spodermanfan1000

This is a dumbass creepypasta obiously created by a Minecraft fanboy

V 9 Comments
5 Lavender Town Syndrome

First every creepy pasta I every read and my heart was pounding during the song and everything - itz_izzy

The first night I had the song stuck in my head, I couldn't sleep & nearly got a knife out and just ended it all! - NintendoROCK3T

All I got was a headache. Thanks guys! You guys suck at telling stories!

That song may be creepy but not to me it only gave me a headache

V 4 Comments
6 NES Godzilla

No doubt this is one of the bests creepypastas ever. The huge amount of graphic "evidence" and a well written story gives this pasta my vote. Besides Red is the perfect antagonist and some of its pictures will get you scared. I strongly recommend it.

This is the best Creepypasta seen besides another one I love the monsters in the story I mean I love them is like one of the best Creepypastas you should totally check it out I am so sad that they don't actually have a game for this wait they do have a game for this

This story does a really good job of building up suspense, the sprite work is nice and it's cool to see not one, but four original creepypasta characters. There's a game in the works too, the soundtrack is done but the game itself is on hold unfortunately.

This story is great, the last few chapters are insane!

V 8 Comments
7 Polybius

I actually liked it for it's known seizures, by the way I have seizures though.

You know what scares me the most about it is that they have no record of it existing yet there are legit photos

8 Come Follow Me

This is literally the scariest creepypasta I have ever read, I took a while but I finally did it

Okay first off I have never seen this Creepypasta

Scariest gaming creepypasta ever.

9 Tails Doll - Sonic R

I played the game sonic R or at least I wish I could I love that you can unlock the character I watch YouTube and I saw a person unlock tails doll

I have played that game. It's not that scary but fun to play. Where tail have to get out his nightmare is to fight tails doll.

Sonic. Exe is my favourite, I love the Mario series so Mario is creepy, but this one is got to be the scariest!

This was such a cool creepy pasta but my friends don't think its scary

V 8 Comments
10 Strangled Red

A shocking turn of events will leave you disturbed. - Drewstar

Okay I have not seen this one either

Definitely one of the best gaming creepypastas out there! Beats LTS, creepy black, buried alive and lost silver too, in my opinion...

The Newcomers


The Contenders

11 Lost Silver

Dang it! I voted for NES Godzilla because I didn't see this one!

Lost Silver is where this Creepypasta addiction of mine started. This is why it is good:
To start, all of the cliches in the story were not cliches when it was originally created.
Also, the symbolism is impressive. The story represents the inevitable death of 8-bit games, as Silver is the last Pokèmon game on the Gameboy. - GREATEST

12 Slender Man V 2 Comments
13 Giygas - Earthbound Giygas - Earthbound V 1 Comment
14 The Theater

So what it's a creppy game that doesn't mean the game is a creepypast now mr.chef

V 1 Comment
15 Shadows - Super Mario Galaxy II

Ohh I didn't see this one, I wish I voted for it. I like Sonic. Exe, but this one might be tied for favorite.

I never even noticed that until I saw the CreepyPasta video. - egnomac

V 1 Comment
16 Glitchy Red
17 Mr. Mix

The ending of Mr. Mix made me laugh. - GREATEST

V 2 Comments
18 Noli
19 Super Mario 64 Damned
20 Pokemon Dead Channel
PSearch List

Recommended Lists

Related Lists

Most Underrated Gaming Creepypastas Best YouTube Gaming Channels Best CreepyPastas Ever Top 10 Scariest Creepypastas Most Overrated Gaming Consoles

List StatsUpdated 23 Feb 2017

300 votes
53 listings
3 years, 162 days old

Top Remixes (12)

1. Ben Drowned
2. Strangled Red
1. Ben Drowned
3. Sonic.exe
1. Ben Drowned
2. Sonic.exe

View All 12


Add Post

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.