Movies that Shouldn't Have Won the Best Picture Oscar

Vote for the films that have won the Academy Award's top award, which were either lackluster, vaulted up too high due to Hollywood Politics, or simply just less-deserving than another film or films that came out that year.

The Top Ten

1 Shakespeare in Love

How could a movie with that snob Gwyneth Paltrow win over what I consider a fantastic and very realistic movie called Saving Private Ryan!

They chose this over Saving Private Ryan, really? - PeeledBanana

2 The English Patient

I really don't think that it was 'boring'..Just a little bit predictable when it came to the aftermath of the crash. It DESERVED the oscar it got..It just requires a particular type of a viewer to appreciate it's plot. - Ananya

3 Crash (2004)

Both Brokeback Mountain and this are 10 out of 10 points pictures, and both with an extremely important message. Both would have been very deserving. - Martin_Canine

4 The King's Speech
5 How Green Was My Valley

Back then, no one could foresee the impact of Citizen Kane and The Maltese Falcon. Since Citizen Kane was critically panned back then, it was a wonder it was even nominated in the first place and on top won the Oscar for Best Original Screenplay. And as for The Maltese Falcon... no one could foresee it would start a whole new genre that is among the most acclaimed ones and be constantly referenced in pop culture to an extent where lines and scenes of it became part of everyday language.
I have not seen How Green Was My Valley, but most modern reviews are great and the premise sounds good, so I assume it is not on here because it isn't a great movie but because of the influence of the other two nominees I just wrote about. - Martin_Canine

6 Slumdog Millionaire

I never really got the praise for this movie. It sure has an interesting premise and also something to say, but in the end it just didn't get me. On the one hand, it's about the serious topics of ghettos in India, on the other hand it's also built up like a fairy tale about love and destiny. While this could go well together - Titanic works as both a big Hollywood picture and as a realistic depiction of the horrible disaster, and ends up being one of the saddest and most gripping movies I know - in "Slumdog Millionaire" it just doesn't go far enough in both aspects. I don't feel the strong emotion both storylines have to offer. - Martin_Canine

7 Kramer vs. Kramer
8 Argo

While I think "Argo" is a really good movie and the nomination was justified, the year was so strong that it just feel right this got the best picture Oscar. When you have a movie like "Life of Pi", which is rich in philosophy and metaphorical meanings as well as being an audiovisual experience one has never seen before, then a realistic movie about an elderly couple having to go through the painful experience of the woman slowly withering away, a Tarantino movie about slavery which is among his most praised works (I don't agree but it still is better than most other movies by other directors), a movie about the methods of the CIA raiding moral questions, the tale of an ulikely relationship of a man with bipolar disorder and a woman with borderline personality, and a hand crafted epic musical based on a literature classic,... this win seems extremely unjustified. - Martin_Canine

9 The French Connection
10 Hurt Locker

Really? Because you think Renner wasn't that good in it? HELL NO, It's a great war movie and Renner did an amazing job. - Ananya

The Contenders

11 Around the World in Eighty Days

Funny movie. - LordofL

12 Moonlight

Some may disagree, but I liked la la land more, it felt so fresh

La La Land > Moonlight - MegaSoulhero

13 Cimarron
14 Chicago

It is okay, but not exactly one of the most memorable musicals out there, neither story-wise nor musically.
Also this was a strong year where each other nominee would have deserved the award much more.
"Gangs of New York" is a brilliant epic with storylines involving around basic emotions and complex characters, and an unexpectedly great performance by all three main actors (yes, Diaz can act very well if she wants). "The Hours" is a sensitive and imaginative anthology film with three of the greatest actresses of today, that mixes reality with fiction.
I don't think I have to say anything about the second installment of the "Lord of the Rings" saga, enough has to be said about this epic. It rightfully has its place in film and pop culture history. And well, I may not personally think that "The Pianist" is one of the greatest movies of all time (there have been more intense, sadder and also more stunningly directed and written movies about the horrors of the holocaust), but I ...more - Martin_Canine

15 American Beauty
16 Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King

It was the best movie of the year. - zxm

Best movie of 2000s - PeeledBanana

17 Forrest Gump

Deserved it. - PeeledBanana

18 The Silence of the Lambs

Man...Are you kidding me? - Ananya

19 Titanic

Deserved it - PeeledBanana

20 The Sting
BAdd New Item

Recommended Lists

Related Lists

Top Ten Movies That Should Have Won the Oscar for Best Picture Top 10 Animated Movies that Should've Won the Best Picture Oscar Top Ten Best Movies Without Best Picture Oscar Movies That Should Win the Best Picture Oscar In 2014 Top Ten Movies Most Likely to Win the 2015 Best Picture Oscar

List StatsUpdated 16 Oct 2017

20 listings
155 days old

Top Remixes (4)

1. Slumdog Millionaire
2. Shakespeare in Love
3. The King's Speech
1. Hurt Locker
2. Argo
3. Forrest Gump
1. The English Patient
2. Crash (2004)
3. How Green Was My Valley

View All 4


Add Post

Error Reporting

See a factual error in these listings? Report it here.