Top Ten Saddest Deaths in Supernatural


The Top Ten

1 Bobby Singer

That was the saddest moment especially when the boys faded away in the scene.

In the scene where he's experiencing his last memories and that is the boys having a normal life, or any time when he referes to the brothers as his own, it just breaks my heart. - AnonymousChick

2 Charlie Bradbury

She should never have died I loved her. She was my favourite female character. I poured my eyes out on that episode - ChelseaPurnell

She shouldn't have died

My poor lesbian nerdy wife didn't have to die. Why did the writers take her so soon? And why did they make her funeral in the next episode so depressing? - AnonymousChick

3 Kevin Tran

He. Was. Taken.Too. Soon. - AnonymousChick

4 Jo Harvelle

People usually put her death with her mother's, but it was different, seeing that she died before the place exploded. Poor girl. - AnonymousChick

5 Sam Winchester (Season 5)

The time when he basically killed himself to save the world from lucifer. - AnonymousChick

6 Ellen Harvelle

Just thinking about it is making me want to cry - ChelseaPurnell

She held her dead daughter in her arms and killed herself to save Sam and Dean. - AnonymousChick

7 Mary Winchester

Her death was what started her children the horrible path of being hunters. - AnonymousChick

8 John Winchester

He was a jerk and horrible to his kids as they grew up, but he ultimatley sacrificed himself for Dean - AnonymousChick

9 Sam (Season 2)

Are we going to forget how Dean held him and cried? Or how in the next episode he sold his soul to bring him back? I've seen that episode 4 times and every time I'm reduced to a pile of tears.

10 Gabriel (Season 5)

I cried every time I thought of him he should be number 1.


The Contenders

11 Castiel (Season 7)

Cas is and was such a loveable character. And I was super attached so it completely broke me.

It's just that... he was dead for so long... I thought we'd never see him again... - AnonymousChick

12 Dean Winchester (Season 3)

Never cried so much over a T.V. show

The first time he died. And the first time we saw hell - AnonymousChick

13 Eileen Leahy
14 Crowley Crowley

He took his own life to save everyone else’s to trap Lucifer in the other world. I sobbed for hours.

15 Balthazar

I loved Balthazar, he was so funny - ChelseaPurnell

The... the heartbreak on his face. As god! Cas stabbed him. I will never be able to unsee it.

16 Ash

I loved Ash, it was so sad how he died - ChelseaPurnell

17 Bela Talbot Bela Talbot

She may have been a jerk and all but she had a reason, she was sexually abused and the poor girl was eleven and sold her soul, and still had to run from her home and she acted selfish when really she was trying to make the most of her time, Sam and Dean were bigger jerks to a lot of other characters and got those people killed yet everyone loves them doesn’t she deserve more?

18 Mick Davies

Just when I started liking him. And he died wanting to do the right thing. For a moment I thought he was going to be a regular. :(

19 Pamela
20 Jess
21 Samandriel/Alfie

Why doesn’t anyone ever mention this angel not only was he the most adorable character, but he was one of the few good angels, and he died all because he was forced to tell the king of hell stuff he didn’t even know he knew. He deserves to be brought back, he deserves to be in the top five at least!

22 Rufus Turner

Of all ways to die he was killed by his friend who was like a brother to him, I don’t care if it wasn’t the real Bobby still.

23 Meg Masters

Is no one going to bring up megan masters! Seriously she was just a teenage girl who had a demon ride around in her meat suit watching them slaughter people in front of her. When she died laying on the ground choking on her own blood being cared to by the ones, who shot her stabbed and threw her off a building that was incredibly sad!

She was such a nice demon and her last words were “Go save my unicorn.” She was referring to Cass. She saves all of them and deserves more credit. This made me done for hours.

24 Dean Winchester (Season 9)

Sam and Dean had been fighting all season and a bit before and Sam had basically disowned him. And after trying so hard to defeat Metatron, died in Sam’s arms. The worst part is what happened afterwards with Crowley.

BAdd New Item